Discussion Locked

Noise from hard drive

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
This is quite troublesome. I am runnung Windows XP Pro SP1. AMD Barton 3000, 1 gb ram. I had a Maxtor 160 gb ATA quit on me last week. Grinding noise and came to a halt. This drive was purchased in February this year(2004). I took it back and was given a new drive. After formatting and installing the new drive it started making a peculiar noise when the drive was being accessed. To me sort of a fluttering noise or vibration but very audible. I taked to Maxtor and was told to bring it back which I did and received another new drive. This one I have now is making the same noise when being accessed.I ran the Powermax tool and drive passed all tests.While the Powermax program ran (from DOS) I did not hear the noise. This noise is only loud when the drive is being taxed by a program. I have tried everything I can think of but no success. I also have an older IBM 40 gb drive in same machine as slave and it is quiet as can be. The original Maxtor that died was also quiet. Any ideas would be very much appreciated.

4 replies

by thechas

Mechanical problems with hard drives are either design or production run related.

If the 3rd drive is the exact same model, it could have been from the same production run of drives, and the entire run may have a manufacturing defect.

Any unusual noise from ANY hard drive is cause for concern.

The PowerMax tests only check the performance of the drive. They do not check the mechanics of the drive for impending failure.

I suggest that you contact Maxtor again.
See if they have analyzed your old drives.
Then ask if the noise that you are hearing is indicative of a problem.

Next, I suggest that you check the air flow in your case.
You may want / need to install additional air intake fans to help keep the hard drives cool.

Chas

by cabal1208

I don't think this will fix it but here goes.

It may be a problem with the screws if they are not tight enough when a program needs to read something on the disk that is in difrent places it turn at a high speed and it shakes and makes the nose. A dos may not support the high speed so it doesnt shake.
hope it helps

by crivet

Talked to Maxtor again today (June 28). The person I spoke with said to put the phone as close as possible to the drive, which I did with the side of the case off. Ran a program that would tax the hard drive. She said that the noise was hardly audible and what she did hear was normal when the drive was seeking.I told her that the original drive I put in in February was quiet as can be. She answered that I couldn't compare that drive because it eventually died a premature death. I gave up with that nonsense with Maxtor. I also defragged the drive, wiped it clean reformatted (NTFS) and reinstalled with Norton Ghost. Nothing worked. Today I put a new power supply in (Antec True Power 550 watt) still no fix. In regards to air intake I have two front fans 80mm, two rear exhaust 80mm and of course the two fans from PS. Don't know what to think at this point. Open for suggestions.

by borginva

Am I understanding you are having this problem even with swap out drives? Okay, some possibilites:

1 - The type of drives they are giving you are faulty. If theya re the same exact brand and type, then they could be faulty. Try a diff type.

2 - It is not the drive at all!!!!! Could be the cables or the motherboard itself sending some bad signals to the HD.

I say, since you swapped the drive more than once and talked to a tech, I would return the machine for a working replacement. Hopefully you have some sort of warrenty with them.

This discussion is closed to new replies.