Discussion Locked

IT industry failing due to Insourcing (H1B) or Outsourcing?

0 helpful
35 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Why is it so unpopular to be a US citizen these days? So many in the US, including IT professionals, moms and pops and college grads have bought in to the "media-hype" about globalization and the need to compete with the "best and the brightest" in other countries... really?

No, the shift in IT jobs, from the US to other countries) isn't about skill set, experience or qualifications... rather as many of you know, it's about who can do the work the cheapest$! Clearly, an unfair disadvantage for US IT workers, who paid college tuition in the US, has a high cost of living, and who simply cannot compete with someone who can live comfortably earning $10 per hour.

Although the US Non-immigration guest worker program has documented rules and guidelines for safe-guarding US jobs, they watch as US corporations find 'loop holes' and continue socially irresponsible practices, which harm US IT workers...In the meantime, while the government continues to put US workers at a clear disadvantage, ... IT workers are told to re-invent themselves, ... accept it and stop "whining". I shake my head, much like Scooby, hhhmmmm?

The logical answer is that IT workers, in specified areas (e.g. Help Desk, support, QA and some programming) simply cannot compete in this scenario that the US government/ corporations have created. In all cases when possible, the company is going to chose the "cheapest" option, plain and simple; fair competition, skill set, experience, education, interviewing skills... sadly none of this is part of the equation. A sad reality that they treat US jobs, US workers like "widgets" to be traded for higher corporate profits.

What's worse, is those who've bought in, those who use fuzzy logic, or no logic, and tell the unemployed IT worker to stop "whining", really this sort of thing really drives me nuts...

What can be done, or what should be done is part of another discussion, however for starters we can stop underestimating the concerns, experience, education, and skill-set of those IT workers from the US, who have lost a jobs to insourcing, or outsourcing... If we buy into the hype and accept this as so called competition, well... we're buying into non-truths; hurting the morale of unemployed US workers; allowing US jobs/and training opportunities to be lost, and naturally we risk a loss of potential opportunities for college grads and those thinking about getting into IT.

One poster recommended I talk about what can be done, so here it goes =)
-1 Learn about these issues and write your politicians about e-verify, Doha Rounds, and the impacts of the H1B program.

-2 Write the Obama administration and ask about the promise made to raise taxes on companies who off-shore US jobs.

-3 Support unemployed, US workers and stop suggesting they are not the best and brightest...=) or that they should just accept it and move on... In a sense yes you have to accept everything that comes you're way; however there are things that can be done... refrain from hype and bogus talk.

-4 Blog, email, talk about how Insourcing/ and Outsourcing has impacted you! Were you forced out of a job? Are you unable to find a job? Was your job assumed by a "guest worker"?

35 replies

by santeewelding

Sinks your platform.

And, since you don't mark it with quotes, but carry it unadorned, part and parcel of your premise, I conclude you think there to be such a state -- "reality" -- ascertainable if only you can garner enough answers with your post.

by megabaum

Yep I think you got me... I am biased with my own opinion, however want to learn more about what others are thinking about the issue, or non-issue, to be fair. ... there's a pretty substantial gap in thinking regarding all of this.

Best.

by ansugisalas

How do you think it all works?
Why do you think india is getting helpdesk services outsourced to them?
Do you think India's best and brightest are doing helpdesk?
Do you think it's wrong to attract foreign experts the US? And why? Did a nobel-prize class immigrant steal your job? Or will s/he create your next one?
Do you think the wheel, once invented can be uninvented?
India has a large english-speaking population capable of doing acceptable quality work for less.
Do you think they will remain cheap forever?
Do you think China will remain cheap?
What do you think can be done?
What do you think should be done, even if it can't?

by ansugisalas

It was a recommendation, not a laudation. Sorry.
You could answer those questions you know.
Simplified populist agitprop will do no good.
If you're competing with India's "best and brightest", then you can get a job anywhere, anytime. Odds are you're not, no offence.

by megabaum

Okay dude, I went socratic, ... if it's a laudation oh well...=P Clearly I'm passionate... but perhaps you don't like reading very much? no offense =) I'm more interested in your thoughts on the issue... but thanks for the extra added critique.

Do you have a job in IT? Still in school? Have you ever worked in the US?

Best

by j-mart

But it only works for some, the rest of us just pay for it, with our jobs, disappearing lifestyles and the collapse of the world we grew up in. We, just like the indigenous peoples that once happily lived in the lands we colonized and stole from them, have slowly but steadily been seduced by shiny trinkets, cheap consumer goods produced in sweatshops in under developed countries in conditions and wages unacceptable to us to work under.

Of course, us working in the "Professions " did not care when it was the blue collar workers making clothing, appliances and the other "shiny trade goods" we purchase to make us feel good and look important, we were just "over the moon" at how cheap these trinkets have become, those damn local workers, if they are too lazy to work as hard as me and be competitive with some sweat shop worker in the east working in a hell hole for a dollar a day or less, that's their tough luck, the should learn to work as hard as me. By the way have you seen my new plasma TV boy was it cheap.

IT workers, and other professions welcome to the new world order. Those with no money or power have already been screwed, the middle classes are just starting to get screwed, the rich are just dandy, they have found a much cheaper source of sweat, they have never had it better, more cash than they know what to do with and they can buy more for less with it.

But don't worry, all things go in cycles, in a thousand or so years, if we don't screw up the planet, in the meantime, we will eventually be the third world, emerging, hungry for a dollar, and they will be the tired old first world just starting to crumble under the pressure.

But my money is on us either screwing the planet or blowing it up before then.

by j-mart

And of course the hope is that it all turns to custard after we kick the bucket and it becomes the next generations problem

by boxfiddler Hot topic

exist 'only' as concepts we use to make judgments. 'Reality' doesn't give a crap about fair.

by ansugisalas

Fair is what gives me an icecream cone, while it prevents the other guy from having it.
Unfair is the same situation from the other guys perspective. :p

On the other hand, is it fair that people who've been on the receiving end of the sewer get to do flushing for a change? India has been standing in line for a long time, and have been doing it's homework. Heck they even knew enough to get nukes without permission, so, what can you do?

Ultimately, for IT, I don't see the problem like it's presented. Do people expect a tech field that's the same as in their parent's time? Things change, niches change, to live is to adapt. To stand still is the kind of bravery few can afford.

But I think there are limits to outsourcing, and the security problems work to the advantage of on-site techs.
There's limits to what you can afford to put out of reach of your power switch.

by megabaum

Agreed, it seems you don't seem to grasp the problem.

Boy if the US populous had your attitude, we as a country would have NEVER succeeded in changing policies that were harmful to our society... yes things change, but we (US citizens) do not, and should not sit around letting life happen, even if it sucks and just accept it... Uh no, if there's a negative change on the horizon well, we're there to raise the issue and make changes...

Interesting that you imply, it's NOT Okay for parents/ and US workers to "want" their kids to have a good life, just as they had. Really? Dude that's what this discussion is about! You seem to miss the point.

Of course we WANT our children to have the same Tech opportunities (and other) that we had. Obviously, within reason, we understand that things have changed, jobs have been lost, the IT industry has been impacted, ... we have no choice but to deal with it; however we shouldn't suggest to anyone that we accept poor policy, or unfair treatment as the status quo!

Yes we want the US government to be "fair" and naturally want our politicians to enforce existing laws which protect US jobs. Do we all remember when Obama said that he was going to impose a higher tax on companies that off-shore US jobs to other countries? So if he fails to do this, should I sit back and have a smoke and say 'oh well life just isn't fair'? HA =P no way.

We need to stay on top of these issues and hold Washington accountable. ****And if something isn't fair, raise a stink, whine, complain, post, blog, speak out, whatever it takes. And we do NOT and should not be told we have to accept harmful policies quietly and cheerfully smile, as we watch IT jobs, careers and opportunities go down the drain. It's actually a bit irresponsible for anyone to even suggest this... IMO.

Anwho, the whole globalization thing has run amuck, ... sadly so many have bought in and try to suggest that the US should accept this as reality or destiny (more baloney smoke), with very little understanding of the harmful impacts, or the imbalance in trade between the US and other countries. No please don't try to gloss over real social issues, with economics, or the desire for 'globalization' or corporate profits.

Yes there will always be trade, imports and exports, ... But these issues go way beyond general trade and imports. We are people, we're citizens which hold this country together, ...NOT widegts, subjects or things... to be traded.

Best

by boxfiddler Hot topic

in that I think it 'impossible' for 'fair' to exist in a socio/political/economic system that is based in money as opposed to skill.

Money based wealth acquisition is a skill that not all possess.

by ansugisalas

I was suggesting you investigate your premise, the mind broadens from the inside, don't you know? Socrates knew that he knew nothing, which made him stand out among the truly ignorant.
I read your post and made counterquestions to start from. You can answer those, or you can implode, and bravely run away, away.

by megabaum

ansugeisler,

I understand that you don't bring any practical IT experience or knowledge of US policy, much less an understanding of these issues... But the lesson on Socrates has been interesting.

Good luck in your studies =P

by santeewelding

While not old and seasoned, he is no kid in school, either. I suspect he, like others here, calls himself "student" purely for the recognition that we all are no more than students.

I know I am...in all things.

To pull the tech bit, [b]megabaum[/b], as a way of putting down perceived inferiority with your perception of your own superiority does not fly with me.

No more than did your wholesale change to your original post without explanation, leaving my response about reality twisting in the wind. I also remind you that my response was decidedly untech -- therefore not to your original point?

by megabaum

...K that hurts a little.

Sorry you didn't like the wholesale change, to clarify, I was actually trying to take ansugeisler's suggestion to be Socratic, (laughing) in my own way. UR right I was also presumptuous about his experience, or lack thereof,... I could be wrong, but it was kind of bratty. Also didn't realize I left your thought (re: reality) trailing in the wind, sorry I'm not clear on what you mean by that. I generally do a better at listening and understanding other points of views with these types of discussions, but clearly not this time =P Sorry.

If that's all, I'm going to go lick my wounds. My boe is not going to be happy if I spend any more time posting this weekend... house and yard work today.

~Bye for now

by santeewelding

You argue at a level with those who argue oppositely; not unlike abortion, or socialism, or concretization versus abstraction.

You will remain at the level until you climb out of it.

by megabaum

You are mysterious, I like that... but you argue in riddles, with a sense of urgency and superiority which leave us more ignorant folk (>insert sarcasim) feeling confounded and inferior. It's seems your style, but not one I haven't seen before. =)

In English next time, K?

by santeewelding

Like [b]ansugeisler[/b] parade in the plural beyond yourself -- "us more ignorant folk" -- assuming their constitution yours?

In which case, yours is Sanskrit; not mine.

Yard work, remember? Before you put your other foot in your mouth.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

it's worth noting that in speaking for others ([i]us more ignorant folk[/i]) you engage in multiple presumption. That of knowing the intelligence of others, and that of presuming it less (or more, as the case may be) than the intelligence of another - whether yourself or santeewelding or me or God...

It may well be that presumption is at the root of [i]feeling confounded and inferior[/i].

This is a thing I but barely grasp, yet it strikes me as of incredible importance as regards 'self'.

by santeewelding

Is an affront to God, the omniscience of which you parade in order to make the statement.

Do it again -- any way, shape, or fashion -- and I abandon all hope for ye.

by ansugisalas

...reliant upon it's recipient for interpretation?
I understand not.
Does not compute.
Say again?
If Pi=4 Then e=Pi/2!

by ansugisalas

The problem is this: the discovery that some IT functions are outsourcable to India happened already.

The non-problem is this: you'll get work anyway, just different work. The IT field is just different. Some parts have been outsourced, but not everything can, and not everybody wants to.
The IT field changes all the time anyway, so you can't really feel cheated.

Besides, soon indians are going to be too expensive, and there's not that many other populations with similar prerequisites, so things will stabilize.
The US policy of H1b visas is another non-issue (for you guys), it's called brain-drain, and it strengthens your economy at the expense of those of the "donor" countries (a better term would be unwilling organ banks), who have spent nonexistant resources on training professionals only to have them up and leave for the land of milk and honey.
So, yes, it is a wage depresser.
But ultimately it increases the power of the US economy and hence synergistically increases the success and hiring power of US companies.

Globalization is. It screws over a lot of things. But it's not the US governments doing, and the US government can no more stop it or slow it down than it could have stopped or slowed down Katrina.

Anyway, the fact remains, the security development means that being physically present is going to be a huge advantage in the future. If a server is botnetted to smithereens then a tech out in India can do only so much.

by ansugisalas

And I also was wondering about that "really", it seemed a foreing strain of mysteriousness :p

@megabaum: it's funny that you thought I was being bratty. I thought the same of you :p
But if you ever want to discuss the global impacts of brain drain, or strategies for adapting to a changing ecological niche, or you need a study mate when you're taking hindi-lessons when India starts outsourcing it's helpdesk functions to the US, let me know :)

by megabaum

Bud easy, I was referring to me being bratty, not you.

And even if I was working in Help Desk, which I'm not, that was a pretty crappy thing to say. My job isn't being outsourced and it won't be in the future, that's now why I'm posting, but enough said...

It's been real, but not real fun.

by ansugisalas

...if I had meant it as you read it.
As it is, it's a mere extrapolation from your own assumed scenario.
And as the indians doing help desk right now can tell you, you don't look a hard-currency paycheck in the mouth when you're living in a clay hut. :p

by megabaum

Correction, it was a simple, misunderstanding, not a mere extrapolation from my own assumed scenario =). Anyhow, I went back and re-read your post and realized that's not what you meant...my bad=P

by av .

Face it. Its never going to be what it once was again. Insourcing, Outsourcing, etc. are here to stay and we'll have to compete globally for jobs from now on.

Its never been about the abilities of IT people in the US, its about money. We can't compete with cheap labor. Theres something else though. Now, companies can cherry-pick workers from around the world, instead of settling for people that live there.

AV

by ansugisalas

"we can't compete with cheap labor"
I'm not sure about that. Not entirely at least.
I mean, look at blue collar jobs.
They still exist. Even in very expensive countries.
In some european countries minimum wage is in the range 15-20 USD per hour(depending on exchange rates), and with legislated rights to paid vacations, sick leave etc. etc. and yet, people still get jobs building things that could easily be built somewhere cheaper and just shipped in. How's that?

I think there's something being overlooked here.

by av .

Smaller places don't outsource. Theres still opportunity. Still, I learned everything I know at big companies and I don't think that opportunity is there today for future techs because of outsourcing.

Blue collar jobs are different.

AV

etu

This discussion is closed to new replies.