Discussion Locked

Job Search Quandry: Contracing Vs. Full

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi All,

I'm in a technology-rich area of the country. I'm also considering putting myself back on the market (having studied the summer to get my MCSE and CCNA certs).

There's a good chance that I will move away from the area in the next year(family reasons). Should I keep that fact to myself and go for a full-time permanent position, or take a year as a contract consultant through a placement company? What the Pros and Cons of each? My wife is worried that I'd end up on 'the bench' but I don't see that happening here.

Thanks for your thoughts!
-Russo91

21 replies

by cedric king

Contract:
Pro:
You are better paid. You can leave when the contract is up and the company is lousy.
Con:
You must leave when the contract is up though there's a possibility that they might extend the contract. No contract = no income.

Permanent:
Pro:
You can stay as long as you want unless you are not competent for the job and you hit the sack. Stable income though normally lower than contract based. Better career advancement as you are permanent to the company unlike a contract based.
Con:
Lower income.

Generally it's better to get a permanent job than a contract based. Contract is more for those hit and run jobs. Permanent is more for long time commitment where you don't see yourself from running from the company in the near future. Hope this brief thoughts of mine solve your problem.

by g_c_scott

If the area you are in is so "rich" in technology do the companies there need entry level people? No matter how much experience you have your certificates are very recent. After 20 years in networking I got an MCSE (etc.) and it was still hard to get a job at the right level. Read Nick Corcodillos book "Ask the Headhunter" and follow his advice. Sign up for his career advice here at Tech Republic. Make contacts, go after a position not a job, and keep your move (which could change in the futurefor numerous reasons) to yourself. Don't bet on the 'good-chance' (like your move) but work towards the sure thing. A job. Contract or permanent. And get it yourself. Placement companies aren't worth anything and are normally staffed by failed consultants. Your wife is right about that bench. Your certificates are only door openers. Get yourself in front of the hiring manager, not an HR person or recruiter, and let them decide if they want your initial offer to be a short term contract or permanent position. Offer to try a contract (if they seem hesitant) to 'try you out' but take permanent if the Hiring Manager wants to 'lock you in.' You can talk over moving later with your obviously career marketplace savy wife. Good Luck.

by hsaadi

Hi Russo91,

Actually, I had some ideas when I read your question, however, the wisdom of the two wisepersons who sent answers # 1 and 2 have captured the essence of my thoughts. In that regards, I would like to second their opinions strongly. In addition, here are some more of mine:

We are suggesting solutions for you while we do not know any particulars about your situation or obligations, and we do not have to. Therefore, it is necessary to observe the following considerations and weighthem carefully.

If you have kids in school age, and you like the area you live in now, get a permanent job and settle. Work towards building a professional career path. Family reasons a year from now do change. What is of paramount importance nowmay seem trivial a little while later. Your concern and loyalty should be to your wife and kids first, then the rest of the family.

Also, make a pro and con matrix for your career priorities vs your social obligations and committments. If you canmake what is called a SWOT analysis. SWOT stands for Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats. I do not intend to make your case a philosophical question, but really it works. This is how business and economical studies examine a situation and deduce a decision. Look up a reference on the method or ask a friend who has a business development education/experience. He/she will help you out.

I hope this works for you, and you reach a decision which you'll never regret. Good luck.

by keblerelf

All three of the other answers provide some excellent advice.

Another thing to consider if the possibility of you moving is really high and you know where you might be moving to is multi-location companies. Many even smaller US companies have offices in numerous cities. It might be that you can find a permanent position in a company located both where you are now and where you might be moving to.

If you are seriously more interested in consulting and have a good experience base then checkwith various consulting firms in your area. There are ones out there that don't do "hit and run" contracts that are more temporary, but have consultants that are more permanent employees and just hop from client to client as needed in the area they live. A lot of these consulting firms have offices in other cities or allow for remote consultants. Also some consulting firms (usually the bigger the more likely) have paid bench time. Something to ask them.

As the others said though any type of short term consulting contract can be pretty iffy as to what might happen at the end of the contract and with having a family that can cause unneeded personal problems as well. Just weigh all your options heavily before making a decision. Best of luck in your decision.

by daddio

If you are young, need benefits such as medical, dental, and 401k plan, my advice is to look for a full-time job. If you are older, not not need to have hospitalization and other family-related fringes, go contracting. Higher fees are usually paidfor people with enormous wealth of background in may subjects related to your line of work.

by teauteau

I was surprised to see the negativity regarding contract work in the previous answers. I can only conclude it is a result of misinformation or lack of information.

While a permanant position could be a solution, it is not true that contract isunreliable or only short term. As a technical recruiter, I have people who have been working on a contract basis for more than five years with the same company. Their skills and incomes have grown with time.

The advantage to the company hiring long tarm contractors is that our company takes care of all the risk management, ie: unemployment compensation, workers compensation, health benefits, 401k, holiday, and vacation pay, as well as the training needed to grow and progress in their career.

Many contracting firms have all these benefits and more. Gone are the days of professionals working as temps with no benefits or security. If a contracting firm you work with operates like that, it is wise to find another.

In the end, the better placement firms place both direct placement (permanant positions) and contract positions (both long and short term). There isn't much difference between a permanant position or a contract position with them because full benefits are often available, as well as many positions that focus on long term contract work.

Take the best paying, and best possibility of career development, position, whether contract or direct placement. Just be sure it's with a strong and stable company.

by ftleejerry

Over the course of the last decade the idea of a permanent "job" has eroded. As far as tenure with a company is concerned, there really is very little difference between being a per-diem (contractor) employee or being a per-annum (permanent) employee. Therefore, the choice you have to make should be based on which among your current opportunities is best for you right now. Which opportunity will provide you with the skills you will need a year from now when you have moved to that new communityand are, again, looking for work opportunities? What skills do you want on your resume for that recruiter, a year from now, to see?
The workplace has changed. Careers are no longer tied to one or two specific companies over the course of a lifetime, so don't be concerned with the prospect of spending only a year with a given company.
Unlike in earlier decades, a company should not expect, not should it assume, that the worker will be there for any long period of time. Likewise, unlikein earlier decades, the worker should not assume, nor should he or she plan on being with the company for any long period of time. This is, indeed, a radical departure from the way things have been for a long time. It goes against much of what, in an earlier era, business implicitly stood for. Yet this is the nature of any paradigm shift. Much of what we were taught has changed and now we must rethink our premises and rethink our plans.
So pick the "job" that will best give you the skills and resume "buzzwords" that you will need a year from now when you are in a new town looking for a new position . . . then make sure that the new position you take, a year from now, provides the skills and "buzzwords" you will need 2 or 3 years further down the line, when you are looking again.

by bv2

Go for full-time permanent. The market is such that many businesses are offereing instant vestment in stock options, retirement, matching funds, etc. You can easily transfer those things to another company, should the need to move arise. However,if you decide to go consultant, do it yourself - Touting your own business when looking for employment is generally more effective than placement company employment, often viewed as temp work, which leads a perspective employer to wonder why you can't hold a job, although it was entirely out of your hands...

by kellyr64

Having worked in both type of situations may I offer the following - Doing contract type work over the next year (be it one 12 mo stint or two six month positions) will provide you with 1) possibly broader knowledge base (different needs in different places) 2) more money 3) a break from the grind 4) more contacts for networking. Also, you can better plan on where you want to go and be placed in that type of a category. Good Luck!

by ccrain

I read all the answers that were posted priot to my adding anything to the information pot. I have worked as a consultant and a permanent employee so I agree with many of the things said in reagard to the pros and cons for either. My only additional comment would be to find out what types of companies are in the area youare planning to move to within the next 12-18 months and find employment that will enhance you ability to secure a good position. If you know for certain the move is going to happen and when, I would starting interviewing in that area before the move. You might even find a company that is willing to pay for the move
Good Luck!!

This discussion is closed to new replies.