Discussion Locked

ISP connecting to DNS

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I currently have two dial-up providers for internet access. The problem is when trying to connect to certain DNS (domain name servers) I get two different results. Using the tracert command on the DOS prompt one ISP will find the DNS all the time for the page I'm trying to find. The other will intermittently find it. What would be causing this..? A router problem from the ISP's end or from the DNS's end...?? A glitch in the routing of my request...? When I checked with the problem ISP they could not recreate the problem and said they would look into it further. My main reason for wanting to use their service is there are no timeouts which seems to be normal (8hrs 0r less) for others. Any suggestions or info would be greatly appreciated.

2 replies

by shanghai sam

This would all depend on who is allowing access to what on the varying networks... If I'm reading you correctly, you have:

1. First ISP
2. Second ISP
3. DNS server you want to access on a third network

While you *can* configure your machine to do this, many networks don't like you to... DNS is not exactly the most secure of services to run on a server. However, due to it's inherent need, it's a necessary evil. That's not to say that I'd let you use *my* DNS server for host lookups on other networks (assuming *I'm* the third network in the equation above).

Something else to note... tracert or traceroute uses an entirely different protocol than what you will need to do name lookups against the server. Even if you *could* get a consistent reply on a trace or ping, that *still* doesn't mean that the third network will let you use the DNS server.

All is not lost though... *most* every ISP provides DNS server access for their clients, and most times it's an automatic configuration. Dialup networking acquires both IPaddress and DNS settings from the dialup server and most cable systems using DHCP will autoconfigure DNS when the address is acquired as well.

Unless there is something so heinously wrong with your preferred ISP's DNS server (in which case I'd be addressing customer service), I'd stick with what your preferred ISP assigns you as a DNS server.

by pres3

I have addressed customer service with this problem and they are stumped by it. I think you missed the question all together. I was asking why two different ISP's could give different results when trying to access a web page DNS.

This discussion is closed to new replies.