Question Locked

Monitor doesn't turn off

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Bob, before I get to my issue, do you understand what those last 2 posts were in the thread we just finished? I also suspected spam, but it didn't make sense to me. They were on topic (even though the problem had been resolved). They weren't promoting anything and there were no links. What does someone have to gain from such posts? I'm baffled.
Now, to my problem. Last week, my monitor suddenly stopped turning off after 15 minutes of inactivity. When I did a restore from a 9-day-old backup, it was back to turning off. But now, it's suddenly not turning off again.
It stopped right after Windows installed an update, but uninstalling the update didn't change anything, so as unlikely as it seems, the update's not the culprit.
I disabled all services in msconfig and disabled all startups in Task Manager, and that did solve the problem.
I was ready to play detective by enabling a few at a time, but I ran into a snag. When I opened msconfig, I found that a number of services - among them AVG and ZoneAlarm - had turned themselves back on.
That leaves me wondering how I can pinpoint the cause.
An additional question. I chatted with a Microsoft tech support person and mentioned that despite the fact that I had Updates paused, an update or updates was / were installed when I rebooted. That made him suspect that I may have corrupted files and he suggested that I do an In-Place Repair. He felt that would not only solve my update problem, but could even fix my monitor issue.
Your thoughts?

23 replies

by rproffitt edited

When PCs started to use HDMI this was an recurring problem.

But I read nothing about updating the video card driver the old fashioned way. Or is this an unsu[ported OS?

For now I don't agree it's corrupted files. Just decades of same old driver problems.

by doniel edited

We just got finished working on my problem booting into Windows.
The video driver is up to date.
And my monitor's not connected by HDMI.

by rproffitt edited

Up to date, maybe but the makers are not supporting this configuration any longer.

Sorry but such is the new way of things.

I'd load the factory install and supplied OS to see if it's working as intended from the makers.

by doniel edited

I don't blame you. My threads aren't the only ones you join. In the thread we just finished, I wrote that my configuration is an upgrade I did myself. I bought a new (though not the latest generation) CPU (Core i7), m/b, RAM and SSD. The CPU has onboard graphics.
To jog your memory, I already had Windows 11 Pro installed on a hard drive. When I installed all this new hardware, I installed Windows 11 Pro on the SSD.
All this worked fine for several months. The monitor turned off as it was supposed to. Suddenly, last week, it didn't.
As I wrote in my first post, I "narrowed it down" to non-Microsoft services and startups, but can't investigate further because some programs turned their services back on.

by rproffitt edited

Time and time again I find it's something changed or added after the factory install.

For example some don't want the PC to "LOCK" and disable that. To test for that I press Win+L and wait to see if it the screen times out.

The list is long and on various Reddit discussions for reading at leisure. The one thing I've learned is it's rarely what I'll call out.

by doniel edited

My question is how to pinpoint it when programs restore their services without asking.
And another question: Is there any downside to doing the In-Place Repair the Microsoft tech support person suggested?
So . . . I'm looking for answers to 2 questions.

by kees_b edited

In Control Panel > Energy settings, right on the first screen, is an option to set the timer for turning off the screen. Maybe it's somewhere in the Settings app also, but I didn't check that. Does that work with you?

All monitors I know have on/off-button. That works in 1 second. No need to wait 15 minutes to start saving electricity if you don't shutdown or hibernate, but just walk away to make a cup of coffee.

As for the installation of a Windows update after booting, that's not influenced by pausing updates. Pausing updates only pauses downloading. When it's downloaded and the first phase of installing (when shutting down), the second phase (after reboot) is done automatically.

And about your first question: some people just post nonsense, or (in your case) totally unnecessary posts, like repeating a solution already done and effective. Such posts can be removed, even if they don't promote anything and contain no links. No need to be baffled.

And have a look at https://www.techrepublic.com/forums/discussions/keyboard-9/ . Just an example of someone suspecting a hardware of software issue when something behaves in an unusual way in stead of thinking about settings.

by doniel edited

I assume you mean Power settings, not Energy settings. Yes, of course. It's always been set to 15 minutes.
I've been using the on/off button,. The problem is that I often don't remember to shut off the monitor.
I want to emphasize that maybe it's you who's right, but the Microsoft tech support person said that even if the update's been downloaded, pausing updates will prevent it from installing.
I'm baffled because I don't understand what motivates them to post such stuff.
The keyboard post: Who says he suspected a h/w or s/w issue? Maybe he didn't but simply didn't think of settings. At any rate, I thoroughly checked settings and everything was as it should be.

by doniel

The problem with wipe and reload is that there's no guarantee that the problem won't surface again.

by rproffitt edited

This has been the way it is since the beginning.

The Apple OS has been a bit better in that respect and Linux too. Linux however can be too much for some because you're at the command line more often for the power off issue under discussion.

by doniel edited

Hope to try it over the weekend.
Thanks.
Edit: This happened in my previous thread, too. I clicked on Reply to a specific post - in this case, your latest, kees_b - and instead of placing my reply immediately following the post I was replying to, it knocked it all the way down to the bottom.

by kees_b edited

As far as I know (but I never tested it) that misplacing of a reply totally at the bottom happens if it would be indented too much to the right to be posted as a reply to the post you replied to. Apparently there is a max reply depth programmed in the forum software. Imagine what would happen if that would be 100 ...

by rproffitt

And are ready to restore to BARE METAL because drives and more are prone to failure my stance is there is no downside here.

Now if someone wants to only get the "this is what is wrong" answer I can't help because this area has hundreds of causes.

I don't expect folk to reveal all because that's asking far too much.

by doniel edited

I'm asking HOW to pinpoint the cause.
Remember, it would appear to be either a non-Microsoft service or a startup. If some programs weren't turning their services back on, it would just be a process of elimination. But some programs ARE turning their services back on.
Also, I have to wonder. Even though my monitor turned off after I disabled non-Microsoft services and startups, thereby "proving" that it wasn't the update that was the cause, the update was the only change to my system and my monitor stopped turning off right after the update. Hard to believe it's a coincidence.

by rproffitt edited

You load a working install then compare the what thousand variables?

Windows 11 updates BIOS, Drivers and more. I've been a bit lucky in that I can use factory installs then a few changes and never think about adding more drives etc.

I've yet to find a write up on how to pinpoint the cause in any document. It's been decades and Microsoft and most will toss in the towel and say, wipe, reload.

by kees_b

A service is started by booting if set in services.msc to automatic, or by a running program or service. And there never is a question for permission.

However, it seems unlikely to me a third party service changes the way Windows or the BIOS or the hardware interact with a monitor. Prove that by uninstalling and reinstalling AVG and ZoneAlarm, with enough shutdowns in between.

A repair install of Windows should work without giving new problems.

by doniel edited

When all I had to deal with were IBM 360 mainframes!

by doniel edited

reminds me of something I forgot about when I wrote my original post.
I tried a number of utilities that turn off the monitor. Every one of them did that for a second or 2, and then the monitor came back on.

by doniel edited

As you can see at the very end of this thread, carl0001134 is at it again.

by doniel

that I'll never understand computers and I'm saying it now again.
Beginning about an hour ago, my monitor suddenly started going off again.
So the problem may not have been solved, but it's resolved.

This discussion is closed to new replies.