Discussion Locked

Municipal WiMax and the USA

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Do you think it is dead in the US? It seems like the only thing close to it is if you are lucky enough to live near the Googleplex in California. It is alive and well in Asia I heard. Just the other day, my friend in Taiwan was marveling at the convenience of the city wide WiFi there.

6 replies

by dr dij

Wimax is an emerging standard that is not even yet ratified tho vendors have non-standard prelim prods.

WiFi is what you're talking about.

Cities are re-thinking these because they:
1) realise they take twice as many transceivers as they thought
2) for this and other reasons it costs more
3) private companies that wanted to do for free are now backing out for above reasons and:
4) the city itself needs to commit to use the service yet in many places municipal users do NOT use it giving it even less reason to exist.
5) reception is poor inside houses (for some of above reasons)
6) as shows in socialist countries, anything done by govt is overused if free, service is cruddy if done by govt, and why should taxpayers pay for it if they are not using it if it IS subsidized instead of being provided by companies.

when electricity first came to cities, they thought they could build several very tall towers and light up the entire city very cheaply. they were wrong. people needed electricity wired to their houses and street lamps spread out.

by wesley.chin

I was skeptical when the person kept referring to it as Wimax, but the person was insistent and said that was what he had heard. That is why I referred to it as WiFi.

As Sprint-Nextel and other mobile carriers have abandoned attempts, to me it seems like it will be something similar to the supposed inclusion of WinFS in Vista initially. What is your opinion on when it might emerge?

by dr dij

phones need to be able to access both voice and data between the cell network and 'hotspots'. as costs come down I think spots will charge less and less for 'hotspots' but instead use to attract customers.

the cell phone ocmpanies actually like hot spots w/ voice because it reduces use of the cell network portion.

wimax will slowly replace existing wi-fi as it matures due to higher speeds (close) and longer distance (at least out in the boonies under ideal conditions).

it will really take off soon as suburban / rural companies can offer it both as a broadband connection and with services such as voice, tv, data / internet. if they can create encrypted mesh repeater networks for the remote boonies will take off even more.

handsets need to support both types of networks seamlessly and carriers need to reduce roaming so using a competing carrier's network is just 'regular charges' if their signal is stronger and /or not available. (and pay the other network so they have an incentive to allow other companies traffic).

Cities will allow companies to integrate transceivers on infrastructure such as light poles, etc, and prices will come down for these as they standardize, obviating the need for the city to subsidize them.

Ok, so much of that is dreamy idealism but I can hope?

by michael kassner

This can be a point of confusion and as already mentioned WiMax is still in the development stage, especially in the US.

I think you are referring to city-wide Wi-Fi rollouts, which are running into some problems. It appears that the network design, financial planning, as well as ultimate responsibility was not clearly thought out in many cases.

I am fortunate to live in one location where the program is flourishing and is running efficiently. I even wrote a blog about how the network helped during the bridge collapse here.

http://blogs.techrepublic.com.com/wireless/?p=121

This next link is to an article that talks about the health of that same city-wide Wi-Fi network.

http://wifinetnews.com/archives/008097.html

by wesley.chin

That kind of brins to mind how the govt. is freeing up some spectrum with the transition to digital TV. Right the freed up spectrum is planned for emergency personnel. Perhaps some of it could be used for a nationwide WiFi (if it all possible)?

by michael kassner

The sale of the 700MHz frequency block is a huge deal and several big name companies are investing in the bidding process. It appears that the main use will be in WiMax types of technology (Internet and cell phone access) as 700 MHz is the lowest frequency yet being considered for WiMax and will have a larger coverage area and more penetration ability for a given amount of RF output power.

http://www.computerworld.com/action/article.do?command=viewArticleBasic&articleId=9053580&source=rss_topic15

This discussion is closed to new replies.