Question Locked

Making Windows2003 DNS nonauthorative for the domain

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Making Windows2003 DNS nonauthorative for the domain, or at least for www. mail. pop3. pop.

currently my domain is named domain.com and when ever local users from domain.com went online everything works fine until they go to domain.com then the dns resolves www. locally instead of on the isp. I have corrected this by adding hostA records in the dns for www and for mail - so now isp resolves the addresses and local users can access domain.com website.

my problem is that domain.com has some email clients setup for domain2.com which have been bought from the same isp so the ip addresses for mail and www remail the same in the hostA records. but domain2.com users cannot send emails but they can recieve emails. and domain.com people can send and receive emails.

all clients are xpsp2, email clients are outlook 2003

and emails used to work with the current configuration

5 replies

by scott_heath

Your internal and external domain name is the same. Yuck, that's a sticky situation. We have issues with that where I work and it takes a lot of effort to keep things from getting screwed up.

The issue here is that you DNS server is authorative for the domain in Active Directory at your location. There is no one else to send it to. It is not authorative for the users coming to your web site for from the internet. MS best pratices discourages using identical names for AD and Web presence because of the issues.

Anyway, who is hosting the mail servers, you or them? Do they get errors when sending or does the email go to never-never land?

by anabolic0omen

www and mail are hosted by the isp, they sometimes get errors and sometimes they dont.

2k3 server is hosting dns and some other services.

are there any hacks, patches or duct tape fixes for making my dns server nonauthorative for local users ? ( i understand that server.domain.com has to be authorative)

p.s.

i have read too many best practices guides and alot of them contradict each other about what domain name to use - but personally i agree never use real domain names for 2003 domain name..

by anabolic0omen

according to the users the emails work again, i have done nothing to correct the problem.
i hate when an isp is to blame and im going mad trying to fix not my problem.
i assume it was the isp since i havent done anything.

i havent done any domain renames, would it be worth it ?
renaming my current domain to a silly nonexistant name ?

by scott_heath

I wouldn't bother if it's working. Wait for some other upgrade and combine it. I don't think it is easy.

This discussion is closed to new replies.