Discussion Locked

IT Staffing agencies and recruiters are the worst!

0 helpful
224 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

224 replies

by obiwaynekenobi

I recently had a bad experience with recruiters.. about a year ago I applied for a job via one of them, and whenever I would call the recruiter to find out what happened she would say some garbage like "I'm waiting to hear from [hiring manager]." so I would wait a week or so and call again. And she would tell me the same thing and say that she didn't want to keep on calling the person. Said she would let me know definatly what was up in another week, and that was the last I heard of her or her company.

Then, just the other week I met with another one.. I won't name names but the firm is called IT Resources. Guy was trying to get me a tech support job with BrightHouse Networks (cable/internet provider, if you don't know) and I was excited because I have a friend who works for them and they paid for his MCSE. So I follow up with him and, lo and behold he tell me "Unfortunatly, the position may be on hold." Haven't heard anything from him since.

IMO these people are vultures who do nothing but make false promises to already downtrodden IT people. They guarentee that you'll get such and such "great" position and then never follow up with you on the matter, or like with me give you some BS about not being able to get in touch. It's completely ridiculous, and I for one will never go through a recruiter now. It's not worth the hassle.

Just my opinion.

by briandesu

The problem with staffing agencies is that they are sales reps. They want your resume to have nothing but buzzwords for technologies they do not understand.

Entertainment

Recruiter: "Do you know WINS, DNS, HTTP, DHCP?"
Me: Yes
Recruiter: "So, you know those programming languages?"
Me: "Uh, they are network protocols?"
Recruiter: "So, do you know TCP/IP?"

I think the point is made by now.

I find it amazing that companies rely on these twits to determine whether we are qualified for a job, yet they have no understanding of how we fit the equation. ARRRGGGGHHHHH!!!!

by bfilmfan

At that bill rate, we need to change careers DC. I am sure that writing resumes cannot be as complex as architectural documentation.

So today's special, B and D's Resume Rewriter's Special Resume Makeover for Recruiting Scammers! We use all the special keywords in resumes so you don't have to read them! Guaranteed word scanning friendly! Hurry offer won't last long!

And for $19.95 an hour more, we will even teach ya to use email so ya can spam potential employers and candidates!

ROTFL

by tekkydave

I hate these guys. They call you and say, "I got your resume from a year ago, I Got a great job for you, Great salary, and you are totally qualified."

Then, you get all pumped up, you go home, tell the girlfriend, "I got a great call today, I think this could be a good opportunity."

Then you never hear from them again, and if you call the recruiter back, you just get their voicemail.

I think there is a secret society of fake recruiters whose sole purpose is to get out hopes up, and then knock us down. Theyre goal is to keep us downtrodden.

Damn the man.

by beahwolf

...that has been my experience. I've worked with accountant recruiters, legal personnel recruiters, and IT recruiters. All of them do the same thing. They take your credentials, make outrageous promises, then rarely, if ever, contact you again. I've resorted to mining for information from them when I initiate contact. I haven't worked for an agency or recruiter for nearly a decade, but I have managed to find contract work based, in part, on the information that I glean from them.

by shawnbishop

I have had the same experience with agencies, i think they use a hit and miss approach, they assemble as many CV as they can and then submitt all of them to the company looking to employ, the CV that arent succesful are then cast aside and they dont call you back to inform you that your application was unsuccesful.
Where i come from (South Africa) it is even worse due to Affirmative Action and Employment Equity, the companies need to fill a position with unqualified people, and train them to their standards due to the fact they were previuosly disadvantaged.It is quite discouraging.

by mauryyoung

I have dealt with recruiters since 1980. They are a sorry lot. Unfortunately, the industry has AGAIN turned away from straight hiring and going throught these twits. Anything to save the company from paying benefits, workman's comp, additional accounting services or unemployment. I have seen an incredible escalation in illegal activities by these not to bright people. If you get tough with them about the position and in general, try to find out if its worth your time to give them a moment, they will immediately tell you - you have a bad attitude. (I believe they are telemarketers at best)

In May I will be leaving the IT industry forever. Took me a year to figure out what I could do to make more than $10/hr after 25 years of experience and I have.

There appears to be no way around recruiters unless you market yourself. Its very tough and you will have to learn to be savy at lightspeed.

I believe you should slap every recruiter who calls. Too bad its not possible without being charged with assault.

by mauryyoung

I'm an old broad myself and you and I have the same opinions as seen (evidenly) through the same eyes.

Thanks for relieving some of the hostility from working in IT FOREVER.

by clindell

I haven't read the whole thread but all I can say this is legalized prostitution and us the "IT" workers are the prostitutes and the IT Staffing agencies are just pimping us! If they were forced to close their doors more of us would get better paying and longer-term jobs.

by khalidjamali

i had an interview lined by an agency. An hour before the interview they tell me its cancelled after i have taken half the day off and spent the weekend preparing for it. bastards !!

by ccypress

You people are a bit rough. You think recruiters are bad, you should see how many people I have helped get a positions only for them to accept another offer 2 days later...or show up to an interview in jeans...you don't know the half. Trust me, it's a two way street

by dermon1

Sounds to me like you aren't very good at what you do. I've used a recruiter for almost every role I landed, and they always call me back.

by clindell

I said it before & I'll say it again, their pimps. YOU have used them because you have trouble selling yourself or finding companies to talk to. If there were No recruiters we would take out the middle-men and there would be more wages available to the newly hired worker since the recruiter isn't getting a piece of the action.

by jw_mchugh

I don't do input drudge work for free. If they want me to do data entry work then they can damn well pay me.

by yobeech

Hello everyone I have read a lot of the posts about the headhunters that never follow up. It's true I felt the same way many of you have in the past. I was in IT before and have used many recruiters only to experience the same results. Now that I have switched over to IT I'm following with my conviction of not trying to be like those general recruiters out there who have no idea about the industry or their client. I really despised headhunters that never got back to me no matter how often I would call them or bug them. But now being in the business I am meeting with some of my old IT contacts and talking with them about what they do to try and get a better understanding; though I know I won't be an expert on it at least I will have a better grasp of it and I will be honest to my candidates and up front with them as possible. If I don't have jack with them but still I'd like to meet with them about maybe future possibilities. I think a lot of it has to do with timing. IE your skills represent the right skill that the client wants and also the headhunter remembers who you were and what impression you had on them so as to recommend you to their client. The market is get better but its true a lot of IT jobs are being outsourced for contract work so its making my job more focused on finding the really top of the class candidates that have the skills my clients want cuz most big companies dont want to hire perm. staff they are a cost for the company.

Anyhow just try to be optimistic I think things will turn up!

cheers

by pticali

The recruiter's world is changing.

-IT morale is low
-Employee churn has stopped because of the bad job market.
-The ecomony hasn't helped - companies are still looking for cuts
-This isn't looking good for the recruiter.

The average hiring manager is under the gun. They are forced to consolidate multiple job requirements under one person, and the fees the recruiter charges (although a value) still come out of their funds to hire talent. Most companies have implemented strategies to avoid the recruiter as much as possible.

Employee and networking refferals is truly where the jobs come from. Send in a resume for that post on monster? Do you really expect it to be read? 1 out of 2000? No way.

If a contact personally hands your resume to the hiring manager, its much more likely your phone will ring.

by net_prof

I have now been laid off since August after being with my company for the last 2 years. I was laid off for 6 months during that time.

As a result of my job search, I have determined that there are two different types agencies/recruiters. There are the truly professional organizations and there are those that are just in the business of placing bodies - I call them body shops. And I tend to shy away from working with body shops because of how they do business and how they make me feel. These are the companies that want someone to fill a position now, but then never respond back and act as if you are wasting their time if you solicite a response to a perfect position posting.

But another part of it has to be the candidate themselves. You have to understand that right now is an employers market. The recruiters are literally getting flooded with hundreds if not thousands of resumes for each position listed. A lot of candidates will submit themselves for positions that they really are not suited or qualified, with the hopes of getting that next job. Another factor involved is your amount of patience involved with contacting these companies - when you submit your resume are you constantly hounding the company for an update or do you wait and/or follow up no more than twice a week?? Positions with larger companies usually take a period of time and especially now with the holidays just getting over, most companies are just now getting back into their hiring cycles. If the position is a fast moving opportunity and you are truly qualified and a candidate, the company will contact you.

I am in the running for several jobs with several different agencies, one local and the others located regionally. I have also taken steps to build a consulting department with my former boss's business that specializes in EDI, EC, UCCnet and RFID services and systems, so that I can build my own business without having to rely on someone else to want me or hire me.

Another area your resume needs to indicate is what have you been doing while you have been unemployed?? Although I have not added it just yet to my resume, I have stayed busy doing some volunteer work with Excel and Access development for my work and a friend. Shortly I will add this to my resume to reduce the appearance of having been out of work for too many months. If you don't have work to show, some employers and agencies wonder if you have just been sitting around and waiting for your next dream job. Any work or continuing education needs to be clearly represented and added to your resume.

A lot of IT people are qualified in more than one skill. You also need to have multiple resumes available, at least two, to highlight your skills separately in these areas. While I like EDI would like to stay with an EDI job, I also have a great deal of experience with Visual Basic and MS Access. I have prepared a second resume which focuses on these skills separately. This improves my chances of getting hits in more than one area.

by sishir85

The major problem I have had with these recruiting agents is that 99% of them are not qualified to even understand the qualifications and just go by the literal matching of key words in the posted job requirements. It's pathetic how qualified prefessionals have to rely on these so called recruiting agents for job leads..A bunch of monkeys hitting throwing darts will have a better rate of matching jobs to qualified professionals than these people......
There should be some sort of certifications to be a recruiter and companies have to insist that whoever works with them should be certified.......

by sjohnson175

I've been working with VB since 1995 and could make the leap to .Net but just haven't been in a shop that has done so.

In my last search all they cared about was years of .Net experience. The prior 10 years of experience was completely ignored.

by sjohnson175

With independent wealth the last thing I want to do with what little precious time God grants us on this Earth is actively spend it on idiots.

by navgr34

I SAW A JOB POSTED TWICE, TWO DIFFERENT RECRUITERS, SO I DECIDED TO GO FOR ONE OF THEM AND THOSE GUYS WERE NICE AND THEY THOUGHT I QUALIFIED, SO THEY SEND MY RESUME.. TO THE OTHER RECRUITER!!!!!
I GUESS COMPANIES THAT HIRE RECRUITERS ARE IDIOTS, THEY INCREASE THE PRICE !.. A RECRUITER TOLD ME ONCE THAT THEY CHARGE 20% OF MY SALARY.. SO, IF THERE ARE 2 RECRUITERS INVOLVED..DO THE MATH!

by solara2003

Hi Ray,

I here ya buddy, I am having the same problem. These staff
agencies promise you the world. I recently had a interview with a
staff agency, first of all she has no background in IT at all. She told
me she would do everything her power to get me hired. But at the
end, nothing. Even if you wanna get hired directly, your resume
will be sent to a recruiter, it really sucks big time.

by now left tr

I would not waste my time with them anymore either as you clearly don't know much about IT. Windows 2003 Server???

This discussion is closed to new replies.