Even though a hard drive can be permanently damaged by a spec of dut too small to see with the bare eye, it can't be destroyed with a sledge hammer. While this would certainly make the drive unusable, this would not stop a place like Ontrack from recovering what is on the drive. Also of note is that an electromagnet, even the kinds used to pick up cars in a scrap yard will not erase a hard drive (especially if the cover is on).
Most of what I have heard required overwriting with 12 sets of 0's, 1's, and a combination of the two, followed by other characters depending on the standard.
For permanent destruction of the physical platters you have to heat them (white hot - make sure they warp) with an acetalyne torch, bake them with a blast furnace, or dip them in acid. All of which require specialized equipment and safety measures and should not be done by Joe Public.
The question now is how much is the data worth to you, and how much is it worth to the competition? If you dealwith DOD, than they have their own specs for decommisioned hard drives. Lets say your in Pharmaceuticals, that drive could easily, litterally be worth millions. The majority of the time a drive wipe utility will do just fine, provided the drive to be wiped is /not/ the boot drive.
If it's a very "touchy" situation, you'll have to destroy the sticks of memory too as they can hold residual data.