I am implementing a new PMO, as part of this implementation I am putting together metrics (standard for performance measurement) to measure success. These are not specific to an individual PM. However, they may give you some ideas.
Excerpt from my PMO Charter ??
[Metrics should measure those aspects of PMO performance that are directly related to its Mission. On that basis, the following areas of focus can be used to judge PMO value:
Does the division create a written project description for all of it?s major activities?
Does the division have a complete and reportable listing of DPHIS projects and their overall status? Do we maintain it?
Does the division estimate resource requirements for each project?
Does the division have and maintain a resource plan?
Is a process in place for the proposal, selection and authorization of projects at all levels?
Is a process in place to track project cost information?
Are the organization?s IT projects more successful over time?
Is there evidence that DPHIS staff is taking a more professional approach toward management of the organization?s IT projects?
Are the products of our projects meeting the customer?s business objectives?
Do we measure the outcomes of projects?
The PMO will develop or acquire appropriate instrument(s) with which to obtain objective measurements. The PMO Sponsor will approve the instrument(s) before they are used. Examples:
Measuring PM maturity using a standard Process Maturity Model.
Improvement in project success over time can be measured through decreases in schedule and budget variances or the tone of customer comments
Project Management approach can be measured by quality and timeliness of project planning documents, accuracy of time and cost estimates, and effectiveness at managing risk
Customer satisfaction can be measured through post project surveys/interviews.
]
? end of excerpt.
You could turn this into an individual?s performance measure in the following way:
Do the follow you companies standard methodology at an appropriate level for the project.
Is the customer satisfied with the product delivered and the way it was delivered?
Does the project team work in cocert or conflict with the customer?
If you are a mature PM organization you could measure ROI on the project.
Etc.