25 replies
I have to ask, are you for real? Or are you just trying to start a flame thread? If you are serious I'm happy to respond but if not I'd rather not waste my time...
It is true that upgrades often fix security holes. Despite the bad reputation UAC in Vista has it is no more intrusive than security on the Mac or Linux and it does help secure the PC.
But there are valid reasons for not upgrading. Not all businesses can afford to upgrade - especially when the cost is more than just licenses. Often critical systems break when a new OS or update is introduced, and it takes money to fix those systems and make them work with the new OS.
You said XP is "useless" which is patently untrue. If it were useless it would not still be, well, in use. For many it is "good enough" - especially to those resistant to change (though there are many other reasons to stick with XP as well).
I'm a fan of Vista and plan to upgrade to 7 in a few weeks, but I support over 200 XP computers in my organization. It all depends on the use.
Regarding Mac's, I support 72 of them as well and they are not a bad platform. They have their problems and weaknesses like any other OS, but overall they work well, just differently. The Apple iPod is not "garbage" and does some things better than the Zune HD, though I admit the Zune HD has strong points too and surpasses the iPod in its video display.
I appreciate your zeal, but please don't make unfounded blanket statements about technology; it doesn't serve or assist anyone.
by jck
with your last statement. Enough hasn't been said. That's why I'm writing this reply.
XP is by FAR more secure than Windows 7 for 2 reasons:
a) Windows 7 hasn't been exposed in RTM form to the world. Wait until the Chinese and Indonesian and American and European and Russian hackers get a hold of it. Within 24 hours, they stole a cert key from Lenovo and published it for Win 7 ultimate. They'll find ways to do things without having inside info too.
b) Windows XP has been put through the ringer for 7 years now? It's been patched and patched and patched.
Vista still has security holes popping up with its new "security features" that aren't vulnerabilities in XP. I know. I have 32 and 64 bit versions of both XP Pro and Vista Home Premium at my house. I see all the updates.
But think as you will. But I warn you, don't be naive to this new software = better security always.
by oz_media
Your right Win7 has been hacked at sicne early evelopment leaks. I've had a hacked copy for nearly 8 months now.
there are new licence workarounds released almost daily for Win7.
However as an OS, it is secure, far mroeso than XP WAS when first released, however it is much more secure today of course.
Agreed, new doesn't mean seure, just look at XP when new, the most insecure release ever, being sold as the most secure.
by jck
XP was at its most insecure at SP3.
And by means of Win 7 having the benefit of Microsoft having been made aware of security holes in XP and Vista that they would have fixed them.
3 critical vulnerabilities so far in Win7 in its beta phase that were found were old variants of the 1 XP and 2 Vista holes.
Microsoft seems to do patchwork fixes, rather than analyse their weaknesses and formulate a best solution.
I wonder if I worked long enough how long it would take me to find another WMP control weakness. :)
Apparently.
"Anytime there is a new operating system upgrade, it is for security reasons, and for businesses not to change puts customers and others at security risk, ... XP has been over-exploited and is easy to hack"
XP can be made quite secure. Businesses shouldn't relies strictly on its OS for security; other tools are required such as firewalls, malware scanners, etc. When these tools are used, the differences between XP, Vista, and W7 are negligible.
"... it is better to update to stay in the here and now. XP ... is outdated and useless."
Why is it 'better' to spend money to replace an existing functional machine? Just because you don't find XP useful doesn't mean hundreds of millions of XP users don't still get value from it every day. If staying up to date is important, you need to update the last four characters in your alias.
"And new software and programs will NOT run on XP."
And as soon as I get a new application that requires W7, I'll get W7. Why buy it before I need it?
"... you can stay in the loop or fall behind. ... It is their loss, not mine."
Why should you care what XP users care to do? If you've made your plans and it's not your loss, why did you bother posting this?
'Also mac and Apple lost when Windows came out, and iPods are garbage and inferior to the Microsoft Zune and Zune HD."
Irrelevant and unsubstantiated. Tango Romeo Oscar Lima Lima.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by notsochiguy
Are you a reseller, or a stock holder? Honestly, that is the only way I can think that your post is serious.
When Vista first came out, upgrading to it would have killed Dynamics/Great Plains. Not upgrading wasn't due to being 'tightwads', it was due to trying to maintain a functioning business.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
According to our friend:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=215919&messageID=3057437
We're beating a dead horse here. Apparently he only posts semi-annually, either pushing the latest from Bill's Boys or identifying comic con cosplayers.
"Big Bang Theory on line 3."
by jamesrl
I take your point on security, but its not necessarily a given. As another poster points out, at least with XP I know where we stand. And in big businesses like mine we have multiple layers of defense, from Firewalls, intrusion detection systems, group policies, and so on. My work computer is far more secure than my home PC.
With XP there is a large community of users monitoring security issues, and MS is continuing to issue security updates.
I do business cases for projects, and upgrading all the PCs in a company is a project. To upgrade a users PC takes a technicians time, reduces the productivity of the employees while the install takes place, and incurs a licensing cost. Some users may also have to buy more RAM.
So those are the costs, what are the benefits that offset those costs. Sure some users may beenfit from new features, but many won't use them. My new work PC came with XP, and I can't think of anything I need from Vista, for work purposes.
Personally, at a previous employer, I created a policy that said we would skip one version of MS Office or the Windows OS. One version back is always supported. I still think that for many companies that is the right policy.
James
by oz_media
LOL, nice rant, well said.
ZP was actually more insecure from eth start than it is today though, it had mroe holes than anything MS had ever released.
As for Ipod I agree, even my Samsung has 10X teh sound quality of an i-pod.
PLUS ocmpressed music period is absolute GARBAGE, I simply cannot listen to MP3's unless a minimum of 320kps and even think its hard to listen to a track with half the dynamics missing.
I find people nowdays have no ear for music, laels release poorly producded junk knowing it will just be compressed and traded in poor quialty formats. Even the new CD's don't osund as good as old CD's, the compression is just horrible on todays' releases, because they KNOW that most people don't care or can't identify real sound anymore.
by jck
all the MP3s I've ever downloaded were like 400k+ sampling. I can't stand the tinny or muffled sound and chopped off resonances.
I still have a Teac turntable and break out the old BB King or CSN or James Taylor just to hear pure tone.
Thank God I take better care of the stuff I've collected better than I did the Sesame Street albums I did when I was 6. :^0
by oz_media
My desk is in front over $54K worth of high end speakers in our sound room.
I grew up with Chesky records super high resolution recordings, Telarc disks, etc.
Last night I treated myself to a listen of my 20+ year old copy of PF The Moon on vinyl, I like my LP's too. :D
by jck
I don't have any $54k of speakers...maybe $1000-1500, but I have 7.1 and all that jazz.
(BTW: I haven't got the speakers yet...I think they are coming tomorrow...)
I like getting out the LPs too. You can hear the fade downs clearer and what not.
BTW, that Sony AV system is sweet I got. Has a "Sports" audio setting. I can turn it on while watching a football game, and it sounds like I'm sitting in a football stadium listening to PA announcers :^0
Just the speakers suck. Hope that will be fixed by Saturday. :)
by oz_media
I know quite a few people who picked up a set too, they are still waiting of course but it's worth it.
I have that DSP filtering (such as your sports audio setting) in my truck stereo too. I find the echo is kinda cool when listening to a hockey game, which happens by accident once or twice a year. In teh most simple terms, it's just delaying certain frequencies to make the sound separate and sound more spacious, a la the 'stadium', 'hall', 'outdoor' settings.
Hopefully your EMP's will arrive tomorrow and you can find some time to sit and have a real 7.1 listen, don't forget to try out some standard 2-channel audio too, the detail and clarity is awesome but not shrill or sibilant!
by jck
they came yesterday evening. I have them stacked in the front room still in the boxes.
I have to wait to install them this weekend. I have too much going on right now scheduled tonight and tomorrow.
I haven't even had a drink of beer or booze in 5 days. That's odd for me. Oh well, $hit happens.
by kenone
My company is still running a few NT4 workstations and at least one Win98SE WS, why? Because it would cost thousands of dollars or, in another case tens of thousands of dollars to upgrade the specialty software being run on those systems. So, yeah, if you're not running anything and/or just playing around with the computers I suppose you could take that stance. But anyone who's trying to keep things running can't afford an attitude like that.
"Anytime there is a new operating system upgrade, it is for security reasons"
Yes, the financial security of the software companies usually.
by oz_media
by oz_media
People seem to think that XPSP3 is solid, I don't use it so I wouldn't know myself.
I DO know that as of release, there were some 385 security vulnerabilities found in XP and none were patched or even considered at teh time as they waited for SP1 to fix them all in one shot rather than offering individual patches. Nearly 400 vulnerabilities in what was touted as teh most secure MS OS ever. :D
Gee, I ate to see what they deemed INSECURE.
When Vista was released, one thing nobody could say is that it was insecure when released. With only a handful of minor vulnerabilities discovered they were easily available and patched individually in very short time, long before SP1.
by jck
1) Microsoft got to dub what was "critical" themselves, not someone impartial.
2) There were several writers who found Microsoft's own count tool was showing different numbers than what Microsoft was press releasing, but then the tool disappeared off Microsoft's site.
3) Some flaws reported as XP exploits were application based and not part of the XP kernel. That is a reporting practice that stopped with Vista, and they no longer consider an IE security flaw a Vista issue.
So, there are discrepancies. That and the fact that MS hasn't radically changed their kernel since NT kinda leads me to believe that if they did have tons of OS-based holes that they need to hire some new engineers.
by jck
I don't want to talk to my boss. He's done a couple good things for me, but the b.s. that I otherwise have to put up with from him is getting on my nerves.
I give him a lot of BOTD because it could be coming from people above him.
Nonetheless...well...no sick day. Just taking a personal day off tomorrow.
I keep having more and more to do, which makes me wish I could just find a security loophole in the banking system in the Caymans and transfer about $50M to an account for myself in Switzerland.
Then I'd just quit, move to Ireland, and go fishing and drink Guinness.
In fact you are in first place.
Dumbest post on TR 2009.
Write this down somewhere. Businesses use IT to save and or make money. If the latter are not true then they are being used by IT, but not for long....
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Windows Forum posts
Sort by Trending