Discussion Locked

IT Debate: The e-business czar

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

According to Gartner, many enterprises are choosing to move their e-business programs ahead by creating a new position: an e-business czar. Do you think appointing an e-business czar is an effective plan for companies interested in a Web presence? What responsibilities do you think this role should entail? Would you want this role at your organization? What would you recommend to help an e-business czar succeed?

You can read the related Gartner article, which will be posted at 3 A.M. Wednesday, at
https://www.techrepublic.com/article.jhtml?id=r00620010124ggp01.htm

11 replies

by Member 23255219

The "E" Czar must be based on a clear definition of "e-business" vs "e-commerce." Note: The Gartner article refers to an "e-business" czar, but the TechRepublic's "Post a comment... Is appointing an 'e-commerce' czar an effective plan....What wouldyou recommend to help an 'e-commerce' czar succeed?" refers to this role as an "e-commerce" Czar. These terms are not interchangable. The absence of an operational definition of e-business will doom the role to failure before it starts. (Download the the White Paper "From Web Enablement, to E-Commerce, to E-Business" from the website below for more on this issue).
Corporations need to integrate IT into their business model before creating an E-Business Czar. To do otherwise is to leave IT undfined as a "business variable" and makes "fuzzy" the role of the E-Business Czar in relation to the other business functions. (A new integrated e-business model is also discussed in the White Paper).
Finally, the Gartner E-Business Czar appears synonymous with the "Transformation Officer." The Transformation Officer/E-Business Czar must be broadly experienced in e-business IT and business management principles. He/she must be skilled in directing the research, planning and management of theconvergence of the IT and business models into a new e-business enabled structure guided by a detailed Transformation Plan based on the same disciplined decision making model used to validate any other business initiative justified by ROI. (The White Paper details convergence/e-business enablement management). The E-Business Czar will not produce e-business enablement, quality process and human resource reengineering mangement will.

by Member 23255219

The "E" Czar must be based on a clear definition of "e-business" vs "e-commerce." Note: The Gartner article refers to an "e-business" czar, but the TechRepublic's "Post a comment... Is appointing an 'e-commerce' czar an effective plan....What wouldyou recommend to help an 'e-commerce' czar succeed?" refers to this role as an "e-commerce" Czar. These terms are not interchangable. The absence of an operational definition of e-business will doom the role to failure before it starts. (Download the the White Paper "From Web Enablement, to E-Commerce, to E-Business" from http://www.e-businessmanagement.com for more on this issue).
Corporations need to integrate IT into their business model before creating an E-Business Czar. To do otherwise is to leave IT undfined as a "business variable" and makes "fuzzy" the role of the E-Business Czar in relation to the other business functions. (A new integrated e-business model is also discussed in the White Paper).
Finally, the Gartner E-Business Czar appears synonymous with the "Transformation Officer." The Transformation Officer/E-Business Czar must be broadly experienced in e-business IT and business management principles. He/she must be skilled in directing the research, planning andmanagement of the convergence of the IT and business models into a new e-business enabled structure guided by a detailed Transformation Plan based on the same disciplined decision making model used to validate any other business initiative justifiedby ROI. (The White Paper details convergence/e-business enablement management). The E-Business Czar will not produce e-business enablement, quality process and human resource reengineering mangement will.

by kathy melgar

The article talks about helping the czar succeed but ignores the question "Do you think appointing an e-business czar is an effective plan for companies interested in a Web presence?" A czar may be essential for certain types of organizations, but is not essential for all companies that are interested in a "web presence." Unless the company's survival is dependent on bringing their e-product to market within a small opportunity window, the czar approach may be destructive to an organization and counter-productive in transforming a traditional business.

by shanghai sam

Such an appointment can be effective. The article addresses a number of situational positives that can make the czar effective. Even with these, unless a company has dynamic infrastructure conducive to fluid e-business requirements and a strong security emphasis to avoid disaster, the czar may be severely hampered in his or her effort, or worse, fight a losing battle. In the absence of a ready infrastructure, the deployment of e-business initiatives must be leveraged from successive infrastructure enhancements that augment performance, simplicity and ease of use.

I would not recommend establishing this role, except in smaller companies where a large inertia is not required. I believe the environment for ultimate success in e-business endeavors is a sweeping company culture where every major segment of the business, buys-in, clearly focuses on, supports, and rewards a streamlined set of e-business initiatives that generates regular successes. Then team is built and success is shared.

by kevinh

Such an appointment can be effective. The article addresses a number of situational positives that can make the czar effective. Even with these, unless a company has dynamic infrastructure conducive to fluid e-business requirements and a strong security emphasis to avoid disaster, the czar may be severely hampered in his or her effort, or worse, fight a losing battle. In the absence of a ready infrastructure, the deployment of e-business initiatives must be leveraged from successive infrastructure enhancements that augment performance, simplicity and ease of use.

I would not recommend establishing this role, except in smaller companies where a large inertia is not required. I believe the environment for ultimate success in e-business endeavors is a sweeping company culture where every major segment of the business, buys-in, clearly focuses on, supports, and rewards a streamlined set of e-business initiatives that generates regular successes. Then team is built and success is shared.

This discussion is closed to new replies.