Discussion Locked

Notice: Short site outage possible around 4pm EST today 6/28

0 helpful
40 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We'll be deploying new Alerts functionality today. There could be spotty feature failures in
Community for approximately 30 minutes during this upgrade.

We're changing the system that handles subscriptions to Questions and Discussions. This should be seamless for you, meaning that you shouldn't lose any subscriptions or have email alerts service interrupted.

You will notice that you'll begin receiving updates with a different look and feel. We'll be improving that template soon, so any suggestions for formatting, etc. will be considered.

You'll see a new "edit subscriptions" link on Discussions/Questions to which you've subscribed. When you choose to edit, you'll have new options for how you receive updates. HTML or text, combined or individual notices, hourly, daily, etc. The default one-click subscription for threads will be HTML, daily, combined alerts. To learn more about the options, check out the bottom of this page: http://nl.com.com/rss_mgmt.sc?brand=techrepublic

Of course, you'll still be able to see your list of "Questions subscribed to" and "Discussions subscribed to" by using the filters at right on your My Forum Posts page: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5268-11518-0.html . Notice that an "Edit Subscriptions" link has been added to the bottom of these lists.

Please report any bugs/weirdness in this thread.

Thanks!

40 replies

by sleepin'dawg

The Alerts boondogle is just the tip of the ice berg.
People complain but little or nothing is done to adress those complaints. There has been an influx of a lot of new members and with them have come an undue number of perverts and trolls. There has got to be some better way of handling these little pervs and idiots than what is currently being done.

Also, while we`re at it, why is it now necessary to run Java scripts??? It didn`t used to be that way and it has driven away many of the old regulars who contributed heavily on the technical and creative fronts. Why is there no spell checker capability yet??? Okay you people supposedly sorted out the problems with Tech Q&A but your replacement isn`t that much better and whioever came up with the dumbass thumbs up business should have his shoved up where the sun doesn`t shine. He can then change back and forth between that one and the one he sucks. What genius thought that up??? Amazing!!! The proper thing would have been nothing at all or you could have left Tech Q&A as it was and eliminated the sillyassed points business.

by hal 9000

If I remember correctly I had something like 61% of my answers unrated. Granted I know that I'm incompetent but I can not believe that 61% of the questions that I answered where asked by people who where afraid of hurting my feelings. :D

With the change came a limit to the number of questions that could be asked and I've even answered a question that may have been in a discussion on why this person couldn't ask any more questions. All that they had to do was go back to the questions asked and rate them even if they rejected every answer it would have been OK but instead they seemed to think that this was an unnecessary imposition on them and they moved on. I suppose to a place where they didn't have to exert what little Grey matter that they had in the first place.

I can understand the reasoning of why TR made the change and what was hoped to be achieved but it hasn't happened and short of holding a firearm to the person asking a questions head I don't know what else can be done.

Most will not even reply to a request for more information so they make it impossible to answer their questions. There was one recently that read

[b]How do I setup a Router?[/b] or [b]I have a 2,000 square foot floor what type of router do I need?[/b] No mention of any make or model and you are supposed to tell them how to setup something, or the person with the 2,000 square foot floor what did they want a WiFi access point or a wired router to connect to the Internet.

Unfortunately these seem to be the normal now and not the exception. Another one that I really liked was one person claiming to be a LAN Administrator asking for a step by step list on how to connect a new workstation to their server. I must be getting old as I see all of these questions as either students attempting to cheat or End Users wanting the [b]Big Bucks[/b] claiming that they are more than what they actually are.

Col

by absolutely

...even if it's Standard Time. I just giggle at the phrase "Daylight Savings Time", as if you can store up the daylight, or as if anybody is really prevented by the physical clock on the wall from adjusting their non-work schedule to enjoy more daylight.

What a waste of the thought process.

by deepsand

Return to the prior format, in all respects.

A 72K tome, with full text of Posts, is [b]not[/b] an "Alert."

Absent the Title of the Discussion/Question, the Identity of the Poster, and a clear & obvious delineation between items, it's virtually useless.

Also, lose the non-editorial content; it's useless clutter that serves only to take up storage space on our e-mail accounts.

by captbilly1eye

But the new Alert emails have no functional purpose in their current state.

Reviewing and subsequently checking updates to subscribed posts now takes many times the effort it did previously. The result is a major time-waster rather than a time-saver.

Sorry Beth, as a relatively new member, I have tried to stand back and wait for the more 'seasoned' members to raise their voice. But I just couldn't sit this one out any longer.

The alerts need to include the title of the post and the name of the person that made the most recent post in order to be of any value.

I can appreciate how it may have been perceived that having the entire post included in the Alert email would be of benefit. Unfortunately, it makes no sense without seeing the rest of the thread it came from and only serves to make the Alert email laboriously long. For that reason, the previous format was considerably more functional.

by deepsand

Nearing the 3 yr. mark, as you are, makes you closer to a veteran than a newcomer.

The only reason that more of the "seasoned" members have no posted here is owing to the fact that:

1) Mention of the change to Alerts was buried in Beth's notice re. an anticipated outage;

2) Said outage has passed; and,

3) As many of us have long lamented, to no avail, the churning of the "All" listing in the Forum area results in new Discussions quickly vanishing from view.

Bottom line: no one's been posting here because this discussion was both invisible & of seemingly little import. That is why apotheon & jdclyde started there own discussions re. the Alerts problems.

by captbilly1eye

although I shoulda said 'relatively new [i]active[/i] member. I joined back then but did not become active until the past few months.

also when I said I was waiting, I meant more that I was waiting for a larger response in relation to the Alert email changes.

Anyway... thanks for the heads-up.

by beth blakely

I apologize that you hate the new format. Your criticisms are valid. The improvements will be coming next week as I and the person who needs to change them are both out on vacation right now.

Again, my sincere apologies to you all for messing up something that was working for you. Hopefully, after we change the mails back to more like they were, you'll enjoy the flexibility the new system provides.

Thanks for your patience.

by jdclyde

is there a way for the system to look at our selected option on how we choose to receive our emails? I know I am not alone in preferring to NOT receive HTML emails, nor of having to reselect TEXT emails everytime we subscribe.

Thanks, and enjoy your vacation.

by deepsand

There was a time when a Discussion tagged as "feedback," or, under the previous incarnation of the site, one in the "TRI" ("TR Insiders;" by invitation only) category, would bring a relatively quick response.

Now, it seems that the only way to get their attention is via e-mail.

Perhaps they've grown weary of our ganging up on them in public.

by deepsand

just plain dumb.

So too was the failure to require that the supplicant accept peer-to-peer messages.

Your observations re. the presence of a lot of students looking for others to do their work for them is spot on.

Oh, almost forgot. I got the same PM that you did re. choosing a PhD thesis. As I've been away from academia for a while, I'll allow that there are things that have changed that I'm not aware of; but, did they really do away with the Thesis Advisor?

by absolutely

post to "Discussions", clogging both areas with inapplicable content.

I can see HAL9000's point about valid reasons for the TR management to *try* some of the new formats, names, etc. being discussed here, but I think it's perfectly clear that most, if not all of the recent changes have been for the worse.

by deepsand

who actively sought our input, and then implemented something quite different from what was suggested.

This is not to say that they necessarily discounted our input, as some of what they proposed was close to some of our suggestions. More likely, I think, is the case that they themselves were ignored by TPTB.

by jdclyde

Isn't the whole point of the alerts to get people to come back to get more hits on TR? Why on earth would I NEED to come back if I have already read everything? ( unless I felt compelled to reply, which as they have stated, most members don't )

While the notices were not pretty before, they had exactly what you needed.
- The name of the discussion,
- who did the posting,
- the title of the post.

Remember the KISS rule. Keep it simple stu....

by hal 9000

So that you didn't constantly open up items that you have read previously or worse still something that you posted.

Col

by deepsand

[u]But[/u], it is [u]machine dependant[/u].

Ditto for the Updates pages under My Workspace.

by deepsand

To expect that the Ad content in the new "Alerts" will compensate for the loss of page views is sheer nonsense.

Someone at TR seems to have become enamored with RSS; I've just noticed a reference in one of my newsletters to its now being available via RSS. No thanks.

by hal 9000

The last Alert here was 128K and is full of junk that is impossible to open well at least the first 20 or so listings are as that is as far as I've actually got down the list.

I tried a couple of days ago to change the frequency that I got notified and after changing 1 Listing it went back to asking for my User Name/Email Address whatever & Password but the frequency of notifications hasn't changed.

I'll have to look at adding things to My Workspace and trying to access the site that way, pity that I learned to procrastinate many years ago and never do today what I can put off till next year. :^0

Col

by captbilly1eye

The last five I have received were over 100kb.
Since they are pretty much worthless in their present format, I set up an Outlook filter rule that puts them automatically in the Junk folder. :)

If I had gone to the trouble of setting all the alerts to 'Hourly', I'd have a total of about 20MBs of 'em just in the past week.

by jdclyde

Back when you could click on a heading and only see questions that were related to the category AND were current.

Because there isn't a standard guide for tagging, it is less than ideal.

I greatly miss the categories, at least for the questions.

by hal 9000

now it's less than ideal and when you click on a question it can be almost anything and the title doesn't give much of a clue with many questions.

Though to be fair I tend to use the [b]Browse By Tag[/b] option of the right hand side of the screen but here I'm stuck to using a Windows Machine with Java Scripting enabled, not my favorite means of doing something but as they have enough security in place things are fairly safe I think. :D

For some reason I have to bring in Windows Only boxes and when I use a Live Linux to break Passwords they go crazy as they think that I've loaded Linux onto their system. :^0

It may only save a few minutes with most machines but I'm always scared that I'll get one with EFS running and trash the Encryption Key using the easy method and then have to recover the data. That's both time consuming and not my idea of fun.

Col

by deepsand

Now, it's hit or miss; most often, hit [u]and[/u] miss.

I've given up on browsing the Questions forum. I've confined myself to viewing the Questions listings on the Forums page.

Oh, well, it's not like I've nothing else to do; in fact, this season, I've gotten a mere 2 Violation notices from the Township re. my lawn!

by absolutely

paid subscription content, until the site change. Come to think of it, now that the Questions are so degraded, I've recently bought more books from local bookstores than usual. I wonder if the strategy of the Management was intended to convince me to buy their content? If so, it almost worked. I started buying more, of something else.

by jdclyde

they are usually so basic, great for intro stuff, but rarely any real meat for a more advanced user.

I used to hit that a lot, when I myself, was a beginner.

It used to be almost a game to try to beat some of the big boys at getting an answer in first. Game over. Sure, we don't have to deal with the number of unrated, but this has been a huge price to pay to "fix" that. The cure was worse than the initial aliment.

by deepsand

At the moment, my Alerts are Balkanized, owing to my futile attempts at using the RSS preference settings screen. Not only is having to reset each item individually one royal pain in the ass, but some mysteriously "un-reset" themselves, with the result that there are now at least [u]8 different setting[/u]:

1) HTML, Consolidated, Daily
2) HTML, Consolidated, Hourly
3) HTML, Individual, Daily
4) HTML, Individual, Hourly
5) Text, Consolidated, Daily
6) Text, Consolidated, Hourly
7) Text, Individual, Daily
8) Text, Individual, Hourly

I shudder to think what a HTML, Consolidated, Daily Alert might weigh in at, if all where so set.

by deepsand

Given the great difficulty of locating "old" posting activities using TR's functions, an archive of the alerts has served me well.

Now, with Alerts weighing in at 20x their previous size, storing them is no longer economically feasible.

by hal 9000

Some of the listings in the Alert.

Apparently it includes posts which have been removed from the various threads so they get pulled but still listed in the Alert so Steffi your [b]Tuppence Post[/b] remains. :D

Col

by deepsand

Are you saying that the percentage of Questions that have their Answers rated has increased?

I ask, 'cause that's not been my experience.

by hal 9000

If anything the number of unrated answers has skyrocketed. I don't know what the stats are now but on the old system I used to have something like 61% of answers unrated but now I think that it would be closer to 95%.

OH I've had one accepted today out of about 60 that I've submitted answers for over the past few days so things have improved slightly instead of 100% unrated questions for the last week or so I think that here have been 2 accepted none rejected because I might burst into tears and have hurt feelings. :D

OH well only one to go to reach my desired number of 666 and then I can start to play up. :^0

Col

by jdclyde

so it doesn't MATTER if you get rated or not.

And I think I have gotten two "thumbs up" since the change, so I am batting about 98% ignored/unrated.

Can't enforce something? Ignore and downplay it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.