Discussion Locked

Jon Huntsman for President, maybe

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I wanted to end my title with a question mark, but couldn't.

I am totally impressed that Huntsman has presented a pretty comprehensive jobs plan early on, well ahead of the other GOP candidates. His plan isn't perfect, but I think it could have appeal across party lines, because its more moderate.

http://www.jon2012.com/

AV

18 replies

by seanferd

The rest of them are positively ignorant loons with visions of theocracy.

I'd be greatly impressed if any significant number of people in his party vote for him.

by av .

But I doubt he will be the favorite of today's Republican voter. They have taken an extreme right turn lately. They should consider though, who is best suited to challenge Obama.

AV

by charliespencer

'They' being the right-wing, 'tea party' Republicans that currently dominate the party. The majority of the nation's voters in the general election are in the political middle and unaligned with any party. To consider a candidate who could appeal to those voters and challenge Obama would require the right wing to compromise on their litmus tests and accept a candidate who isn't ideologically 'pure'. Right now that purity is more important to the most vocal branch of the party, as oppose to those 'unpure' and willing to cede some positions as the cost of getting something, anything, done.

by charliespencer

That was very informative. Mind you, it left me favorably inclined towards Huntsman, which I don't think was your goal.

On the other hand, third-party presentations and YouTube videos don't factor much into my political decisions anyway.

by jp85257

you think Cap and Trade and Obamacare are good ideas? No wonder you would support a RINO like Huntsman.

by charliespencer

I'm not as interested in the party as I am in a candidate's position on issues.

I think C&P is a good approach to managing carbon, an issue that needs to be addressed regardless of its (non?) affects on global climate.

While I think the mandate to purchase insurance is a violation of the Constitution, I also think there is much in the Affordable Health Care Act that deserves consideration.

by jp85257

by all means, vote for him. Just don't expect any conservatives to go along with his tax and spend policies. If I wanted that, I'd vote to re-elect Obama. Better the devil you know, as they say.

by charliespencer

It's just a question of the degree.

I'd rather have a person who taxes and spends than one who spends without a plan to fund the expenditure. For example, see the way 'conservatives' funded the Iran and Afghan wars. During the Bush administrations those wars were funded outside the budget process via separate legislation. I grant that this isn't a situation unique to those wars and that both parties have pulled this trick, as have multiple ideological factions.

Bypassing the budget is one reason the much-touted 'Balanced Budget' amendment as proposed isn't a guarantee to reign in Congressional spending. Another is that it wouldn't prevent 'borrowing' from one source to fund unrelated expenditures, similar to the way Congresses of all majorities and leanings have stuffed the Social Security fund full of IOUs. I support the idea of such an amendment, but I haven't seen any version of it circulated that isn't full of loopholes Congress could fly a C-17 purchase order through. I'd really love to see it combined with a line item veto.

Oh, and I haven't ruled out voting for Obama. It's way too early to make choices; who knows how many of these candidates will still be viable when the SC primary rolls around in late Feb.?

by jp85257

Anyone who would even consider Obama after the way he's mucked up the country for three years is beyond reasoning with.

by ansugisalas

if you disagree with him, you're totally fringe... not!
;)
Way I see it he just forcefully endorsed this huntsman by taking offense at his politics :D

by jp85257

Nice try, but typing "If I wanted that, I'd vote to re-elect Obama" Is not an endorsement of Obama. It should be obvious that I don't agree with his politics so the "if" statement would never be satisfied.

by jp85257

it's really a moot point since Huntsman will never get more than a few votes. Conservatives won't vote for him and why would liberals when they have they "real deal" with Obama?

by charliespencer

"Conservatives won't vote for him (Huntsman) and why would liberals when they have they "real deal" with Obama?"

That's the point I was making earlier. By viewing the contest in terms of who conservatives and liberals would support, you're ignoring the majority in the middle. They're the ones who will decide the general election, and they might find Huntsman preferable to Obama. With what little I know at this point, I certainly do.

The Republican party used to have a tactical advantage over the Dems in that it didn't eat its own young. After the primary, the faithful would rally around the nominee for the good of the party regardless of who each originally supported. I didn't see that happening with McCain, and I don't see it happening this time. If a party can't get its own members to support its nominee, it won't get enough non-members to vote him or her into the White House.

by jp85257

There's too many views or issues that he's supported that would turn off most of the middle:

He's Mormon
He supports illegal alien amnesty
He supports illegal aliens getting benefits and tuition breaks
He supports tax breaks for corporations
He supports a flat tax
He supports tax breaks for people dealing with China
He supports Cap and Trade
He supports Obamacare
and on, and on.

There's at least one or two of his views that will alienate almost any voter. He's just too weak to have a real chance.

by av .

Thats very true. Jon Huntsman doesn't have the purity. He doesn't register in the polls at the moment, but I think he has to ride out the more right wing regalia at the moment and see where the Republican party ends up later. Eventually, I hope the Republican party comes to its senses.

AV

This discussion is closed to new replies.