Discussion Locked

Occasional scrambling of harddrive

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
We have a camera that takes fundus photos (also called retina photos). There are about 10 PCs that are able to link over our internal network to view these photos and 3 that are actually allowed to make changes by lightening/darkening the photos and saving back to the repository on the originating PC(ie RetScan PC). During the day I do an "xcopy" to have the photos saved in another location. Given this, we have a situation that always seems to happen at the end-of-day when all the linked PCs are shutdown and the retscan is also shutdown. The next day when the retscan is booted up, the main data drive with all the fundus photos is "scrambled". The secondary/backup drive is usually intact. To give you a little more info, we have tried FAT32, and NTFS respectively and had the same difficulties/results. Is this a network issue? Is there something that we are missing to prevent this anomaly? It happens often enough to be concerned, but not often enough to isolate the cause...

9 replies

by softcorp.us

Hello...

Please provide some more information:

1. When you say "scrambled", what do you mean?

For example, what did you have to do to correct the scrambling? Reformat the hard drive?

2. Have you run CHKDSK on the drive? Did it find and correct hard disk errors?

3. Which operating system is the PC in question running? Since you mentioned NTFS and FAT32, I presume it is Windows 2000 or XP.

Thanks.

-----Steve Jackson

CEO/CSA
Software Corporation (Softcorp)
http://www.softcorp.us/probono
Advanced pro bono tools and utilities free for personal use

by softcorp.us

Hello...

Regarding "...when I look at the drive content I get garbage list of directories rather than "documents" and its subdirectories..."

This is consistent with a flakey hard drive...One that will soon stop working completely. This should never happen.

---

Regarding "...I have run chkdsk and it cannot fix the problem...."

Did CHKDSK fail while trying to run? Or, did it run, report no errors, and complete normally? If it is the former, it is consistent with a flakey hard drive. If it is the latter, it is not consistent.

---

Regarding "...Is this a network issue? Is there something that we are missing to prevent this anomaly?..."

I doubt a network problem is the cause. If your network were somehow corrupting data, it would not even get to the hard drive because the server (the Win2000 system hosting the drive) would detect the network problem and report a network error. Or, the client system that is trying to write to the shared drive would detect the problem and report the error.

I suggest that you have a flakey hard drive and you should replace it.

by rockalah

We are using W2K Pro, AMD P4 2.4ghz, HD WD200gb and ASUS motherboard. I have run chkdsk and it cannot fix the problem. I don't know how else to explain the drive being "scrambled" other than when I look at the drive content I get garbage list of directories rather than "documents" and its subdirectories. I have a backup drive that I replace the aborant one. Since I cannot "fix" or reformat - I have to delete the active partition before I can format again. I have run Western Digital HD Diagnostic utilities on it and it reports that the drive is healthy.

by sgt_shultz

i would start to give intense scrutiny to:
the hard drive (anything on the website, new firmware?)
the hd controller (can you get a add in one to try) and drivers and firmware for same (you may want to flash the bios on the computer to latest greatest)
dma settings on the above
you say the secondary drive is 'usually' intact. you saying it get corrupted also?

by lmayeda

Is there any scheduled end of day processing performed on the PC that is the repository of the photos (ie defragging, any other process that would be writing to the PC)) that may get scrambled if the PC is powered down? Can you leave the PC in question "on" continuously and do shutdown on weekends? Are the PCs 'secured' at night?

This discussion is closed to new replies.