Discussion Locked

IT Debate: What did 2000 mean for ERP?

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Did ERP in 2000 warm you up or leave you cold? According to Gartner, it was a little bit of both. While e-business received a lot of the year's hype, organizations realized that a practical ERP plan was still vital. But ERP in 2000 also left a lot of users disillusioned and a lot of vendors with less of a bottom line.

What do you think were ERP's highs and lows during 2000? Do you think ERP will survive? How do you think consolidations in the market will lead to better products and services?What do you think about the potential of ERP II? How can ERP change the momentum? Is there any way it can prove its importance to the enterprise after years of negative press?

You can read the related Gartner article, which will be posted 3 A.M. Wednesday, at
https://www.techrepublic.com/article.jhtml?id=r00620010228ggp01.htm

11 replies

by shelbybarnes

I do think that ERP will survive but not without a major shift in attention to the bottom line. The technology is nice but in order to be successful the hype must be greatly reduced while promoting successful ventures.

by james.noblitt

ERP(I) and ERP II are nothing more than software that allows an enterprise to process data and information that helps enable necessary business processes. ERP, by nature of the integration of functions, also allows an enterprise to better integratetheir operations. That is it! How an enterprise chooses to utilize their ERP is up to them. My experience, as a consultant, would indicate that the vase majority of the "disappointing results of ERP" and self induced. That is, most companies simply don't implement their ERP in a way that will make it successful. They are typically poorly run/managed businesses that, although they spent millions on ERP, still have a poorly run/managed business. As far as ERP being here to stay; of course it is. Enterprises will always need software to enable their business processes. Vendors and consultants may have come up with a new name to mitigate the bad press ERP has been getting over the years but it will certainly be around forever. The opportunity is there to get those poorly run/managed businesses on track. We will either help them fix their broken ERP or implement something new, e.g., ERP under a new name.

by aonwell

2000 caught (or divided) IT organizations into two basic parts. One fixing the legacy ERP systems that still had bugs undetected after the new year, and having to implement new ERP systems with a lot of hype (some which just didn't prove out). Experience taught IT to do the same Y2K testing of any new system. In the meantime, advances in CRM and eCRM at the corporate level outdistanced the new ERP systems resulting in new requirements for connectivity. Introductions of new OSs and more powerfulhardware platforms helped to ensure that networked computing was ready for prime time. ERP systems developed on older technology were retired to that of a legacy system and IT organizations began architecture work on ERP II. To much "Internet Time" has expired for 2000 ERP systems to gain any momentum and the winning vendor(s) will be those that move to market with ERP II systems.

by plantogo2000

ERP will never become the vanilla application implementation touted by vendors or consultants. When ERP II was initiated, the gravestone was set. This was validated when TechRepublic looked for ERP success stories and the ?pickins? were few to slim.

ERP is difficult because it encompasses the entire enterprise and attempts to standardize a business process that requires change and flexibility. ERP has become a technology card and it cannot be played as a wild card or as a separate hand.Add to this that ERP depends completely on people. Hardware and software in total are markedly less important than the people that make the enterprise work. Forgotten is that it is people under leadership that solve problems and provide solutions.
Every enterprise including those in the same industry is different and there is no single system or consultant template. The vendor or consultant expects to install a boiler plate system while the business stands still.

The second element withleadership necessary for system success is training. Without leadership, training is an exercise in futility. ERP companies and consultants can train till they are blue in the face. Trained employees directed by a vendor or a consultant won?t work. Any effective system implementation must be a tool of the enterprise leaders.

The only effective mechanism that satisfies the customer is leadership combined with training. Any substitute is hoopla and five years of ERP is evidence of an idea that has served its time. Let?s get on with life in the IT lane and stop the tail from wagging the dog.

In contrast, CRM and KM are reasonable alternatives and replacements to ERP and this is the reason why the change in focus is being accepted so readily.

by lihou

If the millenium issue had not existed, the high growth in ERP pre y2k wouldn't have either. Growth would have been driven by the dynamic to increase back office systems integration. However, IT vendors were forced to divert R&D to fixing y2k and reduced investment in 'fashion technologies' leaving an opening for new players to provide point solutions for e commerce, crm, scm, etc. This will once again result in poorly integrated systems until the ERP (II) vendors build in what remains of the real business requirements to the back office. Customers didn't buy ERP with a real focus on ROI, they bought it because they needed it as much as their production lines. The fashion technologies will provide some ROI, but despite best of breed considerations, customers will not want to manage multiple supplier relationships. Experience has proved this is too problematic. So when some pain has been experienced, the ERP II vendors have an opportunity if they are ready.

This discussion is closed to new replies.