Discussion Locked

Microsoft must be really feeling the PAIN of WGA !

0 helpful
41 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have wandering into several stores and they DO NOT have any Computer with more than BASIC "VISTA" on them . .
Some stores are afraid its going to crash before they get it out the door ( got that from Circuit City Person) . .
And Best Buy will not talk about it, then there is Staples and the person walks away very fast when ask questions ! ! And I have noticed a LOT OF LAPTOPS turned off and will not turn on at various stores . . when you push the "ON" button it lights up but thats as far as it goes . . Make me wonder whats wrong . . Maybe WGA problems . .

There was a person at Circuit City whom said he was going to get a laptop which was held back and has XP on it as he did not want the NEW "VISTA" on his computers . . Wonder why ?

And they claim to have sold 60 million copies of the "Vista" Me thinks its a MAJOR LIE . . Or they are dumping the "Vista" and putting Win 2K or XP on it or even Linux of some version

By the way Mac has had a MAJOR up swing in Profits this last quarter . . Make you wonder if its people switching from Windows to. . . .

41 replies

by jackofalltech

I just bought 4 laptops for my family. They had Vista Home Basic on them. I let my family play with them for a few days then asked them if they wanted to keep Vista or go back to XP. Not ONE wanted Vista.

I, personally, can't stand Vista and will never use it unless I have to at work.

Ralph

by rhomp20029

Either that or you are a glutton for punishment. What happens if WGA strikes again? on either O/S, Vista or XP? If I dual booted it would be to something other than M$ for at least one of the O/S's so I could at least do something - and then I would have a backdoor way in that other O/S that would let me access my M$ files. Anything else isjust asking for trouble.

by neon samurai

Grub or Lilo boot loaders work great though Grub may be the more modern choice since it can hid partitions from the booting OS. *nix, XP, Vista.. tripple boot. Heck, if you have an Apple then quad boot; osX, *nix, XP, Vista.

If your XP or Vista boots jump ship because of WGA or some other "feature" you've always got one or two other solid OS to choose from.

by hal 9000

Under M$ sales pitch I have brought 5 of those 60 Million Copies but in reality I only bought 1 X Volume License of Vista Enterprise of which I currently only have one installed on a test computer.

When you consider how many copies of any OS that all the big makers buy monthly 60 Million is really a drop in the bucket when you consider just how many computers per day are sold world wide.

If anything I would say that it shows a marked resistance to this new offering from M$ as that is less than 10 Million per month since the release of Vista in all of it's current forms.

Col

by locrian_lyric

Yes, there were grumbles when Win95 came out, more with 98, less with 2000, MUCH more with ME, a little with XP.

but not even the rancor against ME was anywhere NEAR the outright open hostility to VISTA.

I think MS jumped the shark on this one.

by jackie40d1

More like swiming hard JUST in front of the SHARK . . And screaming loud to attract some attention . . Aw to bad seems NO ONE is listening this time . . And 60 Million is what 1/100 or is that 1/1000 of the world population . . NOT TO GOOD from what I see . .

by jdclyde

I think Vista only lasted a month in the local stores as the sole OS to have preloaded.

When you had to jump through major hoops just to get going, it was a bear.

A friend got a laptop with vista. she was an earthlink subscriber, but the software was not compatible. You had to download the newest version that would run on vista, but if you couldn't get online to download it......

And other than promising eye candy, there was never a convincing REASON why a company would fork out the money to change over from XP and have to throw away most of their existing hardware.

by legendsofbatman

I hate them, and would rather go without internet, if my only choice was earthpuke.

It doesn't surprise me that they would have you go online to get the updates. Question. Would they allow you to save the updates to CD/DVD? Knowing them, no. lol.

by rknrlkid

You mentioned that MS sold 60 million copies. How do we find this information? I am not saying this to criticise what you are saying, but because I am curious as to find out the source of these numbers. For all we know, "they" might be saying that 60 million units are sold...but the number could be misleading. Sold to whom? If its units sold to manufacturers, that is different than numbers sold through stores.

Does that make sense? In my warped sense of curiousity, I'd like to see sales figures of ALL products so I could see how they really stack up. Shipping 60 million CDs to manufacturers is different to me than 60 million actual individual sales. (And sales of CDs/licenses doesn't mean that the OS is actually installed either! I have a stack of licenses of Windows 95 and NT Workstation in a closet that are brand new, never used. They were sold, but never installed!)

by jackie40d1

The numbers were MS numbers in some article I read on one of the places like this had a link to some news put out by MS . . I got 3 Win 2K CD's yet ! So I know there are a ton of those "Vista" CD's which are collecting dust some where . .

by hal 9000

60 Million Licenses for Vista which is really a lot less than shipping 60 Million DVD's. If you buy a copy of Vista Home preloaded on a new computer you can then buy another copy [i]Product Key[/b] to get Vista Ultimate or Enterprise which is what you really needed in the first place and all you need do is change the product Key to get the Higher Version of Vista working.

This at least in the US involves nothing more than buying a new licence from M$ and they e-mail you the new product key so you will effectively have 2 Licensed Copies of Vista on that 1 computer according to M$ numbers at least.

As for shipping DVD's to the big makers they don't even do this they just supply them with the number of COA's that the company wants and then that company makes a Recovery Disc which only has the necessary drivers for the supplied hardware included.

M$ Sales Figures of Vista are very misleading as that where claiming at the 4 month stage to have sold 40 million copies of Vista and then at the 6 month period selling 60 million Copies which seems to be stuck at the 10 Million copies per month world wide.

Actually I'd be far more interested is seeing the figures of all the copies of Vista being sold and all the copies of XP that are being sold now.

Col

by techexec2

.
The data I would like to see for each month is:

1. Number of XP activations.

2. Number of Vista activations.

3. Number of Vista re-activations via Internet (bleh!), automated phone call (boo), and Bangalore phone call (hiss).

Microsoft's activation servers certainly have this data but Microsoft is not releasing it. Instead they are putting out bogus nonsense like "40 million" and "60 million" and "The Wow Starts Now(tm)" and "Vista is Ready Today(tm)" and "Proceed With Confidence(tm)".

(Gag!) (Wretch!)

by neon samurai

"
This at least in the US involves nothing more than buying a new licence from M$ and they e-mail you the new product key so you will effectively have 2 Licensed Copies of Vista on that 1 computer according to M$ numbers at least.
"

Email still travels in plain text between servers even if the user connects to there pop with tls/ssl right?

by techexec2

.
Microsoft has made two claims about Vista sales:

1. Microsoft claimed Vista sales of 40 million in the first 100 days, about 3 months since launch (1).

2. Microsoft claimed Vista sales of 60 million through July 26, 2007, about 6 months since launch (2).

So, never mind that I don't believe ANY of Microsoft's many lies, even MICROSOFT is admitting Vista sales suck! :^0 Sales during the second 3 months of life were ONLY HALF of what they were during the first 3 months of life.

Vista sales suck! :^0

------------------------------------

(1) Nine burning questions about how Vista is really doing
http://www.computerworld.com/action/article.do?command=viewArticleBasic&articleId=9021838

(2) Windows Vista ships 60M
http://www.computerworld.com/action/article.do?command=viewArticleBasic&taxonomyName=operating_systems&articleId=9028118&taxonomyId=89&intsrc=kc_top

by jackie40d1

Close to KLUTZ ( bungling ). . Maybe he has to say those things to keep his cozy job, but to say they only shipped 60 million :-) . .

There are over 50 thousand stores they sent lot of those to . . There are a ton of PC's out there just in America let alone the rest of the world and to ship only 60 million . .

SALES Really SUCK BIG TIME :-) And there are what 6 BILLION people on the planet . . thats what 1% of the world . .

According to my web site stats I am getting about 1/3 of the hits from Linux OS's and Mac has 1/6 the rest is Windows . . Does not say much for Windows as much as its been touted and used . .

by oh smeg

Perhaps you would also like some of the advertising posters as well. [b]The Wow Starts Here.[/b] :^0

Other than seeing what was in that tube I haven't opened it since and have no plans in the immediate future to either. I can personally think of a lot of things that start now and maybe Wow might be right but certainly not for the same reasons that M$ dish out. :D

Col

by rknrlkid

In order to have a "true" comparison, we need more information that we are getting. Unfortunately, MS may never be open with actual sales figures.

How about a comparison of XP activation and Vista activation for the same time period in the release cycle? Or retail sales of both in the same time period?

I am very skeptical of numbers for a reason. I am a writer, and was a semi-professional musician. I have no doubt that the software industry works just like those two industries. Number of units shipped does not mean number of units sold.

Example? If I want my book to be a New York Times bestseller (on the list, not a #1), all I really have to do is get a second mortgage on my house, and buy 50,000 copies myself. (Ever wonder how these celebrities have "#1 New York Times best selling book" when you never meet anyone who actually read it? Now you know. The publisher SHIPS a million copies, and gets it on the list.) Why are there "cut-out" bins in record stores? Because a record label will ship a million copies to get it on the charts.

In Microsoft's case, since they are selling licenses to manufacturers who are basically forced to use their software or nothing, all pre-loaded software must be discounted from the total figures because computer sales are actually sales of hardware, not the preloaded software. Preloaded software figured as sales to me is an erroneous number. Its sold to somebody, yes (a manufacturer). But those sales do not equal customer preference, since the customer doesn't really have much choice of what comes on the hardware they are buying.

It will probably take someone smarter than me to figure this out. But it would be fascinating to know!

by hfeddema

I got a Dell E520 in December, with Win XP installed and a coupon for Vista. When I got my Vista Ultimate DVDs (very late), I installed Vista in a separate boot partition (instead of using the Dell Upgrade disc). My Vista partition is very fast and has never crashed. My Win XP partition is very slow starting, probably because of all the Dell crapware. I uninstalled as much of it as I could find, but no doubt there are residues in the Registry. The only problem I have with Vista is that there is still no driver for my HP Deskjet 9670. But I have two other printers that work fine with it, so that is not much of a problem.

by jackie40d1

There is a program I use for removing stuff from the registry after deleting it
Tuneup Utilities 2007 does the cleaning of the registry for you and it runs a gob faster costs a bit of money but its good for keeping stuff clean . .

by neon samurai

I mention it because it would be an interesting comparison. You'd have to whipe your XP partition and install a clean XP rather than the Dell restore disk. Along with crapware, I suspect you also have your usual collection of user apps installed all of which will slow the overall performance. Add to that the kruft and dust that collects in your temp folders and such.

You'd need to have a clean install of XP and Vista with the same collections of user apps installed, same ram, same CPU, same cache settings and same physical hard drive.

CCleaner is a good program to add to your collection along with what is recommended in the previous post to clear out the Dell crapware.

As for printers, I have an HP at home that only works with windows. Man is HP's printer bloatware a hog; I just want the damn document to print and the printer to tell me if I need more ink but HP feels I need to see a cheesey bling bling "print job progress" panel.

Good little printer/scanner for my humble needs but I could do with more minimal win32 print drivers and *any* support for CUPS printing or scanning when not booted into Windows.

(Edit): I just read the above post. I believe CCLeaner also does the registry along with the rest of the usual temp folder places. It's the geeks choice these days and won't cost you a license fee.

by colin.hempsey

When I decided to upgrade my old P3 laptop I went for a core 2 duo with Vista home premium. I am absolutely happy with it. It hasn't crashed, runs fast, the Aero interface looks good, the sidebar is useful (when you have changed what gadgets are on it) and media playback is good, Office 2007 runs perfectly and my games run well.

This is what I wanted my laptop to do and it does it well. I use McAfee Total Protection to protect me from virii and online threats.

Alot of people post that linux is virus free and talk it up as the best OS out there to use. I have previously used Ubuntu as an OS and used Open Office for my office programs. Yes they worked ok, yes they were free and yes OO could do some things that Office 2003 and 2007 can't. But if you are buying a new computer and Vista comes as part of the package then why change to Linux?

ps I do not work for Microsoft!!!

by jackie40d1

I see you even use McAfee ( hahahahaha ) Thats below Nortons on the scale of Anti-Virus programs ! The "Vista" works for right now huh ? Ok but when WGA makes it crash don't come running to me I will sit here and laugh a lot . . I have a Lapt op coming which has Vista on it but it will get erased and add maybe linux or Win 2K Pro to it reminds me got to get a new CD as mine has been used so many times its getting a few minor scratches on it and some times it says can't find file xyz. . So Its due . .

by neon samurai

If you wanted to send over that Vista DVD and license. ;)

Oh heck, even just the license documentation, the DVD is the easy part to get ahold of.

(couldn't posting the joke)

by neon samurai

You did mention games so Windows is probably the better choice for you unless your ready to try one of the four or so ways to run Windows games on a Linux based OS. Running Ubuntu once for a little while doesn't really give grounds for questioning why people choose a Linux distro over Windows though. That's not to nock your preference for Windows, it does what you want and that's fine.

A few reasons why others have chosen something besides than Windows:

- WGA sucks for both technical and ideological reasons. It has no benefit for the end user.

- The Vista End User License Agreement sucks for both technical and ideological reasons. It basically states that the end user is assumed to be a criminal and will be treated as such. The end user does not own the software they have just paid for, they only rent the privilege of using it while Microsoft retains all rights to choose how the software is used on the end user?s own hardware. Further, if you don?t pay the premium price for the ultimate edition, you are not allowed to run Vista in a virtual machine even though there is no technical reason behind this. The next Windows EULA will probably state that the end user may not go to the washroom while Windows is booted and running.

- There is *no* technical reason to upgrade from WinXP to Vista. Has a lot of pretty makeup and eye candy but until software only supports Vista or games only support DirectX 10, there is no reason to run Vista unless it was forced on you with a new hardware purchase or enjoy exploring different OS and consider Vista another OS oddity to tinker with.

- Hardware support in Linux is currently better than Vista, especially for hardware that manufacturers have lost interest in writing new drivers for. This will change as more vendors release new hardware with drivers but perfectly good older hardware is SOL. If you get Vista with your notebook, this is an issue for the reseller more than end user though.

- Hardware requirements are less than Vista with all the bling bling enabled; your user apps (what your actually using) can make use of those extra resources. That translates to ?your games run better when the platform doesn?t take half the ram.? It?s also why I?ll continue to run my games on a minimal install of winXP.

- Linux based OS are pretty much virus free since the developers consider viruses a proof of concept for a bug in there program not something you need third party software to protect against. For Linux, viruses are blocked by releasing the corrected issue with the next program update. For Windows, viruses are blocked by AV software taking resources away from your user apps (what your actually doing). Again, translates to ?games run faster when you disable the virus scanner since it slows drive access and takes up both CPU and Ram.?

- That last point leads into the better security inherent in Unix design architecture versus the Windows onion OS.

- The last point also leads into the mention that Linux users get regular updates for *all* there installed software but that?s covered in detail lower down.

- OpenOffice may not work 100% with older Office documents but neither does the latest Office version and at least OOo has a valid reason for that issue. (I got a drive full of XLS docs so I'm stuck with Excel for the more advance files too)

- Linux based OS providers don't have a history of breaking standards and bullying vendors or pushing better technologies out of the market. That's a choice not to support the MS business racket rather than use the OS but it still counts.

- Other than high end 3D and the latest video games plus a hand full of very specialized industrial software, there's nothing you can do with Windows that can't be done with a Linux based OS (or BSD for that matter). ATI/AMD may have just changed that 3D issue though.

- LiveCD. Any of the Windows releases run from a single DVD with a complete suite of software? I think there is just now a program or two that let's you build minimal run from DVD Windows installs.

- Flexibility in general. Windows is not a very flexible OS. It has a large selection of third party applications but the OS itself does not allow one to install only a small subset of its included software. I can only install it on one or two different CPU chip architectures (four at most I?m guessing). With any Linux distro, I can install just the OS core (kernel) and what drivers I need for my specific hardware plus a console to enter commands. I can install everything from the distribution knowing that it will all run together just fine though that would duplicate individual functions many times over. In reality, I install just the software that I need and my selection of programs may be very different from the next persons. Don?t need a web browser? Don?t install one; the Linux based OS are not dependent on having it. (The office secretary won?t be browsing facebook and myspace since a browser is not needed for the assign work tasks.)

- Repositories. *nix just plain handles program installs updates and installs better. Imagine if Windows Update included installs and updates for all drivers and win32/64 programs available even if the program was a direct competitor to an MS offering. The big Linux and BSD OS providers do this after first testing the software and drivers to make sure it works with there OS distribution.

(
install = urpmi
upgrade *everything* = urpmi -auto-upgrade
uninstall = urpme

Most distros have a command prompt and GUI interface for package management though I've only given the much faster command prompt example from one distro. I just had to plug that because it's such a clean to manage software.
)

Other Reasons:

- I was issued a notebook for work. If I'm in a coffee shop, I can run a liveCD Linux distro of my choice for all my browsing and file working needs. This way the company?s hard drive is not exposed to an un-trusted network. It would be irresponsible to expose my company?s data to some coffee shop cracker wannabe skript kiddie.

- At home, I can also run off a liveCD leaving my company?s hard drive untouched. I get the bonus of running all my usual user programs off my workstation in the basement and displaying them on the notebook upstairs on the couch. Heck, the other day my wifi cut out while browsing the web. When I went down to my workstation and reopened the program (firefox in this case) it asked if I?d like to restore the last session and there I was looking at the same ten or so website tabs lost moments ago due to the wireless phone blowing out the wifi network (freaking 2.4ghz, I gotta get a new wireless phone).

- X just plain works better for the user than IE as a graphic desktop. For example; in Windows, when I open a new program, it loads in the foreground taking focus regardless of what I (the user) am doing with the machine. I often load a large program then return to my previous task knowing that it will be a minute or so before I can use it. I just don?t want to sit there staring at a Photoshop splash window yet there it is not allowing any other program to take the foreground. Sometimes I?m typing in a document while that other big program loads; suddenly, my text is being fed to that new big program instead of the previous task I?m not finished with yet. In X, programs load without taking focus of the screen, mouse and keyboard leaving me (the user) to do what I want rather than what Windows decides that I want. I can install one or many window managers of my choice rather than a single IE window manager or a select few Windows supported third party window managers which never work as cleanly as IE anyway. Heck, sometimes I don?t want or need a graphic desktop at all and since I don?t start X by default at boot (though I could), I simply carrying on with the non-GUI programs I need; a graphic desktop is always a quick ?startx? away.

Anyhow, just a few reasons why one would not choose to run Vista even if it is forced on you with a new hardware purchase. In my case, I?d probably install it as a dual boot or VM (depending on BS license limitations) since I enjoy exploring different OS and would simply consider it another addition to my OS collection (some people collect baseball cards). There?s no reason why it would ever be my primary working OS but that?s me. If Vista is what works in your case; more power too you. I?m not trying to change your mind or start religious war; just give you a few points on why it?s not so crazy that one would wipe Vista from a new machine and install something more suited to there needs or preferences.

by colin.hempsey

Thanks for the informed points neon. I asked the question because I genuinly was interested. Your answer was balanced and clear.

As I use my machine primarily for Games, e-mail and Internet and Office apps and given that I am now familiar and comfortable with Vista and Office 2007 I am unlikely to change. I did ask a question in another thread though about installing Linux on my old Laptop (PIII Celeron 2.8) and using it as a print server and for media applications (I read somewhere that some of the FOSS apps for media is very good) so I?ll say never say never.

by colin.hempsey

It works, I bought it wondering if I would have problems with Vista and I didn't. I'm very happy :)

As for WGA, my copy of Vista is genuine as is my copy of office 2007 so why would I have a problem?

by neon samurai

There where a lot of Geniune(tm) copies of Windows that recently had some problems due to WGA. There are also a few Geniune(tm) copies of Windows that required re-registering because users have changed hardware components in there own computers.

WGA is public enough that issues will emberase Microsoft into addressing them pretty quickly though at least.

by jackie40d1

When I got my NEW laptop I was talking to the TECH's at Best Buy ( ACER Laptop ) and asking them about "VISTA" hahaha got this roll of their eyes and a sorta cough about it . . Seems they did not like it very well either as they changed the subject really fast ! ! :-)

by absolutely

How long have you been using Vista? For
what tasks, primarily, do you use it?

I have no problem with Microsoft's desire
to protect their software from
counterfeiting. I do have a problem with
the methods they use, which punish
legitimate purchasers based on hardware
changes. They could [b]just as easily[/b]
use the same data that WGA gathers to
punish pirates by looking for multiple
copies of a single registration key
associated with different CPU IDs or
mainboards simultaneously.

They have no right to interrupt me, take an
inventory of my system, or compel me to
talk to them every time I add a peripheral.
I won't buy Microsoft until they implement
counterfeit protection that actually looks
for counterfeiters & respects my right to
purchase my software once, and be finished
with the transaction.

by techexec2

.
[b][i]"...As for WGA, my copy of Vista is genuine as is my copy of office 2007 so why would I have a problem?..."[/i][/b]

Good luck with that. Here's some stuff you are apparently unaware of. Vista de-activates on legitimate customers under everyday use, not just significant hardware changes like in XP. I refuse to run it because of that.

A few Vista WGA stories in the victims' own words
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=222826&messageID=2235539

Windows Vista Validation Issues Forum
http://forums.microsoft.com/Genuine/ShowForum.aspx?ForumID=1004&SiteID=25

The Windows Genuine dis-Advantage (WGA)
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=212977&messageID=2291763

Vista de-activates on genuine customers
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=212977&messageID=2298108

UPDATE: Normal use of USB devices can trigger Vista WGA de-activation
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=212977&messageID=2215786

by neon samurai

By Microsoft's count, that's probably accurate. If a Vista license leaves Microsoft the count it then claim there final sum is how many Vista machines have been sold. They don't mention how many licenses are being "sold" through vendor agreements only to be stock piled.

An interesting figured would be how many Vista licenses are actually installed and running on end user machines. Microsoft has that figure also through there own update statistics but I'm sure it's not nearly as valuable as marketing propoganda.

(Nice new makeup they put on the old Get The FUD website by the way.. really love the Highly Reliable Times ads.)

by jackie40d1

The Laptop I bought had [&%@#] "VISTA" on it ! can't get a ( more nasty words here ) Laptop without eerrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr ! VISTA on it !
I immediately added LINUX to it and erased the above mentioned stuff ! So another computer is no longer has that stuff on it . . Wonder If I can send a message to M$ saying well another one of the Laptops you had that stuff on is now LINUX . . Just to make them irritated ;-)

by neon samurai

Heck, you already paid for the OS so they're laughing; they get a license fee and have no expense providing end user support. You may want to look into returning your unopened Vista license from the next machine. I've heard of some success with getting your MS Tax back since the EULA states "if not used and unopened then return to hardware vendor".

Mind you, if a huge number of people started to notify MS of the software replacement and got there MS tax back from vendors they may take notice.

by neon samurai

But it'll be so hard acting like an average user until after they answer. The jig would be up as soon as I slapped in a liveCD to properly test the unit before making my purchasing choise.

I am due in there looking for some other accessories though.. hm.. maybe I'll make a fun trip of it.

I'd still love to see someone take a stack of liveCd through a bestbuy and simply reboot all the display machines to see how customers respond and how fast the store staff react. Somehow I think there may be legal implications to the poor lad who made that garilla marketing run though.

by neon samurai

Mind you, frequenting the forums and interacting with other tech literate people has greatly provided balance back into it. I gotta admit, I was spiralling off a little being out of IT work and serounded by tech illiterate friends and colleges for such a long while. (admining a server and chatting with the regulars can be great therapy)

I expect your old laptop would work well as a print server. Depending on how old it is and how little ram it has, you may want to stick a Damn Small or Puppy Linux liveCD in it to check it out. The only issue with printing would be if the printer is supported. Other than that, it will probably be like learning to fly a helicopter; a bit of work at first but after that it's just take off, move, land (or boot, work, halt).

This discussion is closed to new replies.