Discussion Locked

Not So Private Conversations-Bush & Blair

0 helpful
113 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

How many times has this happened to you -- you're talking, having a conversation you assumed was private only to discover that someone was listening in http://www.essentialsecurity.com/Documents/article15.htm

For most of us, it's just a bit of gossip for a stranger eaves dropping as we have lunch, but the slip-up is much worse if you happen to be George Bush http://www.iwantmyess.com/?p=3, you're talking to Tony Bliar at a G8 event and the subject matter is the current crisis in the Middle East.

It's amazing that two of the most techophobic world leaders could be so clueless about microphones at a public event. Reporter Adam Boulton with Sky news in London has transcripts of a whispered conversation between the UK's PM and the U.S.'s President Bush http://adamboulton.typepad.com/my_weblog/2006/07/bush_blair_unpl.html#comments

Remember that little fiasco a microphone caused would-be Democratic Presidential candidate Howard Dean? "Yeee-aah!"

Letting out secrets in public or over email can lead to profession downfall. For most of us professionally we don't have the luxury of a fixed term at our jobs.

If I have a meeting with a coworker on say sales strategies and don't realize competitions at the next table, my jobs in jeopardy.

113 replies

by nathank9

Are conversations turning into emails in that everything needs to be secured?

If Bush continues to talk like this and think that nobody is listening, he could be an even bigger laughing stock of the middle east. Now I dont think that this could put his job in jeopardy but jeez, I for one do NOT want my president talking about issues in such a lax manner.

by tig2

the original poster noted that the conversation between Blair an dBush was fictionalised.

While the point is valid, there are much better supporting citations.

by jdclyde

to use someones blog as proof of something? When people want something to be true, they will fall for anything.

Reminds me of the quote of the decade. "The supporting documents were fakes, but the story is real".

by j.lupo

reported the conversation as having happened. Interesting what happens if you forget to watch for the microphones. Apparently Bush was sitting and eating with Blair when they were overheard or at least Bush was. That is what Yahoo had posted in their article.

Hey I could be being fooled too. But I tend to think the article was accurate.

Edited to add the link of the story: http://abclocal.go.com/wpvi/story?section=nation_world&id=4348669

by marileev9

Thanks for providing the alt link. Seems a bit cleaned up compared to Sky News'

The question of tact still remains, when President Bush stated: "You see the irony is what they need to is get Syria to get Hezbollah to stop doing this shit and it's all over..."

If Sec. Rice or any of the other former secretaries of state was caught being so flippant, they'dve been reprimanded.

by onbliss

I am not sure if BBC script is a cleaned up version or which is more authentic.

I see this incident as two leaders having informal conversation. Period.

Don't we all have our meeting-room conversations and offline conversations?

by faradhi

I am in no way shape or form called a GWB supporter. I see nothing in this conversation that is an issue.

You cannot possibly expect anyone not to use the occasional explicative. This is an ADULT world. The occasional use of the word S**T is not anything to get your panties in a twit over.

by nathank9

So what you are really saying is that it is not a big deal when the "image" of our country starts throwing expletives on the topic of the middle east?

I'll take my panties out our of a TWIST (twit?) as soon as the bombs stop falling all over my people in Israel. Seem fair?

ex?pli?ca?tive: Serving to explain; explanatory.
twit: To taunt, ridicule, or tease, especially for embarrassing mistakes or faults

by jamesrl

Grow up.

I too am no huge fan of GWB. But there are far worse things to get upset over. He was saying something in the context of what he thought was a private conversation. Yes, he should be more careful. Do you think it makes any difference at all in whats going on in the middle east- if you do, then you have a lot to learn about politics.

You seem very upset about whats going on in Israel. And I agree, its terrible. So are the deaths of 6 of my country's citizens in Lebanon, killed by Isreali bombers. Don't even think of trying to tell me the mother, and the little kids were terrorists. They were the family of a pharmacist in Montreal, who were visiting Lebanon to spend time with relatives.

Isn't that far more important than whether someone said sh!t?

James

by jdclyde

First, this was a private conversation, not a press conference.

The other thing you might have noticed is Bush isn't dropping bombs on Israel, and has nothing to do with that.

And it is a good thing that you are above ever lowering yourself to use language such as that. Or are you?

by faradhi

You are SOOOO SMART. You MUST know what is best and I am sure you NEVER have used the word shit. WOW I am in awe over your magnificence. If I had known that I was being graded on my informal post, I would have told those grading not to get their panties in a twiSt and where to go with an expletive.

As for the "image" of our country. The "image" of our country is not shaped by the President. It is shaped by our media and our actions when we are out of the country. So don't give me that load of crap. You know, I bet in the President actually farted once in public. But I guess that we should expect the president to hold it until he pops for the sake of our image.

Give me a break.

editied just for teach.

by danlm

Im glad it was heard. It showed how much we think of the damn terrorist's. It shows that the gloves really are off when it comes to those a$$ hole's. Maybe if a few more leaders said it like it really was, the idiots would go crawl back in their freaken holes.
I hope Isreal pounds them into dust. And I hope when they are broken, someone gets caught saying. They really were a bunch of Sh*t Heads wern't they.

Dan

by marileev9

Call me idealistic, but there was once a time in America despite National and International conflicts when our Presidents acted Presidentially. When being in office meant being the best American possible. We've had people like that in office in the 20th. Century anyone remember Roosevelt - either one???

by jdclyde

Saying the word sh!t is one of the dumbest things for people to get worked up on, when used in an informal talk.

So, was William Jefferson Clinton "presidential" enough for you?

by tig2

I wonder if NO ONE here uses that word?

I do- and many others besides. Two people in an unguarded moment having an unguarded discussion THAT WAS NOT INTENDED FOR ANYONE ELSES EARS. The only valid statement I have read re: this issue was found in the original posting- never assume that no one is listening.

I'm not a GWB fan either. But I can tell when it's a slow news day. Today would be onesuch.

Is he an idiot for saying the "S" word? Do please recall your answer the next time you find it necessary to do the same... or worse.

Thank you Faradhi for putting it better than I.

by marileev9

This was a G8 event. I'm sure President's tone should have been more formal. Like if I were attending a work luncheon or dinner event.

by nathank9

Hate to say it buddy, but GWB is the president, when he is in such a public setting, how private can he expect most of his life to be.

Assuming that you are from Canada, do you have to put up with this guy all the time and how he deals with YOUR country. Along those lines, does your S. Harper have the utter respect to say things like this about major worldwide issues?

by jamesrl

And having attended and arranged more political lunches that I care to count, I know the expectation is that during lunch, while people are eating food, cameras and mics are supposed to be off.

Kennedy called our Conservative Prime Minister Diefenbaker an a$$(in private), and even though I'm a Canadian conservative, I've got a Kennedy poster in my office. My grandfather, a huge Diefenbaker fan and an elected politican would be rolling in his grave. LBJ swore like a sailor. As I mentioned in another post, our PM Trudeau told an opposition member to F Off in the House of Commons. Nixon swore a lot.

I tend to put more emphasis on what someoen does (actions) than what they say. Judge GWB on what he does.

James

by marileev9

I understand it was supposed to be during a "down time," but GW is still the American President. I've volunteered at different political events and I've never seen either of my state senators Maria Cantwell or Patty Murray let alone Jim McDermott pick their teeth at the head table.

Events as a public figure take some amount of decorum. As a professional attending an industry lunch even around friends attending the same lunch I'd be careful to let expletives fly or be so off the cuff with important policy remarks

by mjwx

for not checking to see if the bloody microphone was on.

Now like faradhi I am no bush supporter and to play the devils advocate for a bit, this was a private conversation no different to one you and I might have about the mid-east. The problem is not that Bush and Blair had this conversation but that the conversation was taped. Being public figures means that Bush and Blair must be a little more careful than you or I.

A conversation like that needed to be had behind closed doors and besides, every room in Russia has had a microphone in it since the Stalinist days (even modern Russians are notoriously paranoid). OK that last bit about the microphones might be a bit of an exaggeration.

Well, I expect some very unhappy men in the Mid-East will have a field day with this but I ask myself (I now live with an Israeli and work with 2 Persians, just putting things in perspective) as much as I don?t what they said is it untrue?

I think Syria is key, not the key but still very important and probably not in the same way as Bush.

by onbliss

...such conversations are being had by all leaders of the world. It is just that this got out to the whole world.

by marileev9

mjwx thank you for brining it back to the point. Statesmen, heads of organizations, countries should know they are potentially "on" all the time.

by danlm

That President Bush is not the first standing president that has been caught in public using language that some do not seem suitable? Previous posts have mentioned the followign names: President Johnson, President Kennedy, President Nixon?

You have only addressed what President Bush has said. Do you turn a blind eye to all other examples because you feel everything that President Bush does is open to critisim? And nothing our previous presidents did in the same context isnt?

Dan

by jamesrl

Back in my 20s, I did some advance work for the Prime Minister. That involves making sure the space is ready, set up properly, the entrances exits for the PM, the press, the guests are defined, the PM knows who the locals they need to greet are etc.

One of the duties is to ensure the Press person has all the assistance they need. The press person would bring in a box that all mics would feed from. Two Mic leads in - in case one mic was bad, and mulitple leads out for the press, the press liason etc. One of the duties of the press handlers were to turn the switch on and off at the appropriate times. I spent time using duct tape to make sure the mic cables weren't a tripping hazard (or would get accidentally pulled out)and ensuring each press person tested the feed before the arrival.

I don't know if they use that setup still, that was 25 years ago. But if its similar to what goes on with the White House, then some press liason person forgot to kill the power, or someone sneaked over and turned it back on.

James

by onbliss

...as this incident has done Bush more good than harm. Or mabye the "accident" backfired for people who had hoped it would tarnish Bush's image.

by av .

I think the film clip of Bush eating his buttered roll and talking sh't with Blair is absolutely priceless. It belongs on The Daily Show its so funny.

I look at it as a fly-on-the-wall view of what goes on at a G8 Summit. If you haven't seen it, check out the video on http://www.cnn.com

I know. Maybe it really isn't becoming of a world leader to talk like that, but he was just being himself and we all know how that goes. At least he didn't say "bring it on". I'd much rather hear sh't.

I'm not a Bush fan, but I have to cut him a break on this. Look at what he has to deal with everyday. He's actually become alot more diplomatic lately. Still, I don't know how he handles the stress.

by marileev9

Being himself, Bush needs to always carry himself as a better version of himself since he is our U.S. President. The Folksiness can cut it when he's at his ranch in Texas, but at an international event as a representative of the nation, this man needs to be "on" all the time.

Would we cut our Secretaries of State so much slack? Is Kofi Anon going around with this little decorum?

by av .

I don't think he is capable of being anything other than what he is - a plain spoken rancher from Texas. Yeah, he should be "on" all the time, I agree, but I think its hopeless. Bush will always be Bush. Folksy.

Its not a matter of cutting him slack. We're stuck with Bush for another couple of years (and thank God he can't run again). If we impeach Bush, we would have Cheney in his place. There's a real image booster for the US. :^0

by tig2

As the reported conversation is widely believed to be satire.

ABC, CNN, Reuters?

by oz_media

"ABC, CNN, Reuters"

"authoritative citation"

Ooookay then, sounds like news to me.
Whil eI agree that a coule of the sources here were pretty sketchy, this was common news shown by most sources around the world.

your chosen few are just the same sources everyone else has, same corporate owners to please, same bias as any other source. How about the fact that many sources cited the same info/source as spoken into(quoted from) a microphone? It's not like they qall had their own microphones, one story is all it takes, others buy and publish that same story, often citing the source (in most cases these days it's all AP BS).

What makes CNN (probably the most questionable of all) more trusted than others? CNN is just about as propaganda laden as it can get, try watching world news and comparing the two. You'll see far more on BBC for example. a 10 minute video report on CNN is usually at least 30 minutes anywhere else because they don't chop it to bits and bastardize it to fit a chosen agenda.

I am not touting the right over the left or anything else, ALL news is to be second guessed, as you rightly did here, but that second guess includes ABC, CNN and all others.

by tig2

Not my fault you were late to the party. Get off me.

At the time I posted this, there were no authoritative citations. So I requested one.

Don't think a civil request is acceptable? Tough S...

by tig2

As the ones that had been posted were seen as jokes- satire at best.

Frankly? It is a non-issue. There are better things to keep in mind these days. A luncheon conversation at a level that none of us are privy to is just hype BS.

The more serious issue is the one introduced- as I stated in my first post. I thought that the original citations led to the thinking that the whole this was a joke.

So we garner two object lessons- that your citations have to be credible enough that the value of your statements is unfettered, and that we must develop a security consciousness in all things at all times.

by tonythetiger

If this had been almost anybody else, the focus would have been on the "rotten scoundrel" who turned on the microphone. and no expense would have been spared to discover the source of the "security breach".

by j.lupo

It is a shame that people just can't have private conversations anymore. No matter how careful we are with our volume controls, someone is always waiting in the wings to blow it out of proportion to what was actually said.

You know it is strange, I have watched the typical political debates on TV then compared what was SAID to what the post-debate said was SAID. What a difference on numerous levels.

by oz_media

We don't cry when actors and actresses are bothered by the paps, we just say that's the life they chose it's par fo rthe course.

A politician should actually have his every word heeded, people are supposed to wait with vaited breath for the next utterance. Why would THEY not be rightly recorded at ALL times when at an international meeting, even if it's lunchtime.

Musicians are chased through supermarkets, bombarded at the airport, that's not the stage but we accept it because, as public, we are nosey; it's just the way it works.

So why woul dteh President of the United States and teh Prime Minister of England be afforded privacy when speaking during lunch at an international summit? Now, I know I have always said that Bush is as dumb as a bag of hammers...but THAT dumb?

I say fair play. He is not wrong, he's not a liar, he's expressing his TRUE feelings for once. It's actually quite refreshing to realize that he does have some red in his blood. I was wondering is he was from our planet for the longest time, perhaps an area 51 experiment in future president creation.

Now we know, he is a living, breathing human being, a completely mental one but one all the same.

by jdclyde

I have to agree, we do need to get Seria to stop this sh!t.

Is there anyone that doesn't agree with that?

by mickster269

But I agree with him 100%. I also think that it's much ado about nothing. So we overheard a conversation between two grown men at dinner. Big deal. If two guys (who seem to get along quite well) have to be formal with each other over a buttered roll... No wonder the world is so messed up.

Personally, I think the next time President Bush has a chance, he should say in a very loud voice:

"What we need to do is have all these guys knock this crap off. Everyone needs a Time Out, because they are all acting like a bunch of kids".

It's time for tough talk, not niceties. People are dying because everyone is afraid to say what needs to be said, what needs to be done.

Calvin Cooldige was a very dignified President. Hebert Hoover was rather dignified.

Dignity has nothing to do with being a good president.

by onbliss

I read some analysts opining that the hardline stance of Israel is Ehud Olmert's way of establishing himself. Looks like there is some amount of Israel's politics involved too.

Sadly, it is just another week in the middle-east.

edited: grammar

by jdclyde

Israel can do nothing right is seems, or at least that is the impression you get from the "analysts". Articles in the Detroit Free Press were very sympathetic to the poor palistinians.

Don't mention that it was the palistinians that were the aggressors, because that hurts the position.

Unfortunately for the palistinians, they are expendable and only there to unite the middle east against Israel. You will notice that none of the surrounding countries would take any of the "refugees".

by pigpen702

I am NOT a GWB fan. If his election depended on me, well he would be trashing another baseball team!

In this one instance I have some respect for the guy. Maybe he is in touch with realityu after all. I think his point was right on target, but could have been made with a more potent word than S***...

by j.lupo

the more I am convinced that was the nicest thing he could say at that moment. I believe all the really strong words came to mind and that was the most politic he could use.

by j.lupo

with a myth and the reality. I have watched where foreign congresses get into fist fights over heated debates, I have watched both local and international politicians curse and do all sorts of things.

News Alert, this isn't NEW. It has happened all throughout history. The myth of "presidential" is just that a myth. They need to becareful in today's society because our media mechanisms will twist and turn or suggest or imply all sorts of things from what is said or done or whatever.

Not to say thise things don't happen, but I have found that the reality is what we choose to believe from the small amounts of facts we are given. The only people that will ever know the truth about anything are those directly involved with it.

Cursing may not be considered polite by certain standards, but it has been a norm in speech for a very very long time in history.

by jdclyde

the only people that would have ANY problem with this are the rabid Bush haters anyways, so why would he care about it. There isn't anything they would ever admit that he has done right, and are just looking for things to complain about. Anything bad happens, anywhere in the world, and the haters get to squeal in delight at how it is Bush's fault. Really pathetic and transparent.

I hear much worse than that from the engineer that is in the office across the hall from me. All day long.

I guess the complainers are either full of sh!t or can go eat sh!t. :D

by faradhi

and say not all rabid bush haters get upset when a president cusses.

What amazes me, is that some of the same people who thought it was OK for WJC to get a hummer in the Oval Office, has an issue with bush saying sh!t.

--- edited to add----

That is really disingenuous. I don't really hate him. Hate implies I care one way or another. I just do not like many of his policies.

by faradhi

I am just that damn important.

I am a legend in my own mind. If you don't believe me, just ask me. I'll tell you.

by marileev9

So, after the US news picked up on the expletive on the late news I watched David Letterman he showed the GW "looking presidential." It was a video clip of President bush looking left, then right and left again.

This is the mass perception of the current American President. I think this is substantial. Presidents are in the end a statesperson, a representative who should always be "on." This is the business of running the country.

by onbliss

Definitely the kidnapping of the soldiers stirred up the present misery. The news network calls it as crisis. And for the people out there, it must be worst than misery/hell.

But both sides indulge in this kind of sparring. Unfortunately such incidents just push the moderates into the laps of the hardliners.

In my opinion, the other countries in the region need to step up, under the auspices of UN, and work towards a resolution. They have not done so in the last so many decades, time for the World to pressurize them.

by jdclyde

First of all, the UN will do nothing about anything, except maybe to try to come down on Israel over this.

Second, the other countries in the region WANT there to be unrest because it gives them a common enemy. It is the process of making a Muslim Super State. The only way to keep the different flavors of Muslims from killing each other is to give them a common enemy to kill first.

The rest of the world is too worried about losing oil to stand up to anyone in that region.

by onbliss

...or else it must be the heat :-)

Over the weekend, I saw few interesting maps of the occupied territories over a period of time. I will try to post them some time later tonight.

by jamesrl

The answer is : Both sides.

Before the soldiers were kidnapped, Israel had been railing against Hamas, who now control the Palestinian government. There was an explosion on the beach which killed a Palestinian family including women and children. Isreal denies responsibility, but had been shelling Gaza around that time.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/5066496.stm

Palestinians kidnapped an Israeli solider.

Israel invades Gaza with tanks, shells targets, destroys bridges, electric transmission. Civilians are killed.

Hezbollah - not directly affiliated with Palestinians - kidnaps two more soliders. Isreal retaliates, bombs and shells, innocents are killed. Hezbollah retaliates, starts sending rockets into Israel. Israel retaliates boming Beruit, killing innocents.

Not all Palestnians are terrorists. Keeping shelling Gaza and they all may become terrorists.

Not all Lebanese are Hezbollah supporters -not even a majority. Many of the innocents killed in Lebanon (and some in Palestine)are Christians. The Christians in Lebanon used to support the Israelis. Keep shelling them and they won't anymore.

Not quite true about other Arab nations taking in Palestinians. Kuwait had many as guest workers, but wouldn't grant them citizenship. Jordan has quite a few. The reason that they won't agree to them in large numbers is because if they did, Israel gets exactly what it wants.

Gaza is for all intents and purposes a prison. Isreal controls all checkpoints in, controls shipments of food and fuel. The palestinians are not free to work outside of Gaza unless they are one of the few with special permission, and there is no work in Gaza. Any wonder why they are not content?

I don't believe that there are simply two sides to this issue, one right, the other wrong. Israel treats the Palestinians worse than the aparteid regime in South Africa treated blacks there. I don't believe that the terrorists and suicide bombers from Palestine are helping their fellow countrymen either. They must share responsibility for the Israeli shells falling among their neighbours. Hezbollah is not supported by most of Lebannon, and certainly not by the Lebanese Government, who sought to push Syria out of all influence in Lebanon. Hezbollah get aid and weapons from Syria and Iran. But the Lebanese government is still weak and unable to kick Hezbollah out.

You have to look at these issues in a larger and longer historical context. If I looked at the American revolution from must one incident, I'd say that after the Boston tea Party the Americans rebelled over Tea taxes.

James

James

by jdclyde

if someone put a choke hazzard in your tea?

It was my understanding that before many of the bombings, Israel dropped fliers warning so civilians could get out? The attacks were the buildings where Hezbollah is, not civilian neighborhoods?

The majority of these unguided rockets from the palistinians HAVE been aimed at civilian neighborhoods.

Or did I mis-hear about this? Correct me if I am wrong, I have not been home much over the last week, so it is hard to keep up on it all.

Another question, if Gaza is so horrible, why did the palistinians want it so badly? All this fighting over what you equate to a prision?

by oz_media

I just read newpaper the other day that timlined it and showed how one mother of 4 children (that were killed during the attacks on Hezbollah)was returning to salvage anything she could from the hrubble that was her street. They also showed many other bombed out aparmnet-like buildings and residences.

[i]
"The Jerusalem Post reported in its Friday editions that the IDF was threatening to strike the Dahiya neighborhood of Beirut if Hezbollah rocket attacks on northern Israeli cities continued.

Israeli jets earlier this week targeted Hezbollah's headquarters in Beirut and the city's international airport, and the Israeli Air Force continued on Saturday and Sunday to conduct airstrikes on Beirut and other targets around Lebanon."[/i]

An international airport is a civilian building and what do they mean by "and other targets around Lebanon?" They blew up anything and everything, hopefully while hitting the intended/key targets also, just like America does.

I see it as a two sided conflict not an attack on one innocent party.

by danlm

Israel was attacked, and won. Including the land. All the Arab states attacked them. To winners go the spoils. Oh, they were wrong for protecting themselves and keeping the land to protect them selves. Excuse me.
Israel takes all its solders and settlements out of land that they had won in a war they didn't start. What thanks do they get, they get rocketed on a daily basis from Gaza and Lebanon. They did not move retaliate. They gave the Lebanese elected government a chance. What did this chance get Israel? More attacks, and then their soldiers
kidnapped.
By the article of the UN, all the little warlords(Hezbollah) were to disarm. Did they? No, they attacked Israel. No, I do not remember this UN article. I applies.
Israel has nothing to apologize for. They have been continuously attacked by Arab countries. And you wonder why they want a buffer zone? They have stepped up and left occupied lands and provided chances for democracy of the people to rule them selves. The people were lambs, and let the little war lords continue attacking Israel.
I hope Israel pounds the the Hezbollah into the ground. Israel unlike the Hezbollah will offer a chance for peace again once they feel safe. They will again provide the people a chance to rid them selves of the hard liners.
If you had rockets crashing into your country EVERY DAY, would you expect your country to turn the other cheek? After these repeated rocket attacks, you had soldiers who protect you every day from hostile nations at the border kidnapped. Would you want your government to turn the other cheek? I think not.
Israel is right in this, the Hezbollah is wrong. And the Lebanese people did not pressure the Hezbollah to disarm as the nations of the world that tried to intervene decreed. If the Lebanese people don't disarm them, then Israel will. And you know what, they have that right.
Again, I hope they drive them into the sea with no life boat.

Dan

by oz_media

Damn, all they need to do is fly you in, you have it all figured out.

[i]"Israel is right in this, the Hezbollah is wrong."[/i]

Quick stop the presses, gather the intelligence officers, droolin has it one the nose! And to think of all those peopl ebeing paid huge salaries to find solutions to these decade long conflicts!

Take your timeline and go back another 10 years or so. You are displaying a typically retalitaive mindset.

"Oh, they were wrong for protecting themselves and keeping the land to protect them selves."

Sure, and you were justified in attacking a country in the middle east because you were protecting yourselves to, from what we are yet to see, but you will believe that crap anyway.

Here's a little quiz; some legal fun

1) if someone walks up and punches you in the nose and then walks away, do you have a right to go and hit him back.

2) if someone walks up and punches you in the nose and then watches you grab your face in pain while staring and laughing at you, do you have a right to pick up a stick and bash him back?

3) if someone holds a gun to your head and you manage to wrestle it away from him, do you have the right to go and shoot him in self defense?

Your replies are too predictable but it will be a fun argument all the same, P.S. there are legal answers to each of these, that apply all over North America, not just state laws, so you can't pull the 'varies by state' cop out.

aclassic mentality in you rcase, not to worry I'm not singling you out, your feelings are extremely common, as I am sure we'll see if we do the exercise here.

by danlm

I feel Israel is justified in everything that they have done and are about to do based upon the past aggression that has been directed at them by previously mentioned parties. Civilized enough for you in this statement?
I feel the world is siding with this opinion and is giving Israel the time to do this, by the world nations not condemning Israel for this. They will condemn Israel after what they feel is an appropriate amount of time, but you do not see this occurring as of yet.
By your last post, correct me if I am wrong. That if this was to occur to you. You would feel justified, be damned what others think. In retaliating against the aggressor? Is that a correct assumption on my part?
With that said, I put in not so polite words that I would agree with you if you would do this. And that I felt that you should pound the snot out of the aggressor for the attacks against you.
Oz, I feel that Israel is an extremely small country that is surrounded by much larger, more populated and economically powerful neighbors that must strike back hard when it is attacked to assure its survival. That is where my opinion is from.
I'm 5 foot 7, and 160 pounds. I would pick up the biggest stick I could find if I was attacked and pound the living tar out the person that attacked me. Because, as I think Israel feels. Next time, I might not have the chance and I better do it right this time.

droolin
Sorry, I didn't address one of your issues with my last post Oz. I read more into your post then you just critizing my original post. The way I read your post, I felt that you totally disagreed with Israel having the right to protect themselves. I don't feel that's the case now, and I apologize for that assumption. Still think your wrong though, but that's ok.

by j.lupo

just a few points. If you would notice, my post indicated people should be allowed to have private conversations. At no time did I expressly say the President. :)

For the record, I can't stand the "paps". I believe that anyone who is in the public view should still be accorded the courtesy of some privacy. If they don't want to give a statement, if they want to just spend the day at the beach with their family, they (being actors, actresses, musicians, politicians, etc.) should be able to do so without someone waiting to ambush them.

I realize that consumers are part of the problem because consumers want to live their lives through the public figures. We want to pass judgement based on our own morals and values about others or hold them up to a higher standard that we want to reach. When public figures fall short of the pedistals we put them on, then we want to "slather" it all over for everyone to see.

It is a shame, but if we turn off the news, the media, don't buy those magazines, get involved to stop using those products, then and only then will the media MAYBE change to some other topic.

Hope this made sense, but I am going on several weeks of very limited sleep.

Edited to add: And you are right OZ it is a shame that this is the way we (society) treats our public figures.

by j.lupo

I forget. Given Cheney's health issues, I don't think he would survive very long as President if we did impeach Bush.

Personally, I prefer the straight talkers. That doesn't mean I am a fan of Bush, but I prefer it when people say it like it is. They don't have to be nasty, just honest. I think he was when he spoke his mind. I also don't think he was nasty about it. But that is me.

by j.lupo

but would be interesting if we could. First though BUSH has to go, then Cheney is a no brainer. Afaid I don't know much about Denny Hastert. Hmmmm. Wonder what he is like. I can't see Rice in as President though - kinda reminds me of the show Commander-in-Chief or whatever they call it.

by av .

I'm amazed he is even up to the job of VP. I swear he is probably bionic at this point after all his heart operations.

If Cheney was ever President, he would operate the entire government in secret, not just have certain secret programs like we do now. Those programs are so secret, even Congress doesn't know about them. You can certainly see Cheney's influence over the Bush presidency.

I think Bush was being honest and to the point about his feelings. Its risky to do it at a G8 Summit, but he pulled it off because he's folksy. I think it could be possible too, that maybe he wanted to be overheard and caught on tape so he left his microphone on.

by tweakerxp

You have to remember that EVERYTHING you write on the net is recorded somewhere. That is why employers are turning to Google to search the web for blogs and stuff to see what kind of person YOU REALLY ARE! I saw an article about a company that does this for businesses. They try and find everything you ever posted on the net to give the company an idea of who you are.

As far as Bush cussing.. Good, at least he's human. Everybody has cussed at one time or another. He is also in a no-win situation. No matter which party is in off they can't win, the OTHER side won't allow it. That is one job I would not have. I hope the media doen't make too much out of it, because we have WW3 lurking on our doorstep with the middle east.

by jdclyde

Please show how this is anything but a well known terroritst organization, that got its start by consoladating other terrorist organizations.

As for your 1,2,3, everyone has a right to be safe and secure. That means PREVENTING someone from being ABLE to come up and punch you in the first place. You don't have to stand there until your bloodied, first of all.

Second, if someone DOES walk up and punch you, you CAN call in law enforcement legally. As the UN is not in the business of protecting or defending countries from Muslims, they are not the organization to be called in. Enter military.

At no time do you have to do NOTHING. Israel called in their version of the cops and are doing the law enforcement, just like if you called a cop to resolve your dispute.

#3, if this person is a threat to yours or your families life, and you get the upper hand, you do not give them a "fair chance", you eliminate that threat to yours or your families lives.

If it was you or your kid that had that gun pointed at with full intent to kill you and/or your kid, if you got that gun away are you going to say "freeze" or are you going to fire that gun ASAP? If you say freeze like they do on TV and he doesn't freeze, then what? "Stop! or I shall say stop again!"?

by jamesrl

But Israel is going the extra mile.

To get at Hezbollah, who are concentrated close to the Israeli border, Isreal it bombing Beirut, a long way away. Not only is it attacking suspected terrorist targets, for good measure it is hitting the airport. Its is bombing targets in Beruit where inevitably innocent civilians are being killed. It is blockading all Lebanese harbours which may prevent terrorists from escaping, but also traps innocents from fleeing the country. It is destroying bridges so people are trapped in their villages. In Gaza they targetthe electrical facilities, and as a result hospitals have no power and civilians wounded in shelling will die. They also deliberatly go supersonic over gaza so that they create sonic booms and shatter windows.

Yesterday they hit a Lebanese Army barracks, the same army they agreed to work with to control the border and try and prevent terrorist raids.

Hezbollah and Hamas are evil. Israel, in a disproportionate response, is not saintly. They are pressuring the Lebanese Government, which only recently persauded Syria to leave Lebanon, by bombing them. The result will probably be that the Lebanese government will collapse and Syria will move back in. That won't make anything more peaceful in the region. And civilians, including Canadian citizens will die for it.

James

by jdclyde

because of the way it was reported as this horrible thing that Bush has done now.

There are just so many people that will stop at nothing, regardless the cost, to "get" Bush.

"The supporting documents were fraudulent, but the story was real" sound familiar to anyone?

I would say it was a setup that backfired, as the mindless masses really don't care if the President used such a tame word as sh!t, as many of them use much worse than that at work on a daily basis. It just showed the people that WERE making a big deal out of this to be as stupid and petty AND desparate as they really are.

by onbliss

You said "It just showed the people that WERE making a big deal out of this to be as stupid and petty AND desparate as they really are."

Maybe that is what "they" wanted :-). Say, in the event it was staged, the creators of the plan knew how people, comedians, bloggers would INITIALLY react. And they possibly also knew how people would view this after the dust settles down :-)

BTW, I did not read or see the incident being reported by the major news media in a negative manner. I did not follow too much on this incident. Even many of the non-Bush supporters at TR have taken it with a smile or so, to say.

This part of the Conspiracy Theory is brought to you by XYZ Co. :-) (I just hope there is'nt a XYZ Co.)

by jdclyde

that it would be news worthy internationally in the first place?

With everything going on in the world today, how does this rise to the top? Even for a day?

by onbliss

You said: "Please show how this is anything but a well known terroritst organization,[b] that got its start by consoladating other terrorist organizations.[/b]"

Can you elaborate on the part that I highligted, in the above statement?

by jdclyde

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hizbollah
(extract)
[b]Origins[/b]

Scholars differ on when Hezbollah came to be a distinct entity. Some organizations list the official formation of the group as early as 1982, (GlobalSecurity.org, 2005) whereas Diaz and Newman maintain that Hezbollah remained an amalgamation of various violent Shi?a extremists until as late as 1985 (Diaz & Newman, 2005, p. 55). Regardless of when the name came into official use, [b]a number of Shi?a groups were slowly assimilated into the organization, such as Islamic Jihad, Organization of the Oppressed on Earth and the Revolutionary Justice Organization [/b]. These designations are considered to be synonymous with Hezbollah by the US[22], Israel[23] and Canada[24]

----------------------------------
And it is not just US/Israel/Canda that recognise Hesbollah as the terrorists organiazation that it is.
------------------------------------------
http://www.answers.com/topic/hezbollah

On March 10 2005, in a non-binding resolution, the European Parliament voted overwhelmingly (473 in favor, 8 against, 33 abstain) branding Hezbollah in whole as a terrorist organization, but as of yet, the EU has not endorsed this resolution[citation needed]. The resolution stated that the "Parliament considers that clear evidence exists of terrorist activities by Hezbollah. The (EU) Council should take all necessary steps to curtail them"[12]. The EU has also decided to block Hezbollah's Al-Manar television from European satellites in order to enforce European regulations against "incitement to racial and/or religious hatred".

-----------------------------------

Even the ever useless UN knows they are terrorists, but will do nothing more than lip service.
-----------------------------------

http://www.answers.com/topic/united-nations-security-council-resolution-1559

United Nations Security Council Resolution 1559 was a resolution adopted by the United Nations Security Council on September 2, 2004. It called upon Syria to end its military presence in Lebanon by withdrawing its forces and to cease intervening in internal Lebanese politics. The resolution also called on all Lebanese militias (including Hezbollah) to disband.

by onbliss

..but, I thought you would shed some light on the reason for their formation too :-) that being opposing the 1982 invasion of Lebanon...

My point being, each side has been blaming the other for decades. There is an uneasy calm now and then, and then skirmishes break out because of the underlying unresolved differences. Instead of the world siding with just one of the parties, the World should unite and chastize both parties and force them to come a conlcusion.

Don't we - the World - that make the UN [b]appear[/b] useless?

by onbliss

It is news when a man bites the dog, this incident was little unusual and hence caught the attention of the world, especially with the unique importance USA and Bush enjoys in the world. And, because of USA's involvement in Iraq in the last few years.

by jamesrl

Conrad Black, a very conservative Canadian, who abandoned his Canadian citizenship to take a British Peerage (Lord Black of Crossharbour) and made his fortune with newspapers (London Telegraph, Jerusalem Post, Chicago Sun Times, National Post (Canada)).

But Conrad Black thinks that FDR was the best president since Lincoln, and the best this century bar none.

James

by jdclyde

From the same Wiki site, just further down. Hezbollah wants the complete destruction of Israel and has stated they have no right to exist. Their expressed goal is to create an islamic state.

[b]"Hezbollah supports the destruction of the state of Israel[47] and co-operates with other militant Islamic organizations such as Hamas in order to promote this goal."

"The conflict with Israel is viewed as a central concern. This is not only limited to the IDF presence in Lebanon. Rather, the complete destruction of the State of Israel and the establishment of Islamic rule over Jerusalem is an expressed goal."[/b]

Hamas and Hezbollah will not stop with a cease fire until all of the isrealies are dead, end of story. They are a disease that has to be handled as such. I know I threw a lot at you with the last post, but did you read where the UN DID order these recognised terrorist groups to disarm and disband? Of course the UN will not do anything to enforce their resolutions, and complain when anyone else does (like when the US DID do something about the many existing resolutions against Iraq).

by onbliss

..the part you are referring - disarment of those groups. Also I read about it yesterday, when I was trying to retrieve those links for the maps that I promised you. I ended up re-reading the history of the conflict. It took me thousands of years down the time line. I just had to shake my head at [b]the love of religion and land[/b] held by humans. I might be guilty on some of the charges too. Emotions. Emotions. Emotions.

As outsiders, we can not afford to pick the problems from a given point in history. The other side is just going to shout "Unfair". Countless accords have been signed and trampled. People are tortured and killed inspite of accords, treaties, ceasefires and whatnot.

by tonythetiger

Every Israeli is born with a target on his or her back. The extinction of Israel is the goal of many, if not most Arabs. Nothing Israel does now in self-defense, NOTHING!!!, is an over-reaction. It's going to get ugly... and it needs to! They've simply run out of 'other cheeks' to turn.

by jdclyde

you can not rationalize with unrational people.

The terrorists that run Iran and Syria, as well as the Hamas and Hezballa, have shown that it is the extinction of the Isrealies that they are after, and the creation of their global Islamic state. There is no room for the Isrealies, or us, in that world, and our turn will come if they are allowed to spread like the cancer they are.

And before you get stupid, no, I did not say all muslims. You know exactly the ones that are to blame so quit making pathetic excuses for them.

by oz_media

First of all, the fact that THIS thread was posted when it was is completely irrelevant. Late to the party? YOu responded to a post I made in another thread stating that the information was not available at the time. It WAS, of COURSE it was, that's where I got it from, it was common world news by the tim eI posted that thread.

If you like, I can backtrack and give you the posts where you claim as much, but I think you may be able to remember for yourself.

Your comments were posted in another thread I started where the news was readily available all over the net, TV and printed media at the time of post.

I posted the thread, how can you claim proof wasn't available when the thread was posted? You can't...thank you.

As for "getting on you" you seem to have forgotten, you posted a reply to a thread I started. You clamied you were right but couldn't possibly be so, even NOW you continue to imply the information was not available when you replied in the thread I started.

I don't think you really know what's up and down anymore, that's okay, I didn't expect too much more.

Cheers.

by oz_media

I was replying to nother posters comments, there was a reason for teh post I shared. It was purely a recollection of reports, not aan opinion.

by oz_media

Making excuses for them? Who am I making excuses for? What pewrsonal opinion did I offer? None. Thank you, sit down, have a Coke and a smile and STFU.

by oz_media

I don't know what your post was about, I didn't even go back and read my own, there' sno pointsometimes not when there is no rational discussion anyway.

1) You woul dbe the assailant and he could sue you

2) You would be th eassailant and he could sue you

3) You would be the assailant and he could sue you

When you remove the gun, he is no longer a threat, YOU are armed he is not. Knees, Elbows, licks on the nape of the neck or open mouth kissing is pure assault at that point. Funny how so many Americans think they can do whatever they want when they FEEL threatened without actually determining the reality of the threat.

by danlm

1). Israel is attacked by multiple nations and wins. They also ended up occupying land. They should give it back so they can be attacked again. Is that what your saying.

2). If someone walks up and punches you in the nose and laughs, do you have a right to pick up a stick and hit him back. yes, and that's what the Arab hardliners have been doing since Israel was established. All Israel has done is protect itself.

3). If they hold a gun to my head, and I wrestle it away. Do I have the right to shoot them. I would, cause they have shown that they are out to kill me.

Israel is fighting for its survival, it's as simple as that. Everything you have said makes no sense.
If it was you oz, would you have given the land back after they attacked you?????
If it was you Oz, would you just let rockets rain down on your neighborhood?
If it was you Oz, and they took your family. Would you have turned away and said I must be wrong and they are right.

BS. Your so full of crap in this argument it's unbelievable. Israel is protecting itself and trying to clear out the freaken hard liners.

The argument here isn't about United States, even though your trying to make it so. It's about a country that is repeatably attacked by all the nations that are at its borders and its right to defend itself.

Or do you just forget about the history of the attacks. 6 day war, who started it Oz?
When Israel was granted nationhood by the United Nations. Who attacked it Oz?

Or, do you feel they have no right to exist and feel that they should be wiped off the face of the earth as Iran has said, and also the Hezbollah.

Like I said Oz, this argument I totally disagree with you on. And I do read all your posts.

droolin
And no, I will not lower myself to saying stfu. Cause, you always present your arguments well and I do want to see what you have to say.

by oz_media

While offering an fairly impartial comment by simply questioning someone else conclusions, I am instantly targeted as defending Hezbollah? I actually didn't offer personal opinion on Hezbollah at all, I simply looked deeper into someone elses comments. Just because they are Anti-Hebollah, it doesn't mean they are correct. No I am NOT agreeing with Hezbollah, I am NOT defending Hezbollah, I am merely scrutinizing someone else's rashly conclusive comments. Someone that feels they have decades of terrorist actions summed up in a quick sentence. Remember we only see issues after they become news, not HOW they become news.

No wonder nothing makes sense to you other than you own words.

by oz_media

"[i]Instead of the world siding with just one of the parties, the World should unite and chastize both parties and force them to come a conlcusion."[/i]

Be careful, being impartial is the same as defending Hebollah, apparently. You must claim it is anything but a terrorist organization that must be stopped, hopefully with the assistance of the US military's freedom fighters.
Reminds me of that old Crest commercial;

Cavity creeps:"We make holes in teeth"
Crest Cavity Fighters: [wailing crest siren]CREEEEST, CREEEST "CREST CAVITY FIGHTERS TO THE RESCUE!!!"

by oz_media

1). [i]Israel is attacked by multiple nations and wins. They also ended up occupying land. They should give it back so they can be attacked again. Is that what your saying.[/i]
No, please show me the exact comment where I said Israel should give back the land, in fact, show me a single comment where I offered an opinion towards EITHER party being in the right. I haven't, don't knock yourself out hunting. You most definitely got it wrong.

2). [i]If someone walks up and punches you in the nose and laughs, do you have a right to pick up a stick and hit him back. yes, and that's what the Arab hardliners have been doing since Israel was established. All Israel has done is protect itself.[/i]

Answer again is NO. You may feel justified in doing so, you may well want to ( in fact I most definitely WOULD) but it does make you the assailant. PICKED up teh stick means that your attacker is now unarmed and thus no longer a threat. YOU are the one charged now.

3). [i]If they hold a gun to my head, and I wrestle it away. Do I have the right to shoot them. I would, cause they have shown that they are out to kill me.[/i]

Again, once the immediate and definite threat is removed you have no violent recourse that can be justified. Law sucks doesn't it? Fortunately law is not based on morals and feelings.

Was this anything to do with Hamas or Hazbullah, no not in any way whatsoever. I was merely pointing out the ignorance of a common, pigheaded mindset. So common that you shar it also.

Here's where you lose all logic and ability to reason:
[i]Israel is fighting for its survival, it's as simple as that. Everything you have said makes no sense.
If it was you oz, would you have given the land back after they attacked you?????
If it was you Oz, would you just let rockets rain down on your neighborhood?
If it was you Oz, and they took your family. Would you have turned away and said I must be wrong and they are right.

BS. Your so full of crap in this argument it's unbelievable. Israel is protecting itself and trying to clear out the freaken hard liners. [/i]

Hey, YOU just had a converstaion with yourself, I said NOTHING not even vaguely reminiscent of ywhat you just claim I said. You even created your own objection to your own argument, talk about arguing for arguments sake. Get help! I didn't say ANYTHING like that at all, that's your overly active imagination at work on that one.

I think you need to sit down and stop creating your own conclusions, you are only creating issues for yourself.

Instead of creating your own little theory based on straight forward comments, try just reading the post next time. Again, nothing (not one little iota of a comment) YOU'VE said I said, did I actually say.

I could say you called me an a**hole and threatened to shoot me, it makes about as much sense as your comments to me.

nobody is making thi sabout America, not even I, I did note it reminded me of America's attitude though.

by mjwx

of what was said doesnt lie in the language but in the content of the message. I'll take out the swearing to emphasise what I mean.

"They need to get syria to get hezbollah to stop doing this".

I'm going to go out on a limb here Dan and guess that youre an American. I realise that the US and other nations (AU being mine) have different views on profanity but this is not I am trying to discuss.

Some of the not-so-friendly-with-the-US nations in the world are going to see this as anything between an insult and a direct attack. That's my point in short.

But as I said its not the fact he said it that is the problem, its the fact he got caught.