ObamaCare: It's not about medical care; it's about control over your life
This is page 8 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 8 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jfuller05
by tonythetiger
[i]Whenever liberals can't dispute the facts they usually resort to the "Limbaugh" or "Beck" comments.[/i]
... play the race card.
by tonythetiger
[i]if it is that someone is in a lower income bracket lead them to make bad choices, or is it bad choices in life that lead them to a lower income bracket? [/i]
First, I think you're assuming that "higher income" is everyone's goal, or that they made a "bad choice" by not having it as a goal.
Second, luck, fate, coincidence, all could play a role. But that in itself is not an excuse to burden others by force.
Third, bad actions by others could play a part, and if so, those precise bad actors, and nobody else, should be made accountable.
by jmgarvin
Our Founding Fathers are brought up with NO context or history.
Here, I'll start.
Our Founding Fathers clearly stated they wanted health care for all.
Nothing to debate as it's a statement of pure conjecture.
by jfuller05
Just one source that would be worth your time.
W. Cleon Skousen, The 5,000 Year Leap, published originally in 1981. Copyrighted 1991 and 2006, National Center for Constitutional Studies.
Their cumulative understanding of the principles of sound government for the new nation was distilled into 28 Basic Principles which these remarkable men believed could change the world. Those principles were presented two centuries later in the book I cited above.
The 7th principle of sound government outlined the book states, "The proper role of government is to protect equal rights, not provide equal things."
edit: Another good book is: Larry Schweikart and Michael Allen, A Patriot's History of the United States
by notsochiguy
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100412/ap_on_re_us/us_tea_party_militia
I don't think people are crying 'socialism' anymore; I think they've graduated to 'totalitarianism'.
by jmgarvin
The reality is unless we dig up our Founding Fathers and make them zombies with an agenda to eat our brains and also impart to us their intent, we can only decide on what we think was their intention...hence the difference of opinion.
Just because you want it to be fact does not make it so.
They imparted their intent in precisely the manner you impart yours here: in words.
Does eating your own words make you a zombie?
by oz_media
But, Americans feed on fear, they align due to fear and create separation due to fear, fear fuels America, always has and always will.
Socialism, is so tightly related to communism, and those damn Japs and Ruskies of the worlld wars. It is engrained in people to the point thta they use the terms loosely to project fear by associating it with former governments known to control teh people, and that is simply the opposite of what America stands for. United but divided, one for all and all for themselves.
Same old story, no big suprise. Like when child regrets his sibling being the one getting presents on a birthday, Americans feel that nobody else should be given something they aren't given too. While people without affordable health care get a hand up now, those that have paid exorbitant fees for health care seem to prefer doing so rather than paying less and seeing others get health care too.
It's laughable, but it will die down once teh fear is over and they can project fear towards something or someone else instead. I think it is such a common mindset for many that most don't even realize it and simply can't fathom it, yet the reality is so clear and obvious to others.
by ansugisalas
It'd be understandable, if it weren't for the fact that health-care-for-all has beneficial effects on the economy that trump any possible tax cut.
The poor generate a lot of wealth, and if they're all performing poorly because they can't afford to go to a doctor, then a large chunk of that wealth goes ungenerated.
Greed too should motivate health reform, even if basic compassion for the fellow human doesn't.
by oz_media
It's not like it's just teh poor that are benefitting here. There are millions of Americans who work hard at more than oen job but STILL can't make ends meet to pay hundreds each month for care. A good friend was teh son of a woman who worked three jobs, was educated and hard working. Raised three sons on her own since when they were quite small. But he told me how they would make their own casts and a guy on the street was good at setting breaks for them. Another local woman took care of stitches for people in the neighbourhood.
His mon worked and paid taxes, but with the insanely high costs of treatment, she just couldn't afford insurance premiums.
As for those who don't work, most spend a great deal of their checks at stores and pay countless taxes on booze and cigarrettes too. The 'haves' are always whining as if someone is stealing from them and that they shouldn't pay taxes for anything that helps others but not them. It's just the typical, self centered BS that reduces America's strength and divides the nation.
I've hear their excuses here for years, 'I shouldn't have money taken from me and given to someone who didn't earn it' being the most common one, but they are just stupid excuses that would be completely different if the shoe was on the other foot.
by puppybreath
by notsochiguy
OFFICIAL MEMO
From: US Government
TO: Puppybreath
We're trying to keep the secret that the health care bill was really a mandatory insurance bill.
Next you'll tell people that the mortgage rescue bill was really a foreclosure delay bill!
Please cease and desist the use of common sense immediately; as it has no bearing in the governance of this nation.
by oz_media
Regulate companies in a free capitalistic society? Would never happen.
Just the mere mention of regulating the medical industry would have been laughed out of congress. They either take over control or have to let it run free, I couldn't imagine the level of patriotic hysteria around here if they started to price cap the industry. Face it, it simply wouldn't happen and things would stay the same and then continue to get worse as the industry celebrated their victory by again raising prices while waving a middle finger at government.
by puppybreath
by oz_media
aI mentioned regulating/price capping the health care costs a few years back, I was labasted from all direction by PO'd americans saying they don't live in a socialist country where the government can price cap free enterprises. It was instantly and absolutely impossible and against the Constitution and everything Americans stand for(again).
Of course, now it is common sense. Sure, it would fly like a lead fart.
by puppybreath
You can lower costs without regulating the medical industry.
Two that come to mind are tort reform and providing financial assistance to medical students.
I'd rather spend billions on educating and training the next generation of doctors than giving insurance companies millions of new customers that are forced to buy their products whether they want/need them or not. Especially when you consider that the new bill does nothing to limit premium increases.
So, lower the risk of million dollar lawsuits for frivilous claims to the doctor and increase the pool of available doctors, and costs would go down on their own.
I'm sure there's even more possibilities if someone researched it. But I guess it depends if your real goal is helping citizens with their healthcare concerns.
by tonythetiger
[i]Anyway...don't assume to think you are the model of determination and efficiency for providing assistance.[/i]
the model for determining who I WANT to help!
Do you let anyone else determine which charities you donate to?
by oz_media
The other day I watched a National Geographic special on Guns in America.
It was interesting, hough initially somewhat the same old issue and left me at a point of no decision.
The 'problem' has been left too long to reign in a regulate/control, so now it either has to be all or nothing.
I don't have a problem with the right to bear arms, Canadians have that right too (thought it has been masked and covered up with federal legislation, we initially adopted British Rule and we thus adopted a right to bear arms). On a per capita basis, Canadians have more guns than Americans, only one on four Americans legally has a gun.
(there is actually segue coming up here)
Tightening gun laws (even more definitive record and background checks seem to to rile lawful owners, for some reason), yet most illegally used guns are stolen from such people, catch 22.
However, despite the gang shootings and wide use of illegal guns for crime, the majority of homicides by handgun in the US are between couples (man/woman, woman/woman, man/man etc) who legally own guns.
the time where something relevant can be done, to see results in a short time, is LONG gone and activists from both sides are so radical that nothing will be done, just more and more people will die.
The same has happened in health care. Pharmaceuticals is trillion dollar industry in the US, it supports the biggest corporations, politicians, hospitals and doctors nationwide. Health Care professionals are 'bribed' to "sell" a certain drug, where all a doctor should have to do is consider the best interests of the patient. Payola in the music industry is now illegal, though still exists in some forms, but in health care, such 'payola' has fueled it to one of the most lucrative industries in America.
Regulation, especially government regulation is simply not acceptable to most, and I mean MOST, Americans. Costing a trillion dollar industry, millions in lost revenue is not going to happen. Politicians would NEVER be elected for a second term, it would be their quickest demise.
Capping the health care costs would also only help those who can already afford it, the cost has to be forcefully reduced, NOW, and not some time down the road when another president can quickly reverse such changes to support his own best interests and supporters.
If this was done 100 years ago, you'd all be just quietly getting on with your lives and we wouldn't be hearing such complaints about personal taxes etc. As it came so late, to a country that, face it, simply does not normally accept change of ANY sort (It's unconstitutional after all), it has raised hackles of those who didn't vote for Obama and the media is having a field day with it.
Face it, your own health care costs lowering is not a bad thing. And do you REALLY have an issue with other less fortunate Americans being able to afford health care? They all should be able to shouldn't they?
For a nation that boasts power in unity, there's really no unity. After 911 people of New York came together, out of fear of their neighbours, but how many hungry mouths were fed? People still starved. How many people were given beds? People were still homeless. A unified nation would have homeless and hungry. And I am not excluding Canada in any way here, but as a rule people are more compassionate toward the less fortunate in Canada than elsewhere. For example, out main political ranter on TR states how he should only have to take care of those he knows, not people he doesn't know and doesn't feel he SHOULD help.
In conclusion:
When you find that your paycheck doesn't cover your bills and you are poorer, due to the additional taxation, you have a complaint. As that won't happen anytime soon, it's just fear of change being fueled by the media.
You can afford a health care system that rivals if not supercedes others in the world, call it communism, socialism, a dictatorship or whatever you want, you will still wake up go to work and enjoy your weekends just like any other day. The benefit, OTHER people will now be able to live a healthier life too, without fears of medical bills that will put them in the street.
by oz_media
[i]Give a man a fish, he eats for a day.
Teach a man to fish, he eats the rest of his life.
Give a man $5 for fish, 4 out of 5 times he goes and buys a 6-pack of Old Milwaukee[/i]]
In Canada he needs to find two friends with the same and then bum some MORE change. ::) Damn beer prices! OR I guess he could by a goldfish and raise it in a glaa, using popcorm scavenged from the park to feed it.
My friend had a fish tank years ago and his girlfriend bought a few more fish, one being a goldfish, and named them after friends. Of course the goldfish was named after me. So I got a lot of ribbing and teasing when I stopped over. I'd always stop and say hi to my fish though. All the othet fish started slowly dsappearing until there was just one big fat goldfish, named after me, left swimming arouund on his own. I always wondered what sort of metaphore it was sending me.:D
Tony, as for charity, I spend money on taxes that go to help ur poor and needy, so any other 'charities' I donate to, I do selectively and on my own. If not, I perhaps I would feeldiferently and not worry about a monthly tax donation being taken, for the government to allocate as desired. Hang on, that IS what they do afterall! So No, I guess I don't mind. I don't mind paying taxes, we al pay taxes, and if it goes to help out fellow citizens, so be it. Better than being wasted on somethign else. I object to teh government wasting money on light switches, carpet cleaning etc at the most ridiculous costs, the money that goes towards helping others is the part that makes the real waste more palletable.
If it was ALL wasted on war, toilet seats and jets, I'd be a littlel upset. As that is a repercssion that comes with sorting our welfare and medical, I can accept it a bitmore.
In fact its the absolute opposite of your own view, which seems to ignore he real wasted tax money while you only gripe when it is spent on other citizens. As far as I'm concerned, that's what taxes are best spent on, beyond the basic infrastructure costs.
by tonythetiger
I do bitch about both how it's spent and how it's collected.
The cost to simply comply with the tax codes was $265 billion in 2005. The IRS' budget was $10.1 billion. Considering that 2.1 trillion was actually collected, that's 13% administrative costs... grossly inefficient in any real sense.
And then there's the people who can't or won't pay their fair share. estimated at $345 billion, less $55 billion that they collected leaves $290 billion, meaning that the average taxpayer is paying 12% more than he ought to be.
In theory, not changing ANY government spending (except the IRS (don't worry, those agents can find work in the debt and child-support collection industry)), we could have 25% lower taxes by changing to a consumer-paid-at-the-register national sales tax...
Excuse me if I think there's PLENTY to bitch about!
by puppybreath
by deepsand
by oz_media
by oz_media
Just how well are you, Oz, geared for same?
Your pen is only mildly toxic.
You confront the completely toxic; nay, deadly.
All citizens will be equal in terms of talent, beauty, physical features, and the government will be happy and we will be happy.
All will bend a humble knee to the greater powers and it will be for our own good, for we have been weakened by a sense of pride in ourselves.
Who are we to work for ourselves or try and better ourselves by having a job, making money, and providing for ourselves? We, all along, should have turned our eyes to the government, stretched out our arms and extended the palms. We can do nothing ourselves, we are ignorant, we need the only good, the Government, to help us; for we are nothing alone and we can't do anything on our own.
We need big daddy Government to tell us what to do everyday and to provide for us. This is the truth that has escaped us for so long. Open your eyes America, it is coming.
by puppybreath
by oz_media
Well seeing as I made a civil comment to jck and tony, then you decided to stick your oar in for no reason other than to bitch, I don't think you can pretend to take the high ground here at all.
If I go at it with someone, they are generally someone that I know can dish it out as well as take it.
You fail to recognize how I also come to the defense of newer peers who get bashed by other regular peers here for no reason at all (as I did tis week also when new peer was lambasted for venting), however selective memory is not unique to yourself here, you just made a point of illustrating it.
You had no cause for your comment this time, you just wanted to be a *unt for the sake of it.
by puppybreath
that you never disputed the fact that you HAVE told people to stop whining because they disagree with Administration policies and their candidate lost. Or that they have an opportunity to vote every four years if they want to change things. You fall back to your normal MO and resort to insults instead.
From reading your posts, we all know you're never wrong and that you consider yourself to be an expert on all subjects. The most telling comment you made though, was when you claimed that you had died and were resurrected. Some ego you've got there.
But you said it best yourself:
You're obviously the one who quickly dismisses any opinion that doesn't match yours. After all, accepting another's opposing opinion would be accepting that you were wrong and we all know that would never happen.
by oz_media
I'll perhaps give you credit for it. As for your character generalizations, derived from what you FEEL I am like, well you have a long way to come before you'll earn that credibility with me.
As for being 'resurrected' by some divine intervention, as you suggest I claim, I actually said the absolute opposite; proving again that you simply don't have a clue or at least the ability to understand what you are reading.
I said I DIDN'T go through any white tunnel, meet my maker etc. The intensive care unit stabilized me until I eventually woke on my own accord. To suggest I claim some great uprising just proves your ignorance as to who I am and what I've said, which in fact was the extreme opposite to what you have claimed here. I was changed when I recovered, as any person would be. And if you feel that it was fabricated, I'll gladly send you a few pics of the fire truck planted halfway through my car. Actually, to tell you the truth, I really couldnt' be bothered as your most unqualified opinions mean absolutely squat to me.
I have my viewpoints and I listen to others, I also challenge others views and push them to solidify their views, and I HAVE had my view changed quite a few times here and have accepted as much, those who know how to engage in such thought provoking debates with me understand that. So before you go speaking for others, try speaking for yourself and at least be right in your assertions for once.
The point you are trying to make here here is simply moot anyway, you stepped in on a comment I made to someone else and threw around your little flames, accusing me of just that. The people I was speaking to, who I hand't flamed in any way at all, engage in like minded and opposing views with me all teh time, your little, catty play was completely unwarranted and remains unsupported by those you were even SUPPOSEDLY talking to.
So why not just go have a Coke and a smile and STFU. Certainly you have your own group of little friends you can play with on TR, you don't and never have amused me. You don't and never have offered any relevant conversation that interested me. You just hang around like a little school girl in the playground, parroting 'what he said' as if it actually makes you someone with a valid opinion. When you step out on our own and try to make a point, you fall flat on your face with false assertions and post links proving that you don't know what the hell you are talking about.
So go play with the other kids who may actually take you seriously. This one thinks you are a fool and not worth the ketstrokes you so haplessly cough up.
by oz_media
I have NEVER, EVER, EVER, NOT ONCE, said that we need bigger government.
However, the blind that see ANY form of regulation being the same as communism, socialism etc. will always interpret things taht way, whether right...or wrong (as you are proving here).
When you get a clue, try again.
by oz_media
Whatch NatGeo's Inside the Iraq war, Which is a collection of films taken by troops on their own camefra's and narrated by them, officers etc. in combat since day one until today. It shows both sides and vert cearly illustrates both US and Iraqi propaganda and the effects it has had on the war. It was also proven that the number one most effective methods they found there, were to go door to door on a 'dinner to dinner' search, where they found cooperation and diplomacy was the absolute most effective way of resolvig the conflicts and saving their fellow soldier lives in the most combatant infiltrated citues, such as Felujiah. It really is wel done and worth your time watching, you can probably find it in pieces on YouTube too. Just the Jessica Lynch videos and interviews prove what lies were spouted about her capture. Her convoy was two days off course and bombed for tracking into a hot zone prematurely, by no action of her own.
Then go watch NatGeo's China vs the US, The Battle for War and study the timelines. Though there is no association made between fighting in the middle east and the war for oil, not at all, the timeline of when Venezuela threatened to cut off the US and met with China is all too telling. The false propaganda surrounding the USA's support for Africa, however as it is not left wing based at all, it illustrates views of and interviews republican supporting private drillers in the USA who also have very valid views.
Both good viewing and informative if you can learn to view and take away both sides. If anything, it proves what I havebeen saying for years, American networks just show a small snippet of what's going on compared to what other nation's news reports. A media machine designed to steer and control the minds of the common people in America.
As for war, I have no opposition to war as needed, when justified. I have no oposition to soldiers of any real army.
I was in the ATC in England and had a military upbringing from a strict father who was in the airforce, behind his father etc. I get it, when justified. Iraq just got worse and worse from the day the US took the government out of power, that is exactly when insurgents rose, along with an endless following. AlQaeda supported camps and attacks and then moved right in to Iraq to set up shop too.
There have been attacks falsely blamed on the US that caused unrest, there were attacks blamed on insurgents that were the work of the US too. The good work that MOST soldiers do is not my issue.
The fithy, disgusting job your government does, which puts Americans and others in other nations in harms way, sickens me; especially when applauded and egged on by the blind followers found there that suck up media snippets as if they are speaking the truth.
Blair was no better than Bush on this one either, except it didn't take more than a few days for citizens to rise up and see reality. In the US there are STILL people who think they are there for good reasons, it's as if they simply turn off their brains and fly flags and sing songs without ever second guessing what BS they are fed.
What's interesting is how citizens oppose anything the government does internally, and yet supports anything they do externally, as if they are right in screwing with others and wrong when screwing with the USA.
I would think that fears that they have an alternate agenda, or just don't know what they are doing internally (as with most other governments)would also be prjected to foreign affairs, however it is not, it is just blindly supported out of pure patriotism. It's f'in sad and blind really.
(Here's when some n00b reads my post and tries to tell me what I think and support again, gets old and tiring real quick :D
Seriously Santee, look up those docs even if on youtube, you'd find them really intriguing. Not saying I agree with it all, but both sides are fairly represented in both.
Here's China va US (a french/australian coproduction)- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HylCsiH-s88
It seems that Inside Iraq hasn't been leaked there yet. But you can down the torrent too
by tonythetiger
by puppybreath
You're correct if you assume that all citizen's needs are the same. That will never happen. Some people are always going to be given more by the Government than others because their needs are different.
The only thing you can hope for is that, if you were ever in the exact situation as your neighbor, you would be given the exact same treatment by the Government.
by puppybreath
and yet you have agreed with me at least twice in this thread alone:
You bring up one instance where I misread an article that I provided a link to as if it it is the norm and yet you claim that I'm the one with a selective memory
Mr. Pot, meet Mr. Kettle
by tonythetiger
I hope my grandchildren aren't so saddled by their government's debt that they have no chance of experiencing any real liberty.
[i]Some people are always going to be given more by the Government than others because their needs are different.[/i]
Their "needs" are not my fault, nor is meeting them my responsibility. To deprive me of life and liberty to pay for it is equivalent to punishment for a crime I did not commit. I will never willingly accept that. What our government is doing is flat out wrong on so many levels, and it must be stopped! I am praying as hard as I can that it will be done peacefully, but it may well turn out not to be...
For all the contemporaneous links. Yours is, I am convinced, an earnest although wayward presentment.
I won't be pursuing them.
My "links" -- sources formative to understanding causality and particulars of war -- are older. Old-fashioned, if you will.
Herodotus, for example. Stephen Crane, for another. Will and Ariel Durant. Erich Maria Remarque. The biographies of Lenin, Stalin, Hitler -- and more. My own military journalism experience chronicling the breaking of things and the killing of people. Then, later, death-penalty cases: the organized, concerted, intentional gathering of all to put an end to the life of another with malice aforethought.
I appreciate your offerings.
Peddle them somewhere else, which, I am also convinced, you meant to do for all those at large who read you.
by oz_media
While history teaches us valuable lessons, history is made every day.
"So understand
Don't waste your time always looking for those wasted years.
Face up, make your stand and realize you're living in the golden years."
Today is tomorrow's history from which our descendents will learn too, may as well pay attention to today and hope that it is very different than yesterday. Otherwise we have learned nothing and progressed no further than where we once were.
I offered the links for nobody but yourself, if you choose to ignore them or even simply keep your head in the sand, that's your choice to make. Why bother paying attention to whats's actually happening today?
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by tonythetiger
by dr dij
Certainly they will try to raise taxes to pay for healthcare.
That is what you get when you whine about greedy insurance companies denying care (the one thing good they did was control costs to some degree), and then let govt take over healthcare.
Govt doesn't have the incentive to control costs. They are in the biz of acceding to every demand. Including fraud, which makes up a quarter of medicare.
However they have ANOTHER WAY TO PAY for it.
You've forgotten that the govt has a printing press for money. In fact it is so easy that the fed doesn't even need to actually PRINT the money.
With the stroke of a keyboard they loan billions that don't exist overnight to a secret list of banks that don't need the money, effectively creating bogus money.
Some of that money is used to buy t-bills, in a process with the medical term 'finansturbation' (sometimes involves the liberal, [or conservative] use of porkfat) or 'encourage' foreign govts to buy treasury bonds.
This is done as increased taxation is unpopular but spending is popular. Inflation takes finite time to affect people. And govt bureaus can fiddle with figures to hide it, basically committing fraud against the american people.
This in particular hits the poorest people on fixed incomes, those who can't get raises and distorts the economy. the 'hidden' inflation is one reason for the real estate boom and bust, as it was viewed (wrongly) as one investment that was inflation proof.
by deepsand
Surely you either jest or lack an insider's view of the industry.
Insurance companies cannot increase their earnings without increasing their premiums and/or decreasing their claims/loss ratios.
The latter is achieved by, among other things, negotiating [b]exclusive]/b] rights to fixed reimbursement amounts paid to service providers, who then seek to recoup such discounts by raising the prices that they charge to those outside such negotiated arrangements.
The only costs "contained" by insurance companies are their own!
by deepsand
To ensure that insurance companies do not engage in predatory pricing, most states regulate their premiums by way of requiring that they maintain a certain minimum claims loss ratio, with 85% being typical. This means that, for every $100 of premium received, the ins. co. must spend at least $85 on claims, leaving them with a max. profit of $15.
In order to increase profits requires, not simply that they increase premium revenues, but concurrently increase claims expenses so as to maintain the required claims loss ratio.
Thus, using the 85% example, to increase profits by $15 requires that claims expenses increase by $85, so as to justify collecting an additional $100 in premiums.
Therefore, the insurance industry has a strong motive for seeing medical costs [b]increase[/b]!
by prpetty
by prpetty
by deepsand
by skershaw1
by dr dij
Thought this was interesting:
canada has now found they are spending so much on healthcare they want to eliminate some govt funded care, while we are going in the opposite direction and setting / increasing govt healthcare.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending