Discussion Locked

Lease Vs. Buy - Laptops in particular

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Does anyone have any recomendations as to which would be most beneficial in this case? Our agency issues over 300 laptops to healthcare workers that need to use a proprietary software at bedsides. We have been doing this for about five years now and the number of laptops that have been decommisioned due to spec upgrades, wear and tear, and just plain outdated technology is becoming costly and painful. Currently we are issuing IBM X31 Thinkpads due to their lightweight and reliability. We seem to be going through an entire model after only 1 1/2 to 2 years. This is becoming extremely costly. It is also becoming more and more difficult to resell laptops that are unformatted with no OS and no floppy or CDROM drives. We have begun leasing them from IBM Global Leasing, but I'm not sure this is going to save us anything but the hassle of disposing of them. Does anyone have any suggestions?

25 replies

by craig herberg

It seems to me your biggest problem is making sure that you comply with HIPAA when disposing of them. This means overwriting the hard drive multiple times, even when returning from lease. You should consider selling to stores that specialize in used computers, as they frequently buy in bulk. Here is one such place.

Practical Computer, Inc.
703-321-3003

There are probably plenty more like them.

Good luck.

Craig Herberg

by ohiois

We always make sure that we completely wipe out the hard drive! Even with the leases this is our top concern. Thanks for the tip.

by capstonecollege.com

Another way to avoid the HIPAA grief is to use a commercial shredding tool, like Winshredder or a freeware tool like Chaos Shredder. Even without HIPAA it would be a good idea-- its a sad old world we live in.

by ohiois

Some people don't seem to have enough to do with their free time, except to try and figure out how to make a living at someone else's expense.

by hockeyist

...equipment for business is if you have more money than you know what to do with. There are some exceptions and that relates to items that will last more than several years past the lease end date which don't date technically, such as a hammer or desk.
You have to take into account the item's NPV by purchasing v's the NPV of the cash flow if you leased.
I have spoken to several business managers (accountants) about this dilemma and they agree that this is the case. There is even a formula that you can use to support leasing v's purchase.
I did a quick Google and found the following would be useful to you (there are a lot more - just Google "lease versus buy")
http://www.adeptscience.co.uk/products/mathsim/mathcad/add-ons/free_ebooks/pers_fin_samp.htm
Different countries give different tax breaks for leasing and depreciation. The previous company that I worked for was based in Denver and they determined that 2.5 years was the optimum lease period there while in Australia it is 3 years on computer equipment.
One more point. To make it easier to determine who will give you the best deal when it comes to leasing with regards to cost of leasing, break the costs down to how much it would cost you per $100 per year to lease the item. It is then easier to see (in a table) if you get a better deal if you lengthen or shorten the lease period by 6 months. Some deals look better than others until you look at the cost per $100.

by ohiois

Those will be useful tools with the board. We are non-profit, so we don't have to worry about tax incentives. But the calculations will still be very helpful.

by angry_white_male

We're in the public sector and tend to get a good 5-7 years out of our desktop PC's and 4-5 out of the laptops (that is the ones that aren't dropped, stolen, left on top of someone's car, etc...). Laptops are something that should be purchased only if the user requesting it has a real legitimate business need for it. I find that most people who have laptops use them as their home PC's or to keep them entertained while on the road.

We're starting to replace desktops every 5 years - telling our users that shiny new PC on their desk is theirs for the next 5 years and it will stay with them as they move about the company until it's time to replace it. One practice I put to an end was giving the execs the new stuff every couple of years and cascading down (my boss tends to give them the newest stuff first to keep him in their good graces). The result was that a lot of time and effort was expended with this practice and caused resentment amongst the junior staff still plodding along with their hand-me-down Pentium-2.

I belive most lease terms are around 3 years for computer equipment. We get state contract pricing on everything we buy, so compared to leasing (and mind you I haven't crunched the numbers) for us buying the stuff outright we come out in the end.

by pr0x1

This topic has been around for a long time, and I was published back in 2000 on the subject, however, times have changed, and so has the technology. So my view, while basically the same, has changed. You will need to make your OWN decision given your factors and the decision points in your research. HEre are some articles to help you with that:

ON TECH-REPUBLIC: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=7&threadID=171043&messageID=1741356

Good one:
http://www.dir.state.tx.us/oversight/lvp/lsvpur.htm

http://www.smallbusinesscomputing.com/testdrive/article.php/2184701

You can easily do your own google or msn search, and you'll get TONS for >> laptop "lease versus buy" << , all you have to do is add a couple of other tags and you'll get what you need.

by ohiois

A decision was made by our Board of Directors to purchase a proprietary software allowing for bedside documentation. Since most of our patients are home-bound this requires them to carry laptops. This was not a choice made by IS, but a directive from the board down.

by italian

The lease should be a three year lease with No residual value and with interest at lease two points below the primary rate. If you do the calculation usind IRR you will see the benefits.
Make sure that the insurance is included in the deal and you are covered with a good SLA in terms of repair and replacements.
After the three years period (no residual) you have a choice to resell the notebook to the user (for his kids etc) and/or sell them within the organisation to recoup some money. After three year you present the owner with another New notebook. Same lease, same procedure.
Benefits:
1) your notebooks will be always "new"
2) you can deduct the expenses of lease from the bottm line as "expense" without incurring in lengty calculation on depreciation
3) you make the owner happy to have his old norebook for home use!
4) etc...etc... etc..

by ohiois

Our biggest concern with selling to employees is support after sales. Right now we receive tons of calls from people wanting us to troubleshoot their home computers. We do not have the staff to do this. Even if it was equipment that we are familiar with, it would be terribly burdonsome. I know you could have an "As-Is: No support" statement, but with this many users we always get the "just for me, I won't tell anyone" requests.

by italian

We have the policy of "as is " and it is enforced! I had some employees requesting support but the answer was always NO!

by aubitzk

I'm assuming any patient data is being moved on
a network to a server based app in real time.That no data aside from the client side app is kept on the laptop. If data is kept on the laptops HIPAA investigation might have a big issue with security of each individual laptop. Do the laptops leave the hospital at any time? This might be a consideration during the lifetime of the laptops. I know it's a sticky issue, HIPAA regulations are very grey as to when an infraction might be in progress without
the hospital being aware of potential litigation.
And any software supplier removes themselves from responsibility and will only reply that their appliaction when configured and used correctly will comply with the regs. Be careful think it through.... The government is giving themselves a big loophole by leaving the amount of data security to each indivdual entity, that if they investigate and feel your short in some area they can lower the boom.

Just some thoughts.

by ohiois

This is one area that I am sure we have completely under control. We exceed HIPAA and JCAHO regulations at least 10 times over. We have at least 3 groups outside of IT that oversee various areas: Retention of data, Data integrity, and Security. There may be even more on managerial levels that I am unaware of.

by regalgs

Had a conversation with a Engineering company that did leasing. What they found out was ( 3 year lease ) was that they lost money on the back end. ie - Cleaning off the hard drives, locating the software that came with the computer that was part of the lease, - that software is "owned by the lessor". They found the Lessor want the original software reloaded before it got back.

Also if the computers were late getting back off lease, additional charge. They had trouble getting all the computers redone and rerolled to the new users, timing, files to back up off the machines etc. You may find that if you are storing no data on the laptops.

as we say - the devil is in the details of the contract.

by bigredbaddad

I used to be the Network and Desktop Manager for a Health System and now run IT for a major Healthcare Architecture firm. Unfortunately, alot of your technology decisions depend on the design of your patient care facilities. At one of the hospitals at my old employer, we designed nursing stations with computers just outside the door of everyother room. The PCs were shelved well above the desk in a vented cabinet. The keyboard were covered with formed pliable plastic covers. This worked well. I was recently in a hospital where they used a specialized PC cart that they wheeled into the patient room to complete their charting and then wheeled out to the central nurse station or even hallway to plug back in to charge the battery. Since the hospital had wireless networks for me, the visitor, I imagine the wheeled station was also wireless. If your nurses are carrying the laptops around from room to room, no wonder they are getting beat up. We always talked about "nurse-proofing" our technology at the health system. Since your room design and work patterns are such that permanent PCs won't work, I'd suggest finding a specialize cart to install the laptop upon.

by ohiois

We are using carts for our inpatient facility. However, the laptops are used for visits in other facilities and home visits.

by anothercio

I've had finance staffs conduct the lease vs purchase study 3 times with 3 different companies (two Fortune 200 companies). In every case the decision was to lease...3 years in two cases and 2 years in the other case.

A BIG issue, as noted earlier, is what to do with the machines at lease end. My experience has been that returning equipment is a giant pain so I looked for other options. In every case I have found leasing companies willing to work with me at lease term. We keep images of every machine I have the machines scrubbed prior to installing the original image.

In my experience, we've had far more employees interested in laptops than we had machines. We've always used a 10% residual and, depending on the particular lease agreement, let the employee buy it directly from us or from the leasing company. With IBM it was a simple credit card transaction between the employee and IBM. When they provided a bill-of-sale, we scrubbed and reloaded software.

I've given the employee using the machine first option in one case and did a simple lottery in another, but due to environmental considerations it is important to have the employee indemnify the company.

by ebgasper

Another option to consider is TabletPCs. The technology is equipped with the same features of a laptop with little performance issues. However, you can use the TabletPCs to connect to the local server via wireless connection to access the patients files with the capability to update the record on the spot. The TabletPCs are lighter, portable and just as efficient and cost effective to use.

by deepthought1

I have done the anlaysis many times - it really relates back to your cost of capital and ROI/ROA targets for the company.

In cases where this has been a relatively stable application (in the event of infromation presented and obtained from the user) for several years, I have gone to a thin client and used hand-helds, even palm-pilots in one case, to host the app and R/F'ed to the host network.

by ohiois

We have looked into using handhelds and using cellular connections, but we have found that the software is not optimal under these conditions. Lost connections and screen resolutions were our biggest issues.

by terri0623

IBM is not the only laptop maker!!! I've purchased both IBM Thinkpads and Dell Latitudes for over 350 field employees. I found the Dell Latitudes held up much better. There are other laptop makers out there too. I never liked dealing with IBM.

by br-549

Lease vs Buy only determines how you pay for it. It does not get you out of anything. Maintenance and obsolescence are priced in or are your responsibility. Generally, involving another party in your transaction only serves to increase the cost in the long run. Lease if cash flow is an issue more so than cost.

by the admiral

You pay double or triple in some cases for leasing. Second, email me and I can help you with the surplus, since that is what my company does (OS or Not), and third, it is not uncommon.

Understand that laptops especially in a high use area are prone to getting broke. So that has to be figured into the budget (Generally an extended warranty will resolve most of those problems)

by dpschneider

There is an organization that offers a turnkey solution to the issue of lease verses buy.
They procure, configure, train, deploy, monitor and incident respond 24/7/365

No organization approach the management, cost effectiveness or metrics provided.

978-377-0988

Good luck.

This discussion is closed to new replies.