Discussion Locked

More Government Lunacy - The Mortgage Crisis

0 helpful
237 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[b]Disclaimer:[/b] I'm not blaming any particular politician or office holder (neither President Clinton nor President Bush, for example), but rather showing the absolute lunacy in expecting government to solve personal problems or to meddle in private citizens' affairs.

[b]Rewind the clock to the early 1990s:[/b] President Clinton, with the blessing of both Republicans and Democrats in Congress, advanced an agenda which they called, [i]The National Homeownership Strategy: Partners in the American Dream.[/i] (Do a Web search.) In short, it encouraged mortgage lenders to loosen-up their requirements for those seeking mortgages, thus making home ownership available to those who otherwise wouldn't qualify - in other words, for those who couldn't afford it.

The government, as a result, relaxed requirements for the federal guarantee on those mortgages: lowered income to payment ratio, relaxed income verification, reduced (or eliminated) down payments, etc. Mortgage lenders, as ones who issued those government backed loans, were encouraged - or possibly directed - to follow suit. (I say directed to follow suit because those lenders had to follow government rules if they wanted to continue to be able to issue FHA loans.)

[b]Fast forward to 2000:[/b] The National Homeownership Strategy: Partners in the American Dream, is a [i]"..... public-private partnership working to dramatically increase homeownership opportunity in America. Under the directive of President Clinton, the Partnership was formed in 1995 by nearly 60 national organizations that care about homeownership. Today, the Partnership consists of 66 members representing lenders, real estate professionals, home builders, nonprofit housing providers, and federal, state and local governments.

HUD Secretary Andrew Cuomo said: ?The good news as we mark National Homeownership Week is that homeownership in America is at record levels. But the bad news we face is that many of HUD?s homeownership and other programs are under attack by some members of Congress. The success of our homeownership initiatives proves that HUD in combination with local organizations can further our goal of even more homeownership and fulfill our commitment to liberty and equity for all.? [/i]

Okay, isn't that nice? I wonder? Who were those members of Congress "attacking" it? What were they attacking? And what were they predicting?

[b]The immediate results:[/b] As a result of a huge increase in demand against a limited supply, home prices (and values) rose dramatically. In addition to the injection of even more home buyers (unqualified home buyers) into the market, many people used those increases in their home values to refinance other debt into the more attractive (tax deductable) mortgage debt. Moreover, mortgages are bought and sold on the open market, as they always have been. Historically, behind Treasury Bills, Mortgages were among the safest of all investments to buy. As a result, many investment banks bought those mortgages (government-backed mortgages, by the way).

[b]The eventual (and inevitable?) repercussions[/b]: People began defaulting on mortgages they couldn't afford in the first place. Banks and Mortgage lenders were foreclosing at record levels. (Foreclosures are always a lose-lose proposition for both the buyer and the lender.) Home values began to plummet. Mortgage investments were losing value.

[b]Fast forward to today:[/b] The government, with the blessings of Republican President Bush and a Democratic Party controlled Congress, is now in the process of bailing-out mortgage lenders who made bad loans to people who couldn't afford them in the first place. Moreover, investment bankers, who are also facing a huge crisis - because of the defaults on the mortgages they purchased - are also being discussed as possible government bail-out candidates. (Can you say 401(k) accounts?)

[b]Who's to blame:[/b] Of course, [i]greedy[/i] mortgage lenders and [i]unscrupulous[/i] investment bankers are the easy targets. They're the ones currently being demonized, aren't they? They're the only ones being blamed, aren't they? Why not blame a meddling government? After all, who's more to blame, business or government? Or why not blame borrowers who had to know they were buying something they couldn't afford? No, we can't blame them; they were [i]victims[/i] (sarcasm), weren't they?

Yet again, we see the failure of the [i]private and public partnership[/i], which really means more government control of private lives. And yet again, the taxpayers will bear the burden. How much will this add to our national debt - a debt that will burden future generations of Americans?

Whatever happened to the days of having to verify one's income and show the ability to repay a loan before one is issued? I guess that was before the government - in its infinite wisdom (dripping with sarcasm) - decided it would be politically expedient to make home ownership available to those who really cannot afford it.

[b]Bottom line:[/b] The role of government IS NOT to solve personal problems, but rather to ensure a society in which people can find their own solutions and solve their own problems. The government CANNOT solve those problems; but it can do a masterful job at CREATING them. (I wonder if it's all planned, or if they really are that stupid!) When will people realize that?

If we knew then (in early 1990s) what we know now, what would we (should we) have done differently?

(Edited to fix a few formatting things.)

237 replies

by the scummy one

it probably would not have made a difference. The greedy would still have done what they did most likely, and the buyers (many had the income, but soon after purchase lost their jobs) would likely still have bought.

Now IF the rules/regulations were not made, we probably would not be facing this now.

by the maverick phantom wanderer (formerly macoza, nodice, kp, etc.)

"I wonder if it's all planned, or if they really are that stupid!"

Possibly both.

"If we knew then what we know now, what would we (should we) have done differently?"

Answer 1 (What should we have done differently?): I lack the knowledge necessary to provide an alternate, but I can say that we should not have passed that law.

Answer 2: (What would we have done differently?): Change the wording of the law so that enough people would be convinced to pass it anyway.

Nodice

by jck

That it is the responsibility of the government that private enterprise [b]chose[/b] (in many cases) to:

- falsify income statements to make the loans go through
- not check income (I refuse to believe that a lender would loan money to someone who can not make the base payment on a mortgage no matter what you say...that's business suicide no matter who backs the mortgage)

Blaming the government for the ill-reputed practices of many private mortgage lenders who have done so, is like blaming the parent for their child stealing from the neighbors.

I agree with you...it is not government's role to solve personal problems.

However, it is their role to write law as well as fabricate rule and regulation to keep checks and balances in a fair, open market to prevent fraud.

Personally, I say let the banks fail and fold.

I say let shareholders go storm the homes of corporate officers who took $100Ms in compensation while they were doing corrupt and unsafe financial practices at their firms.

I am sick of government not writing law to make things work right because of the good ole boy network (it's not the form of government which is flawed, but those who are supposed to follow its model and do not do so)...

and I am sick of private industry not being held to a higher standard of business practice where unscrupulous practice is punishable and proper practice is rewarded.

I am about ready to promote the old bumpersticker slogan:

"Kill em all. Let God sort em out."

by ontheropes

I've been saying that right along. It's their own damn fault for not doing good business.

Same goes for the auto companies. They had their chance. If they didn't build better, longer lasting, affordable and fuel efficient vehicles it's just tough sh*t. Let somebody new step in to take their place.

No more bail-outs at tax-payer expense. I don't see anybody bailing me out when I make a bad business decision. Why should big business expect it and get it?

by jck

they pay for the political campaigns?

That's probably why... ;) lol

by the scummy one

Why all of the bailouts. Because may businesses depend on being imporant enough for bailouts. Utilities that manage poorly, airlines, auto makers, and down the list.

Let them fail, others will move in. If need be (as in the utility companies) an outsourced service should be put in place tempoarily until things get straightened out.

Execs for these failed businesses should get NO Bonuses if they screw the company up!

by delbertpgh

Sure, some players need a bullet to the brain. Bankruptcy is a great disincentive to careless behavior.

However. If you have major, major institutions suddenly go bust, then all the deals they were holding fall to crap. Deals that were sound turn bad because money can't move. Bond holders start demanding that insurance companies pay on their default insurance contracts. That's what bankrupted AIG, except in an environmental collapse, a disaster like AIG could develop in a matter of days. You'd have big banks, local banks, life insurors, and every other kind of institution going broke because their assets were locked down or disappeared in somebody else's collapse.

One of the reasons Americans have the richest economy is that we have the biggest and deepest system of finance. We let the players get careless, though, and now the whole thing is in trouble. If we just let it fall to the ground, we all become poor for twenty years. It'll be the new Great Depression.

The Bear Stearns "bailout" lost the stock holders of Bear 90 per cent of their investment. The AIG "bailout" gives the government an 80% ownership share, meaning the stockholders lose 80% of their value. If your million dollar investment turns into $200,000, would you feel bailed out? There's plenty of punishment built into the terms of the deal.

by netman1958

<< - not check income (I refuse to believe that a lender would loan money to someone who can not make the base payment on a mortgage no matter what you say...that's business suicide no matter who backs the mortgage) >>

It's called no-documentation loans. They just check the borrower's credit rating and take their word on the income, but do not verify it. Here's one example:

https://www.quickenloans.com/home-buying/learn/loans/no-doc-home-loans

by jck

indeed...let the banks fail.

Any businessman who'd not confirm someone can pay them...needs to fail.

That's just bad. I had to take my last 3 months of income statements to get my mortgage...and my SSA card...and driver's license.

Credit rating? Maybe I should have bought a house on that program.

Next thing ya know, they'll wanna mortgage to ugly people easier cause they can't get jobs at Hooters or Chippendale's. :^0 lol

by jdclyde

Allowed people that were closer to the edge to get that big house that they had no business getting.

Many people were two paychecks from bankruptcy because of paying out to much for their house and car. When car loans stretched out to seven years, it was a bad sign.

People were sold on the monthly payment, not the total price.

And then there were the people that didn't stick with the fixed rate mortgage. I know someone that lost their house because the economy changed, rates changed, and so did their monthly payment. They couldn't make the new payment. They couldn't sell the house because they owed more than it was worth because of the previous over-inflation of the value of houses.

The bank paid them 2k to hand over the keys and walk away. This is becoming more common, as it keeps the previous owner from trashing the house before they leave.

Find people that broke the law, fine them twice what they took in (instead of the slap on the wrist that is common) and then throw them in jail. If this means complete liquidation of all assets, so be it.

by jck

[i]Find people that broke the law, fine them twice what they took in (instead of the slap on the wrist that is common) and then throw them in jail. If this means complete liquidation of all assets, so be it. [/i]

What if they have no assets?

You just spend $10Ks trying to find someone who doesn't have anything more than a bed, a $30 pawn shop TV, and a $30 pawn shop bicycle now?

Like mom always said...can't get blood out of a turnip.

by tonythetiger

[i]I say let shareholders go storm the homes of corporate officers who took $100Ms in compensation while they were doing corrupt and unsafe financial practices at their firms.[/i]

What about the ones who GAVE those compensation packages... I wonder why nobody asks about them?

[I kinda asked this in another message, but 404'd when I hit send. Sorry for the sort-of repeat]

by jck

If you're doing wrong, you're doing wrong.

The Board might just be paying what is "SOP" as it was called.

However, the upper management know what is going on financially in a corp. They know what is and is not happening.

Again...if upper management takes fat paychecks and they know their corp is tanking and still take the money...what kind of person are they?

Just another crook, IMHO. If they are there to run a company and make it profitable...and they fail...they should have to surrender their pay.

If I don't do my job and take money for it, I get sued for fraud.

CEOs should be no different.

by tonythetiger

[i]If we knew then (in early 1990s)[/i]

Most intelligent people I know could have predicted this outcome, which is probably why most of us didn't jump on that bandwagon.

If you don't understand the risks or can't afford to lose, you shouldn't be playing the game.

Whatever happened to the "thirds" rule (one third for living, one third for short term goals, and one third for long-term goals)?

by jck

In the early 1990s?

I was more concerned with getting drunk with my buddies in college. :^0

by jck

[i]Execs for these failed businesses should get NO Bonuses if they screw the company up![/i]

If a corporation wants to go belly-up...the upper level management becomes fiscally responsible, and must repay all salary and bonuses from the period from which the company is found in bankruptcy court to have become not solvent.

Just watch the CEOs cringe as their $14M house in Aspen is sold off to pay back shareholders...or their investment accounts are liquidated as collateral.

If they can be rewarded for financial success from the corporate...they should be obligated to be responsible for its failure.

by the scummy one

however the govt. cannot even make politicians responsible for their actions, and you want them to pass laws like that? Good Luck!

by jck

If I take pay from a company and don't do my job, it's called fraud.

If a CEO does it, it's called a market downturn.

The government, since they (SEC) regulates these corps, needs to step up and use the SEC to enforce that along with the Treasury Dept.

Accountability is not something that should be held to only those making less than $1M a year.

by jck

But loss of your assets due to negligence and/or poor business practice and/or unscrupulous and even sometimes illegal action is tortable.

Seeing that a lot of mortgage reps were paid based on turnover of mortgages to sell, that were not properly done or even falsified by the firms...they should be held accountable.

Just like if you lied about your income on a financial statement to the IRS or a lender, it is punishable.

Business shouldn't be immune.

And I agree, the workers really got screwed.

by ontheropes

The salaries of some of the chief executives are outrageous. They're too out of line given their job performance. That seems to be SOP almost everywhere.

by tonythetiger

between them and someone who wanted their services, and it's "SOP", as you say, "outrageous" is a matter of opinion. But outrageous or not, their salaries are but a grain of sand in the sandbox. It makes a good distraction, and to some, a scapegoat, but its a minor part of the overall picture.

Answer the unasked questions... Who decided to pay them that much, and what were they expecting for that money? Who's the heat NOT on?

by jck

That's usually, in a shareholder held corporation, the Board of Directors.

Which in corporate circles usually means...all of their buddies from other corporations.

by tonythetiger

[i]Maybe I should have bought a house on that program. [/i]

There are a few real deals out there on foreclosed homes :)

Every cloud has a silver lining... If someone's selling, someone else is buying. If someone's losing, someone's winning. It all evens out.

by ontheropes

I look for low cost houses around here, just to see. There have been some real good bargains. A few small groups and individuals are making money flipping them.

by netman1958

I can't believe they were doing it. Less than a year ago, just about every lender around was offering those. It seems not so many are offering them these days.

by charliespencer

NetMan's point was that it did indeed happen, no matter that jck refuses to believe it did.

Why? Because the people selling the mortgages aren't keeping them. Almost all mortgages are bundled and resold as soon as the deal closes. Since they aren't keeping the paper, they don't care if the house buyer can keep up the payments. It's difficult for those buying the bundles to research every mortgage in the package, and they know Uncle Sugar will bail them out anyway.

by jck

I just never heard of any deal like that when I bought either of my homes.

I could have used something like that too.

And, I work for what I get. Guess I made too much. lol

by netman1958

Like you, I had to show 2 years worth of W-2s, several months of pay stubs, SS card, I think they even ask for my sister-in-law's bra size! Of course I was going for the lowest interest rate available so I was more than willing to comply.

by netman1958

because I don't actually know her bra size. I would have to say she is cute, especially since she is a few years older than me and a long-term cancer survivor.

Where she's at sorta relates to this discussion. She is a real estate agent here in Birmingham and my brother is a home builder. My brother has 3 new houses he built that haven't sold and one has been on the market for over 2 years, so I suspect she is out trying to sell those houses.

The Birmingham metro area is one of the best examples of a place that had over-inflated real estate prices and now it has come back to bite people in the behind.

by jdclyde

I was talking about the people that broke the law, in predatory lending practices and such. You know, the people you were crying about that made a profit out of the whole thing? If they did break the law, hang'em high....

by jck

when you said go after them...the people who dump the houses and tear them up and what not.

my bad.

yes...anyone who breaks the law...PUNISH THEM!!!!

MAKE THEM WATCH RE-RUNS OF THE ROSIE O'DONNELL SHOW!!!! lol :^0

by jdclyde

we don't even joke about such things....

You thought the shock to find out what was going on in the iraqi prisons was bad, human rights watch would be all over us for that! :p

As for trashing the house, if they do it while it is still there, I don't know how much can be legally done against them. If the house is collateral for the loans, there should be something that they are liable for. There is no excuse for doing that, and it should be punished. A nice prison cell shared with the loan officer? People that do that are scum and deserve to sit in prison.

by charliespencer

We purchased a house in '04. I refused to discuss anything other than conventional 25- and 30-year fixed.

There's plenty of blame to go around. The gov't encouraging this, the mortgage brokers for reducing the lax gov't standards even further, the investment banks for buying the sub-prime loans, and the buyers for closing on contracts they either didn't understand or hoped to get away with.

by jdclyde

bring back the chain gangs. We need the sides of the highway to get picked up, and clean up the beaches. B-)

by jck

they have prisoners in most states clean the roadsides anyways.

Just don't let em touch the lawnmowers tho! :^0

by jdclyde

like:

Why do the road side workers look like they have a better disposition than they normally do?

Why are the road side workers doing a better job than they normally do?

How did they get so many to show up for work on the same day?

How did they get them to work longer than 15 minutes at a time without having to take a 30 minute coffee/smoke break?

;\

by netman1958

Do these ring a bell?

What we've got here is a failure to communicate.
He's got to get his mind right.
Anyone who's mind ain't right gets to spend the night in the box.
What's your dirt doing in Boss Keen's ditch?

Oh yeah, and there's a guy in the background singing "A Closer Walk With Thee"

by jck

[i]that the problems are in organizations that tried to emulate the way governments are set up [/i]

I have never seen the FBI director and Treasury Secretary and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs sit on a panel that votes payraises for the President or Congress.

Check out sometime some big corp and their "Board of Directors" page. Take all the names down, and then go look at their corp enterprise's board.

It's like playing 6 Degrees of Seperation. They're all on each other's BODs.

by jck

there is a lot of scum in this world...including the CEOs who would take $200M payouts while their company is tanking.

Whether you're screwing a bank...or a shareholder....

Whether you are rich or you're not...

Scum is scum.

by maxwell edison

..... most people are jumping on the [i]Let the banks fold and fail[/i] bandwagon. I've seen very few acknowledgements that the government actually was, in the very least, an accomplice in creating the problem in the first place.

For those who think that lenders can choose to ignore government regulations when it comes to granting FHA loans to borrowers, they are sadly mistaken. And if those same people don't believe that the government relaxed the criteria, again, they're sadly mistaken.

I place 100 percent of the blame on government for backing and guaranteeing the loans in the first place. Without that in-place, the lenders wouldn't have given mortgages to anyone other than those who could REALLY qualify.

Either people have very short memories, or they were too drunk to be paying attention.

[i]At the request of President Clinton, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) is working with dozens of national leaders in government and the housing industry to implement the National Homeownership Strategy, an unprecedented public-private partnership to increase homeownership to a record-high level over the next 6 years.....

However, the American Dream became more distant for many during the 1980s, as the national homeownership rate fell from its historic high of 65.6 percent in 1980 to only 64.1 percent in 1991. The decline has been sharp-est among segments of the population for whom access to the homebuying market has traditionally been most difficult. The homeownership rate for very low-income families with children fell by almost one-third, from 39 percent to 27 percent, between 1980 and 1991. Even among moderate-income households, homeownership dropped by 10 percent. Homeownership rates stagnated at approximately 43 percent for blacks, whilehomeownership among Hispanics fell from 43 percent in 1980 to 39 percent in 1991.....

Under the leadership of Secretary Cisneros, HUD has forged a nationwide partnership that will draw on the resources and creativity of lenders, builders, real estate professionals, community-based nonprofit organizations, consumer groups, State and
local governments and housing finance agencies, and many others in a cooperative, multifaceted campaign to create ownership opportunities and reduce the barriers facing underserved populations and communities. The National Homeownership Strategy is committed to:.....

MAKING FINANCING MORE AVAILABLE, AFFORDABLE, and FLEXIBLE. The inability (either real or perceived) of many younger families to qualify for a mortgage is widely recognized as a very serious barrier to homeownership. The National Homeownership Strategy commits both government and the mortgage industry to a number of initiatives designed to:

Cut transaction costs through streamlined regulations and technological and procedural efficiences.

Reduce downpayment requirements and interest costs by making terms more flexible, providing subsidies to low and moderate income families, and creating incentives to save for homeownership.

Increase the availability of alternative financing products in housing markets throughout the country.[/i]

There's more:

http://www.huduser.org/publications/txt/hdbrf2.txt

It's government social engineering run amok, and it's run a previously strong industry into the ground. President Reagan said it best: Government is not the solution to our problems; government is the problem. Not too many people have acknowledged that, instead, focusing only on the financial institutions. At best, they (the financial institutions) were led in this direction by the government; at worst, the two are in bed together. Either way, no one with any sense can possibly overlook the government's culpability in the problem - and now they (the government) claim to be the savior!

Another segue question: Why don't people look back at these pie-in-the-sky government programs, and look back to judge them on their levels of success? If they did, the infamous [i]War on Poverty[/i] would be deemed a dismal failure. Their solution? More of the same. Yes, it's lunacy.

by tonythetiger

[i]an unprecedented public-private partnership to increase homeownership to a record-high level over the next 6 years.....[/i]

Since we well know that you don't "own" anything until you've paid for it.

by maxwell edison

Because of the property tax that must be paid in perpetuity. At best, we're all renters, and governments are the landlord.

by jck

[i]For those who think that lenders can choose to ignore government regulations when it comes to granting FHA loans to borrowers, they are sadly mistaken. [/i]

Not all lending institutions do FHA mortgages.

No one forced them to do so.

[i]I've seen very few acknowledgements that the government actually was, in the very least, an accomplice in creating the problem in the first place.[/i]

Because government makes a law that leaves a loophole is no justification for business taking advantage of it and running amok with unscrupulous business practices, and not being responsible in checking things that are a sound business practice in their market.

At most, the government was the catalyst. However, mortgage fraud and boom housing markets occured before Clinton and Bush, and fraud occurred in them too without government interference.

Example: Homes sold in Homestead, FL that were "hurricane rated", but later found to be sub-standardly built after hurricane Andrew.

However, the practices of falsifying income on mortgage statements, offering better than normal deals to mortgagees on notes by mortgage brokers looking to beef up their bonuses, etc., are [b]not[/b] because of an action taken by government...but because of unsavory character and lack of fiscal morality and responsibility by the banking industry and their staff.

Blaming the government for putting a program out there that was abused by the banking industry...is like blaming gun manufacturers for the guns criminals use to kill people.

Perhaps they should have made the program better and with tighter rules, but for lenders to abuse it all in the name of unfettered capitalism and profiteering is corrupt and scandalous and wrong.

by maxwell edison

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac currently control about 90 percent of the nation's secondary mortgage market. To suggest that lenders can opt out of writing those loans is, at best, naive'.

Fannie Mae was created in 1938 as part of FDR's New Deal. It was, in essence, a National Savings and Loan, having a virtual monopoly on the secondary mortgage market for decades to come. President Johnson later privatized it (to keep it off-budget), but the government maintained strict oversight.

http://hnn.us/articles/1849.html

I would be willing to make a wager - those institutions making the 10 percent of loans outside the scope of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are not in trouble of failing, and they have not made irresponsible loans.

Edit:

We do agree on one thing, jck. If a legitimate business fails - ANY business - let it fail. No bail-outs, no tax dollars to the rescue, no subsidies to keep it afloat. But what about this government owned ..... I mean government controlled business that has repercussions on 90 percent of home mortgages?

Government should have never gone there in the first place. It should be a clue - a warning to heed - when future efforts to broaden the scope of government control of, and meddling into people's private lives are advanced. (Can you spell National Health Care?) Of course, as a big-government proponent, you surely disagree. You seem to want even more of it.

by jck

petition for de-annexation. it can be done.

the country club did it from the city and county in my hometown in Oklahoma, so that they could serve liquor by the drink.

by jck

But, that's been going on since the beginning of the Industrial Age.

I just want farmers and barbers and stuff to run the country for 10 years.

I think we'd be far better off than letting 530 lawyers do it for us.

by ontheropes

I've been thinking that for quite some time now. I'd say so more often but my experience shows me that I'm just not very good at communicating and organizing my thoughts very well for some of these discussions. My skills with the written word are certainly not up to your level

Also, since I have your attention for a minute, I want to say that there's been a lot of water under the bridge since we had a 'discussion' quite awhile back. I want you to know that I hold no grudges. There's a clean slate.

by maxwell edison

How about a Hockey Mom from Alaska?

It's funny how people wish for [i]normal[/i] people to run the country, but when a woman who more closely resembles one than everyone else makes an appearance on the National scene, she's chided as being inexperienced.

by oz_media

Of course its Bush's fault, he's an idiot who couldn't be trusted with his own alowance. I blame Bush, he's the reason I woke with a headache last week, he's the reason I can't quit smoking, he's the reason I make $500,000.00/yr LESS than I SHOULD be making, he's the reason I am overweight, he's the reason for every death that has occurred in the last 8 years (natural, suuuuure it is), he's the reason most of the world's problems, he's the reason we are all going to die soon from global warming, he's teh reason most people can't stand America, or at least less than they did before, he's the reason for everything bad in the last 8 years.

I BLAME BUSH and that's all there is to it; now, where's a little kid so I can take his candy away and laugh.

EDITED TO PUT MORE BLAME ON BUSH

by oz_media

I uh, well, er.....hmmmmm. Sigh, I wasn't expecting you to agree with me...I'm at a loss for words....NEWSFLASH!!! I'm am out of replies against Bush,..must make nasty remark, must be anti-American, must hate republicans....oh, there we go, now I've got it again. :)

Actually I don't think you'd be too surprised to find out I am pretty much behind Canada's Conservative Party for the upcoming election here. Although most think I am a left wing, NDP, tree hugger, who wants teh government to pay for my every whim, I think you know I have more right leaning views than that.

by tony hopkinson

'We' did.

Whether you blame greedy bankers or greedy politicians (or in my case both) is simply philosophy.

There's no geting away from house prices inflated because of demand created by parties who were going to profit from it in one way or another.

That's not me and thee, we started off with a house, and if we have been more prudent than lenders wished us to be, we will end up with a house.

It's value is only relevant on death, sell and move in with a relative, or become an affluent homeless person.

A house's value is not $160,000 it's shelter for us, the family and the flat screen tv.

Anyone who chooses to intervene in one aspect of something as complex as an ecomony on the basis that they can predict the consequences, is either some sort of f'ing idiot, or they are going to get theirs before it all goes to rat sh1t.

Anyone who thinks money is value needs to move to Zimbabwe for a bit.

by tonythetiger

[i]A house's value is not $160,000 it's shelter[/i]

If it's an investment, it has risk. Some risks come to fruition, some don't.

If you spend your entire paycheck on lottery tickets and they're all losers, is the government supposed to bail you out?

by av .

For many years, everywhere I went in NJ, people were buying up McMansions like dime store candy. I wondered what I was doing wrong because I couldn't afford that, but always thought that one day, the day of reckoning would come for them. I didn't realize that their loss would become mine to the point of bailing them out with my tax dollars. I also didn't realize my 401k would go down because of their greed and the value of my house would also go down.

I'm a regular person that has worked for 40 years for what I have today. I worked hard for my American dream. I didn't get in on any special deals and when I bought my house 15 years ago, I had to have a down payment, proof of income and extreme scrutiny. It wasn't an easy process.

Unfortunately, government programs are going to be exploited by anyone that wants to do it. People that abused the law, especially predatory lenders, should be prosecuted. Why should I, a taxpayer that worked for many years for what I have and followed all the rules, be forced to bail these greedy-a$$ people out? I know. Because I'm going down with them if I don't.

AV

by maxwell edison

I'm not a doom and gloomer, as you well know, but I must admit that I'm very concerned about the financial well-being of our government and our economy.

We're mortgaging our future - let's pay it off.

We have a HUGE trade deficit ? let?s balance it out.

We're financing dependency on government - let's stop the lunacy.

There are TRILLIONS of dollars in private investments (401(k) accounts) just sitting there ? waiting to be pilfered by government bureaucrats to fend-off the looming financial crisis. (Don't doubt it.)

We're dependent on foreign sources of energy - let's develop and produce our own. And the [i]global warming and/or climate change[/i] nonsense is no more than the justification for others who want to stymie American energy independence. To them I say, STFU ? energy independence first, alternative sources of energy second.

I think what's going on is absolutely crazy.

In the meantime, all people hear is political rhetoric.

P.S. This IS NOT a partisan issue. It's an issue that defines the role of government. People simply will not admit that.

by dr dij

There's a whole 'nother part of government that should take the blame: the fed has drastically increased the money supply, such that your dollar is worth half of what it was worth 10 years ago, via creation of money out of thin air, or 'poof', the money fairy gives billions to the govt for spending, and to banks via overnight lending.

This caused substantial 'hidden' inflation in addition of non-consumer goods (investments) in addition to the 'official' inflation rate of consumer goods and the 'actual' rate of consumer goods which is higher than the figures the govt dinks around with and changes. (they'd have to give raises to people on entitlements - social security, welfare plus raises to fed employees if they let the official figure get too high).

This increase in money supply caused people to view real estate as 'real goods' that can't go down in value. This was of course hyped by the press, and some people who did get right flipping houses before the bust.

(famous recent example: Turkey a few years ago had massive hyperinflation caused by, you guessed it, the turkish govt printing endless streams of money to pay for programs to make themselves popular. The turkish people had a renovation boom during this time. every spare turkish dollar was spent on building additions, etc as one of the few 'real' goods that was hard to devalue in their view.

Freddie and Fannie are 'monetary abominations' - monsters created by govt that are 'too big to fail'. If that is the case they need to be broken up. Freddie and Fannie were in trouble long before the housing bust. Why: they borrow money from various sources and fund mortgages. Even if everyone was able to pay their mortgage loan, and even if they had not been moronic enuf to buy loans from banks that lent to people who had horrible credit and unverifiable incomes, or who could be seen to have to default once ARM's rate changes set in,

they still would have been in deep doo-doo. Their people funded the loans they did buy with money that cost them more than they were getting for the loans!

I still agree with you that the basic cause of this is govt meddling with the housing market, but their general meddling with the economy in general had a great part.

by maxwell edison

The whole Federal Reserve system (which is really a private enterprise), and its relationship with the federal government is a huge factor. Thanks for pointing that out.

I once heard it put this way (and very well put):

It's a game you can't win, one in which you're set-up to lose, but one you can't possibly opt out of (paraphrased).

And it crosses party lines ? like you said, the government behind the government.

Imagine that! We agree on something!

Regards....

by jackofalltech

where were these lenders when I needed a loan? You wouldn't believe the hoops I had to jump through to get a mortgage even though I could easily afford it.

by jamesrl

I've stopped working in partisan politics a few elections back.

And honestly I don't default to voting conservative. I wasn't a real big fan of the Conservative leader when he worked for the Citizens coalition.

But what are my options? The NDP would certainly raise taxes if they fulfilled half of their spending promises, and I honestly can't afford more taxes. The Liberals green shift policy with its Carbon taxes to me is very risky and not fully flushed out.

So I will do as I've always done. Vote conservative because its the best fit for me.

James

by oz_media

Exact same issues but at least we do have some choice in the matter. While I don't like everything Harper has done TO Canada, such as being to soft to US requests to jump in line, I also think that they have at least been responsible with the budget and actually CAN do what they propose without raising taxes, they have already proven that on more than one occasion as taxes were dropped, well done.

Layton will push taxes through the roof, or else do nothing and all of his promises are empty.

Campbell, that whole carbon tax issue is just screwed right up and only caters to the real freakshows who think the sky will fall tomorrow.

Thus it is not so much voting for the lesser of two evils, but we actually get to elect who we feel will live up to their promises, and which promises will actually benefit us. They aren't all opposing, radical forces though, and there is valid reason for each person to select a party without just reverting to avoiding the other guy.

I would vote for Harper simply because he has proven he can pull of what he claims and though I don't like ALL policies, they are mor efocused on the goals I would seek out myself.

by jck

Did the surgeon do the job right, or was it unpreventable? Did the surgeon do everything within their power to do their job to the best of their ability?

You gonna tell me upper management making stupid investments in an effort to profiteer and crank up their bonus packages is doing their job right?

BTW, listen to Jim Kramer sometime. That is one smart dude. He was telling everyone over a year ago...maybe two...that this was gonna happen.

I want him investing for me.

by delbertpgh

A couple of comments:

You say, "As a result of a huge increase in demand against a limited supply, home prices (and values) rose dramatically." Well, yeah, partly, but I think other factors played larger in this than an increase in unqualified poverty-pocket home buyers. The biggest reason was that more money was available, partly because of low interest rates for too long. Greenspan and team were trying to save the country from a recession by keeping rates low, and whenever you keep money flowing easy, it will go somewhere and create an asset bubble. Sometimes it's in stocks, sometimes commercial construction, sometimes world wide fiber optic networks; this time it was homes. It used to be factories and inventory, back when we were the workshop for the world.
Money was available because financial people wanted to receive fees for making loans, and investors had plenty of savings to use to buy bonds, and interest rates were low, meaning that if you didn't have enough to swing a profitable deal then you could afford to borrow more. There is a law of nature in finance, which is, if people want to loan money and people want to borrow it, then the banker in the middle will work his tail off to cut the deal, provided there is no risk personally attached for the banker and his bank. In fact, in just about every bank, there are special divisions that examine the deals that its officers make, to verify they aren't breaking contracts or committing crimes or exposing the bank to crazy risk. Because, if you don't watch them closely, deal brokers will work strictly for the sake of their commission and screw the bank. And if banks can lay the risk off on somebody else, they see no reason to be responsible to the greater society, either. That's why we have banking laws. The greediest and least responsible will make the most money, and while the party lasts, the industry will follow the guys getting rich. This is another law of nature; it is human nature.
Later you say, "Whatever happened to the days of having to verify one's income and show the ability to repay a loan before one is issued? I guess that was before the government - in its infinite wisdom (dripping with sarcasm) - decided it would be politically expedient to make home ownership available to those who really cannot afford it." Well, having to verify eligibility was primarily due to laws that regulated banking, and not the natural state of bankers. If you didn't have these guys pinned down by laws, and acceptable banking behavior defined by law and reinforced by the jailer, finance would be like Dodge City and we'd all be a lot poorer.
I'd agree that it was a bad idea to encourage home ownership by slacking the risk management standards of the bond agencies. It's like trying to run a housing program without the courage to raise the money to finance it (through taxes.) It was the illusion a government program could be free. The rationale, by the way, was that poor people who owned homes tended to behave more responsibly, were more careful about their money, were more proud of what they had made for themselves, and would become better citizens. Not a bad story to pin a program on. Congress should have paid for it.
However, a whole lot more risky behavior was going on in finance than just a few million poor people getting into homes. Across the industry, bankers were figuring out how to isolate themselves from risk, often by just putting the risk on a different balance sheet; and corrupting the bond rating agencies to call any crap they put out an AAA+-rated collateral pool; and spinning more and more lever deals. Great damage was done to real estate by second mortgages and refinance deals, turning a lot of accumulated family wealth into ready cash and variable-rate long term debt.
We should have had good regulation of the industry. It would have clamped down on a lot of the activity that made the finance industry so big and profitable, and that's why we didn't do it. Financiers would say government was destroying business in a misguided effort to control what the industry itself could take care of. That kind of talk has carried the day in Washington for a few decades, and it has led us to a poor balance of initiative versus law.

by jdclyde

It hasn't even been about her record, it has been all personal attacks on her and her family.

She actually has executive experience, something Obama has nothing of.

She comes from a small town, something Obama knows nothing of.

The more personal and shrill the attacks get, the more people will see how the extreme liberals are running scared of her. If Libs HATE her so much, she MUST be a good pick. B-)

Next thing you know, someone will accuse her of being a bad mom, while of course giving a free pass to Obama who was gone as much, being a bad dad. [i](right John?)[/i]

That is ok. Whacko attacks like that will only make her a stronger candidate, as it takes away time that REAL issues with her could be brought up, and intelligent people will see the treatment and not want anything to do with it.

By the by, I have been googling "flurg" but coming up empty! :D
http://thecaucus.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/09/14/fey-palin-character-debuts

by jck

But the stockholders that don't care are the upper management who got $10Ms in compensation while running these firms into the ground with careless business in the effort to "maximize profits".

Doing bad business should be punishable, and those running business and setting policy should be punished for bad business just like they are rewarded for running a good business.

There should be a yin to the yang.

by cactus pete

You seem to be lamenting government meddling in citizens' lives by citing an issue created basically by government deregulation of an industry. That alone would be enough to confuse me, but as the government gave big business more leash (with which to hang itself) and then they did... You then say it wasn't really them, it was the government.

Am I right, or misreading it somehow?

by jck

[i]It hasn't even been about her record, it has been all personal attacks on her and her family.[/i]

Really? From what I remember...she said she stopped those bridges from being built.

In actuality, good ole Sara Palin kept that money she could have given back to the American taxpayers who coughed it up in the first place for projects she deemed as "bad".

But instead, she has kept it. Why? Cause, she's gonna pork barrel spend and build the one bridge...that just happens to be near her home.

She's sounding more like a senator and non-conservative than ever.

[i]She actually has executive experience, something Obama has nothing of.[/i]

Obama ran both the Harvard Law Review as the senior editor. Maybe it's not government, but it is executive experience of one of the most prestigious law papers in the country.

[i]She comes from a small town, something Obama knows nothing of.[/i]

Are you kidding? Obama lived in a small city in Hawaii. Get your facts right. And Sarah Palin lives just a short distance from Anchorage. Do you think she stayed exclusively in Wasilla?

[i]The more personal and shrill the attacks get, the more people will see how the extreme liberals are running scared of her. If Libs HATE her so much, she MUST be a good pick. [/i]

You call them shrill just because they are against the person you want to see defeat a person you claim to know so much about, but really don't.

I suggest you go read Obama's website, and learn about his whole history rather than what the McCain spin machine tells you.

[i]Next thing you know, someone will accuse her of being a bad mom, while of course giving a free pass to Obama who was gone as much, being a bad dad. (right John?)[/i]

Again, you are distorting things to fit your view, [b]JEFF[/b].

I will state it for you again, since I guess your head is too thick for entire sentences to get into:

Sarah Palin was a stay at home mother, with a husband who worked away from home on the north slope. That is all documented. She was a "hockey mom"...he was a roughneck/supervisor for BP.

At the time she chose to be mayor of Wasilla, she was still able to be in close proximity of her children to take care of them and spend time with them, since her husband was away and could not.

When she decided to run for governor of Alaska, she was taking on a job which:

a) meant she would be constantly away from her home
b) would often be out of town (being the capital is in Juneau and she lives outside of Anchorage...some 800 miles away)
c) would sometimes have to travel out of state and even out of country.

Now, you tell me, jd.

How much of a parent would you be to your children if you took a job in Cincinnati while your spouse was working in Minneapolis and one of you was not there to attend to the upbringing, tending to, and needs of your children?

Was it a good part on her or her husband's part? No.

Why don't I pick at him? Because he is not in the election, and she is the one who herself along with her party claims to be so family-oriented and family values.

Hence, I call bull$hit on her for saying one thing and doing another. She was not in dire need to earn more for her family. She chose to climb the political ladder, at the expense of spending as much time taking care of and attending to her children.

Therefore, she is not as family values as she claims. And, she was a bad mother for making a decision that (as a "family values" candidate) meant she chose a career move over that of spending as much time raising her children as possible.

She chose job over family. Good political move. Bad parenting.

[i]That is ok. Whacko attacks like that will only make her a stronger candidate, as it takes away time that REAL issues with her could be brought up, and intelligent people will see the treatment and not want anything to do with it.[/i]

Intelligent people will see she sneaks just like other politicians. She's not the normal American mom.

The normal American mom wouldn't compromise most of their at-home time with their family for a move up the political ladder when their spouse is already working away from the home.

Normal American mothers (and fathers) want someone (they or their wife) to be home with their children to tend to them if it's financially possible.

[i]By the by, I have been googling "flurg" but coming up empty! [/i]

I have no idea what a flurg is either.

And again...while Barack Obama was in Springfield and Washington DC, his wife stayed in the area of their home.

Hence, the Obamas kept one of them near their home base to deal as a parent. The Palins did not.

Or do you disagree?

by delbertpgh

I think that "FLIRG" (or FLURG or FLERG) is probably a made-up acronym. My guess is it didn't exist before the Saturday Night Live writers worked up the skit.

However, if it really does stand for something, it's probably "the first lady is really gay," referring to the oft-repeated (National Enquirer) rumor that Hillary munches a rug in her spare time.

Latest rumor is that her traveling assistant, a former Vogue model of Arab descent, is the object of her attention.

by jck

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were not government "controlled" or "owned" when this all happened.

They operated as government-backed mortgage financiers. But, they were not taken over by the government until just recently.

However, I seem to never get clear to most of you what I want...and you, Max (as well as JD and others) seem to think in black and white and assume that I am the same way.

The government [b]should[/b] be in oversight. That is government's function. That is why they make law, enact law, judge law, etc.

Should they be in private industry? no.

Should they be into bailing out private industry? No

However, government should enact law/rule/regulation that sets the parameters in which business operates.

This whole thing is an example of what Teddy Roosevelt campaigned against so hard. That capitalism operating within reasonable and fair terms is a great thing.

But, the unrestrained capitalism that has been allowed to go on in this country since before Bush or Clinton has now turned our country into a financial cesspool.

Why? Because of two distinct, clear things:

1) Politicians for whatever reason write the law/rule/regulation too lightly since the late 70s and early 80s and allowed loopholes for shady/unscrupulous business to occur.

2) Business, in its rampant desire to chase the get-rich-quick dream (another thing Teddy Roosevelt warned would ruin a country) has taken all of the shortcuts available through most every loophole...rather than running a fair, legitimate, untainted business model.

Hence...sure...government made stupid moves by not making clear groundrules for those they regulate.

However, it does not make it any less fine for a business to take shortcuts, do shady deals, practice negligence, or trick/fool people in the public (especially their investors) with business shenanigans and folly.

It is ruining this country, and no one seems to understand that if all parties are not responsible and do not work together for a fair, equitable, healthy system...we're gonna end up like friggin Mexico.

And to be honest, I don't want to live in Mexico. Do you?

by jck

[i]jck can't possibly defend this. . . . .
.....government meddling into private lives. Your desired plan has failed - try to defend it![/i]

Are you off your meds again? :^0

by jck

wasn't a joke until the 80s, when ye olde Congress decide...since they couldn't take funds out of SSA to spend...they could use it as collateral to write IOUs against.

Funny...I thought you had to pay IOUs back.

That's why our retirement is screwed...not because the plan was bad, but because someone found the loophole to abuse it.

Kinda like...shady business men.

Oh wait...isn't that what we're electing to Congress usually?