Discussion Locked

IT Staff Ratio

0 helpful
91 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello,

Does anyone know the industry standard IT Staff Ratio or have any formulas that could be applied.

We have 225 employees and 3 IT staff support these support users globally.

Thanks,

91 replies

by jamesrl

It depends on a number of factors:

1) role of the IT support staff - what do they do, this varies extensively from place to place.

2) complexity of the environment. If everyone is in one building, they have one file server, one mail server and they all use the same applications, its lower. If there is a mix of technologies (Windows/Unix/Linux) or (Oracle/SQL server) its higher.

3) seniority/skillset of the employees.

4) Service levels - what is the expectation of how soon things get resolved? Is there after hours support for servers? Users?

I know when my company used to pay Gartner big bucks so I could ask them questions like this, thats the kind of answer I got.

I could get some numbers, like how many Help desk employees, or how many desktop technicians, but even then it depends on how you decide to focus your energy - if you focus on remote tools and first call resolution, you can have more help desk and fewer desktop techs. If you decide not to provide support on MS office tools, you can use fewer people. Gartner also used to track based on industry codes (SIC). They also classified businesses based on their use of technology - A companies use IT as a key business driver, B companies are the mainstream, C companies see IT as a cost and use the bare minimum. You require more staff for A than B, more B than C etc.

Hope that round about answers your question.

edited for addition

James

by lindsayau

James pretty well covered it.

I have 2 techs covering three geographical locations - each with multiple "sites". Maximum 100 users at any one time, 7 servers at 2 locations. We have the ratio this high simply because of the level of support expected. I could do the whole thing myself with a laptop, a tool kit, and a car; however the organisation wants (not needs) "now" responses. We don't even run SQL server anywhere yet, but when it comes I'll probably scale up by 1 more in order to support the soon-to-be core business services it will provide.

Horses for courses. The requirements are developed through careful analysis of your Service Level Agreements (grin).

by rob mekel

There are several links on TR covering this issue.
Did some research for you but there are more.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11179-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=178482&messageID=1816981

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11179-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=176341&messageID=1792273

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11179-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=187615&messageID=1921796

are some of them.

Just put "staffing" in to the search field and y'll get them all.

BTW Gartner has a White Paper on this. It's not free but does give you some good hands-on on the subject.

Rob

by mr.wiz

I wish we only had 225 users with three techs, sounds relatively easy to me. We've got 5 techs supporting 20 sites, 3500 pc's 30 servers, and 15,000 users.

by purecoffee

How on God's green earth do you all do this with 5 techs? This is incredible to me! Are most end users technically proficient?

by mr.wiz

I'm in a K-12 education environment. We do everything from desktop support and hardware/software repair and installation to network. It's kind of hard to keep up at times. We normally carry 100-150 open work orders at any time.

by debidaugherty

I'm one IT person for a company with 7 locations.... but only about 150 computers and users and 3 servers.... WHEW!!!

by xyza

My first help desk job consisted of supporting over 1,000 users in almost 200 locations nationwide. I was the ONLY tech. It started out as 3 techs, 2 quit and weren't replaced due to budget cuts. Needless to say, I lasted about 9 months and quit because of burnout.

by shawn

In the ruaral & remote health industry of Aust. there are three of us covering (poorly) 96 internal clients and ~150 external. I have just had the conversation with the boss for another ICT staff member to do more of the "help desk' allowing one member to concentrate more on our 11 servers (virtual + real), one to concentrate more on our external clients and myself to do a bit more of the planning-side of ICT.

by lafatlife

I am one of 2 technicians for our entire school district. Granted it is a small one with just over 1000 students and staff located in 3 schools, but we also have 10 servers and the two of us provide all the help. We have over 500 pc's to deal with.

It would be great if we could hire another tech, but we just don't have the money.

by baylady

In college, this was addressed and I remember that the ratio was 2hr/week per user (support, app writing, training, etc.) and 10 hrs/week devoted to the network itself. Upgrades, patches, maintenance, etc.
Probably outdated now with the additional functions we do but that is the only formula I've ever seen.

by baylady

College was a while back! The ratio was 2hrs/mo/user and 10hrs/mo/network, servers,etc.

LU

by capnpauly

If there is a 'ratio', it's unknown to me. :(

At my company, we have appx. 350 PCs and 30 servers. For that number of systems we have one hardware/network tech (me) and one software/phone tech, but we're the 'main' support group. We also do most of our programs in-house (we have 5 programmers and two project leads who also support their programs), and of course our network admin.

by ray.drummond

I remember hearing a few years back that it was like 1 tech to every 80 users or something like that. It was in response to me trying to get more IT people on staff at a company that I was working with.

by w2ktechman

but a few years ago I was told the industry was moving to 1 deskside person for each 250-400 users. Of course, this didnt include helpdesk, netadmins, etc. And this was the 'corporate model' for large companies

by rclark2

A lot depends on what else you have to do. We do a lot of hand holding and functions that are a hold over from the "Data Processing" era of computing. So a lot of our normal day to day is not actually IT tech.

There is also a sweet spot between 5 and 12 techs where everyone knows everyone elses job and you can do more with less. After you get over 12 to 15, the networks and systems get so complex that you have to specialize the support to keep everything running smoothly. At that point, you start losing the efficiency of multiple person support for each job and redundancy in personnel starts costing additional FTE's. I'm sure there is a multiple somewhere, but currently, we haven't hit it.

I currently (for the last 15 years) work in healthcare and you see pretty much the entire IT support equation in micro. A little bit of everything with pretty large transaction volumes, web support, mainframes, subnets, graphics, the works. So help desk, network admin, programming, systems, and database admin, we get a little of everything. Getting in house support for all of the functions mean that most of us have to be multiple discipline support.

by dmorse

This discussion has been going on and talked about for years. A while back this same thread was posted and a TechRepublic member, whom I forget the name, provided all that wanted it, an "IT supporting staff ratio" sheet. This sheet provided some formulas and calculations that one could use to determine adequate /appropriate staffing levels.
I have a copy for all who want it. Too bad I can't post here for download... If you reply with an e-mail address, I will forward. Please be patient and I will check back every so often.

by chrisfc

I'd appreciate a copy of the sheet to
chrisfc@blueyonder.co.uk

trying to get some documentation on this for my finance boss.

by idratherbdiving

I'd like to see the sheet you talked about. We currently have very high PC support ratios. On average we are aroun 350 PC's per support person. I would like to ask for more help but don't have the numbers to back it up.

by carzer

I would be interested in this formula. Please send to carzer@bradburyco.com. Thanks.

by peterop

have got to prove to the management by way of statistics aneed for a support staff. Plz send me the a bove named sheet.tnx

by bailey_kt

Is difficult to understand all the details and complexity around staff ratio, I agree it depends on the type of service you provide, no. desktops, servers, databases, customers, locations and response time required for resolution - I struggle every day with the same situation. I currently have on the Service Desk 8 staff members answering approx 14,000 p/month for 4 customer agencies across the state of Queensland, Australia. My customers are rearly happy with the call abn, rate and time to answer. Iwould love a copy of your spreadsheet.

by syoung2007

Please send me a copy of the "IT supporting staff ratio" sheet tp syoung@judsonisd.org
Thanks!

by n7ybh

I was just asked to review the help desk. Can you please e-mail me a copy of the worksheet to pbrunson@gmail.com? Thank you.

by toby

can you send the staff ration sheet to

toby (at) littlebrain (dot) com

thanks!!

by theresa.rodrigues

Hello - can you send me the file that everyone has been asking for - I am researching staffing ratios in my industry and would appreciate your assistance.

thanks terry

by rwallis54

Just came across this while doing a search on staffing. If this ratio sheet is still available, I would love to have it! Please forward to "rwallis@unicefusa.org".

Thanks much in advance.

by richard.sanford

This Staff Ratio spreadsheet sounds like it is just what we are looking for... at least as another reference point.

Please send it to me at RichSanfordJr@gmail.com

Thanks in advance...

by key_it

If you're still checking replies to this post, I'd really like a copy of that sheet please :)

joe_gallacher@yahoo.co.uk

by dmgay

If you are still checking posts, please email file to dmgay@aol.com.

Thanks for your help!

by skatz

I just tuned in to this discussion -- if you are still able to send a copy of that report, I would really appreciate it. Email: skatz@savechldren.org

Thank you.

by rudy.gallegos

If you still checking, I would appreciate if you can send me a copy of the IT Supporting Staff Ratio Sheet.

rudy.gallegos@prosum.com

by eitm

I continue to research this topic - IT Staff Ratio many years on. If this post gets through, I would like to look at and assess the worksheet for my purposes.

Warm regards,
Darren Ramsey
eitm@ramstech.com.au

by kbooth

I, too, would aprpeciate a copy of your staffing ratio worksheet. Please send to kbooth at benchmarkpt dot com.

Thanks!

by itulei3

If you still have it, I would also appreciate the excel file. My email is itulei3 [at] gatech [.] edu

by pneufeld

I'm working on developing some staffing ratio models. Might you forward me the worksheet? Thanks Kindly

by raul

If you could forward to raul@bleumasters.com I will appreciate it

Raul

by stephenmoriarty

In my last job I started supporting about 120 computer users and 190 pbx users. three gegraphic locations with about a 20 min ride to any one of them. And never had any help but I got by and thrived in a Time management hell. Thankfully and dissapointingly the company kept consolidating and when it closed I had 70 computer users 100pbx and one location.

by rkuhn040172

We're about 50/1 right now but it depends on many factors.

For example, we have many remote sites and each remote site only has maybe 3 employees each.

Nonetheless, each site has a router, PIX, 2-3 PC's, VPN, cable/DSL, etc. A high equipment to employee ratio.

So a high equipment to employee ratio plus geographically dispersed hurts. Throw in the servers, network, websites, etc and 50/1 seems appropiate here.

by rclark2

It really depends on your company attitude towards IT. IT viewed as an unavoidable expense or as an opportunity for growth and progress?

If you have one of those cut costs at all costs bean counters, the formulas won't make much of a difference. What you have to do there is to cost justify the new person/people. You take the cost of the person .vs. what they will save the company by being there.

Unfortunately, lots of the gains in additional people are intangible unless you are so snowed under that projects are bogged down and new equipment is still in the boxes long after the invoice has been paid.

by capnpauly

That's very true.
Quite a few people kind of 'look down' on IT because we're a pure expense. And seeing as how I work for a manufacturing company, a lot 'look down' on us because we're not getting our hands dirty (litteraly) with the rest of them.

Luckily, the upper-managment have a good understanding of what it is we do and that we're here to help productivity and keep corporate information safe, and that does help quite a bit whenever we look to start a new project (whether it invloves a 'new' labor cost or not).

by too old for it

... we had 3 for a staff of 50. THen again, we did kiosk sales, and sales staff turnover was in the 300% range.

by rouschkateer

225:3 is an awesome ratio!

We have 3 different facilities and over 800 employees. 382 computers, over 150 printers, and telephone lines...not to mention user accounts, software help/troubleshooting/repair and off-site technical help. We receive requests for help via e-mail, phone messages, phone calls, or faxes.

There are three of us at Help Desk.

I believe that ONE person can do the job...it is all about procedures and policies.

We are a Nursing Home, so please do not assume we are a technically-based company. Nurses are awesome to troubleshoot with ...no offense, nurses.

by mphillips

I am the manager of the 'help desk' funtion for our company........almost 900 computers, over 30 servers, 65 locations, approximately 850 users, 6 technicians.

by rkuhn040172

I keep hear 100's to 1 and have a hard time believing you are delivering the same quality of service and turn around time that others like myself are that are more like 50-100/1.

Again, there are too many factors that influence this.

But my job includes everything from routers, PIX's, servers, networking, macros, Office, printers, VPN's, telecom, conference room setups, replacing equipment, SQL, Access, intranet, websites, VB.net, new office setups, training, etc.

Most all is done same day but definitely within 24 hours.

There is no way I could support 100's of users and provide the same level of support and turn around time.

It is a matter of priority, budget, etc but don't sell yourself short. IT is a vital part of any organization. Resist the urge to cheapen it.

by rclark2

Some of the posts are talking about a ration of 1:2000 and others 1:100.

Obviously, those are not comparable and the service can not be comparable.

Several things go into those numbers that we really need to pin down before comparing numbers.

First, where primary support is. Are the support functions offsite (call center) or onsite. Second, what is meant by techs. Third what kind of support are we talking about. Do you mean system analysis, networking problems, operating system problems, driver loading, mouse cleaning, or user assistance?

I think that if you have inhouse developed software, you will probably have lower ratios. If you purchase everything, those FTE's are at the software house and don't count on your ratio. But comparing the two, someone looks overworked and others like they are loafing.

by jamesrl

and had a chance to ask the analysts about this subject. They said basically what I said, just in a more impressive style.

James

by mckinnej

Newer technology generally requires less people to support it. For example, the USMC just released an RFP for running their application hosting environment for the entire Marine Corps. They state in the SOW that they don't expect more than 4 people in the center. That's 4 folks supporting the entire USMC. Kinda makes your ratio look a little better, doesn't it? :-)

The reason they can do that is that they have spent (our) big bucks on a state of the art hosting environment that 4 people really can manage. It reminds me of the graphs I've seen regarding the number of personnel it has historically required to support various aircraft. I don't remember the exact numbers, but each B-17 took over 20 people, whereas a F-22 takes less than half-a-dozen, and it is a much more complicated aircraft. The reason...technology.

by oscaro

From past experience I would say that up to 100 / Techie would be more appropriate. The trick here is that you provide Global support which implies different time zones and possibly require 24 hours of staffed support. In this case you would have to evaluate how many users require support during what hours. Then how many Techies have to be available at what times. In your case 3 Techies may not be enough, and require having to go to a 4th. The time/user analysis is crucial for proper coverage.

by rkuhn040172

Finally someone on here with more than half a brain.

How many people posted their real email address on here?

Hope they have a good spam filter.

by elandis

heh.
but i dint get the file yet.. has anyone?

useing temporry addresses rocks. because once you done with it, you add it to spam rule, and it helps build your dynamic filters because they get 100% spam.

by the admiral

We have a 1 person per hundred ratio here. Now when we do rollouts and the like, we bring a contractor on to fill that roll, but after the fact, they are let go.

by ezio_bobbato

I realize this thread was posted a few years ago but I was hoping you still have the 'IT support staff ratio' calcualtion worksheet. If so, I'd appreciate it if you can email it to me at ... ezio.bobbato@invescotrimark.com.

Thanks

by joannklein

Greetings!

I am currently managing a project that is going to ramp up quickly and I need to put together a document that will support the need for additional IT support help for our patients.

I read that there are documents that already exist that can be used to formulate appropriate support staff:patient ratios.

It would be greatly appreciated if someone could guide me toward this resource.

Thanks,

Jo Ann Klein, MS, RN
Manager, Patient Portal
MedStar Health
Baltimore/Washington DC

by dedlbug

Looks like you just take a Valium and go with the flow. Hey...at least you know you have work. ;)

by rroy

If it is still out there, I would still like a copy. rroy@bjc.org

by fred.clark

I have a presentation from Gartner that provides a ratio of, for level 2, 100 - 250 pcs. I believe the standard has changed from counting employees to counting pcs per staffing. This is because some users have multiple computers. If you would like a copy of this document let me know.

by lmarchel

Hi, I'd greatly appreciate a copy of the report - please send to lmarchel@menominee.edu

We're a small tribal college with a small IT staff, but the number of users, computers, and equipment has doubled in the last 4 years, so we're looking for info.

Thanks much.

by tracy

I would love a copy, as I am trying to justify two positions for my City.

Thank You!
Tracy Gover

by itulei3

I would greatly appreciate a copy of this presentation if you still have it. My email is itulei3 [at] gatech [.] edu

by cathy.brooks

Could you please forward a copy of this presentation to me if it is still available? Thank you. My e-mail is cathy.brooks@mwhc.com

This discussion is closed to new replies.