Discussion Locked

McAfee or Symantec?

0 helpful
31 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Following the corruption of my Windows XP Media Center 2005 system's registry, I was forced to utilize Sony's recovery wizard process, which essentially returned my system to the same state it was in when I removed it from the box upon receiving it last year.

After buying the PC, I purchased Norton Anti Virus 2004. So, my newly recovered system was without antivirus protection. I reinstalled my Norton AV 2004, which still has four months left on the subscription I purchased last year, but now it's refusing to update. I'm tired of troubleshooting it. Norton's support site provides only lame recommendations for fixing the error (Subscription Service cannot update: Reinstall software and reboot to see if that eliminates the issue, or something similar). Which brings me to my question.

Which antivirus protection software works best on home/small office systems? Should I switch to McAfee (I can get it free with rebates from CompUSA), or should I invest another hour or two trying to fix my existing Norton software?

I'm just glad I don't need AV software on my Mac...

EE

Read more about my system failure here: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5254-6257-0.html?forumID=99&threadID=173921&messageID=1838639&id=3334484

31 replies

by zen37

I really like this issue, looking forward to the responses. I have the same issues with spyware removal programs. If anyone have recommendations about those aswell, i would like to hear them.

by Erik Eckel

I'm not sure if they're the best, but I typically run both Microsoft AntiSpyware (which is in beta, of course) and Spybot S&D. Working together, they appear to catch most spyware instances.

I know several sources that also speak favorably of Sunbelt Software's CounterSpy and LavaSoft's Ad-Aware, too. They're worth checking out as well.

EE

by van morris

I've used McAfee for more than 7 years and I'm happy with it. However, since I knew about SafeSystem (which highly recommend) I've used this tool for complementing my other security programs because it protects my system regardless the kind of (known or unknown) virus, spyware or malicious code is trying to infect my computer. In fact, it simply doesn't allow any program to be installed or copied to my system while I'm surfing the Web, reading my emails or working with my computer. Sincerely, this gives me a lot of piece of mind because my system is always protected no matter if my anti-virus and anti-spyware are updated or not. Don't forget that perhaps they are updated but they just don't recognize the virus or spyware which is trying to get into my computer.

I found SafeSystem at: http://www.gemiscorp.com/english/safesystem/info.html
Also, you can see a good PR about this program at: http://www.prweb.com/releases/2006/1/prweb339444.htm

IMPORTANT: I want to clarify that I don't have any direct or indirect relation with the company that owns the product I'm suggesting, so my posts shouldn't be considered SPAM.

by neil higgins

I used to use Norton Internet Security Suite 2004,until my license expired.I did not renew.Firstly,Norton has been "hacked" so many times on the web,it's past a joke.Since Symantic took over Norton,in my opinion,the service has gone downhill.I empathise with you,that the support site can be hit and miss.When I uninstalled Norton from my home pc,it was a nightmare to get rid of everything from the registry,even to the point of editing myself.I now use my isp's full quota of security apps.,which include a firewall,anti-virus,spyware,adware,pop-up blocker,and privacy manager.But this is because I subscribe to a UK cable company.Personally,go with McAfee,it's not that bad,and has reasonable reviews.If you want to read some comments,albeit briefly,see this link site (not McAfee's own):

http://www.sofotex.com/reviews/r3.html

by jamesrl

I wouldn't suggest that McAfee is perfect. But overall I have seen fewer issues with it than Norton.

And while the Mac has fewer issues, its not because its immune - its just not been the target of virus writers, because of the well known MS vulnerabilties, and might I suggest MS hubris attracts a few attacks too.

I experienced my first Mac virus (a trojan) at noon on April 1, 1987. It took over the screen of every Mac it had infected (accidentally distributed with Aldus Freehand) and displayed a "world message of peace" graphic. Unfortunately this program didn't exit gracefully and we had to reboot. I lost an hour's work (stupid me wasn't used to saving every 5 minutes like I do now) on a project I was charging an hourly rate on.

I was involved in the anti-virus fight at a major corporation in the 90s with tens of thousands of Macs. There were viruses that came through - the Word Macro viruses were hard to get rid of. We used Norton Anti Virus on the Macs - it was a great tool.

James

James

by Erik Eckel

That's an important point: Macs aren't immune; it's just hardly any hacker's are taking the time to target Macs. The same is true with spyware efforts.

Is that why my 1.5 GHz Mac seems as fast as my 3.4 GHz Sony? Apart from the obvious architecture design differences, is the Sony dedicating so many processor cycles and memory resources to Microsoft AntiSpyware, Norton AV 2004, and Spybot S&D on my Windows system that the Mac needn't run?

EE

by jamesrl

The architecture differences are major. Power PC chips have always been better at certain functions than Pentiums that are even 50% faster, mostly math functions(which includes graphics). Not sure if you are running OS X, but the kernel is more efficient.

But you have hit the nail on the head. I find Norton in particular to be a pig. I spent good money on Norton Systemworks a few years ago only to dump it because of the overhead it required. I think Spybot and the Tea Time app it runs on startup isn't too draining.

I find it useful to look at running processes from time to time just to see whats going on. Trimming ones you no longer need can help improve your speed.

James

by lynn.kist

I have used both McAfee and Norton. I like Norton better. I used to work for a company in Illinois that didn't have any antivirus at all. The person in charge said they didn't need an antivirus because they were a small company and didn't have virus. The first week I was there I showed her that they had viruses. I used McAfee and it didn't get rid of this virus on all the files that were infected. I took one of the floppies that had a lot of files on it to the college I was going to at the time. They use Norton. Norton went through the disk twice and cleaned all of the files. The job I am at now in Indiana we use Symantec Client Firewall, it works very well. I use Symantec Internet Firewall at home. Every now and then I get a message that it is stopping a trojan horse.

by rascal1981

My personal experience has been that Trend Micro is a good home based product and corp. wise I use symantec's line of products (best support with the right contract...). That being said Symantec/Norton is a good product and will do as good as any other AV solution out there so long as you keep it up to date. To fix your problem I would download/install the latest update tool from symantec and I would also check the KB at http://www.symantec.com/techsupp/consumer.html to see what is there. The problem is usually that the updater is corrupted and you need to uninstall the updater itself and reload it.

by Erik Eckel

As I've already ponied up the dough for Norton, that's my preference (to make it work).

Unfortunately, I've already uninstalled all the Norton components and reloaded them, and I'm still receiving the same error. I suspect it's because Sony's default install included Norton Internet Security, which didn't remove itself gracefully. Short of manually editing the registry to remove the problematic Norton files, and then only to have to resubscribe in four months after taking the trouble to do so, is worrisome.

I'm going to take your advice and uninstall the updater only, and then install the latest updater (Live Update) available from Symantec and see what happens. If it still can't update, though, I'll have to begin shoveling through the registry. It'll be easier at that point just to purchase McAfee. That's frustrating, as I already bought the Norton AV, but buyer beware, I guess.

Thanks for the suggestion,

EE

by ni70

Erik

Have you ran any registry cleaners, such as CCleaner? I've heard of others but can't remember their product names. Give CCleaner a shot to see if it'll get rid of the registry crud Norton leaves behind.

by av .

Every user that we have that buys a PC with Norton Internet Security or Antivirus has problems - bar none. Almost all of them end up removing it. The ones that don't, continue to have problems with their PC that usually have something to do with Norton.

I don't care for Mcafee's firewall, but their antivirus is a stable product that I have used for many years. I prefer Zone Alarm for a software firewall.

Save yourself alot of aggravation and get rid of Norton.

by robroynj

They don't have a personal version but they have a small biz version that could be used. We use the enterprise version and its great. They do a good job with Spyware as well but we also use Webroot spyweeper. It seems like there isn't a single product that does it all with spyware. Both Sophos and Webroot push out from an admin console and they work really well. I know Webroot has a personal version and I'd recommend that.

by ian lewis

We use the small business version of Sophos on the desktops and Exchange server.

Whilst the product is certainly adequate for the job it does have rather a large memory footprint and a tendency to slow down our workstations if on access scanning is on.

AVG seems to be lighter weight, lower cost and captures viruses just as well.

by jee_grover

Hello mate,

What I would first say is do not limit yourself to only these two vendors. There are other great antivirus and firewall solutions out there that don't cost a bunch.

ZoneAlarm offer a completely free firewall which is unbelievably strong and other vendor's firewall solutions need to learn from this.

You can get TrendMicro's full internet suite for only $50.

You said you installed Norton AV. I am guessing that by this you mean only the AV software so you have either a firewall solution you don't mention or none at all. The TrendMicro suite I speak of is a complete solution and should do you well because it is very simple to setup and use, and does not bog on resources like the consumer Symantec products do.

Symantec is great for corporate products, I've not been fond of their unupdated consumer product engine that they keep charging money for, and I'm certainly not fond of McAfee.

Links:

www.zonealarm.com
www.trendmicro.com

Cheers,

Jee

by Erik Eckel

That's a good tip. Always worth a try.

I think I may have discovered part of the problem. The Norton component that's refusing to update is a subscription services element. I dug deeper and realized I'm using Norton AV 2003 Professional (purchased in Nov 2004, I'm pretty sure). Even though I haven't had it a year yet, Norton's no longer providing support or updates (other than virus definitions, apparently) for that version.

I need to go check when I bought the software, but I'm pretty sure it was the fall of last year, but if that proves to be true, I will have learned a lesson.

EE

by dr dij

I installed it then tried installing a program. It stopped registry changes (which I wanted) and pop-up box was so garbled I could not select allow.

Had to un-install spybot then re-install it with this option off. Too bad, looks like a good option.

by tony hopkinson

and it works fine. Spybot S&D and GriSofts AVG both work fine for me. Both my latest purchases had Norton on them, not any more, not keen on Hostageware.

by antuck

I had nothing but problems with Norton and McAfee lately and personally have sworn them both off. There customer support is terrible and there products have been going down hill for awhile.

I stated using AVG and really like it alot. It doesn't take up the resources that norton and mcafee do. there are two version a free one and a paid version. The free is for home users only.

AVG's web site
http://www.grisoft.com/doc/1

To get the free version

http://free.grisoft.com/doc/1

I use the free version and havn't had any issues with it.

by grbeckmeyer

If you can't get Norton working, I would definitely take a look at Grisoft. I haven't had the misfortune of working with Norton for a couple years now, but about 2-3 years ago I would regularly find viruses/trojans with AVG that Norton either couldn't find or would find but could not fix. Beyond that, I would also agree with other posts to expand your scope a little. I use CA etrust at my office, and my-etrust and AVG at home. Been using my-etrust at home for a long, long time...since it used to be a free product, think it was called IPE (forget what that stood for). Haven't ever officially tested it, but it seems to be less of a resource hog than Norton. Only problem I've ever had was an upgrade issue, they never emailed me the new install key and it was a ridiculous hassle trying to obtain one through support.

by tony hopkinson

I've been using it for about a year at home, it regularly cleans up the garbage my son picks up through using IE and MSN Messenger.

by jaqui

the popular choice with a lot of people. it is far less resource hungry that mcaffee, which is easier on resources than nortons.

I know people using resource hungry 3d modelling animation apps that use avg on their systems, without it slowing down the system while using the 3d apps.

coupled with lavasoft adaware and zone alarm very few have problems from the adware/spyware and viruses attacking thier windows systems.

by riggs25

After Norton expired have been using AVG on all home pc's. Fantastic product, will be getting full version for our office computers. Also use Zone Alarm Pro firewall that has an automatic spyware scanner. Lets not forget a regular sweep with Lavasoft's AdAware and Spybot Search and Destroy. Also Microsoft's beta spyware scanner and SnoopFree's anti key logger. I like to cover all the bases.

by ian lewis

AVG seems to have a smaller requirement for memory and processor resources than Sophos or Norton, can't speak for the others.

I like it and if at all possible will be switching to the enterprise version as soon as our Sophos licence runs out.

by lordshipmayhem

I dual-boot my PC, keeping XP isolated from the internet completely.

I only boot into WinXP when I do income taxes (one reason I don't e-file).

Some day, we'll see Linux tax prep software for Canada, and then I can dump the Windows sector completely.

by gkrew

I have the same issue to get addressed. NAV runs rtvscan.exe on client workstations but takes up 100% CPU while scanning supposedly in the background. This cause horribble slowness for the user until I remotely stop the service. Then the workstation is left unprotected but the user can work at a normal pace. Symantec's boards did not help much. Many NAV users are experiencing the same problem and Symantec support does not respond in a timely manner or with any good advice. I have not deployed McAfee as the replacement because I do not know if it can be centrally managed as easily as Norton's is/. That is the only drawback I can see when comparing Norton's to McAfee.

by ben "iron" damper

In a coroporate enviorment McAfee with the addition of their EPO software for management is a no brainer in my view. I manager over 800 PC's and 50 some odd servers with one EPO server. I keep them all updated daily, run reports, scans, etc. without bothering end users or disrupting the servers response times. While the hardware end of EPO is very very cheap (one 500mhz machines w/256mb of RAM) will do in most cases the software end is not. But then again most solutions that work well in a corporate setting aren't cheap.

by ojahnn

I used Norton for 2 years managing 150 computers had may issues. I have switched to Mcafee for close to a year now wit antivirus and antispyware. For my Mcafee is a better product.
that from my experience

by davemori

I would use PC-Cillin Internet Security Suite for home and small offices.

PC-Cillin is a lot less quirky than McAfee and Symantec/Norton, and there tends to be more junk and games loaded to a home and SOHO computer than to a computer in a large enterprise.

Richard Ku, wrote PC Cillin, and PC-Cillin was using AI virus detection technologies in the early 1990s when everyone else was using less sophisticated and less reliable techniques. In some ways, I don't think that Symantec and the others have quite caught up to PC-Cillin.

PC World and others ahve consistently given it very high marks.

The one quirk with PC-Cillin is that sometimes it is too good at generating alerts. You have to turn some of them off and let PC-Cillin just handle certain types of issues.

I personally think that PC-CIllin as an antivirus is better done than Norton or McAfee, and the firewall is very good, especially for wireless, but the product is a little weaker at cleaning up Spyware and AdWare that get pushed over the browser to your machine.

McAfee was better before John McAfee sold the company to Network Solutions.

I use McAfee on one of my PCd at home, but I find several aspects of McAfee to be very annoying:

1. You have to login to Windows, and then login to McAfee Privacy Administrator in order to start using the internet.

2. McAfee has a monthly, automatically appearing VALIDATION that you have to do to their web site in order to keep getting updates, and McAfee will tend to turn itself off leaving you unprotected if the validation bombs out.

The heavy handed Norton "Countdown" reminders when your expiration date is near, also drive SOHO people batty, and one of the issues with Norton that comes back to haunt me in the way of after hours "free advice" questions from SOHO users is that upgrading an older version of Norton often seems to result in software that is upgraded but warning messages of pending expiration that are not eliminated without calling the tech support line. Product updates occasionally fail.

I have had Norton fail on both viruses and spyware and intrusions through the Norton Firewall into my PCs, despite the fact that I manually updated both Windows and NAV each time I powered up.

McAfee has failed me on spyware and viruses. Product updates have failed when I was not watching closely, but have not resulted in intrusions or other problems.

PC Cillin has never failed me on a virus, although I have seen people break through the PC-Cillin firewall when the Windows is not protected with a password.

In all fairness, I have had the Norton Firewall and the McAfee Firewall also fail, as well as the Firewall on my home router, as well.

Even when the firewall and antivirus is good, viruses and spyware get into a PC because Internet Explorer is not a secure browser. I have been using FireFox, as much as possible. I have basically been forced by Microsoft to use Internet Explorer for Windows Updates.

The stuff from ZoneAlarm and Computer Associates is not bad, but these too have some quirks.

I have had them all fail on Windows PCs. I do put AV on my Mac, as some of my friends with SOHO environments have virus ridden PCs, and I don't need any virus on any of my systems.

by jcritch

Try nod32 www.nod32.com
Updates daily, low overhead and easy to manage.

I have this installed on over 3000 computers now, without the woory of people not updating

This discussion is closed to new replies.