Discussion Locked

My CD-ROM Drive is Eating My Children!

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Well, maybe it's not that bad, but I just upgraded my PC from a 440BX, Slot 1 platform to an AMD Athlon 850 supported by a Gigabyte GA-7ZX (Rev 5), and now my Mitsumi 40x CD-ROM drive is misbehaving.

The bahaviour is intermittant, depending on the CD inserted, and it does not affect home-burned CD's. It will spin up the CD, and during that time I can browse the CD, run apps off of it, etc., but then it makes a whining noise like the read head is jumping from one end of the CD to the other, the CD, spins down, spins back up, makes the read head noise again, spins down, ad nauseum.

CD's affected include the Drivers CD that came with the mainboard, Quake 3 Arena, and WordPerfect 2000. No Microsoft wares are affected (like Win98, Office 2000, Visio).

The worst part is, I've already tried another CD-ROM Drive, I've reformatted the HDD and reloaded the OS, I've updated the BIOS, I've downloaded and installed the latest Via 4-in-1 drivers, tried multiple read-ahead and speed optimization settings in the Windows system setup, I actually located and downloaded drivers for the drive and installed those, I've memorized the entire BIOS, and I've contacted the vendors(mainboard and CD-ROM drive, both say it's the other's fault)responsible for this crap.

Any suggestions?

19 replies

by stillatit

These are longshots.

1. Check the BIOS under power management. There may be some stupid setting attempting to save power by shutting down after some small time period.

2. While you are looking at the BIOS, check for any strange IDE settings onwhichever controller you are running the CD on.

3. Are you slaving the CD on the same cable as your hard disk, or is it on a separate controller? Whichever it is, try the other.

4. If your new board is ATA-66 or more, you may need the new low-noise cables. In any case, I would try replacing the cable.

5. If you copy a CD that causes this behavior, does the copy also cause the behavior? (If not, it is a bizzare workaround.)

6. You have probably done this, but if not, clean the lens.
Good luck.

by redshift

Thanks for the suggesions, the best of which is the workaround - wouldn't it suck to have to copy new CD's before they work?

Anyhow, the BIOS isn't all that I wish it was, so the cornucopia of settings that I grew used to with my last mainboard.
I tried the enhanced IDE cable, and it told me that it couldn't find the KRNL32 on Windows boot! Yikes, so I went back to the standard IDE cable, and it was fine.

by redshift

Additional info and stuff I've tried:

The CD in the master on the 2ndary IDE with a Zip100 as the slave, but I've removed the Zip 100 from the chain, and even swapped the CD-ROM/zip master/slave settings to no avail.

I've set up the CD-ROM drive as a slave to my Primary Master HDD.

I've killed the protected mode drivers and added real-mode drivers to the config.sys, and mscdex'd it in the autoexec.bat. (As a side bar, System applett never reports that there is a real mode driver, hmmmm . . .)

I've toggled the DMA mode on and off - no difference.

I cleaned the lense (a good suggestion, but it still didn't work), checked all cable connections, and verified all of my jumpers.

What did I miss?

by dcraun

I had nothing but problems with a Mitsumi CD-Drive. Kept trying new decivce drivers, nothing helped. Ended up getting a Sony CD-Drive, been happy ever since.

by redshift

I don't want to spend any more money, I had to lie to the wife about how much I paid to begin with!

by shmaltz

As I understand from you question, you dont have the problem with all the CD's only with some of them. Meaning the problem is the media not the Drive.
Sounds like the CD's you are having problems with are either:
1. Scracthed, or:
2. Dirty, or:
3. The top of the CD is scracthed.
If its dirty wipe it clean if its scratched then:
1. If the bottom (the side where the drive reads from) is scratched then try copying the files on the local Hard Drive then write it onto a new CD, or spread it over a few Zip disks.
2. If the top is scratched the there is no way that the drive should be able to read the data on the spot where its scratched, since the top (the printed part of the CD) contains the burned tracks of the CD's data.

by paul d. masley

First, Set the CD up as master on your secondary IDE port. Do not put it as a slave on your primary IDE. This CD is more than likely a MODE 2, maybe a MODE 3 Drive or a 33. The board that you bought probally has a 133 meg front bus speed. This is your bottleneck. The CD cannot handle the excessive speed of the bus. You did not say what type of harddrive you were using. This board requires an ATA drive of 66 or better.

Now, go to the bios, hardrive set up, and look through IDE Drive settings. Disable the slave on the primary and then go to the secondary master port settings. If you see a mode two, three or 33 set it as such. Then disable the slave on the secondary. By the way the ATA 66/100 cables will not work on this drive.Too much input/output again. Also, make sure that the IRQ setting for the primary and secondary are on 14 and 15. This should get the Mitsumi running at its actual speed of about 26X.

Good Luck!

Paul.

by redshift

I'm starting to think that this has to do with the chipset, I have had this problem with other PC's and the VIA chipset, whether upgraded or factory fresh.

by big ray

First off rule out windows. boot using a CD supported DOS boot disk. try to read the CD's. If they do not misbehave under DOS then you are looking at a problem with Windows.

Second, hold down the shift key when inserting the CD's. This keeps windows from starting the autorun feature. After the CD spins up and down release the shift key and see if it starts making the noises. If it doesn't make the noise then right click on the drive in My Computer and select open. run the exe and see if it causes problems. If it doesn't then there is a problem with the autorun feature on those CD's. Go into device manager and under the CD-ROM properties and uncheck "auto-run notification."

To be honest I don't believe it is a chipset problem. The chipset couldn't care what the manufacturer is. If it was the chipset, it would affect all the CD's.

by redshift

I managed to do a clean install of Win98 using this CD-ROM from a DOS prompt, and I had checked out the misbehaving CD's while at the prompt also.

I had also considered the autorun issues, tried disabling that, but it doesn't help either - I can be exploring the CD in the Windows Explorer (or interacting with it any other way), and get similar results.

Thanks for the suggestion, though!

by sparky4

Some 20,000 km long shots:

1. try a replacement older style IDE cable for the cdrom drive.

2. Try installing an IDE controlelr card and see if you have the same problem.

3. You mentioned quite a system upgrade. Did you replace the power supply? What's the wattage, and how many devices is it supporting? Is the fan on it turning properly? if possible try a higher wattage supply. After all, your new CPU/mainboard take a lot more power then the older ones.

4.If you can, take the mohterbard back and get another of the same model, and test it.

by redshift

Good suggestions, my PS is 350 watts, and is in tip-top shape (I just replaced the fan last month, the old one had gone south after just about a year). I didn't replace the mainboard, but I did find the problem, so read on.

by paul d. masley

Creative has an ATA 33. I have one and my bios reads it as that. I have not seen an ATA 66.Due to past problems that I have had with the VIA chipset, I will not allow one in my office. I may pay more for the Intel chip, but Windows recogizes it immediately and I do not have to worry about keeping track of another CD just to load drivers so that the video and sound coards do not fight with each other.

The worst possible senario is mixing an AMD processor with the Via. Talking about a can of worms. No thanks!

by m1wheeler

in my opinion sir i would just give up on the mitsumi or try it in another machine, if it was on your original platform and worked fine than it is apparent there is a conflict with the new setup. you can get another drive from any where it seems like so try another of a different brand and see if it works if not take it back, im sure it is just the cd drive have some incompatabiltiy with the amd chipset, motherboard, or processor. good luck

by redshift

One of the users above, dcraun@lightspan.com had given the same answer, and I knuckled under and bought a new Affrey 50x UDMA 33, installed it, and horror of horrors, it worked just fine. I contacted the fellow to let him know that I had rejected his perfectly good answer and wanted him to post a new answer so that I could give him his points. However, he says that he has enough points (400 is a lot, though, dude!), so I'm awarding them to you.

This discussion is closed to new replies.