24 replies
by mckaytech
Licensing costs are a huge dis-incentive to continue to use Microsoft products but I don't know to what degree I would tie that to monopolistic practices. Oracle licensing costs are also high and there has, so far, been no accusations of monopoly with regards to them.
I continue to consider and deploy non-Microsoft products whenever it makes sense on a total cost of ownership basis. Thus, I use Apache on Linux or FreeBSD for Web serving, Samba on Linux or FreeBSD for file and print sharing, but Windows2000 for Terminal Services and on the desktop (for now).
paul
Paul M. Wright, Jr. MCSE, CNE
McKay Technologies
by itdebate
I work for a medium-sized company which, for the moment, is an MS shop. The current platform for clients and servers is NT 4.0. We are currently conducting a "next-generation" study where the original viewpoint was a migration to Win2K.
But as of this moment we no longer hold this view. Win2K is simply too expensive.
While it is unlikely that we can switch the client-side(we have, ofcourse MS Office), it is a safe bet to say that the back-end will switch completely. File and print services,mail and fax services, web services, databases will be hosted on unix. At this point we're not sure what vendor we will choose for directory services. Novell is a strong candidate.
We are aware of the conversion and migration costs for switching platforms but, and this is the keypoint, we are now *willing* to make them as we believe them to be justified on a long term base.
So, is MS monopolistic? No, because I believe that there are alternatives wich more compelling each day.
Are they bullish and arrogant?
by itdebate
by terindeb
by itdebate
by bruce
by itdebate
by shoffman
While Gartner makes some good points, one has to wonder if this isn't a short term situation (and short term thinking on Microsoft’s part). *** IF *** (and this is a BIG IF) the company is split up per the recent court decision, one has to wonder about the viability of a company whose only products are operating systems. If MS-1 produces Windows-X and MS-2 produces Exchange, there’s no incentive for MS-2 to require their customers to pay extra for the privilege of running on a Windows based platform.
Would Apple see this as an opportunity to come out with a Mac-like OS for the x86 processors? Didn’t Apple go down this road with the original Mac – making the system very proprietary and trying to lock in users and limit choices? (And look what that got Apple…) Either way, market forces may very well force this to change, and if so, Microsoft’s right to change terms at will could mean a DEcrease in costs… In the mean time, this is one more dis-incentive to m
by itdebate
by djake
by itdebate
by davenptr
As I read the article, the only thing that came to my realization was monopoly. Until this article was released I was so sure that Microsoft was being corporately ambushed. But, in light of what I've just read I can see and understand why it came tocourt. Now, if I'm understanding this correctly, Microsoft is charging Win2K CAL fees even when an enterprise uses another vendor's NOS with Exchange; and this is being done because Exchange needs NT authentication. Yet, needing the same authentication, as long as an enterprise uses NT 4, there's no charge. Granted there's more in Win2K, but to have the audacity to charge fees even when its system isn't used is monopolistic from what I understand of the term.
What's even more intriguing isthe fact that if an enterprise uses a Microsoft function here or there, while continuing to use another vendor's system, those functions force the use of other functions that require additional charges, as I understand the article(anyone feel free to correct me if I mis
by itdebate
by user2002
by itdebate
by hameiri
I think bigboss's answer is right on (sarcastically so).
I once felt I could rely on the "Loyal Opposition" in this country (USA) to avoid this kind of situation. But it seems Corporate America is not very democratic or freedom loving. They're willing to buy into a bully's system as long as everyone else is doing it. As usual American business is short sighted.
Of course Microsoft is doing this! It's what they planned all along.
I'm not going to yell monopoly, I'm going to yellviable alternatives!!! Let's use our freedom and consumer strength and make some good choices!!!
by itdebate
by computrn
This kind of reminds me of what finally made me strike out on my own and start my own business. Too many hoops, hurdles, etc from my old boss tends to force me to quit and create my own better solutions.
The quickest one, IMHO, is to get every business registered as an educational facility. Have you seen their discounts! $10,000+ reduced to $1,600 of Level B MOLP.
Anyone needing training???
Maybe some "good" hacker can create a patch to replace MS authentication code with their own. Oops, would that lead to another court case?
Maybe its time to throw more support behind open code OSs and let MS know about it. After all, the diffence between a consultant and a salesman is whether or not you do what is best for the CUSTOMER. And I know which one I am.
Travis B. Creighton
CompuTron
by itdebate
by ttate
This situation also points out how convoluted software licensing really is. It is very difficult as an IS manager to ensure that you have licensed 30 different applications correctly (30 apps may be too many, but it may not be enough either for a data processing environment).
It is also difficult to ensure that the vendor selling you the product is telling the full story on licensing requirements. The industry needs to have some kind of software licensing manager certification or standard license language for applications. The certification or education program is very attractive, but how often would it have to be upgraded? How many vendor's programs would you have to know? This is not much different than a certification for inventory management or project management. License management can be a full time position if there is a lot of turnover on applications and systems.
by itdebate
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending