Hello Dave...
In exchange for the privilege of working for one company, a non-compete agreement prevents you from working for anyone else that competes with that company for a period of time after you leave. Thus, the agreement means they own you. The penalty for quitting is not being able to do your profession for a period of time.
Telling you that you must sign so other employees don't sue may be true but it is not the real reason (as I'm sure you know). They want to prevent you from leaving the company without incurring a penalty. Of course, this gives them leverage over you while you continue to work there.
As others have said, you should definitely consult an attorney on this. And, you should decide in advance if you are willing to be fired over not signing. It's an individual decision.
I don't know about Florida law. But, in California, non-compete employment agreements are illegal. In California, an employer owns trade secrets and intellectual property. Former employees cannot divulge either and this is appropriate. But, they do not own your ability to work in your own profession.
Best of luck to you.
-----Steve Jackson
CEO/CSA
Software Corporation (Softcorp)
http://www.softcorp.us/probono
Advanced pro bono tools and utilities free for personal use
P.S. When you get a chance, be sure to rate the answers you receive and close your question when your ready.