Discussion Locked

Managing a loud and obnoxious subordinate

0 helpful
283 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Ever so often I struggle to manage one of my people. I've just turned 30 and this person is in their mid 40's. I've been her manager for just under a year, and started with the company as her manager, whereas she's been here 5yrs.

This person is loud and likes to try to trip me up (loudly), when she knows the office is an open one, where the conversations can be over heard. I do have regular meetings (weekly updates) away from the environment, but she just likes to try to prove she's right about things that she so obviously isn?t, but because of the noise I back down, because I?m quite reserved, and basically not that kind of person.

People try to look like they get on with her, and there is so much bitching about anyone and everyone you wouldn?t believe.

The company has recently come to some trouble and recovered from Ch11. Her position/ team was moved elsewhere (the helpdesk) and she moved into desktop, being one of the few to stay.

I've come from an IT background, am used to managing younger peers, and am highly educated, whereas her snippets are from experience on the job, although she misses so many obvious things that are staring her in the face.

Often when I?m being nice, and mentor her it's shrugged off and feelings of 'I know that' etc. It's very hard to manage such a person.

Does anyone have any thoughts?

283 replies

by bfilmfan

Depending on your HR process, it appears that this person can't deal with a younger supervisor, no matter what her other issues may be.

Call her in the office and officially reprimand her in writing on her behavior and place her on a performance/mentoring plan. Document everything.

Unless you put it all in writing, it is a "he said/she said" situation and the judge gets to settle those. And usually the ruling won't be in management's favor.

by schighway101

Document everything that has been said by you, and by the other person. Report to either HR or whoever you report to. Report the person. I am much older than you are and I'd be John Brown if I'd put up with that. Good luck.

by zen37

...If she was one of your younger peers?

I would act the same way. Age is no reason to treat anyone differently. I totally agree that it does make it more difficult, but there is no reason why it should be handled differently.

Good luck

by synthetic

Your comfort level, approach and expected response with a younger person might be a little different, and seemingly much more easily approached; however, that is still no reason to generally treat this person any different in response to the job. If you get into a habit with any employee of treating them differently based on age, race, etc than you risk alienating the other employees you mange. I am not saying that these things won't influence approach, but in the end, each employee needs to know they will be treated fairly and consistently, no matter the mitigating issue. Better in the end to have it out with this individual, than to upset the positive sounding balance with all your other charges. As bflimflam said, follow the appropriate HR path and document everything! Good Luck

by amtek

I assume that you HR has and Eval report on at least a yearly time frame. So I suggest you start documenting her job faults for the next report then
inform her of the corrective actions she must take to remain as an employee most normal people pull their head in when they are under the gun.

by amcol

You've just framed your presentation of the situation as an age oriented issue, but that's not it at all.

You don't say if you're male or female. If you're male, is it gender related?

You made a point of you having education and your subordinate having experience. Is she threatened by your academic credentials?

The company's just recovered from bankruptcy reorganization. Does she feel her position is in jeopardy and she's just lashing out?

You entered the company as her manager only one year ago and she's been there five. Is she jealous? Did you get the position she wanted?

The answer is all of the above and none of the above. What I think you have here is the classic know-it-all, someone whose ego demands they be right all the time and that their rightness be accompanied by public affirmation of that fact.

What I really think is that it doesn't matter. The problem here isn't her, it's you. You're the manager but you're not managing. You have a fly in the ointment who's been allowed to upset the team and interpersonal dynamic to the point where "there is so much bitching about anyone and everyone you wouldn?t believe". That's YOUR fault, not hers.

You're making the classic young manager mistake. You're not her parent; you're not her teacher; you're not her psychiatrist; you're not her buddy; YOU'RE HER MANAGER. MANAGE HER. "Often when I?m being nice, and mentor her it's shrugged off". Why are you being nice to her? What did she do to deserve your mentorship? She's not performing, and she's taking you and your group down with her.

Don't be nice. Be tough.

She's there to do a job. She's not doing it. Worse yet, she's preventing other people from doing their jobs. You have enough already, obviously, to document unproductive behaviors. Do so, create a plan for her, make sure it has hard deliverables and hard dates, then make her report her progress on a regular weekly basis. She'll either make it or not...if she does you've turned the situation around, if not she's gone and the pain with her. Either way you win, and in the meantime everyone around you...your team, your management, and your customers...will see you doing what's necessary to address a tough situation. That's how you gain respect, and that's how you succeed.

by zen37

I would not want you to be my manager and if i was yours, you and i would have a serious talk.

You need to weight your words my friend. Your use of absolutes create an environement not of respect but of fear.

Is this the manager's issue? Yes, not his "fault". Should he care for the reasons she is acting this way? Sure, if it helps in finding a solution. If the reason is as you think (know it all), then yes, the reasons are irrelavent. But if they aren't, shouldn't you try to resolve them.

I do believe that this person is trying to deal with the situation the best it can. He or she could do a lot more, yes. A little more action is definitely needed here. But your words suggest drastic draconian methods that may not be called for....yet.

You can accomplish a lot more when you get respect from trust than respect from fear.

by amcol

Not everyone likes my management style, and I'm OK with that. One can't be all things to all people, one can simply do the best one can.

A manager has many responsibilities. You have one to each individual on your team, one to the team as a whole, one to your department and/or division, one to your company, one to the stakeholders, one to your customers, one to yourself...you get the picture. Management is a balancing act in which we discharge our various competing responsibilities in some priority order that makes situational sense.

In this situation we have an underperforming person who's in turn creating an underperforming team. You can take that concept as logically far as you feel comfortable. The manager is responsible for the performance of the team and each individual in it. This manager has taken a half hearted touchy feely approach up until now, and it isn't working. If the issue isn't addressed, firmly and decisively, nothing's going to happen except a bad situation will get worse. It's the manager's job, any manager's job, to make things better, or at least hold to an acceptably high status quo.

I disagree that if it's not the manager's fault. That kind of pass the buck mentality is why these types of situations fester to the point where people lose their jobs, and my advice was designed to make sure that if that happens it happens to the right person...the employee, not the manager.

I disagree that the manager is dealing with the situation at all, let alone as best he/she can. If that were true there would have been no reason for the original posting to begin with.

Should we as managers care about our team members as people? Of course. Should we cut people slack? Yes, but within reason. Does the employee in this situation deserve to have some slack cut for her? I don't see why...she's done nothing to help and is actively making things worse. Should we as managers do what's necessary to get our jobs done, even if that may mean taking some imperative steps...up through and including people losing their jobs? Sorry, but that's what they pay us for.

by paul

Amazing thing, we are now nice to people, walk around them like they can break.
Rule number one:
We go to work to work. If we all keep this in mind much of the problems often mentioned on this forum would simply not exist. When we accepted employment, it was accompanied with a set of rules. By acceptance of the job, we also accepted the rules. Nobody twisted our arms to accept the job. So in my view we are now obligated to live by the rules we accept. Many of those contributing here seems to forget this fact. Rule number two:
IT personnel is in place to make the non IT people life simpler. Not to show superiority. Rule number three: Start managing your self and you will mange others well too. Example works wonders.

by philip.grogan

In management there are so many styles to adopt and all of which will have good and bad points to them.

Yes we all come to work for the same deep reason of earning enough to pay for the things we want most. Yes our teams need to be productive in order to survive and yes the working environment is not the end of the universe as we know it. Life will go on.

Yes I am in philosophical mood today!.

However, it will deffinately enhance our earning potential and the roles we will be successful in aplying for ongoing, if we develope our skills in dealing with difficult situations in a possitive manner. This may mean working on a plan of action and trying to cater for each outcome. The last of which should be through HR as this is irreversable and will set the tone. The company will loose out ultimately. But understand that that action copuld be necessary if everything else fails.

In this situation, If management is the career of choice, I would want to make every effort to win over the employee and get a grip on the rains so to speak. Wouldn't it be a great achievement to successfully turn this situation around to a possitive, productive relationship. We are all built differently and becuase of this, one management style does not suite all individuals.

We all have different reasons to come to work each day. Some of us most of the time will be dealiong with lives great difficulties and unfortunately bring this wot work.

It is possible that this person needs a non biased ear to offload on. I like to have the attitude (right or worng) that most people are reasonable by nature and that abnormal behaviour is an outcome not a cause. If we want to succeed for the long haul with management in my opinion, we need to be able to adjust styles and tackle difficult situations head on.

I have found that directive agressive management does not work for the long term and in this day and age employees seek co-operative approach.

But depending on the business it is really horses for courses!.

by general_custarduk

That kind of absolute is worng, it will casue friction amongst everyone and you could well end up in a position of staff leaving. Whish is not required as they take business knowledge and experiece with them.

If you want to find out what her issues are then ask. Have a quiet meeting in a seperate office with an HR representative and go through everyhting from start to finish.

No warnings, no absolutes just the assurance that everyone is there to work together. If there is a problem it should be brought to you, the manager, and NOT shouted out in public. This will at least let her know that you are not working against her but with her. It should help things move in the right direction.

by arleenw

But it's not necessarily going to solve the problem.

There is a similar situation where I work, except there are two problem employees. One of them is the department head, they are good friends and live across the street from one another (small town, small company). The department head is a little less obvious about it in front of our director. But she either disagrees with the policy the director sets forth, or - if there are witnesses - agrees and then does not follow the policy in practice because she really does not agree with it.

The second employee stomps around the place butting into everyone elses work telling them what the should be doing and how to do it.

Together they team up to berate other staff members, and worse yet they've been witnessed bad mouthing our director to some of our board of trustee members - simply because they don't agree with some of the changes she's made.

These two employees have been with the company for years. They both feel they are the only one's who know what they are doing - based on experience (the department head didn't even graduate high school) - but new hires are not even getting proper training, so it's no wonder.

In fairness, our business has been going through a transitional phase. We were a small place where everyone did everything. But now we've grown, and as a result there are departments to handle different tasks. These two don't seem to get that and think they are in charge of it all.

But the department head does have a lot of great ideas and she works hard. Her biggest fault is she won't take any suggestions or direction to get things working better. To make it worse, she's a big kiss ass that has some of the board members fooled. Even the director was taken in (she just started 6 months ago) but recent events have opened her eyes to some of the problems.

The point is that this woman anyhelpwouldbegreat is having problems with may not be receptive to ANY changes, whether put nicely or not. The situation for anyhelpwouldbegreat may be even worse than we know - we don't know what other office politics are coming into play.

The best anyhelpwouldbegreat can do is document everything and go through the HR process. Perhaps a meeting with a third person from HR or other supervisor where the employee and anyhelpwouldbegreat would be a good idea. Then the two could agree on ways to iron out the differences.

My bet is the employee doesn't really have anything specific, just acts that way because it's been established that she can. A meeting would bring that to light without the unpleasantness of a written reprimand. Then, if the the behavior continues, begin the write-up process until it leads to either compliance or dismissal.

HTH

by wcoupe

Amcol, you're just exactly right.

This type of individual is destructive to a team environment, and way beyond the 'be nice' line.

Work, is just that, work. As managers we get paid to make our teams as productive as possible, not 'be nice' to them.

The way I see it a couple of things need to happen, and quickly.

First, the HR 'reprimand' process suggested by another poster is a very good step. If there's not a formal procedure, simply taking a meeting, explaining the process and then having the emplyee sign a document acknowleging their understanding of the conversation is an excellent first step. It puts the person 'on notice' that you find their behavior unacceptable and that further behavior of this nature will have consequences.

Second, you have to be able to challenge this individual if they are indeed wrong. Point out the 'missed' obvious components to their argument. If in fact they're wrong, it should be fairly easy to illustrate that, and do it simply and without pointing a finger.

I also agree the problem is also at least 50% the result of the managers inaction. This is the sort of thing that requires action, and quickly.

The age old question in management is 'Can we turn around a marginal employee"... My reponse to that is, certainly, but should we expend the energy and resources to do so? Aren't our energy and resources better spent cultivating those folks who are 'good', to be exceptional?

If we spend time, effort, energy and resources to 'improve' a marginal employee what message are we sending those folks who come to work and give us a 100% everyday?

by pailr

One thing that amcol did not stress is the impression that your failing to manage this person and bring her into line leaves on the rest of your team. It will appear to them that you are wishy-washy. They have a negative impression of her already and I can assure you that they are wondering why she hasn't been fired for the way she is acting. Your allowing this woman to disrupt the office karma is going to begin to alienate your reports from you if you do not come down hard on her.
First thing you need to do is to get her into an office with another manager and give her a point-by-point list of the changes she is going to have to make immediately and remind her that she is subject to performance evaluations DONE BY YOU. Her lack of team skills, you will tell her, is going to seriously hurt her chances in that evaluation. Let her know that she can avoid future ratings difficulties by religiously implementing the steps you have outlined for her. This will serve as her oral warning, with the next step being a formal written warning, in which the hard and fast dates and accomplishments will be enumerated. If she has reached the written warning stage, for most companies, the step after that is termination. Failure to meet the goals from the written warning will lift a shadow from the confines of your office environment. EVERYONE will breathe a huge sigh of relief when she's gone.
I worked in an environment where one person was allowed to do pretty much as they pleased, to the detriment of their co-workers, and I can tell you that no one respected the manager for allowing it to go on.
Realize that one of the things that becoming a manager has brought you, if you are going to be successful, is to have to play hard ball on occasion with your subordinates. You do this, not because it is in your nature to do so, but because it is what is best for your other subordinates and your company.
I strongly suspect that if this person is trying to make points showing you up, but having incorrect information with which to do it, then she is also giving your customers wrong information as well. I only hope that your customer base is internal. The damage can be limited if that is the case.

by sql guy

"You've just framed your presentation of the situation as an age oriented issue, but that's not it at all."

You have no idea what's going on through the other woman's head. It may well be age related. You cannot, with any degree of certainty, say that the other woman isn't looking down her nose at this person because of the age difference. Likewise, you cannot say it is not a seniority issue. Or a religious issue. Or a sexual preference issue. You cannot say for certain what the issue is, or what it is not.

I would be inclined to accept the assessment of the participants over the assessment of a random poster 1,847 miles away who has probably never met either one of these people.

"You don't say if you're male or female. If you're male, is it gender related?"

Now for a little reverse political correctness: Sometimes a duck is a duck. If the poster is a male, it may well be "gender-related". It amazes me how people carry P.C. to the extreme, so that the obvious explanation is always dismissed out of hand with no further explanation. "She's black, he's white; therefore it absolutely *can't* be a racial issue."

It's so amazing how many "smart" people forget Occam's Razor. Every now and then the simplest explanation turns out to be the correct and accurate explanation.

Of course there's 1,000,001 lawyers and H.R. people who want to convince you that the simplest explanation is *never* correct: otherwise half of them would be out of work.

by zen37

I'm sorry Amcol, but all i get from your post is aggressiveness and lack of empathy. It is very "type A personnality". All i can say is that i respectfully disagree with you point of view.

by amcol

I've been called worse, which probably comes as no surprise. I respectfully acknowledge your right to disagree.

H'mm...that didn't sound unempathetic or very type A, did it? Sorry to disappoint. I'll have to work on that.

by mike

I am in full agrement that the person is well beyond the touchy feely ..try to make nice line. I work in large scale construction and it is all hard deadlines...can't push it off and take atime out adn try to figure why the bldg isn't comming out of the ground beacuse someone's sign is wrong. Find the problem, adjust it or replace it with a BETTER one.

Yes...but it works on getting things done so you can pick up the phone and get a dial tone EVERYTIME>>>>>>

by zen37

Have you even seen my handle? Do you even know what it means? New age, yes, but whiner....please.

We could sure use a lot less of these idiotic replies such as this one. If you have nothing more constructive to say about the subject, and you resolve to bring yourself down to name calling, please, don't bother.

by darealnic

Hey MTL manager (MTL is my home town). Amcol lays out steps to solve the problem. Concrete, measurable, fair steps which can and should be used for any employee you manage.

The person who asked the initial question doesn't look like he's quite up to speed with playing politics to the level of pacifying the situation. Your tactics might work for you, but if this young manager tries them, he might very well get himself caught in a meat-grinder.

My take... play this one by the numbers as Amcol suggests, and it'll probably teach you more about navigating challenges like this in workplace more than you can imagine right now.

by zen37

To be honest, when i started answering this, i was thinking on how i would handle this from the start, at the begining. Obviously, this original poster has performed some things that i did not know about as they surfaced on later replies.

From what i can see at this point, i'm starting to agree with Amcol, as the polite measures have been taken and did not provide any solutions. I believe, at this point, that the measures presented by him, are the right things to do.

I am surprised though by the way the human factor is very strickly taken out of the equasion for a lot of people. It is very disapointing because i'm a firm believer that the difference between us and simple machines are the human factors. Emotion, mood, hope, aspirations are what makes us grow. If you take that out of work, then it becomes a much heavier burden than it should be.
I have nothing againts having the #1 objective of a manager to be the productiveness of his or her team. But not at the cost of our humanity.

We work to live not live to work.
And work is part of living isn't it?

I realize more and more the differences between the Canadian and American culture. Take the exemple of the lunch idea i suggested. Here, the boss takes us out to lunch often. We never think of it as more than a working lunch. There is no inappropriateness there. There is no assumptions made if one is scene with the other.

Very odd and interesting at the same time.

by jdmercha

A loud person is a loud oerson and will always be a loud person. You should not try to make this person not loud, you will fail. Since the company has ben having dificulties this would directly explain a lack of morale in the office. Mentoring can be done in several ways. Pointing out and correcting mistakes can be demeaning.

My Suggestion:
When she loudly tries to trip you up, don't correct her. Ask questions to get more details about her concerns. You should then be able to guide further questions so that she will arrive at the truth herself.

by anyhelpwouldbegreat

Thanks for the one helpful comment...

My Suggestion:
When she loudly tries to trip you up, don't correct her. Ask questions to get more details about her concerns. You should then be able to guide further questions so that she will arrive at the truth herself.

I have tried this. I get the "whatever", or depressed "oh right". It's like being in school. When she's your friend, she asks questions and sounds genuinely interested, when you've upset her she holds a grudge. An example, a silly one, but none the less an example. Some memory came in - usually i take them out of their boxes and put them into dedicated central boxes. I got the "i'd rather you did'nt do that". Due to tidying up mess in stock rooms due to lack of organisation in the past, and people leaving rubbish all over the place i'd decided to un wrap the memory as i'd done in the past. Replies of "ok, whatever" followed by uncomfortable silences became obvious. I'd upset her again. How to recover from that?

by zen37

Can you tell if she is acting this way only or mostly with you? If it is the case then she has something againts you for sure. A sit down and talk is definatly in order. Asker to go to lunch with you sometime. It will be out of the office, which should make her feel confortable and it's a public place, so she shouldn't make a scene.

If that fails then i'd go with JMGarvin said.

Good luck

by amcol

All right, I'm a glutton for punishment. Last try to get my point across, only because you're asking for help and I assume that means you actually want some.

Remember what I said about being the manager? Would you really have us believe it's written anywhere in your job description that you're supposed to stock the supply room and clean up the trash, which is what you're doing?

I know you don't want to hear this but you are not doing your job. You are not managing, or leading. You are taking the easy way out. You're not confronting your problem employee, and now it sounds like you have more than one. Whose job is it to unload memory, to put it into the boxes, to clean up the trash? Whoever's job it is isn't doing it. Your response? "I'd rather do it myself." It's no wonder this woman has problems with you.

Stop doing everyone else's job. Stop not holding people accountable to their responsibilities. Stop wimping out and not confronting tough situations toughly, and if that sounds draconian and unempathetic you can pick up any one of about a thousand management textbooks and you'll find this approach documented in all of them.

Be a manager. That's the real problem.

by karen.walls

This employee is trying to emotionally manipulate you and is turning you into the victim - if you are treating her fairly and with clear communications and expectations (not doing the "nice" thing to hide the conflict), get VERY CLEAR with yourself that you are NOT responsible for her feelings. If you want to keep this employee, get unentangled from this emotional dance with her and approach the situation with compassion, clarity and firmness. If clearer communication and firmer boundaries (HR rules & regs, job duties, job reviews, etc.), don't work, be prepared to document and fire. However, NEVER attack the person, just the behavior - keep that very separate between you and the employee.

But what I'm hearing pretty clearly is that you do not appear to have enough tools or training in the area of dealing and/or communicating with difficult employees. I have seen this happen over and over again with younger managers and with people promoted into management without the requisite skill set for handling people. So often new managers think they have to figure these management mysteries out all by themselves or they're not good managers, which is entirely back-asswards logic. Management is not a mystery gifted from on high to some people and not to others - it takes training & experience and there are lots of resources.

If your company offers management training, grab it. (If they don't, shame on them.) Talk to management professionals outside of your company & find a mentor, go online and look at sites that specialize in human resources information, go to the library and find reading material, contact any professional organizations in the area. Find fact-based professional information, not opinions from friends or coworkers.

This is not going to be the only difficult person you'll come across in your career so you'd better educate yourself as to all the types you'll be dealing with at some time or another. Your role as manager requires that you care enough to educate yourself so as to not waste human potential in the people you manage. Once you have paid YOUR dues to be the best manager you can be, then you can be a tough as necessary with a clear conscience, knowing you have done everything possible to save a situation... even to the point where saving the situation means firing someone to uphold the greater good of your team.

by g'nat

I had someone very like this for my boss for five years.

IMHO, this has much less to do with anyone's age, experience, or education.

I think she's a bully:
1) instantaneous, unpredictable mood shifts, often extreme
2) contradicting herself often, sometimes in the same conversation
3) beating trivia to death, shrugging off major issues, so that you feel silly for even bringing up the issues

She is poisoning the workplace, and that needs to be dealt with. The really big problem you have is that bullying is almost entirely legal in the US.

The site www.bullybusters.org would be useful here, I think.

Getting worried over her being upset is a warning sign for you. You are giving her too much power over you. You're there to get your job done and help her get her job done, and whether she gets mad *should* not be a consideration.

I know the books say that you're not supposed to remark on "how" someone talks or behaves, but her behaviours are sufficiently eggregious that you have to step in and mitigate the damage she's doing to the workplace.

***

I was able to eventually deal with my boss after having a child - no kidding here - and reading the toddler chapters in childrearing books. She was subsequently squeezed out of the organization by her boss. He stripped her of all of her responsiblities and essentially hired her replacement while she was here. I'm not sure you could do the same, as this lady was faculty and couldn't be fired outright.

Good luck!

by hal 9000

When she starts off being loud talk quieter and the louder she gets the quieter you get so she has to stop and listen to what you've said.

Some people just don't like being told a different way of doing things particularly if it is from someone younger and who they consider "Lack Experience!"

When she says do it this way you should reply in a very quite voice yes you can do it that way but then you'll have such & such a problem wouldn't it be better if you tried this? Since the company has had its troubles could a "Performance Related Bonus System" be introduced? Nothing big but just something as little as being invited to a after work do or something like that for the High Achievers. You don't even have to leave the premises just have something at the end of the week to thank those workers who have pulled their weight.

You are however perfectly correct in not wanting to fight with her in a open environment as this is just not the proper thing to even consider if you have to discipline her do it in a closed office where no one can see or hear what is happening. But when you are out on the "Shop Floor" so to speak just keep it quite and she will give up very quickly or learn. At one particularly bad board meeting I reduced my voice to only slightly higher than a whisper and it had a wonderful effect as it stopped every one from getting worked up as they constantly had to stop and break their train of thought to listen to what I had to say, they actually had to strain to hear me and I was often asked to repeat what I had previously said and I did it all in the same low almost unheard voice.

Incidentally at that meeting I was the only one who had their budget increased. :D

Col ]:)

by rough

Since when does a subordinate tell management what to do,even if quoted as (I'd Rather)

by jmgarvin

Force her into either choosing A or B.

A) Pipe down and be respectful of your peers
B) Come to my office and we'll have a talk and I have a nice form for you to sign

Lead her by making sure she understands she is not only wrong, but she is hurting the customer by being wrong. Also document what you are doing. Talk with her co-workers and if they feel the same, perhaps it is time to have a sit down with everyone to go over what is going wrong.

If she still can't work it out, fire her. I know it is ugly, but in the long run she will hurt the team and moral.

by bhunsinger

How do you gain respect from a bully- stand up! She is in a new position and she would seem to resent that she cannot continue to tdo helpdesk. She is as new in her position as you are, her time with the company not withstanding.
The military term here is "Lock her heels!" Officers, especially young ones , often are dealing with this situation. Until they USE the authority that they have, they get run over. You tel the person to stand at attention and then you explain in great detail, how their behavior does not measure up.In your style. Quiet is fine, but brook no interuptions etcetera etcetera. How you company does formal this is your BOSS talking to you, is a cultural thing, get advice from you peers. It may be the review, it may be the stand at my desk while I speak more in sorrow than anger, but find out how to do it.
Of Course there is a flip side. The enlisted man gets to look straight ahead and say permission to speak freely at the end of your monologue and deliver one starting "with all due repect sir..... " and unload his frustrations as well.(If of course, the young officer wants to lead not just push people around)
Be prepared for her to unload the frustation on you-- it's called clearing the air.
On the petty example- Why did she not want the memory unwrapped? You ask her opinion then do it your way anyhow, that is not respect either. Just a thought to look at your behavior.

by roadmanjim

I am sorry to hear about your trials and tribulations! I have been in a similar situation and can relate. At a previous job we an office loudmouth and the two of us were like night and day. I ended up leaving for other reasons and she got fired. That is neither here nor there.

I too am soft-spoken and tend to be reserved. I dislike confrontation so my future as a manager is suspect (post-graduation). However, I do think that I could provide some insight.

1. Whatever motivates this individual, there is slim to no chance that you will be able to change her behavior or point of view. She is what I call a Big-Mouth Frog and learned long ago that certain behaviors have rewards (meet a need).

2. Decide if she is worth keeping. Does she do her job? Is she punctual and dependable? Do customers have problems with her performance? Does the company have an HR department with a spine? Do you have the support of higher-ups? Whatever the case, you need to start documenting EVERYTHING! This paper trail will be invaluable when the stuff hits the fan. Be advised, that day is coming and it sounds like the office is not big enough for both of you.

3. Learn to hold your ground without raising your voice. Often, you can calm an excited person by speaking in a calm and measured voice. She is using volume as a power tool and will continue to do so as long as it works. You may have to take her aside, counsel her and document the meeting. Put copies of the counseling sessions in her personnel file along with any accolades that she has earned.

4. Good luck!

by furl129

Mentor? I?d say you?re the one who needs mentoring -- or more accurately, coaching.

Look at the words you use to describe yourself: just turned 30, reserved, not that type of person, highly educated, nice.

Now look at the words you use to describe what you DO: struggle, back down, mentor.

It might be very interesting to hear what she thinks of you: weak, naive, arrogant, judgemental?

I?d say that she thinks you?re a poor manager and is trying to get rid of you by being deliberately abbrasive. She?ll succeed, too, if you don?t clean up your act. The company obviously knows that she?s the one worth keeping.

by jmgarvin

Don't actually help the guy or anything. What you are saying is what EVERY inexperienced manager will do. This employee is testing her bounds and he needs to dicuss the issue(s) with her.

If she can't take the fact that he is in charge, she needs to look for work elsewhere. Further, it isn't HIS fault that an employee is acting like a jerk...

When did this whole blame the victim thing come into vogue?

by keyguy13

And mostly because he doesn't NEED to be a victim.

He could turn this around by being responsible for her behavior. She's being loud because he is ALLOWING it. That's why blaming the victim has become so popular.

by jmgarvin

A happy and trusting employee isn't a productive employee. I highly suggested you read:

"The Manager's Job: Folklore and Fact" Mintzberg
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B0000YHO3W/ref=pd_sxp_f/103-3463892-9047801?v=glance&s=ebooks

"On the Folly of Rewarding A, While Hoping for B" Kerr
http://www.facstaff.bucknell.edu/pagana/mg330/kerr.html

"From Control to Commitment in the Workplace" Walton
http://harvardbusinessonline.hbsp.harvard.edu/b02/en/common/item_detail.jhtml?id=85219

"Work Motivation: Theory and Practice" Katzell & Thompson
http://lib.leeds.ac.uk/search~/i?SEARCH=0003-066x

Just because they were happy and trusting didn't mean they were doing anything. The whole socialist ideal that somehow, magically, people won't take advantage of a system like that is insane. The concept of leadership is leading by example. You must want to achieve and succeed. You shouldn't be power seeking and you should be social. Beyond that the rest is mumbo jumbo that tries to lead managers to the conculsion that by using socialism in the workforce your employees will somehow work more efficiently.

by dc guy

Socialism? I was there, I spent some time in Eastern Europe in the era before Perestroika. The workers were most definitely NOT happy and trusting. They had the highest rate of alcohol consumption of any demographic group I've ever met. They managed to get along without blue jeans and tape decks, but if the supply of slivovic, pivo, wodka, or whatever, had been interrupted, there would have been a revolution. They were so depressed that they lost the basic human urge to procreate; their populations were falling precipitously and the governments were trying to entice them with something like two-year maternity leaves. As for trust? This was the national motto in every Slavic language (plus Hungarian, Romanian, etc.): "We pretend to work and they pretend to pay us."

by dc guy

People are criticizing you for not knowing how to manage, when your problem actually is that you don't know how to supervise. Welcome to American business's largest club! Don't feel so bad. Well, I mean you do have to solve the problem, but the fact that it exists is not a reflection on your own adequacy.

As I've said on this forum many times, the workstation revolution squeezed the position of first-line supervisor out of most U.S. organizations. That was a big loss. People are promoted directly from line work into management. That means A. they never had a supervisor, and therefore B. they never learned how to supervise.

Supervision is not the same as management. It's 100 percent dealing with subordinates, especially the troublesome ones. First you figure out what you need to do to solve the problem, then you teach them to be a good subordinate, and, bingo, by example you've taught them how to be a good supervisor when their turn comes.

I would suggest tracking down the oldest people you know, such as myself, who remember the good old days of having a supervisor and being a supervisor.

That said, what would I tell you? For starters I'm rather at a loss here without being able to hear the loudmouth's side of the story. You have to learn that every story has as many sides as there are players, plus one more: the truth. Like many previous posters, I'd be interested to hear her description of the problem and see how it agrees and differs with your own. That's where the dynamic is in these situations: in the tension between different views of the same situation.

So hey, there's your clue. I can't come to your office but you go there every day. What you absolutely HAVE TO do, and I'm not the first one here to say it, is understand how she relates to all this. What motivates her, what bothers her, what does she think of you, of her job, of the company, what does she want and what will she settle for?

Only you know her well enough now to decide what tactics would help you know her better. Lunch, bowling, dog, cat, camping, trains, tv show, there's bound to be some connection and a really clever SUPERVISOR will find it. It will probably be harder to start the conversation without looking like you've been replaced by a Pod Person than it will be to find the subject of mutual interest; you've gotten your relationship with her into a rut and getting it out will be a bit of a lurch. Just grit your teeth and do it.

Perhaps all you need to do is establish a cordial relationship with her based upon something completely external to the job, and the rest of this stuff will evaporate. Believe me, it's quite possible.

But the one thing you may find, and is often the root of problems like this, is that the woman is simply depressed over the state of her life in general and you only play a very small role in that. In that case there's not much you can do. Even if she were a close friend it's not easy to nudge somebody into the right direction to resolve depression. Some years the world really does suck and there's nothing anyone can do to make it better.

Your choice then is to put up with her or not. This choice should be based on the welfare of the company, not you or her. Workplaces are full of discomfort and sooner or later you'll have to learn to withstand it.

I can see that in your heart you want to help her. That's a good thing, don't listen to these people who are shouting, "Touchy-feely, touchy-feely, DC Guy already admitted he's really from California." You wouldn't like yourself if you didn't find yourself caring about people you know. But if you can't help her, that's when it gets hard. If the best interests of the company dictate that you have to let her go, it will feel bad. You'll feel like you've failed.

Don't. If you've tried your best and the problem is on her end, then you have to let go and move on to your next problem. And THAT, my dear boy (?) is what being a manager is all about! Staying focused.

Are you up for it?

by amcol

In the words of that famous philosopher, Mr. Spock: "A difference that makes no difference is no difference at all.".

Supervision, management. To-MAY-to, to-MAH-to. The main reason you don't find first line supervisors in the corporate world any longer is that their responsibilities were subsumed into entry level management jobs...where they belonged in the first place.

It's all the same, anyway. It's all about getting people to perform at the peak of their ability, for the good of the organization.

The rest of your post makes some good points, except for the psychobabble parts.

by bluegiant

I agree with most of the points you discuss DC Guy...These are effective methods to get at the root of the problem and get it resolved. These steps should be taken after some ground rules are established.

As another poster mentioned, this employee is testing her boundaries. She is determining how far she can push her manager and exactly what she can get away with. This manager should pull this person aside and lay down some basic rules of behavior. For example, public discussions are to be professional and respectful (that works both ways). Disagreements are to be handled privately, not in front of customers (internal or external).

This is a necessary first step because behaviors are objective, measureable, and defined. You can define acceptable behavior in writing and hold her accountable for maintaining acceptable behavior as it is defined. You can take corrective action for violations of acceptable behavior.

IT is a service business with both internal and external customers. Disagreements, arguments, and personal attacks in front of customers reduces their confidence in you and makes your department much less effective.

Once the ground rules of acceptable behavior are established, steps can be taken as you describe, DC Guy, to get to the root of the conflict and get it resolved.

My 2 cents...

Mark

by von291

First off, let me say the best manager I ever had told me that her job (read:management philosophy) was to help me succeed at my job. Ever since then, I have adopted that philosophy for myself.

I am 37 and have been in management positions for 13 years, so I have experienced the resentment of senior (in age or longevity with the company) employees too.

In fact, I had a 75 year old woman that had worked with my company since I was just a toddler! Believe me, it was difficult for her to handle me being her manager. She had a lifetime of expertise (from on-the-job experience) that I could never understand. When I first started working with her, she called me a "brat."

This is how I dealt with the situation:

1. I made it clear to everyone on staff that I was selected for the position based on my skills, expertise, and experience - not my age. At the same time, I am not arrogant or full of myself. Confident, yes. A jerk, no.
2. I respect everyone equally. Even if there are problems with an employee, I still hold the same management philosophy.
3. I continually strive to lead all of my employees to success. I support them when they ask. I back them up when the chips are down. I don't humiliate them in front of others. I encourage, rather than discourage them. I discipline privately and respectfully, and in accordance with policy. I lead by example.

A lot of how the situation goes down is up to you and how you approach it.

From your post, it sounds a little like she's been able to intimidate you because you have mentioned things like, "she misses so many obvious things that are staring her in the face..." etc. In saying that, you reveal your intimidation and insecurity. Rather than point out her flaws, it is up to you to help her succeed in spite of herself.

Don't forget that your subordinates' failures are a reflection of your leadship. Look at this situation as an opportunity to grow and learn how to improve your skills as a leader. You know you have the IT expertise. Now it's time to improve your supervisory skills. Also don't be afraid to ask YOUR supervisor for assistance in handling the situation.

Finally, try to step back from the situation, let go of your ego for a moment, and take a good hard look at how you have been dealing with it. Be honest with yourself. Then rethink your strategy.

Best of luck!
von

by gsinclair

I can understand your case. I'm in a similar position but with a little younger person who is pretty much my age (early 30s. That person was in the dept. longer than I have been. What I have done is try as much as possible to communicate by way of e-mail to same employee. ie. pretty much all task I assign that person is documented in a e-mail and is copied to my superior so they can also see what is happening within the dept. By doing this I find that I talk less to that person their is less doubt/challeges about past issues, and I can foolow-up on task more effectivley based on those e-mails. This step have help me. I hope it can do the same for you.

by jmgarvin

It goes on and on how free fuel made the employees happy and healthy, which made them more productive...This is pure bunk.

by it_juggler

Since my own management experience is somewhat lacking, I'll do here what I most often do in similar circumstances; rely on the insights of my father-in-law (RW) who, although retired now from the multi-million dollar publicly-traded company where he served as CEO/President, serves on several Boards of Directors.

The postings from amcol remind me very strongly of RW; I think they would agree on most things. However, the article referenced by The_Breeze also reminded me of RW.

I disagree that the article was pure bunk. Yes, they gave away free gas (that was only one of many examples in the article) but that was based on a pure cost/benefit analysis. Giving away free gas was cheaper than the loss of productivity. Factory workers who show up to work are more productive than those who don't.

By giving away the fuel (a temporary measure to deal with extraordinary circumstances) the company demonstrated that seemingly harsh remedies such as proposed by amcol are indeed just and right.

by tagmarkman

Looks like you managed to get quite a bit of good an conflicting information on this subject. The fact of the matter is this no one here is completly right or wrong. Only you can make the best choice for the situtation that fits your personality.

If you have the time, DCGuy has some great advice about "understanding" her. It's not a great "immediate" answer but it's invaluable in the long run. Do this for all of your subordinates not just this one in which it may be too late.

If you need to get rid of her, then follow amcol's advice. You're not going to make her a good employee but you will build a case very quickly to get her out of there. This is a hardnosed appoach and you can loose some very good talent and lower employee moral quite a bit, but if it's going nowhere, you this might be the best choice.

Von291 does a good job at describing general management and suggests a demeanor that might be good to follow depending on your personality. This is the type of management I'm comfortable around. It's team oriented (you have something I want they have something you want) instead of (I've got something you want... now do what I want).

jmgarvin hits the nail on the head by saying "lead". I completely agree with this. You manage "things" you lead "people". Leading has to do with a team more than an individual so making the hard choice should be one to benefit the team.

I personally belive you are not the person to mentor her. She needs someone she respects outside of your group.

And lastly: Respect respect respect. I make one rule that I don't tolerate anyone breaking. Never ever attack the person, only attack the work.

by davesims2

I was in a similar situation. If your subordinate is as hard headed as the one I dealt with she has to go. You will be better off and ultimately she will too. In my situation my subordinate was actively undermining my authority. I had two choices, fire a person who had been with the company 35 years or find them a new home. Firing a long term employee can sometimes be political suicide for a new manager. I opted for finding my new friend another place in the company. Can you do that, was there anything this person did before in the company? Can you get them sent back there?

I was able to use salary and overall team effectiveness as justification. In my situation I was able to bring in someone who was more compitent for a little under half what this other person was making.

One last word of advice. Before you make a move like this you will want to make sure you know all the things this person is doing. Make sure the work associated with those activities does not falter.

Best of luck

by michaeljoseph31

Sounds like a personality clash issue with many facets including age, length of service and your developing management style.
You need to have a direct conversation with this person on your expectations of them and the need for them to be seen as part of the team. You need to ensure that HR is on board in case the conversation develops in an adverse manner.
Set goals and timelines for improvement and during this period avoid any open office heated exchanges with this person - for fear of diluting the case / evidence you and HR are gathering on said person.
Stop seeing length of service and an inhibitor as your primary role is to manage and as long as you do this well you will gain the respect of all employees - irrespective of length of service.
You should be aware that there are some staff no matter what you do - their thinking and ways of working may never come around to your viewpoint - should this be one of them, my advice would be to part company with them before their disruption spreads and becomes a total burden / distraction for you and the company.

by jim.allen1

Hi
I recognise the problem as a type of bullying I suggest you go to bullysupport at Yahoo.com there are many on there who are suffering similar problems

by efeegilmez

Once I've heard in one of Arnie's movies, "there is a thin line between being smart and a smart-ass"...

As I have been in the IT sector 10+ years now, I had experienced tough times with similar annoyed personell.

Is this a battle ? Yes, it is. But, if you are good at chess then you have a chance. If not learn it fast. Just like dealing with other sorts of personell, you have to be cool and strategic.

Take this as a case. Why is she like this to you ? What does she want ? Why does she want it? What is her tactics. Plan, create a fightback strategy and destroy.

And YES, she hates you. She wants to smoulder you on the carpets...Why ? Just because you are educated and more performable than she is. She has been in the company longer, and most probably was hoping to get your position until you showed up. She thinks you are a rookie and easy to digest.

Must admit, as she has experience, she is one step ahead of you. But not to worry. You are smarter. You are more upto date... You are on a higher level than her.

The simplest strategy would be to hit her with her own weapons. Dig a hole, camouflage it, ambush, destroy. If you have any positional forces, use it wisely and win the battle.

If her career is important for her, after a while she will realize that her job is on the edge. Then she will stop thinking with her childish ego, and will become a faithfull servant.

by chughlett

Slip onto her desk a brochure offering support for people who have impaired hearing. If she comments, then you just made an honest mistake, thinking her louder-than-average voice might be an outward indicator of a hearing problem. Perhaps speak to your superiors in the context of, "we have an employee I'm concerned about."

:)

by iseriesjunkie

As a member of the hearing assisted community, I'd be highly offended at the "brochure on my desk" routine. If you suspect this, talk with the employee privately and don't mention it to anyone until you know for sure. The louder-than-average voice could be stress related.

by probinso

Donald Trump would go here - determine what the weakest link in the skill set is, and task a job in that area. Set time frames and request updates frequently during meetings with groups. A person who knows a little but uses a big mouth will bury themselves if provided the opportunity. During meetings, ask direct questions in this weak spot in front of peers. If this person is is the bane of everyone else's existence as well, they will applaud (perhaps silently) your efforts. Don't be louder - be smarter!

by c.daniels

You could set a knowledge profile gathering exercise. This would allow you to gain the true strengths and weaknesses of you sub's, this also high lights to the subs what are there weakness and may reduce the noise from the said individual once they realise that you know whether they are blagging it.
Put them to task on thier strenghts which gives them self asteam and makes them feel as if the are not just another body to delegate to.

by b_sen

Based on what you have said, I have faced the loud-mouth aspect several times & dealt with it with "concerned ignorance".

i.e - you listen intently, and argue your point with calm reservation, never raising your tone of voice, despite whats coming back from the other side (However, you must be sure that the points YOU are making are in the best interest of your team - that decision, risky as it may be, as a manager must be yours).

Eventually, the conversation will end, and despite loud opinions, the practical application of the conversation will be at your discretion. If you are concerned of any team member who overhead the "debate" - time will show that in the end, you got your way done, with a calm head.

This has worked for me several times with large teams, and employees ranging from 18 to mid 30's. My humble thoughts for you...

by cnwoods

You don't need to change your communication style, but you can use the situation to your advantage by pointing out how inappropriate it is. When she pipes up in open forum and gets loud, try a quiet reply:
"Obviously this is an issue which is of great importance to you. I'd like to make sure it's dealt with to your satisfaction. Since your colleagues are trying to work, and it would be rude to interrupt them, lets take it to the meeting room and bring an independent support person along just to make sure you're happy with the way it's covered. Would you like to do that now or should we arrange a time?"

There's a great book I can also recommend, called "Positive Politics" - not sure the author but it's a few years back now. Covers how workplace politics can actually be used to improve the working environment instead of detract from it.

by critic

Well, we all can "suggest" but you should know your situation best. Anyway it looks like she is having some sort of identity crisis. Giving her the benefit of doubt, first I would try to win her confidence with soft but firm words and at the same time collect evidence on her deeds/misdeeds to save my back. A tip - usually, the way to sizedown an inflated ego is to allow it make a mistake and let the consequence stare in face.

by jos_hort

I have had to deal with these sorts of employees before and it is really hard to deal with them so I sympathise with you.

The best thing I ever did was tell the person how I felt about what they were doing and asked them why they were doing it. This not only got the person to take responsibility for their actions but, much to my surprise, improved my position of respect with them rather than damage it which is what I'd feared. The key is to be constructive and not insult her huge ego. If you explain that when she does something and you feel a certain way as a result you have taken ownership of it and is something she cannot argue with. You should aim to come out of the meetings with actions you can both take to improve the situation.

If nothing else you will end up with a much better shared appreciation of each other and may find it easier to get along.

I also agree with others this should be a conversation that is documented so that you can show HR fair treatment of a problem employee. Good preparation to this meeting is also key to prevent her derailing what it is you need to say.

Hope this helps!

by reyoung3

Question for you "Anyhelpwouldbegreat" does your company have a good HR department? If so, what kind of employee review system do they have in place? I would look at documenting every time this happens to you. I would also make it a point once things are clam, to invite this person to a conference room with someone from HR to address the concerns at hand. I would use the employee review process to address this behavior pattern which you find unacceptable as a goal for this employee to work on improving to continue to grow in their job. Without documentation, you will be powerless. Every employee/employer issue I have ever experienced, seen or read about have shown without documentation, it would always favor the employee. With documentation the company has a way to manage those employees behavior. I hope this will help. It's not easy, but trust me work with your HR department and develop an Acceptable Work Behavior Policy. Publish it and give it an Effective Date. Also develop a progressive dicipline policy if you don't have one. A progressive dicipline program will not work with out having good documentation. First offense is a verbal warning. Second offense is a written warning put into their personnel file. Third offense is 3 days off without pay. Fourth offense is indefinite layoff. Once this is in place you will be able to manage this employee if they want to continue working with you. I hope this helps. Feel free to let me know your thoughts.

Sincerely,

Richard

reyoung3@hotmail.com

by philip.grogan

Management is a fine art. There are some very good managers around and some equally bad ones. Taking your question at face value and without any intended malice.

Have you considered that the employee might be struggling to be heard. Apart from the obvious characteristics of loud people (which I can be from time to time), one possible reason for this behaviour may be that this person has a lot to offer the company, but is not able to communicate this in an articulate way. Finding out what "type" of person she is (taken from the text on types being Expressive, Directive, Amiable and Analytical). We will all be some or all of these types some of the time, but the theory is that we all relate to one of these types when under pressure or duress. This would really help the situation as you would then have a fair idea of how to manage that particular person. With expressive people, criticism is best being specific and as private as possible, for example that piece of work done to that document was poor, rather than that job was rubbish. However, praise is public.

Group Workshops or white paper tasks could aid this with specific task setting to highlight the employees imnportance. Obviously she is valuable to the company or else the survival of a reshuffle would not have happened.

I have found from experience that understanding how an employee likes to be driven or communicated with, praised or mentored makes vast in roads to helping both the situation and build a unique working bond. It will never be perfect as you are in what is perceived to be the power position. When we talk of menoting, could this be perceived as micro management?.

I suggest going to this link. It has a lot of valuable information on management and a lot of good links. there are many around.

http://www.mapnp.org/library/mgmnt/prsnlmnt.htm

A One 2 one to clear the air maybe a good step in this situation. At least you may get to the bottom of the public criticism.

Thats my two pence worth anyway!.

by carl.gregg

If your office is open to viewing by others, place a flip chart in your office facing away from the group. But, you want everyone coming into your office to see it. Write on it for a few days in the presence of your subordinates and peers.

Then when the person arrives, do not verbally answer. Write on the flip chart: "Please sit down. We can talk about the issues quietly and without disrupting the work of the others." Leave the door open so that others can see.

If the individual storms out, quickly turn the flip chart for the subordinates to read. If she does not but sits down, say "Thank you." Then proceed with the conversation.

If this doesn't get her attention, she isn't a worker that I would want. If it does, she understands the "power" you have as her supervisor.

by jstpaolo

There is no hope of ever having a person like her becoming subordinate, it would be wise to just let her have her say and approach any discussion with a "yes you are right but perhaps it would be better..........." or "maybe you're right but can you see a different way of doing......." or just what should work every time, enroll her help on projects you know she can handle which will keep her busy and out of the way.
Good luck.

P.S. Don't forget to respect her views no matter how wrong she is, your staff will see you in a much more respectfull approachable manner.

by jardinier

Loud, obnoxious people in any situation are totally dependent on a reaction from the object of their harassment. They are very insecure people who are not in control of their own lives, and so try to interfere in other people's lives as a substitute.

By not showing any reaction to their provocation, you pull the rug out from beneath them. These people need an audience. Don't be an audience. Ignore the woman.

From my own experience in various situations in life, including the workplace, your strongest weapon is to totally ignore the person. Without a reaction to their annoyance, they are nothing.

I have avoided all kinds of confrontations, including potential physical harm, by merely showing no reaction to the provocateur.

by southpaw

Man, if you weren't confused when this started you must be now.
I've been in customer service and a manager for over 15 years; Amcol & BHunsinger make the most sense of all the post on this issue. Whatever you do don't argue with anyone. Go back to the basics, in a calm quiet voice tell her to lower her voice and follow you to HR. There in front of an impartial witness, politly explain her job role and her new projects (designed to keep her too busy to think about causing you grief). Then give her the option of her making the most of her new role or 30 minutes to collect her personal belongings.

by commandgce

Women test men all the time. I reckon she's trying to see whether you will give in to her brattish behaviour. From your description, her behaviour isn't rational. In fact, for most of us, much of our behaviour isn't rational - it's largely emotional. So, my comment is not anti-fem. Therefore, there is no need to react rationally to her. You need to deal with the emotional aspect. Seriously!
Call her for sexual harrassment. Call her for intimidation and general harrassment. Call her for insubordination. Publicise her inadequacies. Tell the office that she fancies you and that you turned her down and now she's trying to get back at you.
Part of the problem, from your description, is that you want people to be nice - and so, you lack repertoire for dealing with brats. Being nice doesn't work - you've demonstrated that. Act unexpectedly. Stop being nice. Be cocky and funny at the same time - being sarcastic on its own won't work. Treat her outpourings as a joke. You WILL NEED TO REHEARSE YOUR LINES till they're near perfect. Have some perfect squelches available that'll get the whole office laughing.

by bhargaviscool

I too had this problem in my office, where in the person i had to manage with was even more aged than the one u are facing problems with. the best way to win against them is that the ones who stay long in any company or organisation usually have JOB FEAR that is they like the job either they like it cuz they like to play with the flies on their desktop or simple love the routine and just like to pass the time till they punch their card out of the office.

show them the fear of them loosing this current job they have, if u have company manuals or code of conduct or some guideliness or policies set by the top notches, show it to her, first call her / him in to your cabin and tell her that she has to do it and there is no one else to do the job, if u have tried the carrot and stick approach then u can try positively first, dont try to be very persuasive, u will always loose an edge over these kind of ppl, be serious about ur job and be committed to it, they will realise in time (hardly a week), if still no change in behaviour, then ignorance is the key to all emotional reactions, ignore that person and if possible divert the jobs coming to her to another person (again u need to have a pal or a close person in the office who understands ur problems with this person and u might even need to motivate this person to do this extra job, and may be remunerate him extra.

later when this person realises that she doesnt have any job, she might come to you. then from then on dont try to boss this person for a while and just keep giving this person tasks that are monotonous.

try this it helped me

(Bhargav - Manager HR)

by david.white

A long time ago I found myself being the obnoxious, grumpy, disenfranchised employee who moaned about everyting. I'd found myself in that position because of cirumstance and frustration. I really wanted to do well, but it seemed like my career was being held back my a manager who blocked every internal move that I applied for in the company. the reason was simple: I was the only CICS/COBOL/DB2 coder he had and he couldn't afford to lose me. One day I walked out and never went back, spending many years contracting. It was the best move I ever made.

The reason that I tell you this is that ever since that job, I've found myself managing other people, and manging some large programmes of work - and I've encountered other people who are obnoxious, grumpy and disenfranchised. If you read what Jack Welch has to say about such people, you'd just fire them. However I think it's a bit more complex than that.

Each of these people is angry about something, and they've allowed a negativity about their job to overcome them.

My advice is to get to the bottom of that, and to give that person a way out of the mess. If they take it, then coach them out of the hole that they've dug for themselves. If they don't take it them fire them. You can't afford the negativity and neither can they. You have to confront the issue in the open either one-to-one or with HR present. DO ***NOT** LET THE SITUATION FESTER.

Just recently I met one of these "bad apple" types in a bar in London about 3 years after I'd fired him for being the most grumpy, un co-operative human being I'd ever met. He told me laughing that I did him a huge favour and that after leaving that company he'd never looked back. His whole personality had changed. Sometimes it's just better to move on.

Hope this helps.

by marathoner

You don't really tell us enough here. You mention you are educated, she is hands on, you are there a year she is there five.... etc. but you give no more specifics about her performance. Obviously she rubs you the wrong way and its probably mutual. You say she misses things that are staring her in the face. Since you are IT, those things are probably technical. Is it possible you are missing things that are staring you in the face, as well? It sounds like what we have here is classic LACK of communication, and it's being badly misinterpreted by both parties.

How about inviting her out for coffee and letting her blow off some steam. You might frame it as a
"I'm educated but you have hands-on, and I'd like to know what actually goes on day to day and the stuff you know that's not in the books." She might be delighted to show you "her stuff." When people take that know it all attitude its because they feel threatened. Minorities, women, and older workers often face a hostile environment, and after a while it becomes a self-fullfilling prophecy for them, sad but true. Women, in particular, often perceive themselves as always nudged to the background, and this gal obviously does not want to take the back seat. Think about that old line: "He is a treasure trove of knowledge; she is an obnoxious know-it-all." Write down everything she says and REALLY LISTEN. You might learn something, or find out what's really bugging her, and chances are it's fear. If she is out of date on anything, get her some company paid training. Older workers often perceive (erroneously or not) that all the good training opps go to the young pups. She may be making assumptions about you because you're younger and educated. Most people who have any type of problem solving in their job title perform orders of magnitude better if you take away the fear.

Certainly, if her performance is really coming up short get together and mutually come up with a checklist, but make sure it is doable and not just perceived as a way to get rid of her. If a manager does not make crystal crystal clear what he/she values, workers can't prioritize and end up doing a lot of wheel spinning. No vague hints. Everything objective and measurable, eh?

by philip.grogan

In management there are so many styles to adopt and all of which will have good and bad points to them.

Yes we all come to work for the same deep reason of earning enough to pay for the things we want most. Yes our teams need to be productive in order to survive and yes the working environment is not the end of the universe as we know it. Life will go on.

Yes I am in philosophical mood today!.

However, it will deffinately enhance our earning potential and the roles we will be successful in aplying for ongoing, if we develope our skills in dealing with difficult situations in a possitive manner. This may mean working on a plan of action and trying to cater for each outcome. The last of which should be through HR as this is irreversable and will set the tone. The company will loose out ultimately. But understand that that action copuld be necessary if everything else fails.

In this situation, If management is the career of choice, I would want to make every effort to win over the employee and get a grip on the rains so to speak. Wouldn't it be a great achievement to successfully turn this situation around to a possitive, productive relationship. We are all built differently and becuase of this, one management style does not suite all individuals.

We all have different reasons to come to work each day. Some of us most of the time will be dealiong with lives great difficulties and unfortunately bring this wot work.

It is possible that this person needs a non biased ear to offload on. I like to have the attitude (right or worng) that most people are reasonable by nature and that abnormal behaviour is an outcome not a cause. If we want to succeed for the long haul with management in my opinion, we need to be able to adjust styles and tackle difficult situations head on.

I have found that directive agressive management does not work for the long term and in this day and age employees seek co-operative approach.

But depending on the business it is really horses for courses!.

by gs_2005

Hi, From your note, the following are my assumptions.
1. You are young, well educated and are a manager.
2. You have a subordinate who is older, not so much educated as you are, is more experienced in her present job / company.

I feel that she is not cooperative since she is not recognised for what she is worth. Give her importance, ownership and an area to work independently (under you, of course) with well defined / measurable objectives and least supervision. Make her feel that she is the boss of her little domain. This approach will certainly reap dividends.

GS

by jpaullanier

First, examine your own feelings and motives, especially those which relate to age, experience and education. Take a look, too, at previous actions by you which may have contributed to the behavior you observe.

Second, track the behavior objectively. Is this actually destructive behavior on her part, or is it also possible that you just don't agree with what she says?

Third, have a constructive talk in private with her. Let her know how the behavior bothers you, and avoid criticism or condemnation. Admit your own part. Ask her to mull it over and meet again at a later time with suggestions. Be open to the possibility that your subordinate may feel her opinion is not taken seriously by you.

If you want to get along with your subordinate, you can, but you have to be honest about your own role, you have to respect diversity, and you have to want good relations.

regards, Paul

by Former member

When people are loud it represend insecurity. Now if it is always that way that mean she feel insecure in most if not every aspect of her life at work and in her private. Now one basic thing is always identify what she know first, and validate if it is all what she know. Then as she feel she should know more, in front of everyone she will feel more insecure and that other will also have an opportunity to know she is missing something.
That is bad feeling for her and either she will react by beeing more difficult to connect with or will understand that she have a limit. Those self person usualy learn the hard way and are always proud to display their knowledge to people who have more scolarship, it their way to say I also have learn it without going to school.
If you do attack her in this path, you may hurt other that also learn this way and that do not act the same.

When she talk loud some line can be use:
'Tell me something I don't know' is you feel ....
And 'What is your point in disucssing this it is already set....' as policy or other reason ...
Showing that you want more of her tought as a hole to provide you wiht a view of her argumentation (does she take into account all the element of a situation) will force her to understand or feel that you know this part and more that you feel she should know but you do. That shouldn't lead you to say it (this extend) on the spot you can say 'For the rest of the story see me ....' or 'I feel something is missing, lets revisit it at a later time.' (never put yourself in a situation to take a decision faster that you will feel confortable with.)
Good luck. (English being my second language, please forgive my mistake.)

by satornado

I've sat back and read every response to this situation. Some I would say are right on and some are far from being effective. Either way, the only reason I bothered to post was because of the conclusion that loud represents insecurity. I happen to know for a fact that loud does not represent insecurity because at times I too have become loud myself. The only reasons I became loud was because I was frustrated and angry with the injustice of my situation. The one thing I don't hear anyone saying in this post, if you did I apologize for missing it, is that maybe her problem is in fact that she resents the manager because she feels she was over looked for that position or maybe she feels he is not using her as effectively as she thinks she should be utilized. It seems to me that it would be helpful by pulling her into the office and ask her to express her thoughts and feelings without any reprecussions. First find out why she is being this way and if in fact its just her personality then stand up to her and deal with her. There that's my two cents worth.

by jthamilton6

You've received some good advice: 1) bring her into your office and talk quietly with her about her behavior and why it is objectionable, 2) begin documenting everything, every exchange as well as every work-related incident. After your talk with her, maintain a very professional stance--friendly, but still very professional.
It has always helped me to outline exactly the things I want to talk about before I go into such a meeting and have them at my fingertips during the meeting.

by philip.grogan

This response was refreshing from the previous response which kicked off the thread. The first reponse was a little negative and assumed the worst in the team memeber.

Two two traits loud and worthless do not necessarily go together. companies all too often cut off the nose to spite the face. It is easy to dismiss someones abilities beacuse of a personal clash. A manager is paid to look beyond this and get the best out of team members whilst producing the required results. The two go hand in hand.

If our job was easy, anyone could do it!.

by philip.grogan

This response was refreshing from the previous response which kicked off the thread. The first reponse was a little negative and assumed the worst in the team memeber.

Two two traits loud and worthless do not necessarily go together. companies all too often cut off the nose to spite the face. It is easy to dismiss someones abilities beacuse of a personal clash. A manager is paid to look beyond this and get the best out of team members whilst producing the required results. The two go hand in hand.

If our job was easy, anyone could do it!.

by arleenw

anyhelpwouldbegreat tried the nice guy approch already. Meeting with this person alone could open the door for any number of repercussions.

anyhelpwouldbegreat needs to document behavior and meet with her in a controlled environment with a third party to witness and possibly mediate.

by tom.lee

Whatever her reasons, ot sounds as if she is disruptive to the group. I would take it in three steps:
1) Work with your HR department to determine the correct (ie. legal) method of dealing with this. You don't want to give her to anything that she may turn against you in the future.
2) Put together a plan of what you need to do and in what order. This will give you a goal to shoot and will hopefully keep things on track for improvement.
3) Document, Docuument, Document. Keep written records of what she does and how you respond. If you keep good records and can backup your statements, there is much less likelyhood it will turn into a your word against theirs.

Above all, don't let it turn personal. People that are like this usually understand very well that someone that is upset is likely to make a mistake that can be used against them. They are arrogant and usually look down on others thinking that their skill alone will override anything they do. I once had someone like this that worked for me that transfered from another location that had excellent performance evaluations but gave me fits. When I asked his old supervisor if he had always been like this he said he had been but they overlooked it because he was so smart. You need to deal with is because it's not right to pass someone like this off on someone else (In the end, he ended up leaving on his own after receiving poor marks for "interpersonal skills" on his evalualtion).

Good luck.

by zaferus

I agree completely, as a manager you have to toe the line. Let the employee know with HR presence in a closed door meeting that they have an issue that needs to be corrected. Also with HR give THEM a path of dates and consequences to not complying. They will likely either leave or fall in line before termination becomes necessary.

Bully's may be in grade school playgrounds, don't let them be in the workplace. This isn't only affecting you, all your staff is certainly being affected by this disruption to your team.

by ronny.baeb

You are a manager, this job includes some actions that we as human dislike but are really necessary.
So get to bussines, ORDER here to get in line, and tell here that she only got two ways to go, your (company) way or the highway.
If you don't you will have more troubles, not only with here but the other teammembers will revolt and start to behave in the same manner as she is doing now. The problem is that at that point it will be you whom will be forced to leave the company, the reason will be lack of authority.

best regards

by scooterb

My thoughts are this:

There are a couple of seperate issues which are getting mentioned. Number one, seems to be that she is a "loud, obnoxious person". This is a character flaw. Probably doesn't have anything to do with you as her manager. It's just her personality.

Second, she "seems to know it all". This is a work performance issue. Does she? She may think that she does. This might be based on the fact that she has been there longer. She may have been one of those folks that at one time "was good enough" to handle the IT needs. Maybe when the office was smaller and needs were less. But now she feels threatened. You being younger and more educated are a threat to her once held position of esteem.

You need to handle these things separately. If you handle the work performance first, the other may somewhat fall in line. Does she have some of the basic skills that could make her a good team player with the right training and right application of her skills? If so, then find the right way to get her training and then apply her into a good position for her to demonstrate her skills. If she doesn't have any skills then talk to HR about relocating her to another department. Since your company is going through CH11, there is an awful lot of "self preservation" because folks are worried about keeping their jobs. This may be a defense mechanism in order to make her seem more "needed" to the higher ups. If she displays the same behavior in another department, then she should be dumped.

The personality is a different issue. You cannot change someones attitude nor personality. You can only change their behavior. Have a closed door seesion with her (and HR if possible) and explain to her that her behavior is disruptive to the team and co-workers. If she truly wants to keep her job, then she should be willing to modify her behavior to stay in that position.

This is a good test of a young manager. How you handle it now will say allot about what kind of manager you become in the future.

by jose.baerga

I have come accross two articles in the Academy of Management Review that may offer some assistance. The first one is titled "Incivility in the Work Place" which also has a web site (http://www.publicvirtues.com/Incivility_Study.html). The second is titled "Territoriality in Organizations", AMR, Vol. 30, No. 3, pp 577-594. Hope this may offer some new information and you can follow the references to other research.

by tr

Great ideas Karen, but if anyhelpwouldbenice decides to implement your suggestions she's going to be taking valuable company time to do something that she probably should have done before she filled out the application for a management position or she's not going to be able to eat or sleep for as long as it takes to "pay her dues". I don't have any definitive answers to the situation, although I have a tendency to lean towards Amcol's approach, but I don't feel that "basic training" for a position should be done after the position is awarded. It's a tough situation requiring a tough approach. There should be a "policy manual" or the like. I would go by that to the letter.

by k1eg

I read this and really had to think hard about if I wanted to reply to it or not because I'm not sure you will understand my response. You do need to understand that I
have been on both sides of the fence and can see both sides of this question.

"Ever so often I struggle to manage one of my people. I've just turned 30 and this person is in their mid 40's. I've been her manager for just under a year, and started
with the company as her manager, whereas she's been here 5yrs."

You introduced age into this problem and that is part of the problem which I will explain farther down.

"This person is loud and likes to try to trip me up (loudly), when she knows the office is an open one, where the conversations can be over heard. I do have regular
meetings (weekly updates) away from the environment, but she just likes to try to prove she's right about things that she so obviously isn?t, but because of the noise I
back down, because I?m quite reserved, and basically not that kind of person."

Is she so obviously wrong or do you back down because some of her points maybe right?

"People try to look like they get on with her, and there is so much bitching about anyone and everyone you wouldn?t believe."

This is where you maybe wrong. They might just agree with her. If you are having a problem with bitching about anyone then you obviously have a team problem
and as the team leader means you are not doing your job effectively.

"The company has recently come to some trouble and recovered from Ch11. Her position/ team was moved elsewhere (the helpdesk) and she moved into desktop,
being one of the few to stay."

This is where the real problem stems from. You are dealing with employees who don't know if they will have a job tomorrow. She has been thrown into a new job
that she may or may not be totally comfortable with and her actions seem to indicate that she needs some training and reinforcement of her position. You need to
understand that people in her age group don't adjust to change as easily as you may. You indicated that her position/team was moved elsewhere, now if you mean
by that it was offshored then I can understand where she is coming from. Older people are beginning to resent our jobs being sent to other countries when we are
better able to handle them ourselves. It is becoming totally clear that companies don't give a damn about their employees anymore so why should the employee
care.

"I've come from an IT background, am used to managing younger peers, and am highly educated, whereas her snippets are from experience on the job, although she
misses so many obvious things that are staring her in the face."

I think you clearly show an attitude problem of your own here. You maybe better educated than her but guess what she is street smarter about the company than
you. There are things that you could learn from her and I'm sure things she could learn from you. That is what team management is all about, learning from each
other to do a better job overall. Right now I am betting that not just her but others are seeing the company problems being caused by younger managers who are
better educated but don't have sense enough to come in out of the rain.

"Often when I?m being nice, and mentor her it's shrugged off and feelings of 'I know that' etc. It's very hard to manage such a person.

Does anyone have any thoughts?"

So with all that being said I would do the following.

First pull her personnel records and see if she did her job well in her old position. If there were problems then you need to consider bringing in HR and documenting
her mistakes. If she did well then there is more to this problem.

Second, Get your team together and tell them where the company is at and make them realize that if they don't all work as a team you will all be out of jobs. Ask
them for input on how to make the team stronger and throw out some ideas for their comments. Remember you have been there only a year where as they may
have been there longer and have a better idea of what works and what doesn't.

Third, You mentioned the stockroom problem. You missed a golden opportunity. You should have given her that responsibility to handle the memory. This would
have shown that you are relying on her to do something and trust her. It also would allow you to do something more productive with your time.

You and other younger managers need to realize that people over 40 come from an age that the Golden Rule of management was don't ask somebody to do a job
that you can't do yourself. Older employees see younger management people as people who maybe book smart but have no hands on training and until you show
them that you can do their job they won't respect you.

Something that I have done and maybe will help you is to bring the team together and tell them that for you to better understand what the department problems are
that you are going to spend some time with each person. Then pick one day a week and one employee and spend several hours with them while they do their job.
Make it clear that this is not to evaluate them but to better educate yourself about their job. If they do something differently than you would just ask them why they
handled it that way so you can understand. Make them feel that they are an important part of the department because they are and your job depends on them doing
their job to the best they can. Most of all keep your mouth shut about how they are doing their job while working with them but don't be afraid to ask them what
they are having problems handling. After you spend this time with each employee make notes of the problems back in your office. When you have done this with all
of them then have a meeting where you list the problems for all of them to see and ask for ideas on how you can solve them as a team. Present some ideas that you
feel will help solve these issues. This will also give you a chance to find out the strengths and weakness of each employee and you may want to move them around to
be more effective. Remember that if you do this make sure that you let them know it is because they are good at what they do.

I know that a lot of this isn't taught in school but should be. Show them that you want to work with them and use your knowledge to make them better employees.

by ruby_krajick

Her behavior is poor, and she feels threatened (having a reorg and seeing staff go make people nervous, and she wants to appear smart and knowledgeable).

Give her a task that she can handle start to end, define it clearly in writing, meet with her regularly to monitor progress. Keep the issue of her behavior about the WORK. If her behavior towards others hurts her ability to accomplish the project, talk to her in terms of "When you do X, Y happens to your work". Also, when she is right about something, give her praise in a group setting -- you will see her turn around.

Obviously the company thinks she is worth keeping, and the other employees who watch you help her improve her performance (modified behaviour = better job performance) the staff will perform better as a whole.

If she fails at the task, and your discussions with her about how her behavior impacts her job performance fall on deaf ears, then start the HR process to terminate employement.

How you handle this situation will show staff that "personalities" are not an issue, you can get along with anyone, but that how people behave cannot impede the work that needs to be done. Demonstrate the connection of work performance and office conduct and you will come out on top.

Good luck,

RJ

by csettle

You've gotten some excellent advice, so let's see if we can sort through what might be essential here, and what steps you might follow.

1. Before you go any further, make sure you understand your own feelings and motives. If your motives are based in your own insecurities, address those first. If you are not beginning from an ethically unchallengable position, you have to fix that first.

2. Be clear that you are taking issue with your employee's BEHAVIOR, not with who your employee IS. If you begin from the assumption that your employee's motivations are good (whether or not they are), you can prevent youself from challenging her integrity. Focus on challenging her behavior.

3. Make a plan of action. Make sure your management and HR knows what's going on, and what action you're planning to take. Be sure that you have the authority needed to take these actions.

4. You have an ethical responsibility to hold your employee accountable for her behavior. If your employee's behavior is resulting in poor performance and/or a high-stress environment, you must address it directly with her. The message is: behavior X is producing unwanted result Y. Since the employee has good intentions (you MUST assume), behavior X must be replaced with a different behavior (N) to produce desirable result Z. Give her the opportunity to participate in discussion with you about what behavior N is, so she will feel a sense of ownership in the solution.

5. Create goals with your employee to measure her success in changing her behavior. Measure performance with her. Document the process and results. Hold your employee accountable for changing her behavior, and keep her involved in the goals and assessment. If the chosen behavior N is not achieving the desired result, discuss it directly and honestly, and work with her to choose a different behavior.

6. If your employee is unwilling to participate, or unable to meet the goals, discuss the consequences openly with her. NEVER threaten, and never offer consequences that you do not have the authority, your management's agreement, and HR's buy-in to enact. Just clearly state what process you are following, and what action you will take if results are not achieved.

7. Be open to recognizing where your employee's talents really lie if they are not what she's doing right now. If she's in the wrong job, see what you can do to help her move into a position where she can succeed.

8. Resolve to do what you must in order to do your job effectively. That means that you must be able and willing to coach your employee (whether you like her or not) through to better behavior. And that you must be willing to move her to another role, another department, or out of the company if needed.

Best of luck.

by oldmainframer

I got the impression that the original poster was male. If married, this is a really bad idea. You should NOT have a solo lunch with a member of the opposite sex who is not your spouse. Think of what might gfet back to your wife, friends, etc. if anyone sees you.

If not married, again, the appearance is bad, because someone who does not know the situation might think that it is a "date".

Then there is the question of a relationship with a subordinate. Generally we think that bosses should not have a relationship with subordinates... While this is not what is happening, it is the APPEARANCE - to an outside observer.

by shannyhan

amcol, I agree with your approach, however pointing out anyhelpwouldbegreat's weaknesses and/or flaws as a manager and in such a manner may not have been necessary.

If anyhelp knew the answer then we wouldn't be here.

My advice to anyhelp -- take out the constructive comments from amcol's post. Treat this employee just like you would treat anyone else on your team and take control of the situation. You will be happy that you laid the ground rules. It is never to late to take control of the situation. There will be damage that will need to be mitigated, however.

The next time the loud, obnoxious behavior ensures, call the employee into your office and tell them what you expect which includes being respectful.

by kcserv

I have been in a similar situation and realize it is not easy to get out of. You want to be "nice" and you want to avoid confrontations, however I'm afraid that's what is necessary. At least to a certain degree. I think there are quite a few good suggestions here, but the main focus is to establish your relationship as her manager. This does not mean you have to be impolite, nasty or even look to fire her, but you do have to address her behaviour immediately. When she begins one of her loud commentaries, immediately interrupt her and ask her if there is a reason why she is talking so loud (you can do this nicely). If she is trying to "make you look bad", stop her and offer to discuss the matter in private where you will explain what she is missing. Not only will these little steps help establish your relationship, but it will also help morale if the other employees see you "managing" this employee. Some of the other ideas you may want to employ are emailing tasks (written record is critical). Giving her small projects to build her confidence, give her security, feel trusted...etc. is a good idea as well because she will have to give you updates as to how it's going and that further enforces your position as manager. Just my thoughts, Good luck!

by lmcghee

Very often we place the wrong label on a problem, and then become perplexed trying to solve the wrong thing. I think if you simply replace the word "obnoxious" with "insubordinate" your choice of actions should be clear.

This may seem ?extreme?, but this company put you (not ?loud mouth?) in charge, and though I?m not a strong proponent of the ?educated? is better than ?experienced? point-of-view, I won?t question the decision ?who put you in charge.?

What is also obvious is that you don?t have her respect; you cannot go to a classroom to learn it! This is why it?s obvious: you?ve just turned 30, and you?ve been her supervisor for a year, therefore this started when you were 29. Assuming you got your degree at 22 (which is really cutting it close), and ASSUMING that you immediately secured a job, you?d been in the work force 7 years prior to your current position. Since the only places I know of that hire people to be supervisors/managers are the likes of MacDonald?s, Jack in the Box, etc, means that you had to be just another ?worker-bee? like everybody else for 18 to 24 months; and if you got promoted sooner then that why did you leave? Therefore, you haven?t managed very long, a career is at least 20 (military, police, fire) and as long as 40 years (corporate,) you haven?t got that much experience, and managing is HARD work.

You can only EARN respect, and you haven?t in a year, you?ll find that termination procedures may put her in check, and quiet the situation, but you?ve lost all chance for respect, and it will be a thorn in your side.

by keyguy13

No need to apologize for being a good manager, Amcol. Some of these other people have obviously never HAD to manage anyone. And it's obvious Zen37 never has.

The old adage "If people like you as a manager then you must be doing something wrong" is appropriate here.

It's not our job as managers to "be nice" and have everyone like you. If you want acceptance and gratitude, go cry to your mom.

If you want this woman, who it sounds like is just being a pain in the a$$, to stop undermining you, tell her to stop.

And frankly, I would do it publicly, right in the middle of one of her "tantrums".

It doesn't matter if she is older, OR if she has a lot of experience. If you KNOW she is incorrect in what she is trying to tell you, CALL HER ON IT.

These kinds of people need to be knocked down a peg. It needs to be done quickly AND aggressively.

After all, you're her boss. She needs to know it.
Often, that is all it takes, and she will probably respect you for it. I know that *I* don't respect someone being fake and "falsly" nice to me, and that may be her issue with you.

Grow some balls and manage her. Ultimately, you're the one accountable to the department for your performance. If she can't be handled. Fire her, or like other posters have said, bring HR into it and document it formally. It really is your most direct course of action. Sorry if you don't want to hear it.

And if you are reserved and wimpy and unable to confront problems head-on, you probably won't be a manager much longer anyway.

by iseriesjunkie

Looks like you hit a nerve for sure. I also moved into a supervisory position over an existing employee with an attitude. She was younger than me, but it's not an age thing, it's a control issue. I found it best to talk with her behind closed doors and to stick to the facts. If "caught" in the open, speak softly, you will seem to be in control. Certainly don't match the volume or intensity of the other person-you will look like you are reacting and you will be, but let it be on your terms. You can always suggest you discuss the issue at another time to let things cool off. Other employees and your manager are watching your reaction more than the employee's.

On the other hand, get over the other person's lack of formal education and your need to flaunt your education (indicated by the words "highly educated"). I count my 20+ years of experience as valuable as the formal education I've had. Although experience doesn't give us everything, it does show us what has worked in the past and can be used to "shortcut" the diagnostic proceedures to arrive at a solution quicker. Show the person that you value their experience and you will have a team member, not just an employee.
When they, and you, feel more secure, they will "see the obvious".

Good Luck!

by ctos

I have been there, but in the opposite direction...a supervisor was younger than me, but was very controlling and mean. Thankfully, I had another supervisor that was over her, who was not mean or controlling. One day, things came to a crisis and we were standing face to face (about 2" appart), when the nice supervisor came in and broke us up! lol
I will pass her recommendations to you: first, stall off the situation by telling this obnoxious woman "we will make time to discuss that issue, but it is not the time now. Please write down your comments/problems and I will let you know when we can get together to discuss it"
This will change the scene by not allowing her to keep yapping, she will have to make an effort to actually write down things AND she will not be allowed to make a "scene" that will harm you. Either she will back down in time (as long as you hold to this method of handling her), or she will like your attention and your listening to her and bring real ideas that could possibly be helpfull to you.
Overall, making it publicly known that you are not allowing disruptions, but DO listen can do nothing but help you with the rest of the staff!
Good luck and feel free to email me with the results!