Discussion Locked

I've built myself into a corner and can't get out

0 helpful
159 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

159 replies

by hseidman

There seems to be a theme in this message thread that assumes that you are not management material. I will begin from the assumption that you do have the talent set needed to move into management. Some of us geeks turn out to be good managers. If you want to move up it is important that there is not a significant hole left behind when you make the transition. The best way to insure this is to mentor one or more of your co-workers so they can solve the problem next time. I do not mean that they can solve the same problem next time but they learn how to analyze a problem and develop creative solutions. When you succeed at this you will have not only demonstrated you leadership and people skills but you will no longer be considered to valuable to promote. Good luck as you pursue you goals.

by tekonsult

People who can really make the change have the least motivation to do so because they benefit from the existing structure, while those who wish for reform have few supporters because human nature tends to wait for success on the part of the reformer before throwing their support in. Just do your job well and look for better opportunities at the same time. The best time to look for a job is when you don't need it...when you have a serious job offer then you will find out how much your company really values you. Best option if I were in your case is to keep up the good work while developing your own consultancy business...

by wgp_enoch

You got to be kidding. Is it extortion if you shop around for a better deal on a car. You have no obligation not to look for other employeement just like they are under no obligation to promote you.

It may be best to leave the company looking for greener pastures if the glass ceiling can't be broken.

by johnjr56az

The Marine only cited a potential scenario. He never stated a fact. And I do have to agree w/him. Civilians (especially those in the upper suits) are very connieving bosses. I've never met one in the civilian world that cound be trusted as far as I could pick threm up and throw them. Even more so, the ones closest to me in the work environment. Your sarcasm and irresponcible outburst is exactly the type of barrier that she's facing in her own dilemma. So take a chill pill and relax for a while before you air any more wisdom!

by bobfairchild

It is not extortion to take care of yourself! You must get an offer from antoher company then take the offer to your company and see what happens. 9 times out of 10 your company will match or beat the offer. I have done this 2 times with excellent results!! Sometime the company just needs you to stand up and say "WHAT ABOUT ME!!"

by pmadiga

Wanting to be a manager and having the skills to be one are two different things. A good manager achieves the corporate goals while fostering individual professional growth. Not knowing all the details, there may be other reasons management doesn't see you as a good fit. In the last 20 years, in 7 different organizations, I can count the number of focused professional managers I've seen on one hand (this include two Fortune 100 companies.) I would say line-up some other potential positions, have a heart to heart about your goals and where you'd like to persue them. Don't make threats, but leave no doubt that keeping your expertise available to in-house staff as a manager would be your preference, as opposed to taking your career path to outside sources. Be prepared to call their bluff, if pressured. It could mean actually taking one of those outside opportunities. By the way, most uber-techies initially make horrible managers. Any respect you command as a tech doesn't immediately transfer to your role as a manager. Also keep in mind that lower or middle managers are highly expendible in troubled budgetary times. Over time, you'll also lose your marketability as a tech, should you decide to go back, so make sure you're not casually testing the waters. Also remember that your staff's failings as a manager are your failings, but their successes are their own (if you're a good manager.)

by rehorst

Want to get back in gear? The easy way is to ask for a big pay raise. This works every time, if you use the right technique. For details, contact me.

by cathel

If you are as good as you say you are then work for yourself. I was in the same position in the company I worked for for 10 years. When the finaly reconised my abilities, so did I and I resigned. I worked last year as a manager of a small company setting up computer accounts and an ordering system. I left that job in July and set up my own company as an IT consaultant. I now find myself with as much income monthly but only working on average 2 days a week. I could earn more money but do I really need the hassel.

by lynnv

It sounds as if you are confident enough to stand up for yourself. Go out and get what you want - look around at other things first - then tell your bosses that you want a change. If they don't respond, then go elsewhere.
Good luck.

by dadavis5th

If you are burning out it means you have not leveraged other resources, people, others time, to offset some of your workload. If you are working to many hours consistently then you are not estimating workload properly. Management may think you own everything you do rather than are a team builder, by investing in others around you and organizing documentation related to your backlog if any, you will start to learn the skills needed to manage others and manage schedules. If you cannot manage your own schedule, it will be hard to manage others.

I know this from experience being very task oriented, rather than resource oriented. Start documenting all of your time, if not done already and see what tasks can be shifted to others. If there are no others available, get management on board to either deprioritize or eliminate tasks or to bring in outside help on a per issue basis. By doing this you will manage the tasks with others and not let all the load fall on yourself.

This will eliminate your burnout and help you to focus on developing management skills.

Alston Davis
dadavis5th@mindspring.com

by Member 22744991

When I first saw this post, I though to myself "Hmmm. . . SELF? I didn't post this . . what's going on?"

I was recently overlooked (our organization went outside to hire), for a promotion into the Information Security arena. This is an area in which I have focused for the organization for a number of years, carried out many of the tasks and responsibilities, and have spent just nearly as many ours outside of the organization learning, much on my own dime. Yes, I had my regular responsibilities to tend to, etc and have received high reviews and personal recommendation for my work.

Considering I just went through this, what do I have planned? What was my reaction? How did I handle it?

This event made me realize a few very important things about myself:

1-This relationship much like other that I have had in the past . . is one way. Someone is giving more than the other. Relationships like this never work out, well . . unless one party is a door mat, which I am not :-)

2-Some people?s personalities do not fit the organization from a management position. An example is, I call a rose a rose, not a "pretty flower with prickly thorns". I tell people how it is. Some people want a sugar coated version, which I refuse to do. I tend to speak with razor blades at time. I admit when I am wrong, and if something is wrong, I say it is wrong, not ?Oh, well this has room for improvement?.

3-There are to many things in life and to focus all your time on learning/working/playing in one area of life (in this case technology) . . . .is a waste . . a waste of you as a human, waste of time for you, and a waste of time for your friends and family! One day, you and everyone else will die and unless you have made some HUGE monumental contribution to technology, you will be forgotten almost before you body is cold, if not my the organizations, then the industry as a whole.

There are many other issues to touch on but the short of it is;

-If you feel slighted, ask the powers that be "what would it take to get to point B"-
-If you feel disrespected, kick the company to the curb-

Life is filled with choices, but as adults, we need to make decisions and live with then, no matter what we decide.

you might be thinking . . ."well he never answered what HE intends on doing?". I'd have to say your right, I have not decided yet . . . but I can tell you, looking somewhere else is high on my list of "to-dos".

by gaston nusimovich

You don't have to stick to just one choice: keep your options open and try a career move on some other company.

Let the market see what you are worth and go for the best.

by dcperich

Often, a person's skill set and experiences have more value to them on their resume than on their current pay check. Your's is a perfect case.

by it & telecom guy

If you have already requested the move and they know you're burned out. Start Your Job Search "Openly" and they'll get the hint. If they don't offer a "change" and pay raise, then be prepared to leave, when you finally give them the two weeks notice. It's been my exprience they'll cave when the see that your serious.
good luck

by a_dangerous_mind

I've been there several times before, and did make the choice to move to other companies. I would advise to assess the political climate in your company, and decide whether you would want to manage in that company. Management does involve a number of tasks that many techies might find that they could not stand for long, such as conducting interviews, formulating job descriptions, writing evaluations, managing budgets, attending meeting after meeting and having to deal with problem employees. Some companies do provide a 'team lead' position as a place where a techie can make a transition from a technical to a managerial position. You might want to see if your current position could be upgraded to this kind of position, where you could develop and prove your managerial skills as well as pass on your knowledge to others.

Technical presentations and training can also hone your public speaking and presentation skills, and give you the chance to demonstrate that you can communicate and sell your knowledge and ideas throughout the organization.

Being a firefighter can also put you into a position where you can formulate and advise organizational and process improvements. It sounds like you might have the skills and perspective to be able to come up with the ways to avoid many of the problems that you've solved over the years. This would also be a valuable managerial skill to develop.

Some of these things can be pursued on your own initiative, within the amount of discretionary direction that we can give in the way we do our jobs from day to day. But developing in these ways would give you more opportunity to demonstrate that you have the potential to be an excellent manager as well as an excellent technician.

by onthego

I've been there. Been the "team lead". What they are kindly telling you is that they don't think you are management material. You'd be best to move on. If this is your aspiration and passion, other companies might think differently.

by a_dangerous_mind

Whether the team lead becomes a manager really depends on the company. If 'team leads' don't become managers in your company eventually, that's a good sign that it is a dead end in your company. If they do, it would probably be a good idea to get some information on how to make the transition from your position to team lead and from there to management. But even if your company only gives lip service to promoting team leads to managers, being a team lead could mean a transition directly to management in another company, if you demonstrate through that position that you are management material despite the myopia in your current company.

by mollybigd

I feel that you deserve the chance to move to another position because it is well deserving. You're good at what you do, but if you're burning out, it isn't good for you to stay in a position to where you can become very unhappy, and maybe begin to hate your job. Your uppers need to let you move on, maybe a good way to compromise is, if upper man. lets you move, you will be willing to train someone to take your old position over.
Uppers problem is, they have become to dependent on you therefore they're afraid to give someone else a try at your position. In my opinion, its either let you move to the position that you desire, or see a decline in your job performance because you're unhappy. Change is always hard for those that can't accept change, but change has to happen to make something better. Good luck

by lesterlearn

I dont think anybody is indispensable. not 2 say u are without value, but those people will use you till you die, and soon after will find a replacement, and get used to the fact that you are not around anymore. I think you should move on- they will realise your value after you say goodbye!

by latwine2000

I have been in the same situation and i just went up and explained my feelings to my boss. However, they felt they could increase my salary and benefits rather than let me get promoted to a management position.

After a few months, I was called by a rival company accross the street and offered the same job at twice the salary. I took it up and now I am much better off.

by alanrphipps

If you feel you are being passed over, try leaving copies of Job Adverts in Trade Magazines and Papers open on your desk. Circle the odd one or two which are roughly in your career path zone and let your Management see them. They will then have the corridor and coffee room discussions which may lead to them taking you more seriously if they really want to keep you. If nothing happens within a month, trawl the Job adverts for something aspirational and go for it. If you are successful, you can then take the job offer back to your old company and argue for a promotion from a position of strength, knowing you have something else which is exciting, challenging and rewarding already lined up.

by darylcjohnson

Your best bet at this point is to submit your resume for other positions. When you get called for interviews you can easily find out if you're management material by the amount of interviews and offers you get.

If you don't get many offers then it's a good bet you're not management material quite yet and you can use the feedback to determine what is needed to get you there.

Another reason you should look around is now you're too valuable to your job but I guarantee if you slack a little bit on your duties down the road your job will be unhappy and they will not hesitate to tell you. By being "too valuable" you set a pretty high bar of standards in their eyes and you'll have to live up to those standards each and every time, even if the workload has been too much.

I worked for a small company for two years and after the first year they moved me to managing a department. As soon as that happened, not only was I responsible for my workload but the workload of others and it didn't matter if the others called out, failed to do their work, or anything - it was all put on me. Fortunately I was able to get all the workloads done on time and on budget but it was burning me out a bit and two months before my last date there I decided to delegate a bit of work to an employee. She suffered a minor slip that normally wouldn't have been a problem but it was brought up in a meeting and I was questioned on why I didn't do the work myself. I was even told "We don't care about your past success...this is now. You took on the workload of others. Continue to do so." and the next day they hired another manager who knew nothing about technology to take my position. I was placed back as an employee in the department and was even expected to train this new manager on systems, processes, everything.

Needless to say I submitted my resume. What did I learn from this?

I could manage, but I don't want to. Managing goes beyond technology. You have to deal with people. People who sometimes don't want to do their share of the workload. People wh aren't interested in the business but just want to get their money and go home and will yell in a minute at you that they don't get a raise and therefore won't do anything beyond "their duties". People who are your bosses who want to drop all their work on you and expect you to give up your weekends to do work in the office so they can enjoy the country club or weekend getaways.

by pdhutch

I was in the same place in the Air Force...I was lucky, my assignment as a manager was only 1 year. Being a 'jack of all trades' and helping people is very different than directing there work.

You might want to write out a managers resume and make an assessment of your management skills. If you can't file a page, on-line instruction could help. Thinking like a manager is VERY different from thinking like a techie.

I found out early that I like 'doing' rather than 'managing.' I feel very lucky for the experience and finding out it was not for me.
Good Luck...

by seema11909

I am with you buddy, we really need good advice.

I am in same position as you are, 7 years and same job, it's not challenging enough any more. I feel like I have become a robot.

by zaltech

I can relate to this. I have found myself having to leave to prove my true value. It is unfortunate, but it happens to many of us who just happen to be really good at several different things.

I had to take a 10% pay cut when I got on with my current company 3.5 years ago. Since that time I have increased my salary 44%. In my company I support (along with just one other person) over 80% of the applications (200+) running in our 6000+ user, time critical environment. This is not to mention that we have a fairly large IT dept with over 60 people. The balance of work is extremely uneven with some like myself doing a vast number of different tasks while others do extremely few tasks.

Last year I wanted an actual promotion - instead of just a raise. I was told that yes I operate on that level, providing not just application support, but also assistance and guidance to my peers - and not even with just work stuff, but I was denied due to some question about the wording in the duties of the title I wanted.

I felt that I was doing the job, and was told that it would be reevaulated soon. When I was coming up I was taught that you can't go anywhere until you can teach what you know, and have found it to be a very satisfying experience to see the light come on when I am able to export my knowledge and see it click in the minds of others.

Shortly after being denied myself I watched as others - all no more skilled than I, and most with lesser responsibilities and many who come to me for answers - get promoted to the title that I had been denied. I was performing the duties of the title more than they, but they were getting promoted.

I reevealuated myself, then argued the point as it was not fair. Finally after about 8 months of arguing I did get the title change, but it has left a bad taste in my mouth since I felt I was being held to a different standard than others. The title change should mean more money also, but that is not the point. I feel that I am seen as too valuable in my current position, and will be held here indefinitely, partly because I am a critical thinker, and partly due to my varied past experiences that allow me to see things that often do not appear to others - even though I constantly impart my knowledge I have found no one wants to do my job. We have repeatedly asked for an extra body (FTE) since it is becoming extremely hard to keep up with the workload, but most recently were told we "needed to work smarter". I have written many automation processes since there is no way one (or two) people can reasonably be expected to perfrom all the tasks that we do.

It is unfortunate, but I believe I will have to look for work again since although my title has changed, the mindset of my organization will not. It is their loss though since there are many so many details that, although documented will still be unclear because they do not really have any disemination of knowledge, walk out the door with me.

by j-max

All things being equal, and if you have management capability, there is no time to get out like now.

I spent ten years in a position exactly like yours and found that, in the end, I had been there so long people didn't even know what I was doing. When I left management was not so remorseful over it. After six months they replaced me with two people both making twice my salary, then they knew.

Now, after seven years at another company I find myse3lf being streamed into management with little problem. In fact, I now know when they hired me, they did so because they realized my potential.

If you feel like you have become part of the furniture in the office, you probably are.

Polish your resume and look for a more open environment.

by zaltech

My position is the same as yours was - management has no idea of what I do - hence the comment that I need to "work smarter" (see Move on for details).

It really sucks that I am in this position again. In a previous one I left they had to hire someone at almost twice what they paid me and he only had 1/4 of my skill set.

I am sure it will be the same here exept it will more likely be 2 people they hire to replace me, and they will together not have my skill set.

by go4gold

Advice:
Option 1 (starting point): Ask senior management why you were not considered for the management post(s), and what you can do to improve your chances of gaining that 'spot'.
Option 2 (last resort): If senior management has not provided you with a plausible answer as to why you were left out of the 'running', then it is time to reconsider your role with the company.

Frankly... getting into the 'management spot' is not all 'gravy train'. Remember... once you are there... it is difficult to turn back.

by pbobrow

I used to be in the same situation or so it seemed. When something had to be done by a certain time or when no one else could handle it they gave it to me. When It was time to move up or so I thought, I was left behind because I was too valuable at my current spot. When I took this up with my superiors as well as my colleagues I found out the reason was not just my value at that position but my ability to lead and organize more than myself. Social skills and leadership that I thought I had I was informed I didn't have. So I formed a training plan with my boss that had me taking management training classes and other similar classes as well. I used the some weekend seminars as well as taking a few online classes. This proactive approach eventually led me to be the Director of that company. Trying getting some honest feedback without poutting the defense on the field when the repsponses aren't what you are looking for.

by kyuso

Just because someone is technically competent doesn't mean one can't be a manager.

There is a technical manager who manages both technical and human aspects, and engineers are easier to manage compared to other fields, so managers do tend to focus more on managing technology.

Also, people in technical field gain enough knowledge and skills that once they age, they tend to see bigger pictures, and cannot compete with younger geeks who are better at shallow but fast problem-solving, so the only way is to move to manager position. They would have become wiser and have already managed their family, etc.

The author seems burnt out, which basically means one is no longer in the shallow/fast skill level, but already sees bigger pictures of where the problem lies. That itself is a great skill as a manager. Managing engineers is not too hard, you just need experience, unless you hire some employees who were not trained properly as an engineer.

I strongly recommend that the author requests subordinates to help with the endeavor, and start writing timesheets reporting everything that goes in the work, even to the tiniest details, including the report writing itself. That's a good start as a manager experience.

by mckendrick

The best managers out there are constantly looking for and training their replacements, thus allowing for upward movement. Provided management at your company is reasonable and intelligent, perhaps you could demonstrate your value as part of their team, while at the same time offering your skills as a trainer for the IT department. As a Vice President, I know I am always impressed by that type of initiative. Good luck to you.

by mckendrick

I have seen the same thing, and I have no doubt that everyone else has to, if they think about it.

by mgoodspeed

Jim had some good items to consider in his post. Consider this, though -- if the company lacks people with your skills, can you mentor others in what you do, so as to build their skills?

It can be scary to share with others, as the fear exists you may be replaced, but I have had some personal success here, as training my colleagues to perform many of my "fire-fighting" tasks has liberated me from a lot of tedium, and I have been rewarded with a new position that uses my analytical abilities in ways that are very gratifying.

Good luck!

by jsalaz

I really can't offer any real suggestions, but perhaps my similar experience can help your perspective. I did many of the same things for a company that manufactures hardware and software. I helped with their network, but I started with the company as tech support. I only took the job because they said there was room for advancement. There was room alright, they just would not let me off the phones, which I hated. They just gave me more responsibilities, but did not take any away. The burden became too much, so I left. Now, I still work for them from home. They are a client and not my employer. I do technical writing for them because they can't find anyone else that knows their products well enough to do the job. So I may have a suggestion. Find something else, maybe do contract work. With your skill set, that shouldn't be hard. Unless you need them for medical benefits. In that case, you may be stuck. But I'll tell you one thing. They sound just like the people I worked for. They'll never move you up, IMHO.
Good luck.

by mexicanone

I just want to say that DC_GUY's advise can be so far the best one I have read so far. Thanks DC_GUY

by mexicanone

First - Everyone is born with no sense of management skill. You have the earn them so go to school.

Second- If you think you can make it, go for it. A company likes to see options.

Third - If someone is getting you back then let it be. Don't waist your time playing detective.

Fourth - I use to not like Ceasar Salads, now its my favorite.

There is nothing wrong with what JimHM is saying, but it just sounds to negative. Peace out.

by lexva

I've been managing a technical team for four years now. I was the classic geek who performed well who got promoted through the ranks. Fortunately for me, it wasn't a case of them picking the tech performer because they didn't know better: my director has more management skill than anybody else in the company. But he wasn't that technical (though he's gotten up to speed); he was used to relating to leadership types, so he simply trained his technical escalation team to become team leaders and then managers, so that he could relate to us better.

In some ways it's a very different skill set; I had to learn a lot. But if your version of problem-solving involves recognizing patterns and dealing with behaviors (a necessary skill in object oriented programming), it's possible to transfer some of that to managing people. It's like tech support in that people bring problems to you and you solve them. If you're good at helping customers and users understand an issue, you may be good at coaching employees and solving organizational problems.

So let's assume the reason you're not being promoted is that they need someone in your current role and you're the only candidate for that. Here is the test for that premise: do you get good feedback and good raises? If so, this could be the case.

But there is a way out: if you understand a technical issue, you can explain it. If you can explain it, you can document it. If you can document it, you can train it. If you can train it, you can let someone else do it.

In fact, quite a bit of my job involves capturing information that is in my head, or in other people's heads, and putting it on paper. I've developed processes and standards which now make it easy for other people to document what they know.

Management is hard, though, if you're doing it right. One of the problems about having signing authority is that you have to bloody sign everything; there's so much paperwork. And making decisions that involve tens of thousands of dollars and/or the careers of other people is a real challenge; it's like walking into a very high-stakes poker game. If you screw up, the people above you, who play for even higher stakes, really don't give you the slack that one might give staff. At a minimum, the manager has to add more value to the organization than their own salary. Since you won't have time to do much actual work, the only way to add value is to make correct decisions, i.e. to make winning bets.

But to get out of your current job, create a document that lists all your current tasks, when you do them, and how you do them. Do that, and you're free to move up, or out. Taking the effort to think strategically about how you do things will also make a positive impression on higher levels of management.

by mgordon

By now you've seen some mention of heirarchies, maybe even the Myers-Briggs Personality Type Indicator (MBTI; google it). Most ubergeeks are INTP's and are not well suited to management. Conversely, most managers could not program their way out of a paper bag, pay big money for the easy stuff and are stingy where they should put the real money.

First and foremost, a manager is a *survivor*. He or she got that way by climbing the ladder, usually on the backs of geeks that are either happy to be a rung on the ladder or don't even see it happening. I've been both; and after 15 years in the Navy I decided not to be a rung for someone else. Presto, in less than a year a very long postponed advancement arrived -- but it did not "arrive" -- I made it happen. It was work. I had to find the ladder and then climb it.

But that was then. This is now; small and medium size businesses do not have a "ladder" what they have is social clubs. Do you go across the street to 7-11 every morning with the boss to get a Coca-Cola? Drop a few wise suggestions; not enough to step on anyone's toes or seem boastful. After a while, your advice will be valued; after a while longer you'll be invited into the boardroom and not just pow-wow at the soda fountain. Next thing you know, you are a manager.

There'll be plenty of sabotage along the way. People that are ambitious (geeks are seldom ambitious) will toss irresistable challenges in your path. You'll be a victim of your own sense of duty; does it seem that everyone goes home suddenly at 4 or 5 p.m. leaving you to fix the email server?

I have not looked at all the messages, but I'll bet more than one tell you that you cannot be a manager AND a geek at the same time. Geek work is vital but not socially acceptable; it is sort of like picking up garbage. Someone must do it but the fact is, to most people, sitting at a computer is no different than sitting at a video game; they see you as doing something mysterious but not particularly important -- if God had wanted us to understand computers we'd be born with the knowledge.

A geek, of course, *is* born with the knowledge!

by dperna

maybe its best you don't take a management position.

i have the same situation, i work for a mobil telephone operator, i am probably the senior most field engineer, and also being working at the company from the very begining they started.

i was offered a manager position, but i turned it down, knowing that even though it was a manager position, and more money, i knew it wouldn't be a job i was comfortable with.

the electronic equipment has such a nicer personality than those managers...

truely we are needed in those positions to help our fellow engineers/technicians. we can relate to the real job not count pennies and try to make unrealistic goals and forcasts...
but if we did get those positions, we would have a rough life since the things we care about are not what the managers care about.
being more frustrated and maybe lose your job
since you are not following the rest of the managements ways for goals or forcasts.
eventually you would wish you never changed the position.

by nuke57

While I admit that there are a lot of poor managers out there, done correctly it is personally very rewarding, to the manager and to his/her subordinates. The key is to unleash each person's full potential for creativtiy, innovation, productivity, motivation and commitment. I have helped a lot of managers learn what to do and say in order to make this come true and it is a real turn-on for all concerned. But you should be aware of the tools and have confidence that they will work before you jump into management.

Happy managing, Ben
www.bensimonton.com

by rayanik

We recently went thru' a transition at work which created an opening. I have an employee on the team that is technical astute, analytical to a fault and understands the business. Unfortunately, for every issue he goes into great depth about why his position on it is the right one. The problem: Every $20 issue is given the same vigor as a $200 issue. Inability to look at a problem from someone else's viewpoint. A bigger issue is a lack of people skills. The employee will sit and hear you out for 5 minutes without interrupting but fails to listen. We all know that you require different approaches to work with a diverse team. He says he understands, takes numerous courses but to no avail. He has had opportunities to direct others on projects but alas the same issues and team cocerns. Others have had to step in and put projects back on track. He was passed over for a promotion.

by jeremydel2002

I say, "Move on somewhere else." It sounds though they may be taking you for granted. If you were to move up into management, then they wouldn't have anyone else to take the fires. If you?re not in a management position after ten years at the same company, then there is defiantly something wrong. Move on and find a management position somewhere else. You will probably make much more money anyhow. Senses states that you can make more money by moving to another job after three years.

by it24

I too have been at a company and was passed over twice for a position in which I was qualified. Bottom line... move on. Since I left I have been with a company that really appreciates the job I do. I averaged 3% raises at the old company and after only 9 months with this company I received a 6.6% raise! The Grass is sometimes greener you just need the guts to do it. Once you do you will wonder why you stayed as long as you did. Good Luck!

by aspowell20

The Tech. Member can go for the management position but should first make a critical and fair assessment of the situation for as a manager, he will not only manage machines and the entire systems of the organisation, but people who of course are more difficult to manage than tweaking and fixing machines.
Again, if the Tech. Member is convinced that he can sucessfully hold sway in managerial position and bring about growth in the overall transactions of the corporation, then he/she should go ahead otherwise the member can push for a pay rise and stay where he/she is.

by marvinsmallwood

Until you have someone who can take your place you are likely stuck.

Changing jobs is a very serious step since you will likely use your proven skills to end up in the same situation.

When you are the only one great in an area you trap yourself.

by apotheon

You say that as if military supervisors can't be just as petty and spiteful. Judging by what I saw while I was in, they can be. There are some great leaders in the military, but there are some real wastes of oxygen, too.

by bbbc_e

I understand that you may feel yourself to be hard done by, but look at this as an oppourtunity to further yourself. If you are THAT VALUABLE in your present position, ask yourself "What do I want?", if you want more pay , better conditions, more staff, ASK. If you think you want to be in management, ask yourself "Why". Are you happy doing your job, after 10 years, I'd say yes! Therefore "What do you really want?" It seems to me that you must have been happy dong what you do for tha last 10 years, and are recognised for it, That puts you in a good bargaining position. I think that as a manager the "loss" of hands on control may make you roll up your sleeves and get stuck in to solve a problem is youe company's biggest fear and a loss of a manager while you do so. I am in the same type of position and have realised that what I want is to be happy doing what I do, and I am not prepared to give it up, and tha illusion that you will be happy as a manager is pure "marsh gas". Be careful of what you wish for, you may just get it, and spend the rest of your ;ife regretting it.

Your choice
Ben

by specops

I know exactly what you are going through. I have been in that position before and gone through the same promotional let down. The only difference was I was not going for management. I can tell you though you should think carefully of a couple of points;
1) As others have mentioned you could play the EXTORTION game. If you choose this path be sure to be ready for the consiquences as it can always back fire. Make sure you really have a worh while option.
2) Reconsider your quest for management. Do you really want that role? Are you truly qualified and ready for the transistion?
3)Are you ready to throw away ten years of tenure with your current company? Have you exhausted all possible avenues from within?
and finally remember the old adage...
the grass is always greener on the other side.
Sometimes there is something to be said for comfort. If you have a good job, they treat you well and you are are doing well, relax a little. Get rid of the stress, don't work yourself to death. You'll live longer and enjoy life more. Contrary to popular belief, money isn't everything.....

by rao_pj

Hi,
I am from India. So far I have been thinking that only in India there is no recognition for hardwork. other places around the world, I thought one's potential is well considered. ofcourse oflate I realised the situation and accordingly I have changed my mind set.

I too have undergone the same situation and was very deppressed for a long time. Now there is no change in the situation, but I have completely changed.

Management every where believes in Indian karma siddhantha (philosophy). They feel that you are working because you are happy doing all that. If you are not happy why are you doing?. grumbling starts when one expects recognition. for certain things logic does not work. such as love, affection ..etc. one can not define. unfortunately in management lot of western thinking has creeped-in. no emotions. no bonding to the organisation. they think that you are working in that organisation either because that is what is your highest ability or you dont have any other option. I realised it hard way. In fact after reading Indian philosophy, I understood that what Management is doing is right. bondage is the main source of all worries. one should not get too attached to anything.
coming to your problem there are solutions. but what solution one adopts depends on individuals. one solution is to quit or work with detachment. this is because people do not understand (or atleast appear not to understand) words. they understand only deeds.

all the best.

by ariel

I was in the same position. I even doing junior executive work, but when it came to officialy moving me to the management suite, it didn't happen. It's like a virtual promotion sort of speak. When you're needed at certain capacity they pump you up with promises, and they tell you how good you are and appreciate you. But when push comes to shove, oh, "This is our computer guy", they won't even dignify you with a worthy title. Sounds familiar? You've got to move buddy! The sooner the better. You'll burn out and nobody will even care...

by lombroso2

Management is management in all different corporations in America. One becomes a manager because (1)he/she wants more money (2)he/she do not have enough scientific knowledge to do the real IT work. The only way to change this situation is to reverse the Pyramid of injustice by force. Get your friends (or unionize) and just halt the work. Once done in many corporation you will see how fast facts are changing. I think the fact you have the 'know how' should compensate you higher then the manager who just end up deligating the work. Unfortunately managers know that very well and they will hold to their position to death. The manager will promote someone to management only (as programmers say only if) if that one will keep the manager safe. It is like I am the manger and I promoted you, so you owe, keep me in your mind when you talk about me. Managers at corporations are slaves to the pyramid hierarchy that goes all the way to the top. That involves corruptions, injustice, and favouritism. Get the hell out of your job and look for different institution (teach, or be a contractor).

by eziots

Joel,

Very well written and looks like experience is the best teacher in many situations. Defintely a part of management is bussiness skills, and project management, but another intangible that alot of managers dont have is leadership skills, which are alot of what good managers need to be great managers.

You are right about the people skills, nobody wants to work for a boss that doesnt have any clue on what there workers go through, or cant eat some humble pie from time to time when they are flat wrong and been called on the carpet by it.

As for the gentleman, that has reached burn-out, as much as you like the company, and as well as you do in your job, there are forces here outside your sphere of influence, that you cannot control, which you feel are holding you back. You have basically two choices, move on to another job which will get you that opportunity you been looking to more into management, and utilize your "trench" skills there and develop your "interpersonal and management" skills in the new postion with a new set of colleages and different culture, priorites and focus. Or you can stay with the status quo and keep pounding your head against the wall trying to figure out the magic solution to your problems, when somebody else is holding all the keys you need to move up. The choice is your, its your career, make the most of it, and remember no regrets.

Sincerely,
Ed

by phstacker

I realize this will not provide you with the assistance you are requesting but yeah, follow your heart!
We use to call this situation the "golden gloves" as you have quite a few years in one company and most likely are making pretty good money.
Consider that starting over with a new company means working off that first 5 years to enter into a retirement plan. It may also mean the lost of hard won three week vacations each year. And the list goes on.
But what I finally realized is that it is far more important to satisfy my self than to "whore" my wears to a company who will not or refuses to advance based on the scenario you mentioned.

And, as to how to make the decision, here is the advice I give all who ask: Line up several options. Secure placement withing these options (could be jobs or private business). And then, *drum roll* Pick One! That's right, just pick one and see where life pulls ya. Just make sure you align with the first rule - Follow Your Heart -

Peace~

by fgray

From having worked with you in the past i recognize your talents and abilities. The environment that you're working in will never allow you the luxury of climbing the ladder. The place is dying under it's own complacency--time to move on while you're still able.

by pbobrow

One thing that I learned along my climb is that communication and continued development of skills especially management skills are necessary. When you are in the trenches if your technical skills are lacking then you will get run over. However in management it is knowing how to find the person with the right skills and getting the most out of people for them to accomplish the task. It is not you stepping in to do the task because you are the only one who can it is gathering the resources to do the job and then completing the jobs by delegating and communicating. While I have plenty of UBERgeeks who work for me and nowadays certainly know more than me I am the person that everyone relies upon.
Basically go out and get some management training and show them you know how to lead people and take on responsibilities not just that you yourself can do a task.

by monstersound

There is a lost of waste (euphemism) on this post about "R U management material" and "oh management is different/difficult". Com'on, read the original post. He/she knows this. The question is fight or flight? The answer is both. There are numerous and varied types of management bosses and many of them are politically oriented rather than by merit. A good manger / company would have already noticed your abilities and designed a future course for your development. Which leads me to think that your mangers suck. Most intelligent motivated people can and should be groomed for advancement so they can carry their knowledge forward and disseminate it within the company. Shortsighted mangers often play politics for selfish and paranoid reasons, unaware that by not developing the best around them, they weaken the company and their ultimate standing. So, as the saying goes "The aggressive enthusiastic bird gets the worm." Tell them in no uncertain terms that you "Want the job/opportunity", email and CC all concerned. (Be professional but aggressive) and get your resume going, because it's your life and they don't sound like the guiding light. my2c

by ariel

Wow! You hit it on the nail sooooo deep, that sucker isn't comming out. Your response to this dilema is the best bar-non...

by wayne m.

The best way out of your situation is to teach others how to replace you. The next time you get a fire fighting request, take the person who started the fire and show them how to put it out. Make sure the person is doing the work hands on while you explain, do not do the work while the person looks over your shoulder.

This approach addresses two things. It teaches other people how to resolve issues and it shows the powers that be that you have some leadership qualities.

This discussion is closed to new replies.