mjohnson,
Go back to all of your workstations and re-enable serever services and netlogon, they do serve purposes in the network. The TCP/IP, you need that protocol if the network is connected to the internet but for a peer-to-peer Microsoft network, all you need is Netbeui.
I strongly suggest that you back in the control panel and network and re-check the services, re-install or re-enable what you had disabled and it may be necessary for you to repeat the process.
Regarding the SP6, depending on what you have applicationwise, I suggest that upgrade to SP6a since SP6 is too buggy and you'll find all the documentations in the Microsoft's Homepage or Knowledge Base.
The Option Pack is for Internet or IIS and Transaction related services, install them if you think that you really need them.
The LAN modem, if its configured correctly, IRQ setting, connection type, etc,etc, you should have no problem at all.
Here's a little ckecklist of what you should chck:
Computer name
Workgroup name
Network serv