Discussion Locked

IT Security, Privacy, Use and the Law

0 helpful
1 reply
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
blog root

1 reply

by matthew yurksaitis

Blog to Dicussing the field of IT Security, Privacy, Use and the Law as it pertains to both Business and the General Consumer. This is one of the hottest topics of the day. The question often asked is "Has the Law Caught up with IT/Technology", the more appropriate question is have those in IT/Technology brushed up on thier Business Law & General Law 101?. Most discussions in the technology field around security, privacy and use typically center around the "mode or method" used to committ a potential crime, and forget the basic concepts and principles of law. This blog will attempt to cover the legal perspective as well as the techology perspective and invites input and feedback from legal professionals as well as technology professionals.

Here is some legal verbage to consider as part of this Blog:

Here is the text of computer security crimes used in a few different states as well as in federal law. Sec. 53a-251. Computer crime. (a) Defined. A person commits computer crime when he violates any of the provisions of this section. (b) Unauthorized access to a computer system. (1) A person is guilty of the computer crime of unauthorized access to a computer system when, knowing that he is not authorized to do so, he accesses or causes to be accessed any computer system without authorization. (2) It shall be an affirmative defense to a prosecution for unauthorized access to a computer system that: (A) The person reasonably believed that the owner of the computer system, or a person empowered to license access thereto, had authorized him to access; (B) the person reasonably believed that the owner of the computer system, or a person empowered to license access thereto, would have authorized him to access without payment of any consideration; or (C) the person reasonably could not have known that his access was unauthorized. (c) Theft of computer services. A person is guilty of the computer crime of theft of computer services when he accesses or causes to be accessed or otherwise uses or causes to be used a computer system with the intent to obtain unauthorized computer services. (d) Interruption of computer services. A person is guilty of the computer crime of interruption of computer services when he, without authorization, intentionally or recklessly disrupts or degrades or causes the disruption or degradation of computer services or denies or causes the denial of computer services to an authorized user of a computer system. (e) Misuse of computer system information. A person is guilty of the computer crime of misuse of computer system information when: (1) As a result of his accessing or causing to be accessed a computer system, he intentionally makes or causes to be made an unauthorized display, use, disclosure or copy, in any form, of data residing in, communicated by or produced by a computer system; or (2) he intentionally or recklessly and without authorization (A) alters, deletes, tampers with, damages, destroys or takes data intended for use by a computer system, whether residing within or external to a computer system, or (B) intercepts or adds data to data residing within a computer system; or (3) he knowingly receives or retains data obtained in violation of subdivision (1) or (2) of this subsection; or (4) he uses or discloses any data he knows or believes was obtained in violation of subdivision (1) or (2) of this subsection. (f) Destruction of computer equipment. A person is guilty of the computer crime of destruction of computer equipment when he, without authorization, intentionally or recklessly tampers with, takes, transfers, conceals, alters, damages or destroys any equipment used in a computer system or intentionally or recklessly causes any of the foregoing to occur.

If one reads the language of the text the components of the crime are spelled out:

1. Unauthorized use - using something (property or license) without permission from the owner or license holder/user.

2. Knowledge & Intent - the person commiting the act has or is presumed to have "reasonable knowledge" that there is an owner or license holder, and that there is a fee for the property or license use.

3. The owner or license holder (in most cases consumer or business) incurrs financial, real, character, or personal harm, or loss due to the act committed by the offending party.

In short the law basically states that any person having reasonable knowledge to know that computer devices & systems have an owner or license user, and willfully and intentionally access and use these devices and services without the express consent  of the owner/licensee (unauthorized use) is committing a computer crime.

While one can attempt to justify activity such as "wardriving" or variations on it by presenting arguments around the mode or method used to conduct "free opportunistic internet access" at somone else's expense as "legal" because there have not been any prosecutions to date (at least that they could find) the law clearly states different as shown above. So is the question has the Law caught up with technology, or should it really be "Has the law caught up with Technology People who flaunt with the Law?" - What are your thoughts?

This discussion is closed to new replies.