NT or Novell that is the Question?
Novell 4.X is our current NOS, we are looking
to use NT as a replacement(not windows2000)on all new sites....
I would like your opinion, pro's & con's on
NT versus Novell...
Cheers
Steve
Networks
Novell 4.X is our current NOS, we are looking
to use NT as a replacement(not windows2000)on all new sites....
I would like your opinion, pro's & con's on
NT versus Novell...
Cheers
Steve
by fgarber
by mengeorge
by pallan
If I'm reading your post correctly you're expecting to use NT4, since you specifically say you won't be using 2000. Keep in mind that when Windows XP (whistler) is realeased, you'd be left without support of any kind.
I suggest making your decision between Windows 2000 or NetWare 5.1. Either that or wait until later this year and choose between WinXP and Netware 6.
Quite frankly, from the amount of info you've provided, I don't see how someone could give you a non-biased opinion either way.
by saffle
it depends on the size of your group. If you have a small group NT is fine. If your group is larger, then go Novell. Nothing beats NWADMIN when it comes to ease of managment when you have hundereds of users.
Also Novells Groupwise is a very good emial, calender program.
It's hard to answer such non-specific question. We don't know what are these servers used for. If file and print servers, I would stay with Novell. Why?
1) Easier to manage and you probably have planty of experience with this system.
2) If youwill have to migrate to newer version (from NW 4.x to 5.x, or NT4.0 to Win2K) it will be easier with Novell, because for admins not much changes. Basically NDS stays almost the same, only there is something diffrent in server boxes.
With NT, you will first setup domain infrastructure and then (when migrating one day to Win2K) you will have to change it to Active Directory structure. It's not wise to use Win2K without ADS, you will loose many advantages.
3) I belive that Nw 4.x (and even more5.x) has much better performance than WinNT.
4) NDS is MUCH more scalable than NT domain structure, it is also much easier to administer globally. Of course if you will have separate sites, it looks like it is easier to manage small domain, than small NDS tree, but I think, one day you will have to connect all these sites. And it is much cheaper to control everything from one place.
5) It's easy to manage your workstations with NDS and ZEN Works for Desktops. For NT there is SMS but it's notso powerful.
Of course NT also have some advantages, but I usually think about MS product as good application platform. Eventually I would consider going for NT as server platform but with NDS (NDS for NT) as a directory structure for managing it and integrating into existing network infrastucture.
Please, take into account that I'm NetWare specialist (and only MCP for NT 4.0). In my company we are using NT as application platform and NetWare for file and print servers and other servicesfor managing workstations and infrastucture (DNS,DHCP,caching).
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending