Question Locked

Mp3 to Cda ... how to eliminate blank between two tracks

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I use Nero version 6 (OS : XP-pro SP2) to convert mp3 to cda. Generally, it's quite ok. However, some mp3 pieces in cda form, contains vast blank, e.g., say the mp3 number is 6 minutes, and in cda form it plays full for six minutes and then runs blank for several minutes, before the next track starts.

How to correct these gaps during the burn?

I did search for my issue, but all I came up with was about "two seconds gap" between numbers. I understand Nero can eliminate this small gap.
My burnt CDA has several minutes of gap (and not the normal two seconds). This doesn't happen always. So, wondering if it has got to do something with the mp3 quality of particular pieces?

Thanks,

9 replies

by older mycroft

Then it's not inherent in the Audio Track.

MP3s are constant - the digital data cannot change from one play to the next. Have you checked yet that there wasn't a long silence at the end of the MP3 BEFORE you converted it to CDA ?

If there [b]IS[/b] a long pause at the end, you can load the MP3 track into Audacity then trim the silence off the end of the track, before saving it back to your hard disk as another MP3.

If that is not the case, then it is more likely you have a fault in your CD player.

by abanerji

Thanks for the suggestion to edit the original. I have never edited a sound track, but well, there's always a first time.

I am still wondering ... why does the "gap" in the mp3 does not "play blank" when I am running the mp3? The mp3 just plays upto its
full length of six minutes (as shown by WMP), without any silence at the end.

I have played the CD in CD-player (new Bose system) and the PC ... and it behaves the same. So, I had ruled out fault with the player.

by older mycroft

At the expense of another CD, you [i]could[/i] try burning the same tracks again but altering the sequence - placing this questionable track in a different position in the playlist.

That way you can check if the 'silence' is attributed to a particular track OR to whichever track sits at that position on a CDA-burned CD.

If the silence happens with a different track, then the problem is down to NERO.

[i]I must be honest and say I don't have much call to record anything to a CDA format - I've recorded an audio CD about three times in as many years.[/i]

by abanerji

If it was so, I would not have bothered. As mentioned in my original post, "some mp3 pieces" are acting funny when converted to CDA.

In fact, as suggested by you, I did try positioning the troublesome mp3s in different sequence ... still same. That's why, I was wondering about the mp3 quality of those pieces.

Is it possible that some silence towards the end of the mp3 is getting expanded during burn. Sorry, if this sounds silly ... I have little knowledge about the technicalities of sound files.

by older mycroft

In other words, [b]HOW[/b] the MP3s were originated, there is always the possibility of a couple of faults:

#1 The tracks in question have been downloaded from an online site and the downloads were faulty - how this would affect a CDA track I don't honestly know because downloads are always reported as faulty and usually deleted in preference for a faultless download.

#2 The tracks have been ripped by a program that didn't stop recording at the end of the track - it is possible to record to MP3 manually, whereby the recording won't stop until halted by the user doing the recording.

When an MP3 track is played with a utility such as GOMPlayer, or RealPlayer, or VLAN, or WinAMP, or Windows Media Player, or whatever... there is a capability built into the player, that when the last digital byte of music data is reached (playing volume falls below a preset decibel level), the Player automatically sequences forward to the next track in the playlist. The decibel level that prompts this function is built into the metadata of the MP3 file itself, and has long been a problem with MP3 recordings of passages of classical music which contain long periods of little or no volume within the musical track - in these cases the db level is set to almost nothing so that the 'playing' will continue, without jumping on to the next track.

This however will not happen with an AUDIO CD unless the track image has finished.

So - I again suggest you download and install Audacity:

http://audacity.sourceforge.net/download/

Load one of your problem tracks into Audacity and scroll to the end of the track. You'll be able to see if the music ends long before the track actually ends. If this is the case, you can chop the silent passage of the track, saving the trimmed version back to hard drive as an alternate MP3. :)

by abanerji

... for the superb information. I see the light, and will try your advice.

Thanks again.

by older mycroft

I only ask this because I don't often get the chance to deal with a question that I have a wealth of information about.

In this particular case I'd be happy to know that my rambling had proved to be helpful. :)

by abanerji

I opened the troublesome mp3s in audacity. Unfortunately, blank space not seen.

I think I will live with these little irritations of digital music conversion.

Thank you, once again ... at least, I learnt some technical stuff.

This discussion is closed to new replies.