Discussion Locked

New Network Setup

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A small business has two computers that they would like networked together to share an application. One PC in running Win98 and the other WinXP. The application they want to share is QuickBooks Pro 2001. Each PC has a printer attached and both also have a dial-up connection to the Internet. The owner stated that in the future they may want to add more computers to the network and they are also looking to upgrade their Internet service to broadband (DSL)
My question is two-fold :
1. Would it be better to install a server-based system or could these computers be connected by a switch and still perform what the business needs ?
2. Based on the answer to the first part of the question, what would be the best way to share the application between the computers ?

8 replies

by xpertdragon

I believe the newer versions of Quickbooks have a Login method, where it can track the number of users, (% maximum I believe) that are currently opening and or editing Quickbooks accounting data.

Would it be possible to upgrade the Win98 computer to Windows 2000? I just think that the intermediate solution of "Internet Sharing" is easier if you decrease the OS age gap.

1.) I would convince the company to get DSL sooner, rather than later, and invest into a DSL Router/Hub (Most DSL nationwide ISP's have a promotion for a Free DSL router and NIC for first-time subscribers.) Going with a server approach is unecessary and too costly for what you need.

2.) The Quickbooks application can either be shared from Oone PC to another, or it can't...it basically comes down to that. Check out this part of the Quickbooks web site for all your connectivity questions:

http://www.quickbooks.com/support/index/ndxw_9_network_connectivity.html

(eliminate any spaces that may come up)

Paul

by shmaltz

From your question I wans't able to determine if those 2 computers are located in the same building (Local Netwrok) or not.
If they are not in the same building:
Even if you will use DSL/Cable your sharing will be very slow. Don't share it if theyare not located on the same local network.
The only way to share it is using Terminal Software. Which can either be Remote Access terminals like PCAnywhere and VNC or a server based Terminal Services. In both cases the program and the data is on the remote computer, and the only thing that is on the local computer is the Screen and keyboare/mouse singnals, but not the data or proccessing power. The difference is that PCAnywhere or the like locks down the remote computer and only the remote user can use the computer (or only the local user), While with Terminal Services both the local user and the remote user can access the computer and application and data.
Terminal Services is available on Windows 2000 Server. It allows you to have userlogon from any where on the internet if it is connected to the Internet or from the LAN.
2. The best way in this case is to use Terminal Services.

by shmaltz

If they are on the same local network:
You can share it using any OS (Windows all versions) that allows you to share folders/files and have the other computer connect to that share. Performance will be almost the same and it will work fine.
As to your question about using a server based system. I understand your question is about having a computer dedicated as a server (every computer that shares a file is a server). The answer is that it might not be necessary. What you gain by setting up a dedicated server is that on a dedicated server it is: Easy to maintaining files (backup etc.). Easy to restrict (since you control the computer) access. And a few more things.
2. To share the application just install the program on both computersand share the folder where the quick books file is located.
BTW Quick Books PRO 2001 has a limitation of 5 users.

by luke

First off, I must say that, as a Quickbooks beta tester, I would highly recommend upgrading to Quickbooks 2003 upon its release in a few weeks. This version tends to be a good deal more "network friendly", and brings about fewer snags and incompatibilities, especially with Windows XP. To answer your primary concerns:

1. A switch is definitely the way to go in this situation. I have set up quickbooks networks in several small business offices, and it is my experience that with fewer than four or five users accessing the Quickbooks database at once, a dedicated server (a separate computer specifically for the purpose of serving the needed data) is not necessary. Rather, I suggest that you utilize the computer running Windows XP as the Quickbooks server. This simply means that the actual company data file for Quickbooks would be physically located on that computer. I suggest the XP unit because I assume it is newer, and will therefore experience less slowdown from sharing the file than would the other. If another computer is added, it can simply be plugged into the network, Quickbooks can be installed, and your ready to go!

2. See Above. :D To share the file one must simply install Quickbooks on both computers. Then put the official company file wherever the client wishes. Make sure that the folder in which the file is housed in shared on the network. Then, through the File-open within the program simply point the program to the file, either on the drive (XP), or through the network (98).

Thanks for letting me comment on this, and I hope everything works out for the best! It's always good to see more successful small businesses around!

Sincerely,
Luke Salinas

This discussion is closed to new replies.