Discussion Locked

No religion in our schools, thank you

0 helpful
93 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is only one of many such instances I have encountered. What is particularly absurd is that the words of the musical item were not going to appear in the program, or be sung in the performance.

I suppose one could say "God save America," except for the fact that God is officially a "persona non grata" in today's USA education system.

How ironic it is that the country which was founded by people fleeing from religious intolerance in England, has gone more than full circle and is now trying to dissociate itself from the very ideals on which it was built.

SEATTLE, Wash.?A federal district court has dismissed a lawsuit over a school?s decision to forbid a student woodwind ensemble?s performance of the instrumental piece ?Ave Maria? at a high school graduation ceremony. Attorneys for The Rutherford Institute had filed suit against the Everett School District, charging that the school?s actions violated student Kathryn Nurre?s right to freedom of speech and to be free from hostility to religion.

In dismissing the case, the U.S. District Court in Seattle ruled that although music is considered a form of speech that can be protected, the school district was within its legal rights to control the content of any speech at the graduation ceremony in order ?to keep religion out of graduation as a whole.? Taking issue with the court?s ruling that the school?s actions did not violate Nurre?s First Amendment rights, Institute attorneys plan to appeal the case.

?Despite what the district court said, this case is a perfect example of the extremes to which school officials will go in their efforts to sanitize our nation?s public schools of anything even remotely related to religion,? said John W. Whitehead, president of The Rutherford Institute. ?Schools cannot ban performances and restrict students? right to free expression whenever those forms of expression might have some minimal connection to religion.?

In 2006, members of the senior high woodwind ensemble at Henry M. Jackson High School in Snohomish County, Wash., elected to perform an instrumental arrangement of German composer Franz Biebl?s ?Ave Maria? at the school?s graduation ceremonies in June 2006. School officials have traditionally allowed the senior members of the high school?s top performing instrumental group, the woodwind ensemble, to choose a song from their repertoire to perform as a farewell during graduation ceremonies. Previous selections included ?On a Hymnsong of Philip Bliss,? a popular composition based off the hymn ?It is Well Within My Soul.?

Thus, having previously performed ?Ave Maria? at a public concert, Kathryn Nurre and the other seniors in the wind ensemble unanimously chose to perform it again at their graduation ceremony on June 17, 2006. The senior members proposed to perform Biebl?s piece instrumentally; no lyrics or words would be sung or said, nor did the senior members intend that any lyrics would be printed in ceremony programs or otherwise distributed to members of the audience. However, despite the absence of lyrics, the superintendent of Everett School District No. 2 refused to allow the ensemble to perform ?Ave Maria? at their graduation ceremony, allegedly because she believed the piece to be religious in nature. The ensemble was then instructed to select a piece for graduation that was entirely secular in nature. Attorneys for The Rutherford Institute filed suit against the school district in June 2006 on behalf of Kathryn Nurre, a member of the high school woodwind ensemble.

[b]Source:[/b]
The Rutherford Institute
1440 Sachem Place
Charlottesville, VA 22901
Phone: 434-978-3888
FAX: 434- 978-1789
website: www.rutherford.org

93 replies

by john.a.wills

the ensemble had wanted to play Bhairavi or some other Hindu piece, or the popular Hanukkah tune Maoz Tzur , would the superintendent have cared? Or is it only Christian music that is banned?

by rknrlkid

you will find that it is only things of a Christianized nature that is banned.

There is no law that says that religion cannot be mentioned in school. Over-cautious school boards often make these kinds of decisions.

by tony hopkinson

Christianity is so 'popular' it's trappings are always going to be recognised as being associated with it.

Victim of it's own success in that regard.

Name a popular Islamic Hymn

by tony hopkinson

have cared?

Even the non-religious will associate Ave Maria with christianity, the other two tunes might not be recognised as having religious conotations.

Ave Maria is a nice piece of music, worth playing just on that basis, so any object I made as a fundamentally irreligious person would have been context based.

by locrian_lyric

at airports...

oh, and let's not forget the university at Kansas that is building religious foot-baths for Islamic students..

by jamesrl

..is not the one traditionally heard.

Its more modern. And from a personally perspective I have performed it as a soloist and been recorded, and found the experience moving. I would suggest that you can find recordings on the Internet.
http://www.cantemusdomino.net/blog/archives/001366.php Chanticleer do a wonderful rendition, if you are looking for a recording.

I'm not Catholic (and Ave Maria is primarily an RC thing) but I would be honored to have it sung at my funeral.

I have performed in large choirs, where there have been people of other faiths(Jewish, Muslim, Hindu) and everyone of every faith participates in the singing of the Christian pieces, even the popular Masses, which of course were designed to be a church service. I've returned the favour and sung hannukah songs, and sung at a Jewish funeral. I've never sung anything Muslim or Hindu, but once sang in a Zorarastrian piece.

As for me, my kids go to a public school board that is inclusive. They talk about all religions. Works for me.

James

by oz_media

When I was in school in England, having a morning assembly with hymns was a part of life.

I was born under the Church of England, which technically would make me Christian. I don't conciously practice Christian ideals nor do I attend church regularly other than the odd XMas mass or Rememberance day sermon.

I am not a Christian by MOST people's standards of Chistianity.

I had NO issue with singing hymns in the morning assembly, in fact I loved All Things Bright and Beautiful and also was in the choir as a young'un. (Then there's the Monty Python version, "All Things Dull and Cancerous", which was fun to throw in once in a while also).
They would often mumble out some sort of sermon, "God be praised and have a nice day" etc. and we all sat though it, Christian, Muslim, Budhiist whatever. It wasn't a Christian school, just a regular public school (except in England you still wear a uniform to public school)

It had no effect on me whatsoever, perhaps even a little positive effect but nothing negeative thats for sure.

You're right, Jules, 'they' are just hung up on everything and can't handle anything with reason. It is either one extreme or another, just like their politics. Left or right, no comfortable medium or middle groud to be shared. Again, separating the Unity that the nation was supposedly built upon.

Remember politically correct? That was fun here! In Canada, being PC was a way of life around business and mixed ethnicities for a long time. Not something people fussed over but just a casual respect.

In teh US, it became, 'Afro American' is correct and you can't even say the word black when describing a black man. Absolutely RIDICULOUS! I have 'BLACK' friends,a coupld that moved to Canada from teh US years ago. They have no issue with being referred to as black and they refer to me as white, it is what easily differentiates us. You were here for all that BS though.

YOu can't say 'b'unt around a woman in teh US, I am sure in Australia it is much the same as it is in Canada or the UK, just another derogatory term, such as bitch, wh-ore and all the other slags.

Some people just need to get over it and get on with it for a change.

by absolutely

[i]In teh US, it became, 'Afro American' is
correct and you can't even say the word
black when describing a black man.
Absolutely RIDICULOUS![/i]

The opinion of a white Canadian born in
England doesn't count. Politics aside, the
correct term of address is decided by the
one being addressed, not by some noisy
bystander.

by tony hopkinson

or their own ?

I agree it's a bit mad to object to a musical piece to be played by the school band.

I played a lot of religious pieces when I was in the school band, even though I consider religion drivel, and organised christianity morally offensive.

Is playing Ave Maria at the graduation ceremony an imposition of a religious value
No.
Make it part of thanking God for me achieving a pass, Yes.

If the piece had been a tribal ditty in celebration Umbu Gumbu God of the jungle, would the Rutherford institute have filed?

I suspect not!

by rknrlkid

I am a "wierdo" because I point out that there are statistics about the number of court cases involving schools? Please.

by naughtymonkey

where the government has given power to schools to discriminate against a particular culture, religion, nationality, etc...

I think the government is bassackwards in almost everything they do. If they would not allow another religions songs, that would be discrimination. Don't allow Christian and that is okay.

Schools teach our children to not be tolerant to hose that are different, to hide your identity, subdue the cultural differences that made this country great.

Another good example of why the country is backwards that really pisses me off, If you are white and are attacked by someone black it is assault. If you are white and attack someone black, it is a hate crime. I know not always, but with the public prosecutors like Jesse Jackson, it will be twisted that way.

You can't say or do anything anymore especially if you are in the public eye without getting someone after you. Everything is blown out of control and the rules are not the same for all sides. This country is going downhill fast.

by oz_media

And bravo for seeing the issues for what hthey are. Every country has similar screwed up problems, but it's how Americans never seem to see [i]anything[/i] wrong with 'AMERICA' that pisses the rest of the world off, especially when it is as screwed up, if not more, than any other. It's blind defense without reason that just makes people look so stupid to others looking inward.

At least you have a grip on reality.

by tig2

Who look at what this country has become and cringe in horror. There is no good reason for it.

Am I proud of my country? You bet I am. But do I see the myriad flaws? You bet I do.

by naughtymonkey

but sometimes I am sickened by things I see and hear. Especially when I have to deal with things that the government allows businesses to get away with.

by tony hopkinson

School as part of it's dress code banned jewelry.

One young lady protested that this was an infringement of her religious freedom as she wears a chastity ring.

School was upheld after ruling that a chastity ring was not a religious symbol, even though she wore it as part of her belief that young christian women should be chaste until they are wed.

Neither right nor wrong, just an excuse for lawyers to upgrade to the latest model BMW.

by absolutely

[i]I think the government is bassackwards in almost everything they do. If they would not allow another religions songs, that would be discrimination. Don't allow Christian and that is okay.[/i]

Try to get a school to spend taxpayer money on Judaism, Hinduism, or any local tribal religion, and if there's a lawyer who loves the Constitution among the parents, there should be a lawsuit faster than you can say "judicial review".

by mfhawn

My take on the religion thing is this: People who are other than Christian have Xtianity shoved in their faces all the time. I am a Christian, but I don't believe in prayer/religion being taught in school, except to teach the difference between religious cultures. We never learned the difference between the various religions in history; I had to learn it myself. If we taught children about religions in general, and not pray to this god or that god, it would make things much better, IMO.

If you want to pray in school, pray in silence. God hears our prayers even if they are not spoken.

Religious musical selections - I don't think those should be done, period. It is again, our country of religous freedom, shoving another religion down the throats of someone else.

What happened to America? Why are so many so intolerant?

by charliespencer

at the amount of time an Australian spends worrying about U.S. constitutional issues.

Incidentally, religious deities are not "persona non grata" in U.S. schools, just the official endorsement of them. Some administrators are unsure where to draw the line and may curtain activities unnecessarily.

by locrian_lyric

good lord, don't let them anywhere NEAR Michaelangelo's David or pictures of the Sisteen Chapel.

We better be damn careful of letting them see Leonardo's "Last supper" as well..

by oz_media

How an American can dismiss an issue that is pointed towards his own country when his own country spends ALL of its time concentrating on issues outside of it's own problems.

"America will fix the world and tell other countries what they are doing wrong. If they don't fit our ideals, invade them and change thier government until it is suited to our needs. But don't look at OUR country, it's none of your business."

LOL, hypocrisy as always. :D

by jardinier

worrying about U.S. constitutional issues. But I think it is about time more Americans did. Your constitution is outdated, and in so many instances has been manipulated through the courts to take the meaning further and further away from what was intended by the Founding Fathers.

I happen to publish an international news website, and subscribe to all kinds of newsletters in order to get stories that may not be found in the mainstream media. The Rutherford Institute is one of these sources and provides topical and pertinent comments.

If I find an item that I think will make an interesting discussion at TR, I will post it. Doesn't take me much time at all, and obviously I DID choose an item which people are interested in discussing.

by tig2

I wondered as Palmetto when this discussion first posted. Since then, I have read up on the topic and am glad to have it brought to the fore.

We have a lack of leadership in this country. And we aren't going to improve our lot with the next election. We have become lazy and intellectually dishonest. Certainly not all, but enough that the impacts are felt on a daily basis and outside of our shores.

It is "Silly Season" and it has been going on for far too long. Unfortunately, no one seems to have a desire to stop it.

by tony hopkinson

a few years ago, no.

Fanatics are fanatics, the stripe merely helps you identify which group of f'ing loonies thay are a member of.

by locrian_lyric

The court has essentially said that Bach is essentially banned from the schools as well as Verdi, Handel.... most of the music from the Baroque period and much of the classical as well.

Holy 1984 Batman!

by oz_media

Otherwise there MAY be future Americans that actually have culture [i](heaven forbid)[/i]and an understanding of the world around them.

by locrian_lyric

All this PC BS is creating a protective bubble of ignorance.

I hate to dis my own country, but I am concerned when I jokingly came up with five simple questions about the US constitution and about 1 in 10 people I asked could answer them.

1)Where can the phrase seperation of church and state be found in the Constitution

2)How many members of congress (both houses) are there today

3)Who votes to impeach the President

4)Who votes to convict the President.

5)What does the third amendment pertain to?

If you want to have a bit of fun Oz, ask any Americans who get on your nerves those questions.

Carl Sagan railed against this ignorance years ago, mystified that it has suddenly become acceptable to be ignorant.

by jamesrl

I've mentioned before, my wife was part of the parent council at my kids school, and with the school board's permission she put on a celebration of "light" that celebrated the fact that many religions have an eevnt in the Novemeber/December time frame that has to do with "light". It was a very interesting event - even thought there were no Jewish kids at the school, the Hannukah celebration was explained, as well as Christian and Hindu celebrations.

This isn't political correctess - which is an avoidance of any discussion of our differences, this is an admission that people of faith have things in common.

James

by oz_media

[i]This isn't political correctess - which is an avoidance of any discussion of our differences, this is an admission that people of faith have things in common.[/i]

Political Correctness, the most incorrect way of dealing with our differences. Instead of embracing and learning from difference, some choose to simply avoid the issue altogether, as if it will go away if ignored. In this case, they feel like they are PROTECTING someone by being politically correct.

How can ignorance equate to protection?

ouch! big 'USA being scared of the rest of the world' rant brewing on that one, better lay down now. :)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

at government (read taxpayer) expense... How many Christian, Hindu, Buddhist schools are being funded by taxpayer dollars?

And some group of High School kids can't play an instrumental version of the utterly beautiful to the ears Ave Maria?

The insanity in free speech law as it applies to religion is getting ridiculous.

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=57500

http://www.danielpipes.org/blog/758

http://www.onenewsnow.com/2007/08/nyc_group_concerned_about_prom.php

http://stopthemadrassa.wordpress.com/category/bloomberg-nyc-government/

by faradhi

They are usually founded under Charter School provisions.

So why not Muslim schools?

by r153nm

It never fails to amaze me that people that control all but 2 of the seats of congress (besides a muslim and an agnostic), all the rest of the government and 90+% of the country can view themselves as an oppressed minority. You are the dominate force in America, and if you feel oppressed, maybe it IS just you. And America WAS NOT FOUNDED ON CHRISTIAN PRINCIPLES! Most of our founding fathers were not Christian. Read a book about them sometime. Like the Jeffersonian Bible. Thank you, and good night.

by oz_media

He's like listening to a priest on a Sunday morning, when he is trying to make ammends for his pathetic actions as president.

How about his take on same sex marriage? Your president spews the Christian message like no other.

Not politically focused? Sure.

Americans are never wrong, never too much, never to blame for anything...it's the rest of the world that they need to fix.

by r153nm

I am not sure I understand everything you are saying, but I was berating our Christian population (I'm an athiest)for crying like children because they feel opressed even though they represent the majority.

And I am not a fan of Bush. I find his over-the-top rhetoric in bad taste, and his "man to have a beer with" attitutde an insult to all presidents that came before him. I do not vote for someone that I personally like, I vote for someone that will protect our economic future. I do not see why we should regulate who marries whom as long as both can give legal consent. And I think that after Korea, Vietnam, Cambodia, Colombia, Afghanistan (during the Russian Invasion), etc. that we would realize that we cannot be a global police force.

by jdclyde

The particular audience your addressing isn't an American, nor does he live in the US.

Does that change your response to him at all?

by rknrlkid

Your reply has nothing to do with what I said. In almost all the court cases, it is a result of a school or district banning something that has Christian overtones.

But you are also right...it is a victim of being so well known. Christianity is so well known by the majority that it is an easy target. Few know what other faiths believe, or the influence they have, so it is rarely mentioned.

And yes, there are court cases involving other faiths, there are just not as many.

by tony hopkinson

religion pursue their beliefs, it's almost certianly going to prosecute christians in america.

Therefore it's not anti-christian but anti-religion, which is statistically like to be christianity.

So every thing to do what I thought you were saying at least.

In no way do I believe this case was an attempt proselytise and as far as I'm concerned the school shot itself in the foot big style.

by oz_media

And sit down humbly.

I misread your post, after starting in I saw the vold type, "OUR COUNTRY WAS NOT FOUNDED..."

Thus the, 'try listening to yoru preseident'. He and milllions of other Americans feel that Christianity is the cornerstone to a righteous America.

Those who THINK they are politically correct may disagree, but then again those same people think America is multicultural too.

It's funny to listen to/read thier thoughts though, until it becomes just plain scary that they feel that way.

by jdclyde

Here in the US of A, we have Freedom OF religion. It is a constitutional guarantee that we are free to practice any religion and the expression of it.

Of course I wait for some moron to start going on about the constitutional protection of separation of church and state, regardless of no such constitutional protection being in existence. Them mindlessly repeating it over and over among themselves won't change that.

by tony hopkinson

I think this case was over the top personally.

But if you are an islamic graduate and you go to get your bit of paper, are you free from being forced to participate in a religious ceremony of a different faith?

You could orgainse the celebration so those not of your faith can do their bit and then bog off.
You can have a piece of music from every faith, playing at the same time.
You can have a separate ceremony for each faith.
You can keep religion out of it.

I laud the intent of those who framed your constitution, but I don't think they were equipped to think it all the way through, especially in a multi faith society.

So from a practical point of view freedon of religion has become freedom from others religion.

Loud right wing christian middle america is about the scariest thing in your country to the rest of the world.

When GWB said he invaded Iraq because God told him to, I damn near shat myself.

by oz_media

Freedom of religion, if your religion is the religion of favour of course.

REality and the Constitution are two very different entities it seems.

When Buch was making his stand on gay marriage, his comments were focused on what he sees is right and wrong, BASED ON HIS RELIGIOUS VIEWS!?!

How can a president publicly admit that his personal religious views (which of course he is fully entitled to have)influence his decisions on how to properly run a country where a visible minotiry is seekign his support? It's not hypocrisy it's sheer lunacy and he gets away with it, because so many Christians support him.

Bottom line is its hideously pathetic, just like GWB himself. A complete joke and someone I would be incredibly embarrassed to admit supporting, as well I should be.

by tony hopkinson

Course based on your secular constitution, there should be places of worship for every religion, or none.

Can't have it both ways christians or muslims, personally I pray at the bar.

Four pints and I don't care which god keeps the plane in the sky. :D

by locrian_lyric

You can't be telling Christians that they can't sing their music, can't display crosses on war memorials, can't have funding for parochial schools...

and then bend over backwards to shell out tax money for seperate accomodations for muslims.

by tonythetiger

Consider it "affirmative action" for minority religions.

On the other hand, the perceived conflict could be resolved in another way... simply declare publicly funded education unconstitutional :)

by tony hopkinson

A wee speech, a prayer and hymn every morning, every school day.

You could get out of it, if you had proof that you professed another faith.

2nd B flat cornet for four years, had to sit at the back because my hair was half way down my front, and visually I was a bad impression. :D

The only times I enjoyed asssembly were when in the choir and the band.

It's no accident that the church commissioned some superb pieces of music, it speaks even if the words are a foreign language.

by tig2

I suppose you are welcome to berate anyone you please. But frankly, I am getting a bit sick of being lumped in with EVERY Christian on the planet because I have faith in God.

From where I sit, you come off as one of those smug, self-superior atheists that goes through life with a need to transform everyone in his path to the "one true way". And those you can't convert, you hold yourself as better than.

As a Christian woman engaged to an atheist man, I spend a great deal of my time and effort making very certain that his needs get just as much play as mine do. I go to church, he doesn't. I pray, but I don't make it a centerpiece of his life. It is a centerpiece of mine. I have faith, but I don't waste a moment in a fruitless effort to convert him or anyone else.

Ask the atheists of this board- I am as easy-going on subjects of faith as you can ask for.

Not all of us are "crying like children". Most of us don't have the bandwidth to spare. All we are asking is that the world consider us- the non-vocal, not over the top, quiet faithful in an equal manner to the rest of the myriad faiths.

Not every Muslim is a fanatic Jihadist. Not every Christian is out to evangelize. When you choose to respond to the world in global terms, you will run across the exceptions that prove the rule. And chances are we won't be pleased to be lumped in where we don't belong.

by locrian_lyric

My wife is non-denominational, I am methodist (officially).

Neither of us is evangelical. I rarely discuss my faith, as it is very personal to me. I will answer questions asked but I do not preach.

As a whole, we are very tolerant of other religions. We do not impose taxes on non-christians, people are not killed or sent to insane asylums for converting from christianity, et cetera.

As a Rabbi once said to me, "The abuse does not negate the use". The fact that there are knucklheads of a given faith does not negate the usefulness of that faith or the good that it does.

There are good Jains, Buddhists, Shintoists, Animists, Pagans, Heathans, Wiccans, Asatruar, Hindus, Muslims, Jews, Zoarstrians, Lokeans, Dianic Wiccans, Hare Krishnas, et cetera.

I only see atheists slamming Christians though...

I could be wrong though.

by tig2

That there are many who mourn what has happened to our country and seek constantly for a way to get our country back.

Maybe there aren't enough of us yet- but I hope the number is growing. The travesty we have become from a holistic view is painful- especially when we think of how much more we could be.

Maybe not today, but someday. I still believe that leaders will rise among us and help us to turn back the tide of idiocy. I may have to wait a long time, but I am willing to try for something better.

Not all of us. There are still some holdouts for REAL life.

And yes, Bush is an idiot. And yes, I am a Conservative. Doesn't change what Mr. Bush is one iota.

At least in my humble opinion...

by oz_media

And in ways I almost feel sorry for you. I understand that there are MANY well rounded Americans who are just as critical of themselves and America as they are any other.

Unfortunately, the masses have gravitated toward a new level of retardation. They simply refuse to seek truth, they refuse to question the goings on.

I find people feel mroe compelled to support Bush, whether they feel he is right or wrong, just because he is the president. Which is absolutely insane! If you voted for him and actually believe what he is doing, that's one thing but to support him without question is simply stupid and makes your country's people look completely insane.

I think it is every citizens OBLIGATION to take time to question their leaders, to question the governments and to closely watch what they are doing.

This is one of the advantages to Canada's two party system, the minority government watches the majority and vice versa, sure they screw up and pull a fast one every now and then, but are usually called on it and oftem toppled for it.

People are responsible for the actions of the government they elected and keep in office, ALL politicians have a secret agenda, it's up to us to control it.

by jdclyde

He has his moral basis, and that directs his life. I would be more afraid of anyone that claims to believe in something, and then acts contrary to the stated beliefs.

He "gets away with it" because his moral basis is in alignment with the people that voted for him.

The people without the same moral basis voted for someone else. Majority rules up to the point where someones rights (as described in the Constitution) are violated.

"Reality" is all about opinion. We have a set of rules that HAVE to be followed until the rule is replaced with another official rule. Our founding fathers DID see a need for change, and that is why there is a process to change the Constitution as needed, when needed. It isn't an EASY process, but it shouldn't be either.

by jdclyde

one person has no right to interfere with another persons freedom of religion, just like freedom of speech.

If you don't like someones free speech, either counter it or ignore it.

If you don't like someones free religion, either counter it or ignore it.

Either way, you don't have the right to STOP it. At least HERE in the States, you don't, no matter how much it drives the godless left nuts.

by oz_media

HO wabout when he said he was all for equality anacceptance of people's right to choose a lifestyle of their liking, but then followed with, he doesn't support gay marriage because his God does not accept that as marriage between two people of different sexes. :) LOL What a tool!

Okay, fredom of religion and freeedom of sexual preference in OKAY, but his God doesn't support it so HE doesn't either.??? HUH?

Wasn't it him who said you are either with us or against us? Well, what's he on about then? I am for it but should heed my religious values and not support it?!? Er, sure Bushy, sure. Can't wait until that knob is out of the House.
NEXT IDIOT PLEASE!!!

With 330 million+ in population, it is no wonder then cam elect such clowns, even at 25% of the population being stupid (hey I wouldn't suggest Canada or England are any different)that leaves 82 MILLION complete idiots that could be elected.

Another way to look at that is, with 82 million complete idiots in population, how did they possibly find the biggest idiot of all??

Phew, line 'em up and knock 'em down. If only they didn't RE-elect the clowns though, now THAT was a bad one!

by tony hopkinson

Or two different bits of it intersected ?

Would it be constitutional to force a citizen to take part in a rite for a different religion?

If they'd have been allowed to play ave maria and some left wingnut had complained that he was subjected to religious ceremony while picking up his scroll.

Would he have a case according to your constitution?

I am a very practical person which is why I'm neither a left nor right wing loon.

Are you concerned with the attack on this person's rights or on your faith?

by tig2

Respectfully, of course.

I started disliking Bush because I got tired of having his concept of God shoved down my throat every time he opened his mouth. I was always taught that prayer was a private matter between an individual and God. And I treat it as so. Yes, you hear me tell people that I will pray for them. You don't hear me do it. And telling someone that they are in my prayers is often a comfort to the recipient- they don't need proof that I have prayed. They know my heart and the person I am and they TRUST that I pray.

What is the "right thing"? Who knows. I will allow that Mr. Bush is the first president we have had that scared me. I don't understand his rationales and therefore I do not understand, nor can I forecast, what he will do next. I don't know that he is acting in the best interest of the country with some of the choices that he has made and I see glaring omissions in his policies.

Do I know what the right thing is all the time? Not even close. But I try. For all I know, Mr. Bush does too. But I, at least, know my limitations. And I am capable of admitting when I am wrong.

Mr. Bush would do well to just tell us, "I thought it was the right approach. Four years later, I see an error. I worked with the information I had at the time but now see that I didn't have ALL the information. Now, we're stuck until we can meet the following objectives...".

I will follow an honest man all the days of my life. I can't say that the honest man will be a politician.

by jdclyde

What concerns me is the anti-Christian left that will stand by anyones right to any religion and free speech, provided your not a Christian or a Conservative.

We see "leaders" that advocate the killings of gays in their country are invited to talk at our universities in the spirit of free speech, yet when conservatives tried to talk at the same university, they were physically and verbally attacked and the PTB on the campus would not ALLOW the attackers to be removed because they had a right to their free speech, even if it was only to deny the same right to the speakers.

The more the liberal, the more the hypocrite. The party of tolerance only has tolerance for you if you agree with them.

by oz_media

When you said "right to their free speech"

The right to free speech is with regard to a peaceful demonstration. If they are loud or interrupting a speech, they are no longer peaceful, are considered hostile and should rightly be removed. How can they cry about free speech?

You're right though, the left wing is pretty f*&$#d up alright, just as the right is too though. May as well call a spade a spade.

by oz_media

As Tig pointed out, your religious views/faith are a very personal and private issue. No matter what anyone says or does to you, you can still have faith. Perhaps why people feel their god is always there to turn to in times of need.

I have NO problem with anyone having faith, regardless of religion or even a choice NOT to follow religion yet have faith in something else.

The Preident having faith or even stating what HIS faith is, doesn't bother me.

When he openly states he accepts a persons right to choice and then negates that statement because HIS religion stops him from supporting it, THAT'S where I have a problem.

His chosen religion is being used as his reasoning for not supporting gay marriage. He is using Christianity as a crutch.

Keep your inner beliefs and faith as just that, INNER beliefs and faith.

if he had made a statement like that on TR, we'd have lambasted him as a hypocrite, face it, just because he's the president it doesn't mean he's not to be treated like everyone else.

by tony hopkinson

christianity or on religion though ?

Note liberal left is a contradiction in the UK. :D

Freedom of expression vs Freedom to offend.

Obviously you don't think of your faith as offensive, some of it's trappings I do.

Not so much, that I'd choose to sue you for expressing it, though I might stand up and say bollocks.
I'm free to do so, and you are free to be offended by it as well.

Either we are both right or both wrong.
Go to court to 'decide' and it's the lawyer who wins.
So you pray silently and I'll accord you the privacy to do so.
I'll mutter bollocks silently in return.

by locrian_lyric

Yes, right wing christians tend to be loud.

Isn't that a positive method of letting your feelings be known?

Far better than blowing things up, I'd say.

by tig2

But they may have chosen that path for exactly the reason you imply- that it would be divisive instead of welcoming.

I think that there are many who embrace that very philosophy. Unlike me, they are better at keeping their mouths shut. Me? Let's just say that some days are better than others.

My intent has never been to proselytize. Just to point out that not every Christian is rabid.

by jdclyde

[b]Tony[/b], you do not EVER see the liberals trying to silence muslims in the US. They are specifically Anti-Christian.

[b]Oz[/b], Here is how I put it to my Aunt in New Your that is a raving liberal. "The difference between you and me is you think that Republicans are evil and can't be trusted. [b] I[/b] think [b]Politicians[/b] are evil and can't be trusted."

I have been talking to my boys a lot about politics lately as the politics is getting fired up again (We had a partial state government shutdown last night, in part thanks to Canada's spy, Granholm). We have the highest unemployment in the NATION, and the Democrats solution was to raise taxes AND increase what is taxable.

Way too often, it is "what is bad for the other party is good for mine", and no one wants to do ANYTHING to improve things while the other is in power, and that goes with both of the major parties in the US.

We hear all the time about the low polls for Bush, but the media doesn't point out that the Democratic controlled Congress is at an [b]all time low[/b] in the ratings.

And it doesn't matter WHAT they say now, NONE of the Democratic candidates will order an immediate withdrawal from Iraq if they get elected. Just more dishonesty.

Makes me sick.

by oz_media

It's like on that show 'This hour has 22 minutes" where they go to the US and ask simple quetstions that Americans should but often don't know, just to show how stupid Americans are. Unfortunately, it is so bad, most people hink they look high and low for these morons, but I really don't think it takes too long to find them.

But I am sure that if you were to come to Canada with smimilar questions, Canadians would fail too. Mind you, politics is on NO Canadians mind, only Us politics that is thrust at them 24/7, but Canadian politics? Nobody here gives a toss what they do, as long as they leave us alone, don't start wars and just do thier little underhanded BS that is expected while in term.

by oz_media

Regardless of party, and yes I agree no one is better than any other in any way shape or form, tey are politicians end of story.

But regardless of who wins the next election, the world will scream in triumphant joy the day Bush is no longer president of the USA. Not just those Americans who want a democratic government (if they take office) but the entrie world wil rejoice just to see who is now considered the worst president to walk teh planet, FINALLY out of his seat and unable to do more mass harm to the world around him.

by faradhi

I was trying to point out that most if not all airport chapels are Christan. This is mostly implicit by having crosses or other Christian decorations. Additionally, those chapels were built taxpayer money. Finally, it is hypocritical to complain about the mosques that are paid with taxpayer money.

by tig2

Been a nasty couple of weeks and I am in serious danger of becoming thin skinned.

I don't in the slightest disagree with a neutral place of prayer. Indeed, I see the value easily. We had quite the dust up here when traveling Imams wished to pray before boarding their flight. In retrospect, it would have solved the problem before it began if those Imams simply had a place to pray.

That said, I also know that there are fewer and fewer "religious" symbols on display. There IS a desire to include all. It just takes time.

by jdclyde

and the existing ones.

The existing ones do not ban anyone of any faith.

The muslim ones I have a feeling, will not be as open to anyone that comes by.

They are NOT the same thing, and can not be compared side by side just because there are Christian Icons present. Until there was a need/request for others, none were needed, and space has been provided.

by faradhi

Have you tried to enter a Mosque or Muslim prayer room?

Here is my experience. I have a friend who is Muslim. When I go to dinner, he says a Muslim prayer before the meal. He will then provide an opportunity for me to say my prayer. I have been to his mosque and he to my church.

If the "chapel" is decidedly non denominational and has room for Muslim prayers, which is done on the knees, then the individual prayer rooms should not be built. However, if that is not the case, I see no problem providing a prayer room.

Finally, how many Christians would feel comfortable praying in a Mosque/Muslim prayer room? I imagine not many. Conversely, Many Muslims feel uncomfortable praying in a chapel. Additionally, there is difficulty for a Muslim to pray in a chapel because pews or chairs. Most airport chapels are small and packed with chairs or pews.

by faradhi

I took no offense and you stated a valid point I should have addressed.

If the chapel is neutral then there is no need for a separate prayer room. It is a very good point.

by tony hopkinson

Loud right wing christians have blown a fair few things up in my country, a lot more than their islamic buddies in fact. Though Allah's 'chosen' are working on that.

Still at least you don't have people in your government officially lobbying for their funding eh?

I see no substantive difference between a christian or a muslim or a hindu for that matter. They are all prepared to sacrifice a non believer and I qualify as that with all three.

Bombs don't have religion, religions have bombs.

by tony hopkinson

withdrawal from afghanistan or iraq.

Whether we voted for them or not (I did), whether we agreed with that particular policy decision or not (I did not), they are the government we elected to represent us. If they did it badly, that's our fault.

If you teach your boys, politicians are a lying, self serving shit faced bunch of hypocrites, you'll have executed your responsibilities as a parent in an explempary fashion.

by absolutely

[i]I suppose one could say "God save
America," except for the fact that God is
officially a "persona non grata" in today's
USA education system.

How ironic it is that the country which was
founded by people fleeing from religious
intolerance in England, has gone more than
full circle and is now trying to dissociate
itself from the very ideals on which it was
built.[/i]

Which ideals do you mean? I see no
dissociation from the ideals of the
Constitutional Convention evidenced in the
article you posted. On the contrary, the
First Amendment prohibition of state
support of religion was designed to allow,
not to subsidize, free participation in
religion. And the "wall of separation
between church and state" is not a concept
[i]introduced[/i] by Thomas Jeffereson, but
a uniquely eloquent description of the
ideal of religious freedom, exactly as
written into the Constitution.

[i]In dismissing the case, the U.S.
District Court in Seattle ruled that
although music is considered a form of
speech that can be protected, the school
district was within its legal rights to
control the content of any speech at the
graduation ceremony in order “to keep
religion out of graduation as a whole.”
Taking issue with the court’s ruling that
the school’s actions did not violate
Nurre’s First Amendment rights, Institute
attorneys plan to appeal the case.[/i]

Individuals traditionally have limited
rights on government-owned property. You
cannot, for example, carry a firearm into a
post office or any other federal building.

[i]“Despite what the district court said,
this case is a perfect example of the
extremes to which school officials will go
in their efforts to sanitize our nation’s
public schools of anything even remotely
related to religion,” said John W.
Whitehead, president of The Rutherford
Institute. “Schools cannot ban performances
and restrict students’ right to free
expression whenever those forms of
expression might have some minimal
connection to religion.”[/i]

The question before the court was not
[b]only[/b] of freedom of speech, but of
speech on government property, ie
government-subsidized speech. I agree with
the court's decision.

As a footnote, I think we'd all be better
off with more private schools, fewer public
schools, and more student extracurricular
clubs in public schools, with access to
school buildings, less governed by such
restrictions as the ones preventing the
performance of Ave Maria at a graduation
ceremony. Catchy tune, btw. If students
can organize themselves and consistently
not trash the place, they should be not
only allowed but encouraged to have a
knitting club or whatever, even if no
member of the faculty is interested in
supervising it.

by absolutely

to cross the Atlantic before 1776?

I'm beginning to understand why your premises are so faulty. You read history very selectively.

by tonythetiger

on a public property with public funds at the public's request as it's there to serve the public. The problem arises when some demand that others NOT be served. Would you, for example, make a law that bars anyone receiving public money from using any of that money to, say, put gas in their car to drive to church?

The court in the subject case was correct in their ruling, but not in their reasoning. The school does not have the right ?to keep religion out". In fact, if they ban speech "for that reason", they are violating the constitution. However, schools do have the right to control students' speech and behavior for the simple reason that while the students are in the school's control, they are in a parental role. Students have no rights... to speech, privacy, or anything else as long as they are treated no differently from other students (allowing one religion to speak religiously but not another is a no-no, for example). Courts of late seem to have had trouble differentiating "allowing" and "establishing".

by ganymede28211

Why is it that when the decision is made to disallow ALL of something that it's suddenly offensive to those who want it. When ALL is left out then NO ONE is singled out and offended. But somehow someone has to figure out that since they want to include THEIR version instead of excluding ALL versions, somehow that's an act against them and they must fight to get it THEIRS included. Just because a person believes in nothing and doing nothing is the norm, that doesn't mean that you've been excluded in favor of the guy who wants nothing.

I say GET OVER IT. Freedom OF religion is the same as freedom FROM religion. I choose to not partake of a religious belief, you chose to take part of one. You have places for that. Their called churches. Everywhere is religion free.. Why is that so hard to comprehend? Keep you religion in YOUR place. I don't walk around peeing in public... There's a place for that.. It's called a restroom. Again, get over it!

by jardinier

by their very nature and based on their respective scriptures, Christianity and Islam are evangelistic religions. So they will never be practised quietly and out of sight.

What is alarming is that the current trend in both these religions is a reversion to fundamentalism. Now that is scary and Islamists could take "hate" lessons from right-wing fundamentalist Christians.

You see this ever increasing breed of "born-again" Christians WANT a war to erupt in the Middle East because that would signal Armageddon or the end times, when Jesus will descend from the clouds to lift all the faithful up to heaven.

How do I know this? Because for a change of pace I participate in theological discussions at an American Christian website.

It was THESE Christians which Bush's campaign manager at the 2004 election deliberately targeted on the correct assumption that they would consider abortion and gay marriage more important issues than foreign policy and domestic economic policy.

My considered opinion of Dick Cheney and the puppet George Bush is that they are INSANE.

I will give my reasons for this point of view later, if you haven't already figured it out for yourself.

by absolutely

Most of the whining about "political correctness" being unfair is by people who just want an excuse to indulge in what traditionally was called "bad manners". Some topics are off-limits for [i]polite[/i] discussion because agreement isn't possible, in which cases discussion only wastes time and stirs resentments. Some people, unfortunately, enjoy that kind of thing.

by jardinier

Now that's an easy jingle to remember, eh?

I suggest you start a fresh discussion on the foundations of American society and culture.

BTW in Australia we do not have freedom of speech or freedom of (or from) religion enshrined in our constitution. But we are a laid back people who take these freedoms for granted. There is NO WAY that the incident referred to in this discussion would ever occur in an Australian school, public or otherwise.

Nor do we have a law, taken out of its original context, that encourages people to collect a private armory.

As Oz once said -- with any luck you will all kill each other off. :^0

by absolutely

[i]Now that's an easy jingle to remember, eh?

I suggest you start a fresh discussion on the foundations of American society and culture.[/i]

Why? I just suggested that your implication as to the religiosity of the United States is a historical exaggeration. Why does that bother you so much?

This discussion is closed to new replies.