Discussion Locked

Networking

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am a networking student, and I would like to know of the different advantages of using a Switch vs a Hub to connect a small 100baseT network, in an accounts department to accomodate 16 workstations?

What could be a couple of options to implement this network, using the Switch?

5 replies

by shiny_topadm

Hi, an easy way to visualize the differences between hubs and switches (simplified) is that hubs "share" the bandwidth among the active ports (so your individual throughput is a fraction of the network's bandwidth) but switches can deliver the full bandwidth to each device (in turn). Hubs don't usually have much in the way of "traffic" management and can get loaded down with a heavy volume of data. Since switches are generally more expensive than hubs, the exact network applications structuredetermines which to use. So, a small network (like your example) that is just sharing printers and files might work just as well with a hub. If applications are run from the server, or large graphics files are involved, or internal video-conferencing, etc. are used...the switch would be a "better" choice (as well as more expensive). Every manufacturer has their own features, etc. which tend to make the choices a little less clear, too!

by ftormen

I intend to agree with wrogers answer and wanted to add that, taking the size of your network, it is almost unlikely that you will be engaged into a high volume of traffic on your network. Therefore, I have a srong recommendation that a hub would beyour best choice in this situation because you are also required to make your network cost effective as an administrator. Depending on the type of hub which you decide to purchase, keep in mind that some hubs are more faster and efficient than others.
Goodluck.

by jackieb

One other thing you may want to consider, is providing a solution that involves an autosensing 10/100 mbit hub rather than sticking to a purely 100mbit solution. This would enable you to use a printer with a 10mbit connection without having to get other hardware. Most printers dont need more than 10mbit to work fine. And you can plug in your 100mbit devices to the same hub. Just make sure that the hub you buy des not segment the ports running 10mbit from the ports running 100mbit (I don't remember the term used for this). As mentioned by the previous posters, if you are planning to run large amounts of data across your network, like running an application server or large data files being transferred, you may want to spend a little more up front and invest in switches, but still go with the 10/100 autosensing solution, for its versatility. If your use is primarily email and small file sharing, then a hub will work fine. The beauty of this is you can upgrade from a hub to a switch with no recabling. Just take out the hub and plug in the switch. So, if you opt for the hub now, and find that you really need a switch later, it is an easy upgrade. Jackie

by f.mccourry

For 16 users, I wouldn't bother with much more than a hub. You can find a few low cost (non-manageable) hubs that will allow full duplexing, thereby giving you the speed of the switch without the cost (check out www.dlink.com). This does not however give you any of the features such as Virtual LANS and some security features of higher end switches.

I'm guessing that you already have an available switch. (I gathered this from the last line of your message). If this is the case, then by all means use it! Switches are great tools for network traffic management and speed. A good manageable switch will allow you a lot of flexibility in your network.

by vasilmitrev

I have network of 8 komputersand when I use HUB I had problems with the inside network but after I put Switch I didn't have any problems very often.When you use switch you are going to have much better.Using a switch makes the transfer of information faster.The switch can send and receive at the same timebut HUB doesn't have this option it's not posiblle.
With Regard Vass?

This discussion is closed to new replies.