Question Locked

Microwave vs. Infrared vs. WiFi

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've got a little situation that needs an expert's input.

Can anyone recommend a solution to tie in 2 lan's in 2 buildings (less than 200 feet apart), clear line of sight on both roofs to each other. Main building has around 50 users. 2nd building about 30. Need to accomplish some type of a voice encapsulation i guess so that the 2nd building can use the existing "intertel" phone system as well as regular data access from main building's servers/SAN's

Help someone?

6 replies

by mjd420nova

With that short a distance, infra-red would be the best. WIFI and microwave would pose a security risk due to interception and atmospheric conditions.

by oh smeg

This will also depend on one of the buildings not having it's reception spot in direct sunlight that will overwhelm the Infra Red Connection. If you can organize the connections on North Facing walls if you are in the Northern Hemisphere or Southern Walls if you are in the Southern Hemisphere this will work but if either end of an Infra Red Link is open to lots of direct sunlight this will give you problems.

Actually if you can connect with Fiber Optical Cable provided that the infrastructure accommodates this option it would be better and far less likely to suffer any interference. But that depends entirely on the buildings and what is between them.

A underground Fiber Optical Link would be your best option over such a short distance if it's possible but the permission that you may need to get could be a killer.

Col

by tsayyah

Has anyone implemented any such solutions and if so, could you please recommend a product?

by oh smeg

But I've used Microwave, IR, WiFi and Fiber Optic connections between buildings and every different one has it's pros and cons.

Since this is a really close deployment I personally would be trying an Optical Fiber installation between buildings but again you would need to find someone who specializes in this and get them to tell you what Bureaucratic Requirements are placed on you to run a underground cable through the existing conducts.

An IR Link shouldn't really require any permits but again this depends on where it is that the deployment is going.

The same applies to WiFi as this is a common freely available connection form and is well within the radius of the transceiver so it shouldn't require any permits but you'll still have to check with whoever.

Microwave will defiantly require permits but as this is such a short distance I wouldn't consider this option for this link as it's not worth the expense and effort.

As there is going to be voice communication my first option would still be Optical Fiber but this depends entirely on what permits you need to obtain and what hoops the Bureaucrats what you to jump through.

It has the better bandwidth and speed over everything else but the permits could be worth more than the connection is worth.

Col

by walter

Fibre optic is definitely the best option and has the best long term return on invetsment (should last 20-years plus). Multi-mode will support 1Gig up-to 550m (depending on the fibre quality) and single mode 10Gig (I'm not sure of the max distance but should be in excess of 10km depending on the drivers). The cable can be suspended between building if this is allowed or installed underground (preferably) if there are sleeves between the buildings. If there are sleeves you can also install a telephone backbone cable between the buildings at the same time. If no sleeves are present and it is impossible to trench between the buildings or try contacting a company that does directional drilling - these guys literally drill a hole underground between the building and then pull a suitable sleeve through the 'hole', i recommend at least a 50mm pipe. Be carefull of existing underground services if you choose to do this, particularly municipal services if you are crossing a public road and make sure you get the necessary approval from all relevant authorities. If all else fails go infra red (also known as free space optics or FSO). The latest models are not so susceptible to interference from the sun anymore and can be discreetly installed behind a window without any problem. They are available up to 1Gig and will work up to about 550m (at 1GIG - further at 100meg).

This discussion is closed to new replies.