Discussion Locked

Jumping on the rant bandwagon TiggerTwo style

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I was very innocently watching Good Morning America this morning when they decided to cover Maria Shriver's "The Women's Conference" held in Long Beach, CA. This is an event that she has hosted every year for the past five years and is intended to empower women in all walks of life. The roster of speakers is always impressive and covers a wide range that includes celebrities to entrepreneurs. I generally will follow the conference but have never been motivated to attend. I don't like CA and tend to avoid the place.

GMA ran a clip from a speech from Jennifer Lopez. Up until this morning, my personal jury was out on Ms. Lopez. I don't care for her music so she wasn't going to get me that way. The clothing line that she "designs" is not intended for the forty something audience so that wasn't going to pull me in. Her acting seems wooden and contrived to me so I probably wouldn't be supporting her there. The only real place where she would appeal to me at all would be if she had something going on between her ears. She blew that one big time this morning.

One of her comments at the convention was that women who are mothers are the height of womanhood. I damn near spit coffee on the television screen when I heard that.

My parents were both fugitives from the Fifties. They were the ultimate Ozzie and Harriet in every conceivable way. Mother didn't work outside the home- which was the way my father wanted it. They had five kids and my Dad had some strong beliefs about who was responsible for raising his children. He felt and still feels that being a "home maker" is a 24 hour job and that he got a break in that he worked outside the home. When I was a kid, he told me that a successful woman was a good wife and mother. I believed him.

Years later when it was apparent that I would never be able to have children of my own, he was able to amend his earlier statement. Boy was I glad for that because it caused me no end of personal grief- the thought that I could NOT be a wholly successful woman because I could not bear my own children.

I have had to do no end of soul searching over this tiny issue for well over twenty years. It hasn't been a fun journey- especially with the onset of menopause several years ago. While it is likely that I might not have chosen to have children, I wanted to have the CHOICE. I never had that. I recognize that there have been opportunities that I had BECAUSE I didn't have children but I never had the opportunity to make a decision about which I would have preferred. But because the question is moot, I have had to find peace with all that. Mostly, I have.

When Ms. Lopez opened her mouth, she alienated every woman like me on the planet. Every woman who has spent countless hours in the doctor's office trying to figure out why they can't get pregnant. Every woman who has looked at herself in the mirror and saw failure- failure at the one thing that we women are all, theoretically, supposed to be able to do. Every woman that has been forced to find acceptance of that so that they can live with themselves. Oddly enough, I thought that the whole idea of the conference was to empower, not shame.

So I'm ranting about this because I can't do much else about it. I would love to hear from you on the subject. What defines a successful woman? Is a woman somehow less a woman because she can't have children? Is the whole reproduction thing less about emotion and more about an innate need to reproduce and provide for survival of the species? What are your thoughts?

27 replies

by cupcake

My heart really goes out to you Tig...

When I was in my mid-20's I married a man that had
children and always thought that his children would be
enough for me (he had had a botched vasectomy). But by
the time I hit my 30th birthday, the ticking clock became
too much. But that is when I found out that I, too, had
issues! I spent the next five years and the average price of
a house in California in and out of fertility clinics and
doctors' offices until, by the grace of God and the magic
of medicine - I was able to conceive.

And so far from it defining me, I see it as icing on the top
of a very great life. Although I am a late in life Mom, I
have a quite fulfilling and respected career, great friends
and enjoyable hobbies as well as my son.

Oh, and JLo never won me over either. Some women just
don't know how good they have it or how hard some
women had to work to get it...

by tig2

That you were able to conceive.

My Mom had my eldest sister about four years after she and Dad were married. It was another seven years before my next eldest sister was born. But only 18 months later before I was. We talked several times about what she referred to as "the barren years." While it seems elementary today, one didn't go to a doctor to get that fixed. If one did there had to be another reason. Mom WANTED to be a mother so much and that was never lost on us. We always knew how much she wanted us- even when we were busy testing her patience and generally being monsters.

Your child will always have that to hold on to- a certainty of knowledge of Mom's love. I can't tell you what a gift that has always been to me.

by tonythetiger

(or make) their own niche. It is not necessary that it be the same as someone else's (boring if overdone), nor that it be what someone else thinks it should be (at least not until socialism over-runs the country, at which time you'll damned well work where and doing what the government decides is necessary, and you WILL like it).

by tig2

Even in my forties I find that I am constantly trying to re-invent myself. Unfortunately, I am aging like a bad beach party movie and there are fewer and fewer ways to do so.

Since the cancer, I have tried to live without regrets. This is a place where I can't do that fully. I wish to God I could.

by santeewelding

You stare into the face of the question of how it is that you are.

With not a peep about what you hold so dear.

by tig2

Was never enough for me. I want to LIVE.

This is something that I don't generally talk about but it remains a part of me. I think that there is a perception about women without children. I've been told to my face that I had no children because I was too selfish to have them. I disagree with that but my disagreement has never changed anything.

I have faith that my perspective will shift. I have a reasonable certainty that I will never be able to tolerate JLo again. Stupidity of that magnitude is not acceptable- nor should it be.

by santeewelding

You are all over this thing, and adhered to it. I count on your past, as well as your presence, to know between flesh wound and fatal.

by fregeus

...is the same thing that defines a successful man. If he/she live to their full potential or even exceeds those potential, what ever they may decide those potentials to be, they have succeeded.

TCB

by santeewelding

If what is being discussed obtains with both, and I agree that it does, then you are talking about that which escapes definition. And, therefore, "success".

by tink!

Many people (male and female) still believe that a woman's place is in the home, bearing and rearing the children. [i]Obviously I don't, since I'm the sole bread winner in my household and enjoy it that way.[/i] Even with all the highly successful women we have out there in the public's eye, that doggone stereotype still lingers. Just as racism and prejudism continue to rear their ugly heads. It's one of those things that will never be eradicated so long as humans remain human.

J-Lo's words were obviously not well thought out. She was probably just trying to emote pride in mothers, not cut down those who are not mothers. Anytime you make a speech in public you must look at your words from all angles to ensure they will be taken the right way.

P.S. I don't know your situation on the not being able to bear children, but if you ever want to commune, or just observe, other women (many successful) who have dealt with similar issues start here: http://ddtko.wordpress.com/

She has links to others like her. (I don't even remember how I happened upon her blog a long while back. It caught my attention and I peek in now and then.)

by jiminpa

Success is only something you can define for yourself. If you feel like you are successful then as far as I'm concerned you are. Your definition of success and mine could be completely different.

As far as J-Lo goes... that is a pet peeve of mine. It's great that these celebs are willing to give up their time and effort for a good cause but unfortunately most of them have the IQ of an 8th grader. They shouldn't be allowed to speak, get someone intelligent and articulate to speak and let the celeb stand on the stage and smile, wave, and then write a check.

B-)

by notsochiguy

....with this statement: "most of them have the IQ of an 8th grader". I think you unduly knocked 8th graders!!

I've known a lot of 8th graders that would absolutely pants a celebrity in a debate on any topic of note. Hell, the game show is 'Are you Smarter than a 5th Grader' because if it were an 8th grader, no one would win!!!

:)

I agree fully with the spirit of your message. "Be seen, not heard" would be a great mantra for the Hollywood elite to live by save for some exceptions.

by tig2

Because you are absolutely correct!

As a contributer to this site, I am always aware that I have to communicate effectively. Otherwise I will be misunderstood and possibly even hurt someone's feelings unintentionally. I have been guilty of that in the past and I don't like doing that. So I'm careful. Seems to me that someone should tap JLo on the shoulder and remind her that she is dependent on the good will of her audience. If the audience goes away, her career goes away.

That goes for anyone who makes their living on our good graces.

by jiminpa

It has been brought to my attention that I may have offend a certain group of individuals with my previous remarks. I would like to apologize to all the 8th graders I may have offended. I guess in not carefully choosing my words I am no better than those whom I have written about. I hope you accept my apology and my promise that I will be more careful in the future.

Sincerely
Jimmy-Jam

B-)

by tonythetiger

[i]"Be seen, not heard" would be a great mantra for the Hollywood elite to live by save for some exceptions. [/i]

For the most part, they should stick to their "day jobs" :)

by jamesrl

I'm sure J Lo didn't intend to offend, she just doesn't have enough life experience to not simply spout platitudes and actually understand the implications of what she was saying.

What is the height of womanhood anyway - isn't that liable to be interpreted differently by everyone (man and woman).

So define it for yourself, and don't impose your definition on others.

Some women relish the wife and mother role. My wife wanted to go back to work, but fate stepped in and now she can't work, but is forced to stay home. The kids are all in school. She does the best she can. She is no more or less a "woman" than anyone else.

Other women chose not to have kids. Having heard the horror stories about bads mothers, perhaps more women should make this choice, if they aren't committed to being a great parent.

Back in the days of the family farm, women had to work on the farm and raise kids to work on the farm. More kids, the more "free" labor you had, the more successful you could be. Things are different now, there isn't a shortage of people almost anywhere, so why do we feel the need to overpopulate.

I do feel sympathy for those who can't chose. I know a woman who would be a wonderful mom, but circumstances are in the way. She borrows my kids and is a godparent to them. She is still a woman in my eyes, every bit.

In the end, we need to have the self confidence and self knowledge to be able to ignore the ramblings and random thoughts of others who mean nothing to us, and focus on those we know and care about.

James

by tig2

I might be able to tell you how much I value every word you've "said."

I've been "borrowing" kids for years now. I totally understand how that works.

I didn't realize until this morning how deep this is or how much it still impacts me. I was surprised by my initial reaction and am still surprised by all the things that are coming to the surface.

by jdclyde

It isn't the fact of having kids that makes anyone better or worse, because there are plenty of substandard humans having kids all the time. It is how you live your life that determines if you are a being of worth or not.

You, Tig, are definitely a person of worth.

Take care Tig. You are among friend that care.

:x

by boxfiddler Hot topic

In this moment, I am (all that I am), content in that without complacency.
Notwithstanding the shards of my broken dreams scattered about my life.
This doesn?t mean I don?t hurt over deferred or shattered hopes/dreams.
It does mean that I seek fresh to fill the hole left by those shattered, I examine the deferred in the hard light of day to determine whether or not to consign it/them to the dustbin of memory; where I can revisit, reminisce, imagine else. Or not.
It does mean that I live and enjoy and move forward without allowing the deferred or shattered to destroy what remains and/or consume me.

It means that we laugh and we cry with equal abandon, that we project our heart into the world around us, oddly softening existence.

I?ve no children either. Though I didn?t want them, I made the choice not to have them.
I?ve other broken dreams, handed me by circumstance beyond my control.
(That being the nature of circumstance.)
I'd bet she couldn't speak to those either.

etu

by Former member

to post my opinion, although I have no huge saying and the difference in the age. I am really interested in your posting. Because your life style is likely to be my style in the future. (no offence here)

I feel Jennifer Lopez is just the fuse of your emotion which have existed in your deep heart for ages. As catharsis, I think it is good for you. Maybe all of your female friends near you have had babies.

Each woman has her own definition about the success. If there are 100 persons here, it will have 100 defintions about the womon's success. The success in the hearts of some women is to breed babies indeed. There is no wrong here. You and them just have the different values about something.

In turn, what the hell is about the importance of 'Successful'?? Nothing can compare with the happiness. If you are happy that you choose a life like now, If you don't regret your choice, you don't need to care other's opinions.

by tig2

In the US there is still a lingering sense that women should have babies. I guess that is what fuels the desire but I'm not altogether certain. Part of it (probably) comes from the way I was raised. My Mother wanted very much to have children and was a wonderful Mother. Perhaps some of what I feel is a certain jealousy that I never had that experience. I will have to think on that.

As I mentioned in the original post, I honestly don't know if I would have elected to have children. I have ADHD and would have likely passed it on to any child I had. That alone would have had an impact on the decision to have children. My point was that I never had the decision to make because of other factors.

You ask an excellent question on the subject of "successful". I agree with you that being happy is significantly more important. And perhaps that is really the definition of being successful. I will have to think on that.

by santeewelding

That you are, Tig, ought keep you with your hands full. The consideration of deficit is reserved to those who would think they have mastered being, unto fictions of "success".

by notsochiguy

First and foremost, the ability to have children doesn't make anyone successful. Welfare offices and public child care centers/orphanages/whatever they're called are proof of that.

In terms of successful, if you can look yourself in the mirror and be happy with what you see (and I don't mean in the physical sense, either), and go to bed each night with a clear/good conscious, that's 'successful' in my book.

I had a somewhat related discussion with my wife a few weeks back. Long-story short, it came down to the societal pressures put on women.

Usually, I play the role of 'container'; listen, let her vent, demonstrate active listening, and validate her feelings. Not on this occasion; I had a 'guy' response that I think applies here, as well:
"@#$% society".

Society has our economy in the toilet, trash on TV, trash on the radio, sickos having more rights then the victims, dangerous products coming from backwater BuFu plants in enemy countries, etc., etc. etc.

Really, "society" should have a say on what makes any one a success, or on how they should act, or what worth someone hold's in life? PUHLEEZE!!!!!

Just my opinion.

P.S. To summarize, my opinion is that people are best off putting a sheet over the 'looking glass' in 'looking glass self'. We're the best judge of our own success; not someone else, and definitely not some arbitrary norms set forth by "society".

by tig2

And I'm reasonably certain that the eighth graders are over it.

I just think that you give many in Hollywood way more credit than they are due. The ability to make a ton of money does not confer intelligence. And I suspect that many of us here are living proof that intelligence is no guarantee that one will make a ton of money!

by notsochiguy

And as far as intelligence equaling $$$$, speak for yourselves.

My bosses told me they were going to pay me $1000 for every IQ point.

Of course, when leaving the meeting, they asked me for some chocolates, and told me RUN, SAIGMAN, RUN....

Um, yeah, never mind. You're right!

;)

by gsg

I'm not the only one. I've never wanted children, which is a good thing, because there's no way I could have had them. Luckily, unlike you, my parents realized from early on that I didn't want them, and never made the mistake of telling me that was my sole worth.

My grandmother, on the other hand, was not very nice to me as we had totally differing views on a woman's role in society. She told me to my face that I was stupid, and that my only reason for existense was to provide babies, and if I wasn't going to do that, then I was worthless.

She was visiting at the time, and I told my Mom that either she left, or I was moving out. Grandma was packed and out of our house within an hour.

Edited to add: I have two amazing, wonderful, smart nephews that I love dearly, and I would be missing a large part of my life if they weren't there. (Can you tell that I'm a proud Auntie?) If anything happens to their mom and dad, then they will come to live with me. And even though I never wanted children, the only thing that I would regret about having custody of them would be that their mom and dad were not there. I would give up anything and everything for those two.

by notsochiguy

...that without the 'fans', they'd have a manufacturing job; as in, putting together two all beef patties with some special sauce, lettuce and cheese with a sesame seed bun!

Worse still is that people like J-Lo put themselves up as paragons of virtue (I know she does some charity work, and has a camp for kids...but her dealings with the kids always seem so staged and awkward), know that people hang on their every word...and then they proceed to come down with the dreaded virus that causes diarrhea of the mouth and constipation of the brain.

Oh well, they are good for one thing: laughs at their expense. My wife and I spend some time each weekend watching some of the shows, and just ripping them apart from the comforts of our bed.

:)

This discussion is closed to new replies.