Question Locked

Networking Problem for NOOBs *URGENT PLS. HELP*

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Gentlemen,Sir/s,
I have a problem with regards to networking some workstations here in the office. The network setup is basically a 4-port G-router w/ Wi/Fi connected to a number of hubs that connects the router to all 30+ workstations and on top of that our File/DNS/DHCP server(2003)is connected somewhere in those hubs. The problem/s are; One, I monitor the activity of the router by using ping and when many of the workstations are active and are connecting to the web, the router RTOs about every 5 minutes or so then I have to reset it and connection would be OK again. Is that normal in that kind of setup or is there something wrong that I need to fix/replace. Two, The IT guy before me set the IPs of majority of the workstations on static for "Ease of controlling". Now, he resigned and many of the users are complaining about connection problems. I turned the IPs to Dynamic and most stations got its connection back except for some. Some stations can connect to the router/net folders but cant connect to the web. Other stations cant connect to both web and router. NOTE: The users say that the stations are working fine on dynamic IP until the guy before me changed it to static and now even the stations that were not touched cant connect to both web and LAN. Any solutions? I'm sorry to the experts who are reading. I was a hardware technician before this and I'm not very familiar w/ this level of networking. Hope you understand my situation. Any advice/help will be appreciated. Thanks for reading and have a good day.

8 replies

by 45geek

sounds like you fell into the rabbit hole. Without knowing the specifics of your network such as a topology, brands, addressing scheme, etc.... it is hard to give a decent reply. These are just steps to take to try and fix your problem but the ultimate would probably have someone with a networking background come in and fix it with the add-on that they teach you how to maintain the configuration.
First step: create a topology of your network!!!! this will ease tracking down problems, give you a visual of what/how your network interacts. Second start from the POP in to your network (your connection to the ISP) then step into the network layer by layer resolving the problems you find at each step and verifying the fix and documenting the fix for future reference and troubleshooting. Next consider getting rid of the HUBS replacing them with switches. One of your problems might be too many collisions on the lines. Static IP's make for more control over the network but DHCP is easier to administer but causes more traffic which might be causing collisions on the networks connected to the hubs. Remember the more stuff connected to a hub the more collisions as anything a hub receives it pushes out all the other ports. where a switch creates a one to one connection therefore eliminating collisions with others connected on the switch. The bigger the network on hubs the more prone it is to problems with collisions. Also all your servers should have static addresses regardles of which network topology you use otherwise major problems can develop.

Again the best bet is to hire a Network person to straighten it out. Talk the company into sending you to training for networking, attend a networking bootcamp, search out some of the free stuff on the internet such as e-learning on CISCO.COM etc...either way if you are going to be in charge you will have to know what you are doing or you will constantly be getting calls for the network being down or worse lost data from external attacks on your network. There is no bigger stress than being over your head in a situation and you want to have the company have confidence in your abilities or you will be let go, so you have to think about your career also. There is no shame in asking for help or explaining to your boss that you need further training to handle a mess of this magnitude. Better to look like the wizard that fixed the problem then the next guy wondering what the hell you were doing when you made this mess.
GOOD LUCK!!!!

by 1bn0

"A number of hubs" sounds like the first problem. You also need to determine how they are connected to each other. Make sure you do not have a loop in the interconnects between hub.

e.g. make sure you don't have a cable from hub1-hub2,hub2-hub3,and then hub3 back to hub1. That will really cause issues.

If you want to keep what you have for now, try not to daisy chain the hubs any longer than you have to. Connect 4 hubs to the ports on the routers. if you have more hubs left over, only connect one to each of the first four.

Try to make sure the server is connected to one of the first four hubs next to the router. Keep the steps from the server to the furthest computer as low as possible.

Or if you have 6 or less hubs connect 3 to the router, connect the server to the fourth port of the router and connect one hub to each of the first 3 hubs.

Router
|
----------------------------
|?৻৻৻৻৻৻৻|?৻৻৻৻৻৻৻|?৻৻৻৻৻৻৻|
Hub Hub Hub Server
| | |
Hub Hub Hub

Switches would be a significant improvement.
A 32 or 48 port switch would be best. That would elimnate all unnecessary taffic between workstation.

by oh smeg

And they are very important the first step here is assuming that it was working and has now stopped without any intervention is to unplug the Power from the Switches for several seconds and then replug them back in.

What can happen is that Power Spikes scramble Hubs and stop them working so you need to power them down let them clear themselves and then plug back in and let the Network Address reestablish themselves. After you have done this you can then start to work out what goes where and so on but you need to clear the Hubs first before proceeding.

I also agree if it is possible to insert 1 Decent Sized Managed Switch but that may involved rewiring the Network Cabling and if that is the case Management is unlikely to look favorably on that.

Col

by ---tk---

Dump the hubs and get one big switch, or multiple smaller ones...

by Member 25348569

I'd follow Oh Smeg's tip of switching stuff off but I'd go further and unplug most or all of your workstations from the network and bring them back in one at a time once you're sure that your server and router are set correctly.

Make sure that your server's IP is static and that it and the other bits of kit such as your router and any printers that should have static IP addresses are outside of the DHCP scope. Check that the router isn't set to act as a DHCP server as well as your file server!

Use [b]ipconfig /all[/b] in a cmd window to check the IP and other settings that have been picked up by each workstation. Start with the ones that work! That way you'll know what a "good" setting looks like. The DNS servers(s) and the Default Gateway are a couple of things to confirm as OK. IP address and Mask would be good too. :p

Start with that and then get back on here if you're still stuck. Look upon it as a learning experience and DON'T PANIC!

:)

by robo_dev

make sure you understand what is the correct default gateway, and makes sure your DHCP server is handing out that value correctly.

So if you want your server to be the DHCP server, then disable DHCP in the router, or visa-versa.

by jash_kidding

To all the good gentlemen that posted their helpful suggestions, Thanks a lot for your help. I will put those advices to good use.

This discussion is closed to new replies.