Discussion Locked

Microsoft cert vs. business degree

0 helpful
47 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have an opportunity get an MCDBA or an A.S. in business (only 7 classes away) over the next 6 months, free of charge.

What qualification would be more valuable in the job market? I'm leaning toward the business degree because MCDBA seems to have a limited shelf life. I have a BS in CIS and 7 years of experience (jack of all trades).

47 replies

by egerena04

I think that you are right about the short shelf life of a certification like that. I would go for the business associate degree. You can get a cert any other time.
But if you ever take a class in which you have the opportunity of taking a cert test at the end of the class, make sure you do this within one week after class. If you wait any longer you will forget most of the just learned material...Just review it 2-3 times and go for it.

by unclerob

is your website link related to this discussion in any way? Just curious.

What specifically don't you agree with the part about reviewing the material 2-3 times and then to go for it. Alot of people study like that although everyone's methods will differ it doesn't sound like bad advice.

just my 0.02 cents cdn....

by tony hopkinson

As far as HR and recruiters are concerned an out of date cert is useless, but an out of date degree an excellent indicator of their own intelligence. If you see what I mean.

by jaqui

Certifications, when vendor specific, are effectively useless bits of wallpaper in most companies mixed environments.

a Business Degree is a foundation in business logic and practices that actually never goes out of date, and gives a better understanding of the needs of the company.

by amcol

You don't say where you are and I've learned not to assume when it comes to educational abbreviations, especially in countries other than the US, so help me out here.

You say you have a BS, which presumably means a four year undergraduage bachelor's degree. You say you have the opportunity to get an AS...an Associate's degree? As in, a two year junior college certification?

If this is the case, then I'm afraid I don't get it. Why would you get an Associate's degree when you already have a Bachelor's? You and the other posters are correct that any professional cert has a fairly short shelf life. Getting a two year degree when you already have a four year degree is virtually a complete waste of time, never mind that there's no monetary cost to you.

Any reason why you're not pursuing an MBA, which would be the next logical educational step?

Your motivations are also rather askew. Collecting certifications to make yourself more attractive to a wider range of employers certainly makes sense, but once you get the job you have to do it. You might as well like what you're doing, don't you think? Be careful that you're not just in a quest to add a bunch of letters after your name and by so doing pigeon hole yourself into a career you'll end up hating.

by samson06

AS = Associates

I have a BS in Computer Information Systems but the curriculum did not include any business classes. I just feel it would be a boost to my career to have some extra business knowledge. It would also come in handy if I decide to run my own business someday.

I'd consider the masters but the funding that I am getting does not include masters degrees. I cannot afford to pay for it myself at this point in time. Besides, I have a 2.8 GPA and may not even be able to qualify for a master's program. I figure that the 6 classes or so that I need for the AS degree will bump my GPA a bit if I do well in them to help me qualify for a masters program down the line.

I've also considered leaving the IT field altogether as there are few IT jobs in this area. There doesn't seem to be too many viable alternatives though. IT very unstable and trying to keep ones skills up to date is like playing Russian Roulette.

by amcol

Let's start with your last thought, that you're thinking about leaving IT due to lack of job opportunity. I urge you to reconsider.

Why did you get your undergraduate degree in CIS to begin with? Many people go to college with no idea what they want to do with their lives. They get liberal arts educations and use college as a time to grow, emotionally and intellectually, then choose the course of their lives and pursue advanced studies at the Master's level.

You decided early on what you wanted to do. Good for you. Do you love IT? Did anything in your undergraduate program, or anything you've done in your professional career since, dissuade you from this course? You're going to be in the workforce a long, long time. You'll spend more time at work every week than you will doing anything else, including being with your family or pursuing your own interests. It'll get pretty tedious pretty quickly if you're doing something you don't love.

You have one thing exactly right...you don't have a career in IT, you have a career in business and specialize in IT. That's why you want to get more business education. If you go to work for a pure play technology company, like Microsoft or Intel, then you have an IT career. But if you join any other organization you're a business person.

I understand you can get your business courses paid for through an Associate's program. OK, fine. Go for it. Just bear in mind, with no disrepect meant to junior colleges everywhere (I taught in one for a long time, so I know what I'm talking about), you're getting a superficial low level view of what you'll really need to know. You need the information you get in a Master's program, or the equivalent in years of experience in the business world, to truly get educated in this area.

Yes, keeping your skills up to date is tough. That's true in any field. Don't leave IT because it's a lot of work, or because you think some other field is less work. You're going to be disappointed.

Feeling entrepreneurial? Great. Open your own business. Just make sure you're ready. You need education, experience, capital, some way to differentiate yourself from your competition, and a boatload of work ethic. You'll work harder than you ever thought possible.

It's tough finding your way in the world. Don't lose focus, and don't think that anything comes easy. Don't feel entitled to anything, and don't be upset when you find out how true that is. Make sure you understand what personal responsibility really means.

Sorry to get so dogmatic. I'm going very far afield of what you asked, but something in your posts spoke to me and I felt the need to offer some free advice. Take it for what it's worth.

by jdmercha

No education is a waste of time, but there are better ways to use your time than getting an AS after you already have a BS.

I'm not a fan of certs, but in your case I do think that certs will be of more use to you than an AS. Certs will get you in the door quicker than the AS, but a few business classes will help you climb the ladder a little quicker.

Do you need to stay in your area? Your area may be slow, but there are a lot of jobs out there if you are willing to move. A BS by itself should be enough to get a decent job with a company that will pay for you to get an MBA.

by jerome.koch

An Oracle Executive recently was quoted as saying the traditional DBA job is very limited with little room for growth. The DBAs I know do much more than manage databases Some are project managers, or SANs managers, as well as Sarbanes compliance officers.

Buisnesses seem to love people who have buisness degrees with IT expirence. I was once passed over for a job because my competitor had a buisness degree. My IT expirence while good, isn't always the most benefical. The bottom line is: How well do you understand how a buisness runs, and how can you be an asset?

From what I can tell, those people who have buisness degrees and have IT expirnece are those who manage projects, and become CIOs. People like me, who love just the tech side rarely move up. We may always be needed, but we will never be Project Managers or CIOs.

by amcol

Seems to me you have the following choices:

1. Continue to work as a technical specialist. Upside...you'll be doing work you love. Downside...you'll be limiting yourself in terms of career advancement and compensation, and will ultimately be subject to age discrimination (if you aren't already).

2. Move away from day to day technical work into project management (can be done). Upside...career and comp improvement, and exercising a broader skill set. Downside...you have to move out of your comfort zone and you can no longer get into the technical details you love so much.

3. Move into business process architecture. Upside...very interesting work with a broader mandate and significantly enhanced job security. Downside...while still somewhat of a technical discipline this would require an entirely new set of skills.

I could probably come up with four or five other options but this is your career and you should be planning it, not me.

The point I'm making is that you've painted yourself into a corner and you think there's no way out. You're wrong. Don't resign yourself to your fate, and don't regard your current reality as your destiny.

You're right about one thing, you'll never be a CIO. But if you made some adjustments and took more control over your career there's no reason why you couldn't be a CTO.

What do you want out of life? Out of your career? You want a brass ring, you have to grab it. No one's going to toss it in your lap for you.

by mcnock

USeful & good thoughts, but the core question comes back to - What are you going to do with the qualification?

If you can work out where you want to be in 1-3 years time, then the answer will follow. Despite recessions, company layoffs, boomtimes, you are the one who will be putting in the hours. Sometimes the best use of your time is not chasing more paper for the office, but looking after your outside interests, Family, self, community.

by tony hopkinson

I like being a technical head, I have no desire to be a business head, so therefore a certain set of a career choices are precluded. I have n't failed, I aren't some how inadequate, I'm simply no more suited to running a business than I am to be a hairdresser, plumber or any other career choice requiring a specific skillset, innate talent and a desire to be best the best in that particular arena.

Wanting to stay technical does not mean you can't move up, it means you don't want to move up. I don't. I'm more than happy withn my career and it's track, in fact if I had to switch away from getting my hands dirty in at least high level technical design, I suspect I would be incredibly unhappy even when the financial rewards became greater, if they ever did.
One of the first things a good business person in IT will try to ensure, is that they've got an experienced technically directed person in their team. If they are good they'll want one who's good at tech, happy with tech, wants to stay a tech. The bonus point is a tech who's experienced enough to realise how business impacts in their arena and vice versa.

Stay people like me if you want, if you don't, then don't, don't sit their railing at your choice because you want the enjoyment of one and the benefits of the other though.

by aaronpctech

What a great discussion. I dont really ave anything to add to it becauase Im stuck in a similar situation. I simply have an AS in information tech from a technical school. I have tons of certs but no real degree.

I need to and want to go back to school, but i'm not sure if it should be business tech or Info tech.

I really like the point that some of you were bringing out that certs can only last for so long, but a degree stays with you no matter what.

Decisions decisions.

by samson06

"Why did you get your undergraduate degree in CIS to begin with?"

It was a toss up between computers and hotel management....2 very different fields. The job outlook was the tiebreaker was tech jobs were one of the fastest growing occupations at the time. I'm glad I made the choice that I did.
But now it appears that IT is a sinking ship based on what I've read and by talking to people in the industry. It doesn't seem like knowing JUST IT is good enough anymore.

"You decided early on what you wanted to do. Good for you. Do you love IT?"

I enjoy working on projects and completing them. I'm not one of those guys who is obsessed with computers. Computers exist to serve a function in business (i.e. helping save the company time and/or money). I don't care to get caught up in minute technical details. I don't really care to read about computers outside of work. Computers are a means to an end as far as I'm concerned. There are other interests that I have, like exercising, and sociology, but there isn't much money to be made as a personal trainer. And sociology is pretty much a useless degree.

"Did anything in your undergraduate program, or anything you've done in your professional career since, dissuade you from this course? You're going to be in the workforce a long, long time. You'll spend more time at work every week than you will doing anything else, including being with your family or pursuing your own interests. It'll get pretty tedious pretty quickly if you're doing something you don't love."

The main reason I'm considering switching is the lack of job security/stability these days in this field, especially in the area that I'm in. I know many people and have read stories of many people from job boards like this one who have left the field. Also, I'm not sure that this career is good until retirement. I've heard MANY stories where guys in their 40s and 50s (or even late 30s) who are no longer marketable in this field. That's the main reason I'm considering switching. I'd rather be proactive and do something now rather than later.

"I understand you can get your business courses paid for through an Associate's program. OK, fine. Go for it. Just bear in mind, with no disrepect meant to junior colleges everywhere (I taught in one for a long time, so I know what I'm talking about), you're getting a superficial low level view of what you'll really need to know. You need the information you get in a Master's program, or the equivalent in years of experience in the business world, to truly get educated in this area."

Thanks for the heads up on the AS program. My GPA was slightly under 3 and that would exclude me from the majority of MBA programs. I am pretty sure that business is the direction that I want to go.

"Feeling entrepreneurial? Great. Open your own business. Just make sure you're ready. You need education, experience, capital, some way to differentiate yourself from your competition, and a boatload of work ethic. You'll work harder than you ever thought possible."

No matter what direction I go, I understand that there is a lot of hard work to do. Part of me says that it would make more sense to invest all the time/energy that I would on additional schooling/certs on a business instead. There are countless people who have spend thousands of hours on degree/certification programs which haven't paid off.

"Yes, keeping your skills up to date is tough. That's true in any field. Don't leave IT because it's a lot of work, or because you think some other field is less work. You're going to be disappointed."

I don't mind working hard and keeping skills up to date. I know what personal responsiblity means and wouldn't have it any other way. What I don't like about this field is that you almost have to GUESS what will be in demand. It's almost like playing Russian Roulette since most companies don't want to train you anymore. If you learn business knowledge or about the human body or about plumbing, that information doesn't change. Computer technology does change quite a bit after a few short years.

Thanks for your thought provoking reply.

by samson06

"No education is a waste of time, but there are better ways to use your time than getting an AS after you already have a BS."

Even if it's in another field?

"Do you need to stay in your area? Your area may be slow, but there are a lot of jobs out there if you are willing to move. A BS by itself should be enough to get a decent job with a company that will pay for you to get an MBA."

I have a house that I like and relatives in the area. If I don't find something in the area after so many months, I will consider moving. Do you know of any hot areas for jobs in the midwest?

Note to self: make sure the next company I work for has tuition reimbursement.

by kinkylinkn

This has been a very interesting read and couldn't have come at a better time.

I've just enrolled in a Bachelor of Business majoring in International Business Management. It'll take me about 6 years part time to complete.

The reason I have decided on the degree is that I've never been to University before but have been working in IT for 8 years. I have various industry certs e.g. MCSA, MCSE etc and am completly confident that i'm "techie" minded enough to tackle and master any technology in a very short amount of time. But as already mentioned in the reply posts this can limit my career prospects. And with a 15 year plan of becoming CIO staying on the tech orientated course wont help. So it's off to Uni to do a business degree, hopefully followed by a masters or perhaps another degree in HR ( a good CIO freind of mine seriously recommends HR Degree's due to the amount of people management required at that level ).

Like anything in life, it's a gamble but an educated gamble that should, given my determination level, pay off.

by amcol

When I started in this business (when ice still covered the Earth and dinosaurs roamed free) my very, very long term goal was to eventually become Director of MIS.

That's what IT was called back then, and that's what we called the person who headed the organization.

Along the way two interesting things happened. One, I found it took a lot more time, effort, and experience than I'd ever dreamed to make myself a competent viable candidate for such a position. Two, by the time I was ready for the position it didn't exist anymore, and neither did MIS departments as we used to know them.

My point...it's great to have goals, but fifteen years out is a long, LONG time. There's only one thing anyone can guarantee you at this moment, that fifteen years from now things will be different than they are today. Fifteen years ago the role of CIO didn't even exist, nor did CTO...and there's still an awful lot of people, in IT and out, who can't articulate the difference between the two.

The conventional wisdom has always been to plan your career in five year increments. Fifteen years is way too long a time horizon.

Your CIO friend's advice about getting an HR degree...nope. If you want to be an HR professional, go for it. You'll get all you need to know about HR to make it to the upper reaches of technical management simply by showing up for work.

by kinkylinkn

I totally agree with your point regarding non-existant roles in 15 years etc and even that things will be dramatically different, but without a long term ( 15y ) plan how can you effectivley plan your medium term goals ( 5y )?

I'm not saying that I HAVE to be where I plan to be in 15 years, all i'm saying is that right now my plan is to get there. I'd have to be pretty ignorant and arogant to not be open to changes. How many people have you met that say "if someone told me 15 years ago I'd be doing I would have laughed".

It's a pretty crucial point you make about not needing HR / People Management skills so can you back it up with some more info? At any level of management you have to deal with people. More and more management are moving away from the techinical aspects of the role and focusing on the financials and people management aspects. A good manager hires people to do the things they can't / don't want to do. But a great manager is someone that can bring together a group of dissimilar personalities and skills sets into a finely tuned, effective team. I've had my fair share of crap manager's to know this is very true.

by jason

10 years from now that Microsoft cert will be worthless kinda like my CNE.

The degree will last a lifetime.

by too old for it

... and then see about funding the bcahelors in business.

I stupidly went the cert route, and discovered thereafter the One Divine Truth:

There are two things in education: A bachelors degree from a university with old-growth ivy covering crusty brick and mortar walls ... and everything else.

by evmafau

I have a degree in MIS and was starting to look at getting certifications because I found it hard to get into the industry on the tech side with the degree alone. However, all the posts in this thread seem to be saying that the certifications are going to be useless and I should save my money for grad school. Is that a fair assesment?

As I only graduated recently, is there a cert that's going to help me find my next job? I'd like to stay within the tech field for now because I like the work, but realize, through the multiple posts, that it's a tough career to maintain down the line.

by amcol

There's nothing wrong with certs. What's wrong is when folks get them for the wrong reasons.

Wrongest reason number 1...the cert will make you more marketable and, as you put it, help you find your next job. Horsefeathers. You can have 657 letters after your name and the first two questions I'll ask you when you come to me for an interview are "what have you done?" and "what can you do for me?". I couldn't care less what you know, I only care what value you can add.

Go for certs. It's a great way to learn, but that's the only really right reason to go...for the knowledge. Don't even bother taking the certification exam. When you're done apply the knowledge, to the benefit of the business in order to provide real business value. Your experience, knowledge, instincts, spirit of cooperation, work ethic, ambition...these are the things, coupled with an excellent ability to network, that will help you in any job search.

by crypl

I have to disagree with your statement that getting a cert for marketability is the worst reason to get one. Before I finished off my MCSA and MCSE I was having a hard time even getting a call back let alone an interview. I agree that just having the cert doesn't qualify you for the job, but it gets you the chance to get an interview. Then it is up to you to prove your knowledge beyond just having a degree and a bunch of certs.

by too old for it

Tho back in the day (the dot.com era, and only if you were 20-something) a MCSE would get you a seat and $45,000+ a year and experience only would get you shown the door. Companies that hired certs and griped about paper MCSEs had only themselves to blame.

Now it seems as if you need a degree in computer science and a MBA and be 20-something to get a $6.50 an hour help desk job at some places. MCSE? usually you will hear the "trying to be funny" line about Must Call Someone Else (which to me is in the same league as "Why did you waste your time in the Marines rather than going to college?" question that used to be so popular back in the late 70's, but that could be just myself that holds said opinion.)

I digress. At this juncture, I think there are two options ineducation: (a) a bachelors degree from a university with old growth ivy over crusty brick and mortar walls (b) anything else.

by cberding

An A.S. degree isn't worth much when you already have a bachelor's degree.

BTW most people in industry would want you to get an MBA to flesh out your business skills (I know lots of people who have done this).

My take: get the cert, then the MBA if you plan on being around for a long time.

by m_a_r_k

In choosing between a certification and a college degree, there is no comparison. College degree definitely is the better choice. More difficult to obtain, it's accredited, it takes more discipline, more broad-based and you learn more skills esp soft skills, more staying power over the rest of your career.

But why in the world are you getting an AS when you already have a BS in CIS? You're taking a step down to the associates degree from a bachelors. I'd recommend getting a masters in business. It may even be fewer credit hours. Usually 36 for a masters and 48 or 52 for MBA.

by rapell

as someone already suggested, how long s/he is willing, and/or ready to stay in the IT field per se? It would be a good idea to get the cert, save some cash, and run in for the MBA, as I see, most posters have noted: "why go for an AS when one has a BS?"

by samson06

I'm only 5-6 courses away from the A.S., which can be done in a semester or two. And the financial aid that I'm getting will pay for an A.S. or B.S. but not for an MBA.

After getting this degree, I'll either use the knowledge to start my own business or devote the 2-3 years to obtain an MBA. Also, my GPA is just short of the 3.0 needed for most masters programs and I figure that I could boost my GPA and better my chances of entering a masters program in the future.

I'm not sure why this would be a step down as business is a different major than computers. I would think this would beef up my resume slightly, not as valuable as the MBA but it's better than nothing.

by m_a_r_k

And I hope I didn't sound like my suggestion was the only right thing to do. There are many ways to skin a cat, as the old saying goes. Sounds like you have a plan. A A.S. is better than no degree at all. The vast majority of posters agree that the degree is more valuable than the certification. If you think a certification would help (can't hurt), pursue that in addition to the degree. But if you'd have to make a choice, do the degree(s).

The A.S. might be perceived as a step down by potential employers. So be prepared for that. It's a 2-year program versus four for a bachelors. So you obvioulsy take more courses and are assumed to learn more with a bachelors. Less demanding entrance requirements for an associates degree. Four-year programs are taught at full-fledged well-regarded universities. Two-year programs are taught at community colleges. Better faculty and resources at universities. etc Coursework is less demanding (as you suggested when you said that you want to bring your GPA up).

by samson06

I have the Microsoft books so I might try and study for the cert part time while going to school full time. I will be attending a state university (extension campus) which awards bachelor's degrees (it's where I received my CIS degree from) and even a couple masters degrees. There are a number of directions I could go (marketing, accounting, etc.). Hopefully I can get that GPA up so I can qualify for some grad school programs when the time comes. I think I'll enjoy business law more than COBOL.

by jerryfr

The certification will be obsolete with the next release of .... Then you have to upgrade your cert. or its worthless.
These certification programs are great moneymakers for M$, Novell (remember them?) and the trade schools that hold the classes.

'Debits will always be by the window and credits by the door!'

by jerryfr

Let me add to my above comment.

Go to a Barnes & Noble.
Go to the Computer section. If its anything like the B&Ns here in NJ, its probably the largest single section in the store, bigger than cooking, gardening, pets, history etc.
Consider, almost all of the books you see will be obsolete in 12 months if they aren't already!
So will your certification.
Nuff said?

by beckyarambula

You hit it right on the nose!I've been enjoying the discussion and I have had the same questions as to where to focus my education. I'm a Business Systems Analyst (home-grown) witht he same company for 16 years and love it here. But, cannot be promoted to Senior Analyst until I go back to school. I like the idea of BSCIS. Any suggestions from anyone?

by tony hopkinson

I like Business people with real IT expereience, they know where I'm coming from and they can point out why one of my tech ideas doesn't suit the business in terms that make sense. Sometimes I have to say 'Yeah OK mate got me', others times I can address those concerns and adapt what I think we should do to what the business needs to do.

The interface is so important, there are many good tech ideas that have put people out of business and there are many good business's that have failed due to poor choices in tech. Both communication failures, and usually because one side or the other chose not to listen to the bit they didn't care to understand.
If you can provide that interface you are on a winner.

by amcol

I didn't say getting a cert wouldn't make you more marketable, I said getting one simply to make yourself more marketable is a waste of time and energy.

Certs definitely can be door openers. Once it's a little ajar, however, you have to kick it in...and get inside, and stay inside. Certs won't do any of that for you.

Getting attention from hiring managers by having alphabet soup on your resume is one thing. Now I know what you know...but, like I said, what can you really do? That's what's important.

Consider also that we hiring managers always assume that some component of what we read on resumes is either overstated or flat untrue. You know how many times I've seen Oracle knowledge claimed on a resume, for example, only to find out within about 60 seconds of the start of an interview that the only connection between the candidate and the claimed skill is that he/she tripped over an Oracle manual on the way out of the library?

by catadmin

I'm a little confused at your question. As someone with an MCDBA, I'm wondering why you're trying to compare apples to carrots with the "which one do I go for". The MCDBA cert is for people who will be administering and developing databases to contain data. The business degree is for people interested in generating that data. And while the two fields do intersect, it's a threadbare connection.

I think first you need to decide which direction you really want to go in. Database Administrators are one of the few non-outsourced jobs in this country, and one of the higher paid positions for those IT people not in management. Especially since there are so few truly qualified DBAs in any system (Oracle/MS SQL/My SQL/etc.) Data is never going to go away, unless the virus writers have anything to say about it, and so DBAs are always going to be needed in one capacity or another. The cert itself is a lot harder to get than the MCSA/MCSE, even if it does have a short shelf life, so requires a major commitment on studying time.

On the other hand, business people are everywhere and seem to have a better reputation than IT people, though may not have any more job opportunities than IT people do. Beware of post-TechBust lassitude. Just because the industry seems slow and sluggish doesn't mean it really is. I managed to get my first official, full-time IT job right *after* the bust when all the "wanna-bes" were finally weeded out.

I'm meandering a little in my post, but the essentials are this: You can't substitute an MCDBA for a business degree or vice versa. You're looking at two completely different circulum/career fields. Make your choice. What do you want to do with the rest of your life? After you decide that, you can decide if you want to do the degree or the cert. If you plan on becoming a DBA/DB Developer, by all means, take the cert if it's the only way to advance your current IT career. Just remember, you'll want to study the other database methods too so you don't get pigeon-holed as a Microsoft Only type DBA. But if you wanna get out of IT, then go with the business degree. You don't want to do both and have people turning you away from jobs because they think you're over-qualified.

Catadmin

by vegava

I have a BA in Math and MBA and an MHA (Health Administration). I have an IT background, was never certified to do anything and was a student programmer for NASA in the Summer of '85. I haven't taken the time to read any of the other posts but here is my two cents.

It depends on what you want to do and where you want to do it. What are your future plans? Do you want to be management in your company? If you are a straight techie you will only have opportunities in the IT division so CIO is as high as you can go and you're stuck in the technical area.

Are you interested in management outside of IT? Then maybe the Business degree is the way to go. Remember that once you hit a certain level in your career you are no longer (shouldn't be anyway) doing the coding and technical stuff; you are scheduling, writing reviews, pricing projects, assigning staff, etc., etc. No technical certification helps you with that. Remember that ultimately techies work for guys like me.

Of course, if you're a hands on guy then the certification is what you want. The latest and greatest (and continuing educations) keeps your skills sharp and current and allows you to remain "do'in the stuff".

Bottom line is that it comes down to what you want to do with your future. If you want to remain a techie get certified. If you want to manage get the degree.

by tony hopkinson

but unless you wish to remain 'IT shop floor' as in carry out assigned tasks formulated by others, you need at least business awareness. You can have certs coming out of your ears, won't help you in making strategic decisions though. A business qualification will give you that leg up the ladder if you want to be where you can look at the why and the what instead of remaining with simply with the How.

Not knocking guys who enjoy and stick with the how by the way, they are worth their weight in iridium if used correctly, just don't expect one to give you a dissertation on the future IT strategy for your business.

You're extremely unlikely to get to CIO without a business qualification by the way, and you would have to be an extremely good manager, to manage IT successfully without an IT background.

If you've got both and you're good, you should make it.

by tony hopkinson

you get asked 'What red brick university did you go to'. I just put the phone down at this point, as I wouldn't want the job anyway, only a complete twonk would think that was important.

by too old for it

We did a spot check and there are in excess of 25 bachelors-degree granting institutions within 35 miles of where I work.

No wonder that any degree that hints of online status is held on par with a diploma mill (or the parrot cage liner).

(Remarkable bird, the Norwegian Blue, idn'it, ay? Beautiful plumage!)

by tony hopkinson

the fjords it's pining for, are a long way away.

I've met people with degrees from a red brick university who couldn't program a VCR anyway. Spent more time with the snots and making sure the professor heard about Daddy's donation, than they did studying. The one that gets me is university teaches you how to think, personally I thought that should be an entrance requirement, there again I never went so WTF do I know.

by too old for it

... that especially for the older returning student, you never get the full benefit of attending a traditional university that you do when you are fresh out of high school. Especially socially, which is part of the university experience you are paying dearly for.

In their mad rush to attract older student?s dollars, most colleges and universities forgot to tell the incoming freshmen student body that they too were part of the attraction to brick-n-mortar education, and it wouldn't kill them to interact with the guys with gray hair.

by amcol

I didn't say you don't need HR or people management skills to make it as a senior IT manager, I said you don't need an advanced degree in the subject. EVERYONE needs these skills, no matter what your profession or hierarchial status. My point was that unless you plan to be an HR professional you'll get all you need to know about the people skill aspect of doing your job right through OJT.

If you read nothing else, add the following to your must-review list: "Execution" by Larry Bossidy, "The Art of War" by Sun-Tzu, and "The Prince" by Machiavelli. These three books are the equivalent of an MBA degree, for a lot less money and a whole lot faster.

by lincdk

I've literally just started keeping a list of books that I want / need to read so it's interesting that you mention some books to read on a topic of interest. I will read them!

This discussion is closed to new replies.