20 replies
by nicknielsen
I've agreed with you Max!
Let them keep talking, it's their right and every time they open their gob, they convince more and more people global warming is real and who is making a profit out of it. :D
Not only should their freedom be respected, the utter ridiculousness of their 'science' does nothing but forward the cause.
Perhaps that's what and why the good Lord was actually arguing.
Mind you, when a cynic tells another cynic to stop being cynical about a third cynic's argument dispelling a fourth cynic's premise .... well, I just don't know.
by tonythetiger
I liken the role of the naysayers in this as similar to a defense attorney in a criminal case. His job is not, as most people believe, to get his client off. His job is to make sure the opposing attorney does his job accurately and thoroughly. And like most prosecuting attorneys, mainstream science has been wrong before.
The only way to [b]prove[/b] something is right is to prove that all reasonable alternatives are wrong. The minute science refuses to be challenged, it ceases to be science.
by jfp3
seems to me to be that the ability to spend money is automatically equated with free speech. When this happens, those with the most money can speak longer and louder than those with no money. In a pure capitalist, that would be a normal and logical outcome.
The problem is that many people tend to conflate capitalism with democracy, believing that there is some form of equivelence. Capitalism is an economic system. Democracy is a system of government. The two are not the same, and in fact have very natural tendencies to be in conflict.
It is one thing for a company to spend money to promote the results of research that was conducted independently, and which arrives at conclusions which are beneficial to that company.
It is quite another for a company to fund research with the expressed intent of coming to a particular conclusion in order to then use the findings to further its goals. This goes as much for the petroleum industry as it does for pharaceutical industry, or environmental groups.
In a completely free market of ideas and a free market economy, such fraud would be dealt with harshly and decisively by market action. Like it or not, we do not live with either free market. That is why there are laws to protect the public interest.
I don't necessarily agree with the arguements posed by Senators Rockefeller and Snow, or by Monkton. In fact there are significant flaws on both sides.
What I do believe is that the whole arguement does boil down to money. I just get there by a different route.
.....with which, I agree entirely.
You said, [i]"It is quite another for a company to fund research with the expressed intent of coming to a particular conclusion in order to then use the findings to further its goals. This goes as much for the petroleum industry as it does for pharmaceutical industry, or environmental groups."[/i]
I contend that the environmental groups to which you referred, have indeed [i]"funded research with the expressed intent of coming to a particular conclusion in order to then use the findings to further its goals."[/i]
If those corporations did the same thing, who's to say which "research" is MORE correct? Therein lies the debate -- and therein lies the absolute necessity to prohibit any attempts to squelch it.
As far as these environmental groups are concerned (a well as many governments, especially the ones of the European Socialist variety) the debate is over, and the notion of "man-caused global warming" is no longer debatable, and is as obvious as the fact the earth is flat. They couldn't be more wrong, at least in this person's opinion.
[i][b]...the ability to spend money is automatically equated with free speech. When this happens, those with the most money can speak longer and louder than those with no money. In a pure capitalist, that would be a normal and logical outcome.
... many people tend to conflate capitalism with democracy, believing that there is some form of equivelence.[/i][/b]
In many cases, the last thing a capitalist wants is a free, educated market with the ability to question, either economically or democratically, decisions they make.
They wonder why their decision should be up to any scrutiny at all.
by oz_media
Watch outr fo rthe Lord. Whilst his ancestors have a long list of rather impressive accomplishments under thier belts, Christopher Monckton merely stepped into the 'Lord's' shoes by default and is a journalist known for VERY controversial reporting.
In this case I like his comments but many have challenged his comments and corrected his ways of determining the 'facts' he proposes. In a nutshell, it's just another journalists opinion, not a scientists though.
Again, while I like what he says here, he is nothing more than a journalist for several very controversial sources.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/story/0,,1947248,00.html
My suggestion? Beer. Lots of it. Often.
Max perhaps you are right. Perhaps there is nothing we can do. Certainly listening to the scientists will only serve to screw us around.
What's the saying about a man with one watch? Does it work to change the analogy to one scientist?
Whereas a man with one beer is just lucky. A man with two beers is absolutely guaranteed to be doubly lucky. Beer works.
the entire climate, planet, and beyond - the Moon and Sun affect weather too.
One of the most interesting aspects of the people pushing the 'Global Warming is a Imminent Disaster' line, is they have these lovely models that show exactly what's going to happen in 10 or 20 or 50 years, but the models fail dismally when asked to project for the next year or two. Why?
Simple, they're simple and do NOT include all the relevant factors, just a few major ones that their designers think are important. Thus critical aspects are left out.
When the experts run the models that we currently use for fairly (note fairly) accurate short range weather forecasts to model long term, the systems die claiming insufficient data.
The planet is warming, no one disputes that, the evidence is that it's been doing it for many thousands of years (gee, I didn't know man had been using fossil fuels that long, oh well). We have old records going back several hundred years (mostly maritime logs) that show the planet has been warmer than it is now, and also colder.
When the scientist can develop a model that is accurate for in a year and 10 years and 20 years, then we can start talking about what's likely to happen.
-------
The best climatologists confirm temperature changes, note that much of that is natural, and debunk the claims they're due to man's influence only. There is a difference between the studies of climatology and environmentalism. The environmentalists tends to over simplify the climate factors and scream doom, while the climatologists tend to over simplify the environmental factors. we need good models that include all factors, and work well.
--------
Another interesting aspect is that the scientists claim, and have proven reasonably well, that we can't create matter or energy, just convert it. So burning fossil fuels puts carbon atoms in the air, that had been in the air before and stored as plants, coal etc. gee isn't that completing the cycle and returning them to where they belong :p .
OK joking aside, man has an impact on the environment - both good and bad - as does every living thing. Animals produce methane, plants produce oxygen, etc.
In the last few thousand years man has affected the environment in that some areas of forest no longer exist, neither do the forest and range fires they used to have on a regular basis. We complain about bush fires etc, but they are nothing compared to some past fires before man started fighting them and stopping them, or restricting their size through human developments.
Sure we should be taking reasonable steps to limit any appearantly adverse effect, and to repair any we know of. But that does not mean we should financially disadvantage any socio economic group because they haven't yet done the damage others have.
What is interesting is that all those supporting GW danger in the political sphere all have an axe to grind that will leave them financially better off. Many of the international agreements are also set up in such a way as to benefit those that have already done the near maximum damage to their environment.
--------------
We need an environmental agreement that takes, as a base line, the natural environment of each geopolitical region as it would be if there had been no interaction with man. Develop figures as to the amount of oxygen and green house gas emissions for that area. Then compare that with what they currently have in both oxygen and greenhouse gas production. From that we can then determine their effect on the environment.
Want to go about comparing greenhouse gases levels of geopolitical areas, compare them with and without the humans in each area, not the changes since industrial development has started, or in recent times.
edited to fix typo
as its an easy one and then you can go back and wonder what else is so wrong. You put a smiley on it so you must think it's a good point. It's not.
"Another interesting aspect is that the scientists claim, and have proven reasonably well, that we can't create matter or energy, just convert it. So burning fossil fuels puts carbon atoms in the air, that had been in the air before and stored as plants, coal etc. gee isn't that completing the cycle and returning them to where they belong :p."
Carbon gets locked in coal and oil I agree. So the coal and oil contains carbon extracted from the atmospher hundreds of millions of years ago. Under normal circumstances that carbon would remain where it is!
We, humans, are extracting it and converting it to CO2 on a scale that no natural process could do it. Left alone, coal is just another rock.
Burning wood and biofuels are fine just so long as you plant it again. THAT is a cycle.
As a side issue, it's interesting to note that the amount of CO2 produced by human activity simply by manufacturing cement, which frees the CO2 from limestone, outstrips the average CO2 production by all of the Earth's volcanoes even if you discount the fuel used in manufacture.
Neil :)
sarcastic tongue in cheek. I was been extremely sarcastic about the recycle routine of putting things back where they started from. Maybe I should have used sarcasm tags.
The big point is that the co2 had been there before, came out and is now going back. It is also coming out again.
However, my main argument is that no one has enough data to say, without any shadow of a doubt, what is causing any changes. We know that much of the earth's climates are on looong cyclic patterns, some measured in years, decades, centuries and thousands of years. It's possible to say that such and such is having an effect, but not exactly what sort of effect, and totally impossible to say it is the main or significant effect.
Anyway, lets promote the use of biofuels, it'll also help the agri markets.
by benevolence
Lord Monckton is spot on (about open criticism)... but then spoils his statement by making it clear where he stands on the political issue. He should have just left it as making a point about not silencing critics!
"I challenge you to withdraw or resign because your letter is the latest in what appears to be an internationally-coordinated series of maladroit and malevolent attempts to silence the voices of scientists and others who have sound grounds, rooted firmly in the peer- reviewed scientific literature, to question what you would have us believe is the unanimous agreement of scientists worldwide that global warming will lead to what you excitedly but unjustifiably call 'disastrous' and 'calamitous' consequences." - Lord Monckton
He should have been stronger... the point would have been more impressive.
by jfp3
and larger piles of money speak louder than smaller ones.
I'm deliberately staying out of the conclusions drawn by the various camps. What I object to personally is that both sides have contaminated the discussion by skewing research and/or cherry picking results to bolster a previously held belief.
The contending piles of money may both be championing conclusions that are, in the end, completely wrong. The "truth", no matter what it is, is rendered irrelevant by the force of conflicting economic interest. The result is not so much as an enlightened debate as it is a shouting match in which the sides are buying ever louder megaphones.
In my opinion both sides are funding bad science in order to further what is essentially a political agenda.
In a 'free' country, both sides can do it, or both sides can't.
Thin end of a wedge this, should we stop party political broadcasts, because there are countervailing opinions?
Where is free speech, when those in power can make the opposition shut up.
Anyone who decides to say global warming isn't real or is simply because an oil company or a bunch of tree huggers say it's so, is too stupid to live in my opinion.
Always consider the source.
by jfp3
When a form of government is confused with an economic theory... the interests of corporations tend to trump the interests of the citizenry at large.
When the right of free speech is confused with the right to spend money... those with the most money will most often win any debate.
When self-interest and opinion are confused with fact.. attempts at objectivity are viewed with suspicion.
Politics have always been viscious...there are numerous examples of vitriol spanning centuries on both sides of the Atlantic to illustrate that point. I have no illusion that there was ever an era of "enlightenment" in which these areas of confusion have never existed.
When Utopian ideals are confused with a means for resolving real world problems, the result is a headache, heartache, and a stomachache. I know this only too well.
global warming has not been proven. I think it will be, and being a pragmatist, I think it's better to take it as though it has already.
It's in my interest in my opinion anyway. :D
I like self interest, altruists are bloody annoying.
by jfp3
Proving something right is perilously difficult. At most one can try to formulate a theory which attempts to explain and account for past and current phenomena to a high degree of precision and accuracy, which might then also be used to make a prediction about the future.
When conditions arise which fall outside of the expected results based on the theory, then a theory can be said to be proven wrong or in need of refinement to account for the new data. It may also be the case that a theory can be proven wrong when additional evidence from past or current conditions are discovered which do not fit the model. The process can never (or at least shouldn't) end.
This is why there are many scientific "theories" and so few "laws." Even "laws" are not immune from review and refinement.
by onbliss
by jfp3
Self interest can come in two forms: short term (profit) and long term (prosperity).
Personally, I like to take the long view. When looked at over the longest time scales we have available, it appears that there have been cycles of warming and cooling. In past cycles human activity has not been a factor. However when looking at ice cores, from Greenland and Antarctica, it is possible to get a glimpse of atmospheric conditions during those cycles. In my view, human activity does seem to be accelerating the cycle. (There...I'm actually stating my opinion.)
Given that it is impossible to prove a negative, if we act to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and if in fact the current trends reverse or stabilize over time, this is in no way proof that doing nothing to limit emissions would have had no effect, or a calamitous effect.
Conversely, if we do nothing to limit greenhouse gas emissions, and trends continue, or accelerate, this result is in no way proof that doing something to limit them would have had any effect either.
In real world terms, though, in terms of short term profit vs. long term prosperity, there is little to be lost by acting as though reducing emissions will have the desired effect. New industries will be born, both in energy production and emission control, spawning new technologies creating new sources of wealth. It may be true that wealth my shift, but that is the nature of markets.
If we do nothing, the long term view would indicate that investment in inland real-estate would be a wise move, if ocean levels to rise. People need to live somewhere, after all...
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Web Development posts
Sort by Trending