Question Locked

LCD 20" high definition computer monitors for graphic design

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Could people please tell me their experience and opinions on the use of an LCD 20" high definition computer monitor for graphic design work including pros and cons and any helpful hints before I buy one.

Thanks
Bruce

6 replies

by hal 9000

If there are colours involved I've never seen an LCD Monitor used for that type of work as an LCD Monitor is incapable or reproducing the correct colours. So that may look perfect on the screen but when printed out will be different. People that do Add work always use CRT Monitors because of this problem.

However if you are doing drafting work an LCD Monitor may suit your needs. For fine lines I would recommend a DVI interface for the Monitor and a DVI Interface on the Computer so you can have a full digital signal to the monitor so there is less in the way of distortion caused in converting Digital to Analog.

Some people report severe Eye Strain from LCD Monitors and I personally get Migraines from them but if your staff don't suffer from these problems it's no big deal, however as the refresh rate is different the flickering that happens too fast for the eyes to actually see can be an issue that needs addressing. Also as most LCD monitors appear to have a Concave viewing surface rather than a Convex or Flat viewing surface like the majority of CRT Monitors the staff will have to get used to the slightly different view and make adjustments for the differences. Again for drafting this shouldn't present a problem but for colour add work it could be a major issue.

If this is of any use the one place that I do work for that does Computer Generated Images always use CRT Monitors as they do a better job for the needs of these people. But this is a highly specialised Linux Program with some very special features that are not normally seen in other environments.

Col

by bldsm

Thanks for your reply. Have a look at these:

http://www.acer.co.nz/Acer/akc/monitorslcd.nsf/Page/RWPD81A0CFCBDE180CCCA25725D0023BB38?open¤t=9.6&ms=expand&

http://www.acer.co.nz/acer/akc/monitorslcd.nsf/Page/RWPD6495F0C666490BBCA2571BF00021387?open¤t=9.6&ms=expand&

Both say they are designed for graphic design, which I assume is page layout and design of print ready graphics (which is what i do).

I'm interested by your comments that they cause migraines and this is very helpful info before I buy $1500 worth of monitors.

Tell me what you think of the Acer monitors as per the url links I have given.

Thanks again
bruce

by hal 9000

Here in AU they do everything possible not to honour the warranty and will actually drive customers away blaming them because one of their product failed.

Recently here a friend took back an 18 inch LCD Monitor to the shop where he bought it and they instructed the shop to try to pry off the front bezel so that they could change a part. When the tech at the shop couldn't get the bezel off and damaged the screen he told the owner to take it to Acer who promptly refused to have anything to do with it as there was obvious damage to the screen and the fact that it had a service report Number from Acer didn't mean anything.

Their response was someone has messed with this so we are not responsible but because we are nice fellows we'll sell you a replacement with a $50.00 AU discount off RRP when the shop that finished off the monitor was already selling them at a $150.00 AU discount.

But if it does what you need they will be OK provided that you are not counting on a very good warranty service. Take along a piece of paper that you've printed out in colour and a JPG image and see how accurately it reproduces the colour on the monitor. That's about the best test possible as you don't want to spend hours getting the perfect colour only to find that when it's printed out it's a different colour and looks like Crap.

OH remember to use the DVI input if you buy these and make sure that you have DVI output on your computers or replace the Video Card with one that does have a DVI output.

Col

by dr dij

you could also try multiple monitors
most new good graphics cards have support and output for two monitors

by pix

Here is the thing about LCD. they are truly not capable of rendering color. If you use Photoshop, go into adobe Gama and set up your monitor, then find some nice velvet shades play around with them, do some print proofing. Now copy the Hex code and go do the same on an LCD, with that same Hex code, now that nice royal velvet you spendt hours mixing together to get the right shade, suddenly turns teen-pink instead. working with web design thats a big problem (and yeah that HAS happen to me) I can only imagine what the printers will shout at you if they bodge a print because you didn?t bother to color proof you design right(read: huge money spill), or your boss, if you have one, if you turn out to be a big expense because you take too long doing a design due to the fact you are not using the right equipment, or taking up valeable time calibrating it all the time. Even using a Pantone monitor calibrator, the colors on an LCD is just not good enough for pro use. There is also the problem with responds time XX milliseconds will cause lag when panning a big image in Photoshop and in worst case, when you get real handy with the lasso, you will have the same problem those top ranking fps gamers have, with inaccuracy of the tools.

LCD are for show and convenience. Nothing else they are very much inferior in any other case. Motion and color don?t work well on LCD, and those 2 thing are very important for graphic design or web design.

get a big Sony trinitron or FT instead.

This discussion is closed to new replies.