Discussion Locked

Linux on the Desktop at work and worth it

0 helpful
104 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

104 replies

by dstjulien

The numbers may be larger but the problems are the same. It is a matter of how you do it and the commitment of the entity. If the company is fully committed, it gets done and people learn what they need to. It can happen in a fairly smooth manner itf it is planned well and the committment exists.
Novell is an excellent model and has a lot of info on its home page on how to do it. It took them a year to get everyone moved over. They were a total MS desktop software and OS shop until a year ago.

by dstjulien

You really haven't done a Linux install lately -have you?
I watched my son-in-law, who is not a computer professional and below "geek" level as a user, do a complete SuSE linux 9.1 Pro install with all kinds of bells and whistles in less than an hour! This included creating his internet connection and setting up his email client.
The real "gotchas" here are: 1- He has Never had ANY experience with Linux or UNIX; 2- He installed it on top of a broken XP install because he didn't want to lose any of his data; 3- He didn't have any major problems using Open Office on any of his Word, Excell or Powerpoint files; 4- He was quite amazed at how similar the windows interface was. He was able to access all his files in the XP drives with little problem and the system updated itself automatically. BTW: Programs that are installed through YAST, ALSO get updated along with the OS!
The Ximian desktop will do the same only even more thouroughly.
I am a Linux-for-the-desktop fan but I did not help him to do his install. I wanted to see what the experience was like for a Linux novice. Had a neighbor, older guy, user level computer literacy, who had a simlar experience.
Maybe you need to hace another look. Things have a tendency to advance very quickly in the open source world.
I would tend to agree with several other contributors - Linux is a different "plane of existence" the windows. More positive experiences.
Your comments about security don't really have the same weight either. One of the other contributors pointed out a couple of important things windows proponents tend to over look. The most important flaw is windows biggest feature - the apps are tied directly into the OS as is the browser and some of the flash - like Active-X. Sure- it makes for a great game platform but it is an open invitation to malicious outside attacks. That is like leaving all the doors and windows on your house open and advertising on the TV that its available for anyone to walk in. And that is on the desktop. If that desktop is in a MS network - double jeopardy with no way out!
Bottom line - Yes - as Linux grows in use and popularity there will be an ncrease in secutiry breaches but it will never have the same amount of security problems that windows has. It is a fact based on archetecture.

by dafe2

And your right to a degree............but there's nothing worse than politics....and no matter how much planning is done....Monday morning with a floor full of pissed off secretary's does not a nice work week make :-)

Of course there are a thousand other issues too..entity commitement is certainly right up there but then you mix it it up with code compatibility...

Anyway in some places it does work. But those secretary's are still a scary bunch.

by oz_media

Thought TR might start editing that word soon.

I use both so I can't complain but I also kno whow to keep my system running,some of the time anyway.

I wouldn't say it is like open doors and w**dows but I like to refer to it as "locking the screen door and leaving the front door open."

Windows isn't THAT easy for many to hack without any skills or a web search but pretty darn close.

As for XD2 the older version of KDE in XD2 would boot slow and was a resource hog, it didn't work too well with older Ximian I found. Now they they are utilizing KDE 3.3 and offering the download for older users it is WAY faster than it used to be.

This discussion is closed to new replies.