Marriage for Same-Sex Couples - Wow
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
After Hours
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
G'day All,
First a few historic points:
1. Marriage as a civil joining of couples into households was around before the Holy Catholic Church (ie the entire Christian Church of the day) started organising formal religious ceremonies about it. It was known as marriage before then, and still is.
So the Christian churches do NOT have an ownership on the word, nor do any other churches.
2. Current marriage laws in most western societies were originally based on the church rules about marriage introduce during the middle ages. Thus the current restrictions are all religious based.
3. With any government approving same sex marriages they open the door wide for the approval of multi-spousal marriages as well. So you can expect that to be on the agenda very soon after same sex marriage is legalised and being pushed by the Muslim community.
4. Civil marriage and religious marriage do need to be split apart and made as two separate activities, the way they are in some European countries. Thus a wedding is held before a civil celebrant and then another in the church of your choice, if you want a church wedding. This will resolve 95% of the community argument on the issue.
A big concern I see is the legalising of same sex marriage will see some people wanting one approaching churches about having a same sex church wedding and then suing the church when they get refused. If the two are disassociated from each other then this problem won't occur. I do know of some places where ministers of religion who were also approved civil celebrants resigned as civil celebrants when they heard of the possibility of their local state government approving same sex marriage as the existing laws would have seen them liable for charges of discrimination if they refused to marry a same sex couple. By ceasing to be a civil celebrant the changes in the civilian marriage laws no longer had any application to them and they could continue to apply their religious teachings to the religious services without any legal trouble. Sadly this is NOT the way the laws would work in all legal jurisdictions unless the laws actively split the two apart.
5. One big shock for many people will be the fact that there is NO Christian scriptural support for monogamous marriage (ie one spouse) for the general population. This was something introduced by a Pope in the middle ages for reasons of creating more power over the general population. The only reference for one spouse comes from 1 Timothy chapter 3 verse 2: 'A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach.'
Mind you verses 4 and 5 say: 'One that ruleth well his own house, having his children in subjection with all gravity;
(For if a man know not how to rule his own house, how shall he take care of the church of God?)'
Later verses in the chapter say similar things about those seeking to be a deacon in the church.
Other scriptures, mostly in the Old Testament give laws on and discuss the proper way to treat multiple wives, and there are many cases of people who could afford the care of multiple wives having them. It's these same scriptures transferred into the Quran that support the multiple wife aspect of Muslim teachings.
Thus, the Christian churches have no scriptural support for stopping multi-spousal marriage.
....................
The government should change the marriage laws to have the civil marriage as legal contract between any types or groups of people and the only restrictions should be requirements for the welfare of any and all children, the care and conservation of property of the group, and the need for all those in the marriage to approve the introduction of a new member or it can't happen. Anything else is basically a union of church and state in regards to them marriage laws.
Regards
Ernest
Please don't throw too many other cats in the pigeon coop.
by ansugisalas
The whole point of the Christian wedding was to gain control over the nobility and royalty : No church blessing = no legal heir = end of dynasty.
Very simple, really.
by john.a.wills
You can also follow up the references from the articles in your local library or elsewhere, if you want. Wiki page link is followed by relevant quotes. The first definitive Papal Bull on marriage was approved by Pope Pius IV as one of the outcomes of the Council of Trent in November 1563. Despite attempts by some bishops to make marriage a religious ceremony as early as 110CE it was not made that way in the Christian church for many centuries. Although marriage is mentioned in some earlier councils, the first mention of any church procedures on marriage is in the Fourth Council of Lateran in 1213. Prior references include the Council of Chalcedon 451 AD where priests and nuns are forbidden to marry (a civil action at that time, not a church one) and the First Council of Lateran in 1123 where blood relatives are forbidden to be married. The majority of stuff coming out of councils and canons prior to Canon 50 of 1213 Ad dealt with matters of political power for the church, with a few on religious definitions etc.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Council_of_the_Lateran
Canons 50-52: On marriage, impediments of relationship, publication of banns.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage
From the early Christian era (30 to 325 CE), marriage was thought of as primarily a private matter, with no uniform religious or other ceremony being required.[51] However, bishop Ignatius of Antioch writing around 110 to bishop Polycarp of Smyrna exhorts, "It becomes both men and women who marry, to form their union with the approval of the bishop, that their marriage may be according to God, and not after their own lust."[52]
With few local exceptions, until 1545, Christian marriages in Europe were by mutual consent, declaration of intention to marry and upon the subsequent physical union of the parties.[54][55] The couple would promise verbally to each other that they would be married to each other; the presence of a priest or witnesses was not required.[56]
in 1563 the Council of Trent decreed that a Roman Catholic marriage would be recognized only if the marriage ceremony was officiated by a priest with two witnesses. The Council also authorized a Catechism, issued in 1566, which defined marriage as, "The conjugal union of man and woman, contracted between two qualified persons, which obliges them to live together throughout life."[65]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_of_Trent
In the decrees on marriage (twenty-fourth session) the excellence of the celibate state was reaffirmed (see also clerical celibacy), concubinage condemned and the validity of marriage made dependent upon its being performed before a priest and two witnessesalthough the lack of a requirement for parental consent ended a debate that had proceeded from the 12th century. In the case of a divorce, the right of the innocent party to marry again was denied so long as the other party is alive, even if the other may have committed adultery.
That should answer your question on where the marriage laws come from.
By controlling when and how the kings and other secular leaders could marry and what was a legal marriage the Church leaders controlled who could and couldn't inherit property and positions of power, thus giving the church more power and authority.
Check out this article and look at what the Papal bulls gave authority of
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Papal_bulls_by_year
The Pope assigned ownership of whole countries and lands, amongst many other things. Most are political and power matters. If you do a lot more research in major libraries you'll find a hell fo a lot more, but I'll let you do your own now you know where to look.
Ernest
by aaron.cirilo
by nicknielsen
by av .
From Wikipedia:
"In January 2009, it was reported that Obama opposed a federal mandate for same-sex marriage, and also opposed the Defense of Marriage Act,[58] stating that individual states should decide the issue.[59][60] Obama opposed Proposition 8 ??? California's constitutional ban on same-sex marriage ??? in 2008.[61] In December 2010, the White House website stated that the president supported full civil unions and federal rights for LGBT couples and opposed a constitutional ban on same-sex marriage."[57] He also stated that his position on same-sex marriage was "evolving" and that he recognized that civil unions from the perspective of same-sex couples was "not enough", before subsequently declaring his full support for the legalization of same-sex marriage in May 2012"
I don't think he really wanted to pursue this issue right now. Some people say he is using the issue to distract from his poor record on the economy/job creation. If he is, he made a poor choice because this country is not ready to accept gay marriage and the number one issue on voters minds is the state of the economy and job creation.
AV
by av .
As you mentioned in your post:
"I would love to have a discussion on the US Constitution. Maybe it would get some people around here to actually read it."
Something to consider . . .
AV
by dogknees
by john.a.wills
like any scripture it has to be read in light of the surrounding verses. You also assume these verses support monogamy, when the actual text does NOT say that. Go back and re-read Matthew 19 from verse 5 and you find Jesus is replying to a question about putting a wife away, in verse 8 he also uses the term wives. In the reply Jesus speaks about how wrong it is to keep a wife solely for the purpose of sex Matt 19:5-12
Oh, and don't forget, Jesus was a Jew speaking on the Jewish faith and laws.
And don't forget this was originally written in Greek and there are several ways to interpret much of what's in there, based on how you want it to read.
And before you ask, yes, I am a Christian who follows the teachings of Jesus Christ, I just don't follow the way many of his teachings have been warped and misrepresented by various men in positions of power over the centuries.
Oh, nearly forgot - I said reaffirm as the first actual mention of Holy Catholic position on marriage is in the Fourth Council of Lateran in 1213 (as stated above) as Canon law 50 setting when the Church will approve a marriage or divorce. From what I've found out so far, I can't be sure if that Canon sees marriage as a Church rite or a case of Church approval of the civil situation.
by john.a.wills
by john.a.wills
Homosexuality is an improper concept, as I showed somewhere above (I go into greater analytic detail in my book Albatross), but I suppose you mean that the ancient Sodomites commonly practised same-sex mutual masturbation. This is quite a common idea, but Ez 16:49-50 tells us that the sin for which Sodom was destroyed was something else, something like libertarianism or objectivism. How the Sodomites got the reputation of being rapist gays I do not know. But we do know from elsewhere in the OT that gayness cropped up a long time ago.
Anyway, you believe that sexual inversion of the erotic instincts is a psychological disorder while mutual masturbation is a sin. I suggest to you that mutual masturbation is a greater sin if the participants are of different sexes, because there they have the option of copulation, which sexual inverts do not.
many people see a guy having anal sex with a guy as wrong yet a guy having anal sex with a female is OK - yet it's the very same act. Now that's a serious double standard.
And, NO, I am not going to get into an argument about if either is right or wrong - I'm just pointing out the double standard of many who see it differently based on the genders involved.
by john.a.wills
by ansugisalas
by robo_dev
Can you prove or disprove that the interface port on my computer is in-fact controlling the entire universe? (might explain why it lags at times)
And there is the practical issue that you do not know the 'law of God' nor do I, nor can anyone prove or disprove whether what you or I SAY is (or is not) the law of god is (or is not) true.
Thus the 'law of God' is an abstract concept, and as such, can be quite literally anything.
The laws that people create are, at times, what they THINK God wants, but they have no way of knowing what God wants or does not want.
Thus in certain cultures, men believe that God wants them to stone to death any woman guilty of adultery, but here we call that murder. Men use God as an excuse to justify what they believe to be right, or as an excuse to do what they want to do, no more.
at that time did not regard monogamy as the basic marriage situation and their laws on dealing with later wives were very extensive.
However, I think we'll have to agree to disagree on this item.
Homosexuality is when a person engages in sexual activity with someone of the same gender. But the actual acts are those that many heterosexuals behave in as well.
Male homosexuals engage in oral sex and anal sex, while female homosexuals engage in oral sex and the use of hands on the genitals. ALL these activities are also performed by many heterosexual couples.
Now the real oddity is many people get the knickers twisted about the idea of two guys getting together in this way but accept it's OK for two girls to get together like this, and it's perfectly natural for mixed couples to get together like this. T'is a real wonder and example of conditioning, I think.
by delbertpgh
Joe Biden's announcement forced Obama's hand. He had to make a statement. Large forces within the Democratic party support gay rights, including marriage. If Obama said he could not back gay marriage now, or worse, that he could never accept the concept of gays being recognized as entitled to the status of married people, he would have ignited civil war in his party. So, he announced he had "evolved."
The more politic thing would have been to keep quiet while the rest of society worked closer to recognizing this as a human right. There are lots of moderate Democrats, as well as the whole evangelical group that has now become almost exclusively Republican, who are offended by it. He's just fired up more anger and opposition that he just didn't need. The whole gay marriage issue is a wedge, but it's not one that favors Obama.
by kevin888
by mary1010
by john.a.wills
by nicknielsen
by john.a.wills
...by far the most usual way of handling phenomena so novel that they would make for a serious rearrangement of our preconception is to ignore them altogether, or to abuse those who bear witness for them.
James: Pragmatism lecture II
Of course, I am bearing witness not for phenomena but for concepts.
by nicknielsen
That seems to be what your response implies.
Your philosophical offering serves only to obfuscate the issue, which is not the morality of sexual behavior between individuals of the same gender (a religious issue), but the denial to same-sex couples in a committed relationship of the same benefits granted to married couples under current law (a civil rights issue).
It is neither my place nor yours to determine the morality of consensual private behavior that causes no physical or economic harm to others.
by john.a.wills
quote
This really is disastrous. US or any other country the law they make and try to enforce should not conflict with the law of God or the laws of highest authority.
end quote
I won't get into what or who anyone regards as the highest authority, beyond saying the highest civil authority is that of the highest judicial element of that country be it a court or a member of royalty etc.
Now as to the 'Law of God' - assuming you are referring to some one who is a follower of either the Hebrew, Muslim, or Christian faiths (all of which follow the teachings of Abraham) then you have a statement that those who follow that teaching are NOT to engage in same sex physical relationships. Now there are a few important aspects of this that needs to be kept in mind:
1. If the people involved are NOT of one of the faiths that oppose same sex physical relationships, then there is nothing in their understand of God's laws to stop them - end of story.
2. If you follow any of the religious faiths mentioned above, then you know that the scriptures of all three include the teachings that God gave the each and every person on Earth the RIGHT of free will and freedom of choice to follow God's rules and teachings. Thus any true believer of any of those faiths KNOWS they have NO scripturally based rights to interfere in how someone else exercises their God given free agency.
3. At the time the teachings about NO same sex physical relationships were handed down the act of conducting and sanctifying marriage was a purely social / civil activity and nothing to do with God, the priests, or the scriptures. It was thousands of years more before the churches got involved in marriages and it wasn't as part of the directions given by God or any of God's prophets. The laws of Moses had many laws on how to behave in regards to others, including how to treat spouses and how to have a divorce, but not on how to perform a marriage.
I strongly believe the answer on this issue is purely civil and up to the individuals concerned, or, at the most, up to each local community to have a say on if they accept it or not.
by nicknielsen
My philosophy tells me it's wrong to judge the activities of others if those activities are consensual and cause no physical or economic harm to others.
As I see it, you are attempting frame this subject as a condemnatory and judgmental moral discussion. This is based on the use of words and phrases with high negative connotations: sin; indecency; etc. This sentence is an excellent example: [i]What is at stake is the supposed right to engage in simulated copulation a.k.a. mutual masturbation a.k.a. gross indecency - regardless of the sexes of the participants.[/i]
I just don't consider the subject to be a philosophical issue in the manner in which you appear to be trying to frame it.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending