Question Locked

Is open weight AI becoming the new open source?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Open weight More and more, AI is being billed as "the new open source," but the truth is more complicated. As AI models get bigger and more expensive to train, many companies are deciding to only share model weights and not the training data, pipelines, or infrastructure. This change isn't a rejection of open-source ideas; it's because of technical and financial limitations. In real life, open-weight models provide many of the features that businesses value the most.
They let you do local inference, fine-tuning for internal use cases, and distribution without having to rely on vendor-hosted APIs all the time. Open-weight access often gives teams that care about speed, customization, and keeping costs low enough freedom to build and run real systems.
And yet, open-weight models are not as good as the old open-source standards. It's hard to check models for bias, data provenance, or long-term stability when you don't have access to training data or full reproducibility. Organizations have to depend on paperwork and trust instead of clear information that can be checked. Such an arrangement makes governance and compliance more difficult in regulated settings.
We are not seeing an alternative for open source; instead, we are seeing a change to it. Open-weight AI is something in between fully closed models and fully open systems. It makes it easier to try new things and compete while still recognizing the realities of AI research today.
The main problem is not being able to think clearly. If you consider open-weight models to be the same thing as open source, it could lower standards for accountability and transparency. A better way to look at it is to see open-weight AI as a separate area that is useful and important but not the same as open source. The future of trust, creativity, and control in AI adoption will depend on how businesses handle this difference.

3 replies

by rproffitt edited

Claude came back with the usual "You are absolutely right."
GPT, well it waffled on what truth is.

Let skip to the end here.

Ai/Gpt/Claude and others are NOT CREATIVE and not artificial intelligence.

As to trust, we have too many reports of outright lies (looking at you Grok) and then company code bases VANISHING.

-> NO TRUST <-

by alisonsburger91 edited

Explore the evolution of AI accessibility. Discover how open weight models are reshaping collaboration, transparency, and innovation in ways that mirror the open source revolution.

by rproffitt edited

I have to ask since this is nothing I'd expect from even an AI promoter.

This discussion is closed to new replies.