Discussion Locked

Netware and Windows 2000 Pros and Cons

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Does anyone have a specific list of pros and cons between Windows 2000 and Netware 5.0+?

My management team is looking into replacing Netware with Win2000 even though it works very well for us. They are worried that they won't be around much longer. I am looking for benefits and problems between both systems for utilizing either one in the workplace.

Thank you

8 replies

by tbradley

( Omitting several thousand pages of pro's and con's ), the fact is if Novell works well for you, you're comfortable with it, and don't have a pressing need to convert to W2k, then by all means stick with Novell. Security is better, File sharing is better, and the Print Services are the best.

If there is a pressing need for a Win2000 server, ie a specific application that Must run on W2K, then investigate purchasing NDS for NT. It allows a seamless integration, and fills in those security gaps that Microsoft has been promising to fix for years.

Novell will still be around for years to come. The support base for it's product is too widespread for it to die, and it's estimated that world wide, there are still several thousand of fileservers still happily running Novell 2.12.

I'd be more worried about Microsoft. They haven't even begun to roll out W2k the way they did NT4.0, and talk is in the works of a replacement.

by drdon

Short of markerting hype, you need to look at the businees need of your company. Novell will be around for years to come. Their OS still represents about 50% of the installed based. MS has gained on them recently but Novell is still around. Do you have NT already in the mix as application servers? Consider the costs for software that runs on netware but won't on 2000. Consider the hardware requirements. How many users and how many sites are considerations, as well as communication costs and requirements.

A good consultant can evaluate your current setup and make appropriate recommendations.

by estebandelatorre

Get the best form both platforms!
Use w2k prof. as client software
Use it's benefits of remote control, RIS, Image HD and new isuues of w2000.
Setup a simple instalation of W2K server (128MB + 4 GB HD) only for setting up roaming profiles, and centralized config policies.
Use NW as your file & printer system. Nobody does it better than Netware.

Remember this: IN ORDER TO GET THE BEST OF WINDOWS 2000, THE WORKSTATIONS SHOULD BE W2000 FIRST!!!!.

If you have branches, allways do a lab. W2000 replication services are not so good as NW, which has more than 10 years of development.

by webman

I appreciate all of the answers I have gotten on my question. Still to date though, no one has responded to the Pros/Cons list between both operating systems - which is what I have requested since the posting. I have seen such lists before on ZDNET, CNET, and in a variety of computing magazines. I am trying to incorporate the list into a complete project information proposal.

Thanks.
WebMan

This discussion is closed to new replies.