I build custom computers and have ran across this "Same Type Issue" when upgrading an older system that had a Power Supply Unit that was not able to handle the "New Job" - - when it blows it usually takes the MOBO and CPU with it.
And a blown PSU can have enough life left in it that it will actually allow your computer to seemingly "Power On", even though it is not offering the voltages necessary to run the system and even if it was, the MOBO and CPU are now fragged and unable to function. You should be able to smell that "Tell-Tale Burnt Chip Smell" near the MOBO?s Chipset if this is the case, but not always.
The only way to know "for sure", is to have the board tested with a Diag Card like the one I use. At least you will know if both the MOBO and CPU are blown and have that PSU tested without hesitation ...... if it is bad, all you are going to do to an RA or RPL MOBO and CPU is hook them back to this PSU and frag them again.
And the way companies are about this kind of stuff, I am afraid you won't be given that 2nd RPL because they will know it is not a product issue or they may challenge the Return a second time.
You have gotten several good posts and mine is just another direction to look toward and may not be the correct answer.