Discussion Locked

Linux Experience

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
blog root

13 replies

by rkuhn040172

As a newbie to Linux, this is my account and experiences of trying to obtain, install, learn and use Linux.

Having posted numerous times to various discussions about Windows vs Linux, I figured it was time again to give Linux another try.

I know very little to nothing about Linux...

by rkuhn040172

I have tried various CD distros before.  Knoppix and Damn Small Linux to name a few.  I liked both but really didn't use them for anything other than certain networking tools such as probes, scanners, etc.  I hope this time to approach this more from a "can I replace Windows" angle.

I've also tried Fedora (which I liked but that was about a year ago), Red Hat (failed to detect a number of my devices), and Ubuntu.  Ubuntu was great, however, I hope to get a distro with more cabilities and pre-installed programs, similar to Windows.

by rkuhn040172

I settle on the Mandriva distro.  Several people have recommended it.  I go to www.linux.org and find it.

The first link, carroll.cac.psu.edu, is dead for both FTP and HTTP so is the Debian link, the www.linuxiso.org link, the ftp.yggdrasil.com link, the UCLALUG link pops up some crazy message about having too many connections to the server (I guess one is too many!).

The LinuxBerg link sits on an hour glass for 5 minutes...guess I won't go there either.

The Georgia Tech, UNC and Ibiblio links have so many choices in a file tree that I have no idea what I am supposed to be downloading.  I have some educated guesses and am probably right, but if this download is going to take 2+ hours, I hope I'm not wrong.

Ok, I tell myself, go to the source itself.  I go to http://wwwnew.mandriva.com/ and finally start making progress.

Long story short, I finally get what I was looking for at:  ftp://ftp.uwsg.indiana.edu/linux/mandrake/official/iso/2006.0/x86_64/

Each CD takes about 2 hours give or take (CD 1 over a full T-1 and CD 2&3 over a 1.5MB DSL).

With over 7+ hours invested in this now, I think I'll burn the CD's later.  Although at my current salary, if I had just gone to work for the last 7 hours, I could of almost paid for Windows already.  But I won't go there, I am doing this for the learning experience and perhaps have a competitive edge over my peers who don't know Linux.

 

 

by rkuhn040172

So far, the install is going well.  Surprisingly well.

Only one problem...Mandriva Linux wouldn't let me use my KVM switch during the install.  Windows XP does.  Not that big a deal but it would of been nice to not have to get out of the garage another monitor, keyboard and mouse.  Besides, my desk is barely large enough for now 3 PC's (my PC which is Win XP Pro, this soon to be Linux PC, and my laptop).

Other than that, nice colors, graphics, etc.  Smooth and understandable install.  Disappointed with a 3 CD set, but I suppose I'm installing a lot of extra stuff.  Probably the same stuff Linux fans don't like about Windows.  Nonetheless, I hope it will be Windows-like enough for me to start to learn.

I got off to sort of a rocky start but I'm glad things are starting to smooth out.

by rkuhn040172

The default install of Mandriva Linux defaults to firewall off?  How can this be?  Ok, ok, I know the OS is "safer" but is this possibly a good idea?  I can't fathom why this is...

Next, it ask to download updates.  My home router blocks, among many things, by IP and MAC address.  The updates were not downloaded since they were blocked by my router.  No warning of such.  I'm led to believe the updates were successful and they weren't.  Not good!

Otherwise, very fast install and I'm up and running.  Nice and appealing desktop.  So far so good.

Had a little bit of a difficult time getting on-line.  In order to configure with my router, I needed it's MAC address.  No clue where to find that...turned on auto DHCP and let my router get it for me.  Then, switched back to static IP with MAC filtering.

Going to download OpenOffice now and see what else is out there.  This isn't a real PC without America's Army...wink, wink!

by rkuhn040172

Ok, I've got it installed and ready to roll.  Except I have 110% no clue what the hell I'm doing.  So I resorted to playing some more modern version of breakout or bricks or whatever it is called, for the better part of the last hour.  Hey, I can browse the web, make a document, crunch some numbers, etc.  Well worth the $500 PC it's on, right?

I downloaded America's Army but it is one huge text file.  What's up with that?  Why is my favorite game reduced to a piece of text?  That's demeaning!  There's no justice in this world...

Aside from the fact that I now have a deer in the headlights look, need another beer and smoke, and am very short on sleep, most of these programs are familiar enough looking to get by regardless of their Dungeons and Dragons names.  Once I figure out what they do, I can work them.

I'll try again tomorrow when I have more energy.  But I do have a functioning system up and running.  I just don't know how to do anything yet.  It's like seeing a Playboy for the first time at the ripe old age of 7.  I wasn't sure if I was supposed to read it or just enjoy the pictures.

 

 

by rkuhn040172

Ok, I'm installing the same distro (Mandriva) at work today on an identically configured PC.  This will give me more time to explore and learn in addition to see how well the install goes.

I'm going to try to attempt to see how much of my "job" I can do on Linux.  Things like RDC, Netmeeting, email, Telnet, etc.  Typical network and troubleshooting stuff.

More later...

Ok, I have officially crashed a program in Linux.  Not sure what I did, but the Mandriva On-Line services is whacked out.  I can't click on anything and nothing is running.  I can close it, but it repeats the same behavior with closing and reopening it.

Nice that the entire OS didn't crash but I don't see that too often anymore in Windows.  I'll reboot and see what happens...

by rkuhn040172

Wow, I guess it's not just Windows.

55 security patches, 34 bug fixes and xx normal updates.

Grant it, the patching process is smooth and doesn't require a reboot.  Leads one to believe that all OS'es are swiss cheese.

by rkuhn040172

After a couple of days off, I'm back at it.

Trying to get my favorite game to work, America's Army.  Mandriva automatically found my new Sony 1GB thumbdrive.  Nice because it is a 775+MB file.  Here goes, going to try to install it...

KWrite is trying to open the file.  Don't think this is good.  Don't think any text editor is going to open a 775+ MB file, at least not anytime this week.  I was told by fellow TR members just to double click on this text file and it would install.  Looks like that isn't about to happen.

Now my PC is acting very erratically.  Mouse is slow, programs not opening.  Time to reboot.  It must be choking on this file.

by rkuhn040172

After finding out that my favorite game of all time won't run on Mandriva, I'm calling it quits.

Yes, my PC is as much an entertainment device as it is for work.

Perhaps I'll try Fedora again since my game will work with Fedora, but once again, Linux has let me down.  I'm seriously disappointed in all the hoops one needs to jump through with Linux.

My Windows machine, while maybe a pain because of the varies types of malware and all it's Windows up and downs, simply works.  Compatibility is the key.

After reading half a book on Linux, browsing numerous websites and such, I still feel like I can't accomplish anything on Linux.  I don't remember the learning curve being so steep when I first started using Windows.

I know many will disagree with me, but Linux to me just isn't as intuitive as Windows.

 

by g...

If you want to play, yes maybe it's better on a windows machine. I will agree that there's a lot of programs that are made for windows and it's painful to run them on Linux but the thing is that there often a Linux program doing the same stuff as good or even better than a windows one. The problem is that they're not in the stores and most people don't know them...

Windows is maybe more intuitive but kde and gnome are taking ground in that matter. Maybe you should try ubuntu where I nealy never write a command.

But If you want the same kind of control as in Linux on your windows machine like editing configuration files, you'll have to learn much more in windows than on a Linux distro.

As a last thought: keep in mind that you can install a dual boot so you can go and play when you want and work on a real machine the rest of the time.

 

G

by nz_justice

You should use "Linux from scratch", all the Distributions are going to have problems doing stuff you want and your going to have to find the fix or reinvent one for yourself.

If starting that far back isn't ideal use SLAX. This distro is purpose built for easy modification, when you have finished all your mods you can burn it to CD or DVD then run all the apps you want of the CD. Modules for Graphics hardware are available from the site, and it comes with a windows emulator as a default application. http://slax.linux-live.org/ only 128 MB download. SLAX comes with the KDE interface.

You could also try Slackware http://www.slackware.com/  Not sure about the Slackware interface I haven't used it yet still have to download 3 600+ iso images for a total of four iso images.

SLAX is also based on debian which is a million disk distribution. If you have the bandwidth you should download the DVDs.

Alternatively you could ask TechRepublic member HAL9000 to send you some Linux distributions.

Novell latest Linux distribution SLED might be what your looking for as well.

With the delay of Vista you could consider and actually purchase the latest greatest new MAC which hopefully will be released around XMAS.

by rkuhn040172

Oh, I'm sure I'll still experiment with Linux in the future, but having given it several tries now with no luck, I was sure this was the time I would get lucky.

Unfortunately, given my professional background, it is a bigger and wiser investment of my time to continue to purse Microsoft certs and learning other aspects more directly related to my job like Cisco, Citrix, SQL, etc.

The return of investment I'm getting on my time with Linux has officially reached zero.  There isn't a high demand for it in this part of the US and so other than me trying to branch out and play around, this isn't paying off.

I haven't been able to get America's Army to work, I haven't been able to get Citrix to work, and I haven't been to satified with OpenOffice.

I find the concept of Linux to be quite attractive but the reality (for me at least) is that there is little financial, time, or professional gain from it at the current time.

I'm not knocking Linux, it just doesn't seem to be a right fit for me at this time.

I will check out some of the advice here though.  Thanks!

This discussion is closed to new replies.