Discussion Locked

Non-practising MCSE's are efficient ?

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Microsoft and Cisco had started certifications like MCSE and CCNA that was meant for giving recognition to practising professionals. Now-a-days it is seen that people from all fields irrespective of age,qualifications are clearing exams like MCSE and CCNA. In fact, one child of 9 years, from India has cleared the MCSE exam. Will such an MCSE be accepted in the industry ? Will such an MCSE have practical knowledge to perform networking duties ? What is the scope of such non-practising MCSE's andCCNA's?

2 replies

by bhrdwh

Hi, I really think Microsoft & CISCO etc. should have a criteria of atleats 2 years experience for anyone appearing for their exams. I often take interviews of networking engineers & most are MCSEs & dont know even the basics. In fact I took interview of a MCSE who had scored 1000/1000 in Network Essentials & he did not know the diffreence between CAT3 & CAT5 or UTP & BNC etc.
akash

by shanghai sam

I think people expect too much of someone sporting a MCSE or a CCNA, without the job experience to back it up. These are entry-level certifications and nothing more, and I wish more people would realize this, instead of coming down on the newcomer to the industry who has studied hard and passed the required tests yet hasn't gotten the years of hands-on experience needed to be considered a guru yet.

My A+ got me a job at a Compaq Repair Center and I learned a lot more on the job in 18 months than I did studying for the two tests, though I had years of computer experience prior to this. It was the A+ that was required in order to maintain their authorization so I wouldn't have had a chance without it.

While working there I was encouraged to study on my own and on the job and pass the 6 MCSE tests and I learned a heck of a lot that I wouldn't have otherwise, even though I know I couldn't jump in and manage a large network yet. The tests are hard but that's all they are; tests, and if you study hard and try things on your own as much as possible they aren't that bad.

Once I had finished the MCSE tests and got my certificate framed and proudly hanging on the wall I studied for four months for the CCNA test. Having never touched a router I was able to pass it, and I will say I learned a lot more about IP and basic networking in general than was required for the MS tests, but still, it was just one test for me, a goal to strive for and achieve.

Job experience still counts for more than any of these certifications. They make nice line items on the resume, but be prepared to face the music in an interview. Hands on experience has no substitute.

Joe Buchberger
CCNA, MCSE, MCP+I, A+

This discussion is closed to new replies.