Discussion Locked

My car just ruined its head gasket, is it worth trying to repair?

0 helpful
41 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

So I come to a stop on the highway after setting off this morning, and smoke starts coming out of my hood on the left hand side. I stick in in neutral and rev the engine, more smoke comes out. CRAP.... So I drive it to work anyways, about a 15 KM trip.
Pop the hood, and check and sure enough, the rad overflow is bone dry, I unscrew the rad, and its about half full (Hard to tell with a flashlight). Everything was full when I left (I check every day)

So chances are, the head gasket is gone.

The car is a 96 Chev Lumina car with the 3.1 engine, 180,000km on the engine. Its worth (when working) about 100 dollars for the charity receipt I'd get for donating it to a scrap yard. But its worth about 4k to the insurance company (I tried my hardest but no one would rear-end me on the way here).
A car of equal crap would cost about 4-5k dollars, and could have the exact same problem. A good car would be closer to 7-10k.

So, should I try and get this thing repaired? Or scrap it, take the financial hit and get another car?

41 replies

by charliespencer

You don't say how many miles are on it. You don't know what else cracked, warped, or blew when the gasket went. It's even possible the blown gasket was the result of something else going wrong. If you fix it, you'll spend the rest of the time you own it wondering what's going to go next.

by slayer_

So not much.
I suspect the gasket has been ruined for awhile, it has had a very slow leak, about a half a litre of anti freeze every 600km. But the oil looks perfect still (last I checked a week ago) so its not dumping enough in to wash the pistons. Well now it probably is.
But I could probably by a second car the same, and swap engines if needed, not sure what the labour costs would be then.

What is the costs of a head gasket change? (assuming that was all that went wrong with it)

by darryl~

You could have other issues...such as a warped/cracked head....it's 15 years old....time for things to start going wrong....I think I'd be looking to update it.

by slayer_

It just hurts to spend money.... I don't have much to spend to begin with...

by charliespencer

as parting with the faithful '94 Sentra (263,000 miles) back in December, especially its 33+ mpg (14 kpl).

by slayer_

Basically, it has a wire screen in the hose half way down... Is it possible to drain a fuel tank?

by darryl~

I had an Olds with a full tank I scrapped a couple years ago.....I drilled a hole in the bottom of the tank & drained it into a couple 5 gallon jugs.

by slayer_

It was just because it snowed all weekend that I am driving it for one more week.

I probably would have then thought the storage time had killed it.

by jamesrl

If the engine is ok after the head gasket went, and its possible, then it might be worth saving, but what will it cost to find out.

I recently faced a similar dilemma. My transmission was dying on a 2002 Mazda MPV. I loved the van and the way it handles. But the autotrans was slipping, and I knew it would just be a matter of time. And rust was eating it away as well, despite 1200$ worth of body work 18 months ago.

I decided that 3000$ on a rebuilt tranny wasn't a good investment. I bought a 2007 used van for $10K. The body is near perfect with no rust at all.

If the gasket went and the engine is ok, it could be $800 or so to fix. But as others have pointed out, there might be another issue down the road. My Intrepid was like that, one problem after another.

The GM 3.1/3.4 l engine is known for the head gasket issue.

by slayer_

To just take the head off myself and check it. As I drove it here, the engine sounded fine, no loss of power or anything, just lots of steam/smoke.
I haven't checked the oil yet, I will in an hour on my lunch break.

by darryl~

I had the luxury of my friend's garage with a hoist, air tools and other equipment.

I wouldn't use an electirc/cordless drill because of the chance of a spark from the motor....if you're really concerned, get a couple self tapping screws (a large one & a small one)...using just a normal screwdriver make a pilot hole with the small screw then make the hole larger with the other screw.

Or....if you can get under the car and have lots of room to reach around under there....take the fuel tank filler neck off & then it can be siphoned more easily.

by slayer_

Looks like I'm ok, the oil is still perfect even though it drank about a gallon of anti freeze on the way here. It appears to be spraying out of the top of the engine. And I mean spraying, its coming out all around the thing, not just in one spot, and its misting and spraying.

Probably still an expensive repair.

I went shopping briefly at lunch, except for everyone flogging off Chev Aveos, no good deals. Everything is over $8k.

by charliespencer

In that case, I've changed my mind. You may be able to do this yourself; Google it and talk to the guys at your auto parts store. If you can, it will be considerably cheaper than paying to have it done, cheap enough to be worth trying and not regretting if it doesn't work.

I'd stop driving it in the meantime.

by slayer_

The best estimate I heard was $2500 for the repair, and one even said, find a river that's about to flood and park it there.
So I gotta replace it.

by jamesrl

Make it to a Crappy Tire (Canadian Tire for our non-Canuck friends), they have the premixed coolant with water and coolant that you can pour straight in.

by slayer_

And more environmentally friendly :p
It's above 0C now, should be no threat of freezing.

The drive to work was pretty funny, some really long lights left me in a cloud of steam with people staring at me.

A cop wouldn't pull me over for that would they? If they saw me producing such a large amount of steam at a light?

by jamesrl

From a safety perspective, they'd want to be sure it was just steam.

Twice I've driven down the highway and seen something coming from the engine bay, and in both cases, a closer inspection (driving beside them) showed the occasional flame. I called 911 in both cases, and signalled the driver to pull over.

by charliespencer

for those of us still on the English system, and about $6300 US. My parents have had pretty good luck with a couple of Tauruses (Taurusi?). I'd at least give it a test drive.

Can you get Carfax reports on that side of the border? It's an auto history report. If not, get a garage to inspect it first, and ask the owner to knock the cost of that service off the final price. (This applies to any auto purchase from an individual, and even some dealers if you don't have previous experience with them.)

by slayer_

My father is going to go check the car out for me tomorrow. I am stuck in meetings all day and can't go, so I am borrowing my fathers car.

by jamesrl

As well as a Canadian equivalent.

I used Carfax once on a private deal that was too cheap to be true.

Turned out it was a US vehicle that had been written off from flood damage, and brought into Canada, where they had swapped out the speedo at a wreckers yard. It drove ok, but I wasn't going to take a chance.

I would recommend both - the carfax will verify accident history, mileage, the number of owners etc. But it won't tell you if the car has been routinely maintained, has leaks, etc.

Many dealers here will offer carfax or the eqivalent free, I just bought a used van and got it included.

by jamesrl

I've driven that model and my Mazda MPV had that engine (but not that transmission), the 24V Duratec.

So its no secret that Taurus transmissions weren't the best, but the reliability went up in the later model years.

The engine has enough power to move that around fine, big improvement over the Lumina there. I did have some issues with the wires, with point on plugs they weren't cheap to replace, either. Other than that it was pretty solid.

Of course you want to take a good close look. See if they will let you have a mechanic check it out for you - it may cost a $100 but could save you big bucks.

by nicknielsen

2006 was the last model year for the original Taurus, and the SEL with the 24V was the luxury performance package. The user ratings I can find for that year and model are almost all four-star or higher. You may sacrifice some in fuel economy if you have a heavy foot.

You could do much worse.

by thechas

All you need to do is disconnect the fuel line near the engine, attach a hose, and with the help of an assistant run the fuel pump and fill gas cans until the tank is empty.

Keep in mind that the in-tank pump runs at a pretty good flow rate and pressure.

Unless you need to bypass a safety switch, all the assistant needs to do is turn the key to the On position but not start.

Chas

by slayer_

Whats worse than a Lumina... A Toyota yaris maybe?

Anyways, it for some reason stopped leaking for the ride home, and it refused to start leaking again right till the very end.
After we finished voting, I got back in the car (This time, with my father, who is a mechanic) and raced it around Selkirk once, a couple quick jumps to 140kph and back down, a couple high rev shifts, nothing, was running fine.
Got back to the house, I backed itt into place, and my father says to me, I am a bit too far over to the right and am on the grass, so I pull forward to re-adjust, and as I hit the brakes to shift back to reverse, a puff of steam flowed out from under the hood and it started leaking again. Like a child holding its pee. it just couldn't hold on any longer.

by ansugisalas

I don't know squat about mechanics but in another device I'd look at the o-rings or washers or whatever... anything that makes seals tight. If a wall is ruptured it usually stays ruptured, but seal can be on-and-off tight if the washer is decaying.
Of course it could be a pressure fluctuation thing too, but whatever could be causing that?

by slayer_

We got to see it before they cleaned it up, and it was fairly clean already. Non smoker, almost no rust at all (tiny bit on the bottom of the door). The owner lives in Thompson, so it is primarily highway driven.
Engine sound and ran perfect, transmission seemed perfect and smooth, no delays between gears.
Has full service records (haven't look at it yet) and has all the original documents, manuals, etc.
I managed to talk him down to 5,500, then after they add their fees its back up to 5900, and after taxes it was about 6,600.

by jamesrl

When my MPV went in, I got scrap value $200. It was still running, but I knew that the tranny woudln't last a month.

by charliespencer

Although I donated it and got $450 tax credit. It didn't do me any good; I still didn't have enough deductions to make it worth itemizing and not take the standard deductible. Still, donating it lets me convince myself that someone bought it at auction for spare parts, and that the faithful steed didn't go to the dog food and glue factories.

by jamesrl

The van I wanted, with the factory tow package, was 60 miles away. There is no direction public transportation from here to there. So trading it in was about my only option.

As I mentioned in another post, I traded it with steel rims and winter tires on it, then got $225 for the alloy rims and all season tires, so I actually got more for the tires than the van - a little ironic.

This discussion is closed to new replies.