Discussion Locked

Office politics major career obstacle

0 helpful
41 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I recently posted a question in which I asked what kind of career issues most plague IT pros. A good number of TechRepublic members said that tips on developing slick resumes and interview skills take a back seat to finding out how to deal with issues in an existing workplace. For example, how do you keep your career on the right track when your boss is ineffective or you have a co-worker taking credit for your accomplishments.

We'd like to develop a new column in TechRepublic's Career sector in which we talk about some of the on-the-job career challenges that many IT pros face. If you have a story to share or a need for some advice, jump in here. With the help of some career experts and your peers, we'll get you on the right track.

41 replies

by gralfus

When coworkers and the boss are of a very similar personality type (gung-ho athletes, golfing buddies, same political outlook) it is difficult to get promoted even though your actual work far surpasses the others. Cronies get promoted before those who don't fit in, even though you may very well be producing high-quality work. Very often promotions are based on the whims of managers and not on real output.

When I worked for HP, I was constantly told "The bar just keeps getting higher". And when you asked what the others actually produced so that I could know where the bar was located, I was told "that is confidential." So you can't tell me where the bar is, only that I missed it and that your buddies somehow made it... This is simply a way of promoting those who are in the clique while keeping a pretense of objective ranking.

I'm happy to not work there any more.

by lumbergh77

No wonder why so many businesses fail these days. I place the blame on managers who are more interested in promoting their cronies than promoting the best workers.

But that's corporate life for ya and there's nothing that can be done about it. The reason I went into a tech field instead of management was to get away from that shit.

by j.lupo

From experience I always found it more beneficial to ask what I need to do to qualify for a promotion. When you speak to a manager about not getting it, ask what you can do to improve so you are the right person next time.

Most of the time, this will work. I have used this technique for over 15 years in the IT/IS industry. On occasion it didn't matter what I would do for just the reason gralfus specified. However, a lot of times I got really good information about my personality, job performance, relationships with co-workers or customers, etc.

Just a thought that you might want to try sometime. Try not to put the "boss" on the defensive. If you can make it a learning exercise in which you show your qualifications and your desire to go to the next level for the company, you just might get that promotion.

by firstpeter

I'm going to pose this question not as an affront to anyone, but rather as a "sanity check" (great way to start, eh?). I think the place to start isn't why I didn't get a promotion to management even though I "deserved" it more than the proverbial next guy, but even more base than that: what makes me believe that I "deserve" a position in management, anyway?

A common theme I've seen on a number of the postings on this topic is that the perceived better performer gets passed over for the promotion. Not to rule out "you-scratch-my-back-I'll-scratch-yours" and stupid people making the decisions as real problems (it happens - been there, done that), but I think another problem that needs to be considered is the fact that people assume that better performance should equal a promotion. While this may make sense in a lead technical role (where the skills of the individual contributor are still 95% of the job), I would argue that such logic is badly flawed when dealing with a promotion to management or supervision, and as such it needs to be re-examined.

Some people just aren't made to be good managers. Management isn't (or, more appropriately, SHOULDN'T be) a "reward" for good performance for that very reason. In fact, I would argue that if you're the star employee in your department it's probably bad for you, the department, and the entire company if you ARE "rewarded" with a position of management. In that case the company loses on two fronts: they either outright lose or at the very least diminish your efficiency as an star contributor (because you're now saddled with the significant overhead of management), PLUS the effectiveness of the overall group declines. In math terms:

X * 100% + Y * 100% = Business Today
X * 75% + Y * 85% = Business Tomorrow

where "X" is the value added by the individual contributor and "Y" is the value added by the workgroup.

As a business owner, why in the world would I want to reward someone by hurting everyone (including them)? Wouldn't I be better off looking for someone who has the qualities of a good manager (which may mean they are average at best as an individual contributor)?

A great model to look at for this is sales. How many of the best sales people go in to management? And of those (few) that do, how many STAY there? The answer is a small handful. Why? Because the people that are good at selling would rather be out SELLING than MANAGING. There are some that are good at both, but the majority of them (throw me in that pot) are not made to be managers.

That's not to say that star contributors shouldn't be rewarded (THAT would be a Dilbert-esqe situation), but rather that an appropriate reward should be used (not the carrot of being able to move into management). If the issue is money, for instance, there is no logical reason that a star contributor should not make more than an average manager. Pride is the only thing that puts a policy that irrational in place. If I provide more value to the company, I should be rewarded commensurate with that. It really is that simple - it's fair, it's equitable, and it just plain makes sense.

One other quick note - many times the best "office politician" IS the best choice for manager. These folks are generally personable, they're able to get folks to do what needs to be done, they have good communication skills, and they think in terms of "how can I help Joe and Jane move to the next level so we can hit our numbers?" Qualities of a good manager. Now, whether or not they take credit for truly someone else's work or end up backstabbing people along the way is an issue of ethics and integrity - and if someone lacks those they have no business being in management at all.

by tony hopkinson

I shifted into contracting was to get away from office politics. My survival in the workplace is judged soley on ability and cost and I'm good and cheap. Course not suffering fools at all, telling people what I think, and a total lack of desire to wedge my nose in my 'superior's' anus, was sort of killing my career anyway.
One of my major problems was I never realised I was going to be shafted until after I got up and staggered off to re-arange my underwear.

by ohiois

I seem to have a double-edged sword. I have recently been told that I have a type-A personality that is a little too aggressive. I work in an IT Department of 10 people. I agree that I am not shy when it comes to expressing my opinion, but until now that has always seemed to work to my advantage. While I think I am very good at being politically correct, I do not hesitate to question things.

I do not mean my questions to be a sign of disrespect. This is not only how I learn, but how I troubleshoot. When a particular software kept locking up during peak times, I questioned our security administrator's scheduling of the malware and virus scans. This was an open discussion. Another time, I questioned which queries our database administrator was running when I had a user calling that they were unable to retrieve reports.

Both of these caused major problems. I was accused of "wanting to do their jobs" and poking my nose into things that I didn't have enough knowledge about. Can anyone offer any advice in these situations? I truly have no problems with my coworkers, but somehow I am coming off as too pushy.

by j.lupo

Hi ohiois. I too am a Type-A personality. Unfortuantely, insecure people will always interpret us as too aggressive. The only thing I can tell you, is to form your questions very carefully. Try not to make them sound like suggestions all the time. You need to phrase the question in a way that encourages discussion.

I currently am having similar issues at my client site. I am very careful how I say something and have taken to starting some conversations with, "Could you explain why we do [XYZ] the way we do it?" This provides an opportunity for you to understand why something is happening. Then it opens a door for you to say something like "Could that affect other scheduled jobs running at that time?"

It isn't about what you know. It is about how you communicate your opinions and thoughts. I have taken a lot of communications and interpersonal training to help me soften my approach. Just a thought that may help you.

Good Luck.

by observant

I can agree with the others here about the more tactful ways of approaching things. However, I disagree with the phrase "Tact is the ability to tell someone where to go in such a way that they actually look forward to the trip." It's too much "used car salesman" for me. To me, I have the perchance to tell people straight up which gets me ignored a lot. I don't want them looking forward to the trip, I want them to regret their decision to the point where they steer others away from doing the same. Yeah, not very tactful but a few will remember it.

Now, ... most of this approach from me is brought about by a work environment that is rife with legacy. Legacy equipment (30 years old and still supporting it), and legacy attitudes. To some of the folks I work with, an abacus is considered "New technology". These people are very (I mean VERY VERY) set in their ways and view new ideas or change more foreign than UFOs.

They are the ones that put everything in place like the network (albiet, badly) and nobody, no matter how tactful the approach, is going to tell them differently. This especially bad since they dump the support off to those of us who actually do know a better way and do not bother with supporting their dinosaur, EVER. By not supporting it, they are oblivious to the problems and as such, are not motivated to solve them. The solution for them is to just throw more "legacy" money at it versus embracing a BPR (Business Process Reengineering).

Although different approaches may (MAY) help the situation, sometimes the problem rests with management and not the employee. In fact, many of the companies in the "mover and shaker" crowd today are starting to view their organizations this way. But the ones that value employees over management are still rare. Many still consider the worker a resource that is disposable, and as such have not developed the new management skills necessary to help the organization move into the 21st century.

You mention communications and interpersonal training to help you soften your approach which is good start to reach across the aisle, but the managers also need to do some reaching.

Sorry for the long diatribe.

by briankstewart

If you are a tech support person and you think the problem is being caused by the stupid actions of the security analyst or DBA, you might be thought of as stepping out of bounds if you approach them directly and suggest that they might be doing their jobs improperly. The best solution is to document your "findings" or rather "suspicions" as to what the source of the problem might be and then give this documentation to your supervisor to handle. You have done your job, and the ball is now in the domain of someone else. No political risk there.

by rayjeff

Exactly. My supervisor thought it a good idea to keep a journal of everything I do or see. I've found it to be a great help with me as far as tracking all of the ideas I've had on certain situations or to track the solutions to problems I've corrected.

by rayjeff

"I do not mean my questions to be a sign of disrespect. This is not only how I learn, but how I troubleshoot. When a particular software kept locking up during peak times, I questioned our security administrator's scheduling of the malware and virus scans. This was an open discussion. Another time, I questioned which queries our database administrator was running when I had a user calling that they were unable to retrieve reports."

Isn't this the classic problem? For me, Being a younger (under 30) employee at a new job, it's been hard on me. When I came to my current job, I brought with me 4+ years of IT experience working in the industry (higher education). My problem was that I came from institutions that were much bigger than this one and the environments were fundamentally different. But, one of my main reasons for being here is that I can see the future potential of the place, once it's IT infrastructure is changed. And because IT (academically and otherwise) isn't of major importance, the administration has the mindset of "we are the kings--we rule everything-we control everything".

One example of this is when I asked for a simple records request. Not so simple because the request dealt with records going back to a three-five year period. The division I work is going through a national accrediation. One of the conditions of preparing is to have a database system to hold data separately from the main institution database systems. So, I have implemented one. In order for the data to be consistant, I needed current, up-to-date records to compare with the records that are already held to some degree in the division. So, my supervisor and I had to go before the technology committee to present our case of me needing access to the main records to get what I needed. Needless to say it was a battle. The college's MIS director is naturally on the committee. When I present our case, the director basically gave us the run around saying how difficult it would be to handle the request or how impossible it would be to grant me access to the actual database system itself. Even when I offered alternatives that would work just as well, I still go the run around.

Now, we fast forward to yesterday. After almost a year of waiting for a decision on the whole process, I finally got the data that I needed. And what's really interesting about that is I technically could've saved myself an entire year by not even having to go to the committee, but to the actual source of where the data is held and ask that department what I needed.

What it amounted to and what several of my superiors in my division is that because i created the database that was actually asked for to be in place years before I was even hired, a few people could have been taken back by me. But it's more than that. Ever since I was hired, I was able to bring technology up in the division. There had been no IT person. And with bringing my past experience, I've questioned the way things have been done and tried to modify of even replaced the old methods. So now, I have amassed alot of respect from not only faculty, but the staff and students, all who I directly work with. Up the chain in the higher annals of the college, that could be a threat to them.

"Both of these caused major problems. I was accused of "wanting to do their jobs" and poking my nose into things that I didn't have enough knowledge about."

It's been hard for me because I have so much knowledge. And because the MIS department is so small (3 persons; the director, a network admin and a "who knows what she does" computer op). And you would think that if you have access to someone who has considerable knowledge & experience, why not use to, but that's not the case here. Knowledge is keep in secret. Higher education is a very strange bird compared to the corporate world.

by jbaker

I mean no offense, but from reading your post, if you came into my shop with the attitude that you display (concerning how much knowledge you have, etc), and starting changing things, I would be offended as well. You are a young pup, in the industry as well as in the position, and you need to learn how to be diplomatic. Four years is not a lot of experience...and no matter how much knowledge you have, there is always lots more to learn.

by tony hopkinson

I have a type 'A' personality.
Got turned down for a job, once reason given 'too forthright'. Took me a fair while to figure out what they meant, after that I came to the decision that they were wimps, haven't modified my behavior at all. There again I've never been particularly interested in management track. Sounds like a fun, place but you don't want to meet the old guard here, they've just done a two year development to a system running on obsolete alphas under vms in Fortran 77. It runs on an Alpha, under vms and is written in Fortran 77.
Rewind ....
When I suggested that there might have been another way to do it (web based) they said such a solution would be too proprietry. Had to go off and get my dictionary out to check the meaning of the word as I'd obviously badly mis-understood it.

by tony hopkinson

Found this
http://goinside.com/98/11/typea1.html

Transforming Type A Personality

I like to assume that behind most every behavior is a positive intention. This is true even when the behavior is considered by most everyone to be undesirable or problematic. For example, anxiety, ‘bad’ habits, criticism, procrastination, domination, overeating, substance abuse, etc.

So I'm not Type A after all, from now on anyone who says I am will be violenty disagreed with, bullied into agreeing with me, just before I sniff a bucket of glue and have my daily ration of 100 marsh-mellows.

by tlconsultants

My problem is I'm a civil servant that happens to not have the seniority of a programmer. Therefore, He is now my supervisor. Now when it comes to our AS400 mainframe, he's the man. But everything else I seem to be more knowledgeable and more experienced. Everyone knows this, and WILL NOT utilize him, so I'm overworked and of course under paid. I work out of title so often that it has become second nature. How do I go about getting the people who matter desire to make a change in my status, without seeming like I'm trying to backstab the programmer?

by observant

Without knowing your options, it's difficult to pose a response but you have identified a MAJOR issue in many companies. You have an AS400 Mainframer/programmer for a supervisor. Statistics have shown that these people very rarely make good supervisors/managers. And for the very reasons I laid out in another posting.

I'm in a very similar situation. My supervisor (and his supervisor) is a mainframer from 25 years ago. He (they) overlook the usefullness of the newer technology out there but continue to try and get the two to interface. It's like the original Star Trek Movie where the aliens built this massive highly advanced ship to support a 600 year old, rusting hulk. We have this HUGE HUGE server farm with gawd awful processing power and it's connected to an old AS390. We are still using multiple flat files where data is inconsistent and calling it a database.

The only way for the powers that be to embrace anything is for the legacy support to disappear. This may mean for you to transfer to another department (we had several that went into programming) or just plain left. When the attrition gets too bad, upper management will eventually see the results of the middle management problem.

One time during the life of Thomas Edison, his lab in New Jersey burned to the ground. He commented that now they could move forward because all their mistakes are burned up. For some companies, it will take a significant catastrophy for them to wake up. Again, as I mentioned in another post, the companies that are moving forward and being recognized are the ones making these tough decisions. (Interestingly, many of these organizations are not U.S. held.) You'd think that in a country that prides iself on being the most advanced, we still have the "Abacus Attitude".

As a suggestion, try to find a way where the others will have to rely elsewhere (i.e., the mainframer). My only apprehension to this is that it will just trickle back down if you are still available. They only time a change is seen as apparent is when the speed bump finally sees themselves as the obtacle. This comes from them having to continually do the work.

My previous job was a network manager at a college. I was the only one that really did any work (not trying to be prideful, just truthful) outside of our student interns. I was also the most educated and certified individual in the department outside of the PHD department head. My immediate supervisor had no authority or autonomy and was just a figure head. when I left, the Dean had a cow "What are we gonna do?!?!?!" he kept harping. My supervisor spoke up and said, "you have to let me treat my people right - decent raises, recognition, training, etc." - The next month, he got funding to send everybody to Cisco training. - Oh, and they sent the PHD department head back to teaching after forcing him to take a one year sabatical.

I guess I was the sacrificial lamb.

Be the best you can be. Be such that when you move on, the remaining hole will be too difficult to fill. Only then will it really sink in.

Then quietly say to yourself, "told ya so!"

It's unfortunate that it comes to this so many times.

by rayjeff

"My previous job was a network manager at a college. I was the only one that really did any work (not trying to be prideful, just truthful) outside of our student interns. I was also the most educated and certified individual in the department outside of the PHD department head. My immediate supervisor had no authority or autonomy and was just a figure head. when I left, the Dean had a cow "What are we gonna do?!?!?!" he kept harping. My supervisor spoke up and said, "you have to let me treat my people right - decent raises, recognition, training, etc." - The next month, he got funding to send everybody to Cisco training. - Oh, and they sent the PHD department head back to teaching after forcing him to take a one year sabatical.

I guess I was the sacrificial lamb."

I'm still trying to figure out why that is after almost 2 years at my current job. Why does the environment has to be this way? Attrition is so bad at this place, but no one seems to care why that is. And to have good and experience people to come and then leave...it's a problem that needs to be addressed.

by tony hopkinson

sure that you are the man for everything but AS400.
From the sound of it he's been promoted in order to be paid a salary commensurate with his technical skills, based on my experience he could be very uncomfortable with being your manager and could be your biggest ally if you work it right.

by tlconsultants

Yes, Yes, and Yes to almost everything. But unfortunately, I enjoy working there. Almost meaning, he enjoys being an overseer. I'll have to continue making sure I'm the WOMAN in everything but AS400 and try NOT to be so invisible.

Thanks Guys

by dtsonly2004

Quit your job and post where it is so I can apply. You are lucky to have a job in IT. Keep you mouth shut because there are not many places to work in this area.

If you think it is all suppose to be fair, go outside and play in traffic because you are not living in the real world. The world is not fair or just. Take your salary and stop looking at the other guy.

If you were any good you would not still be there.

by observant

Should they ever post the position, I would advise them to be on the lookout for you,.... and quickly blacklist your resume. With such an attitude, you sound as if you would not be a team player and become a detriment to the organization. Especially if you think there are not many places to work in this area. You haven't done much job searching lately.

As far as things being fair, you are right. Life is not fair. But there is nothing to say that we can't expect ethical treatment (there isn't a law against that yet).

Now let me get this straight - You say if the other guy were any good, he/she would not still be there but yet you want the job? Hmmm. I could infer a few things from that!

by ohiois

don't you think? While I understand the point you are trying to make, I thought this was a forum for venting and posing these types of problems. As unfair as life may be, we all have our moments of "poor-me". As fellows in the same industry, shouldn't we (of all people) be a little more sympathetic?

by susansweb

I am working on my bachelors in IT currently and have about 18 months to go and I will be finished. I have been with the same law firm (largest in our City with over 300 attorneys) for 15 years as a legal assistant. I have applied for positions in the IT area and so far nothing, one position I got the "you are over qualified" speech, and I would have had to take a big (almost half) cut in pay for an entry level position. It is hard to leave when I have so many vested years at this firm. I may consider waiting until I do finish my degree, but I am getting impatient to start using my capabilities. I have sent my qualifications to everyone that has any power to get me into our IT department. I just hope something happens soon! Any pointers, suggestions is greatly appreciated!
Susan

by ohiois

We had a similar person in our agency who was hired as a data entry temp. He was a temp for two years, but that is beside the point. He was going to college to finish his masters. Although we had no openings in IT, he found out we were outsourcing web development and he received permission to take on the project as contract work. He did an excellent job. He truly impressed our IT Director and CIO. Both of them tried everything in their power to find a spot for him to keep him in the agency, but to no avail. Our budget limitations prevented a new full time position. He moved on to another company as a wesite developer based on his experience with our agency. While he did have to change companies, he gained valuable experience to compliment his education. And who knows, it may have worked out exactly as he wished.

by rayjeff

"While he did have to change companies, he gained valuable experience to compliment his education. And who knows, it may have worked out exactly as he wished."

I'm using this method help me to stay at my current jo. Because of all the issues I've dealt with, there is a positive. I'm have managerial duties and developing my programming, database and networking skills & knowledge as a professional. It's a trade-off that for now I have chosen to accept.

by dbertsche

I think one of the problems you may have is that you have been with the company for as long as you have but in a different position from where you want to be, thus everyone there has gotten used to you being in that position and apparently are having a hard time seeing you anywhere else.

I have experienced this as well as seeing it with many other people and sometimes it's such a roadblock you have to leave the current company for another where they don't have this perception.

Short of that you could approach management and ask what it would take for you to get into IT.

by observant

This post will depend on you. As I've mentioned before, statistics indicate by a big margin that ITer's (like the AS400/programmer) rarely make good managers. Why this is so remains clouded. Some "experts" say that it's because we geeks don't have good people skills since we are used to interfacing with inanimate objects like PCs and such. Others think that its because we like the binary world of on/off (i.e., yes/no) and we are out of our element when it comes to gray areas such as management judgement.
Still others would say (and I agree with this philsophy the most) that we are used to rolling up our sleeves and diving into issues and problems. Whereas a manager should be one to delegate such tasks and, for the most part, let the employee(s) do the problem solving. The perception is that we as techs will have a difficult time separating the responsibilties and thus be mis-allocating our time by trying to "be in the trenches helping out" rather than ensuring we, as managers, provide the resources and environment for them.

Granted, a manager should not be so far removed from the work that he is seen as some distant king (or ogre, as many of us have experienced).

So, where is this going, you ask? - Well, another suggestion is this: Instead of staying in the IT trenches, sidestep the current AS400'er and see if there is a management track in your organization. If you are one of the rare breed that can become a good IT manager, you will quickly bypass this bad superior individual (he will naturally be ticked off - Payback is a bi***).

For me, that is my short term goal. To become an IT manager such that I become a change agent with enough authority to enact a different working methodology (my personal aim is to haul our 390 mainframe out into the parking lot and have a 50 cent, sledgehammer raffle and beat that think into critical mass and replace it with something more powerful, like a palm pilot). Our company is spending many several millions of dollars on technology and support people for antiques (remember my Star Trek trivia). But Jack Welch (CEO of GE) said of such change when he was asked how the older staff will deal with the new technology "they will either learn it or their replacements will!"

Sorry, got off track there.

Should you decide to stay in the IT field you have chosen, you may have to change organizations. However, companies are looking for that individual (yes, the aggressive ones) who can take that drive and ambition and put it towards a management position. If you are willing to step out of the IT techy box, ... if you are willing, you can take that type A energy and make some significant, positive changes - even if it's not in your current company.

by j.lupo

I agree with you in a lot of ways, but exactly what you just described is the way it is where I am now. NOTHING and I mean NOTHING in my ability to communicate or attempt to work with others will work at this site.

Your last sentence is the big kicker for all organizations. It is a two way street. Both sides have to collaborate and compromise to make it work. In over 15 years in the IT industry I have run the gambit of organizational behaviors. Only my current situation is not workable.

In general I try to start by working hard on my communication and interpersonal actions. However, as I was informed last night, they consider me to be "too assertive", "too opinionated", etc. I could go on. What they want (and they gave an example) is someone who is EXTREMELY submissive to their way of doing things.

My only point is, that for Type A personalities (especially consultants/contractors) you need to watch the communication and interpersonal skillset first. Then go from there.

by observant

Isn't it amazing that what we (you and I) experience is so prevailent? If it's any consolation, as far as communication skills are concerned a lot of that has to do with "good ol' boy" speak. (or like you said, it has to sound a LOT like sucking)

My last performance review was a month ago. It uses the typical 5 point likert scale for things. I took the initiative to write up my self appraisal (never been done before, so I'm already the red-headed stepchild). I rated myself with fives in many areas and gave copius notes to justify them. For example, in technical ability, I justified my five by saying that on average, every 15 months I have obtained a technical certification. In esprite du corp, I mentioned that I kept pushing a collegue to get his A+, offered mentoring to him, developed mock tests for him, AND EVEN DROVE HIM TO THE TESTING CENTER 75 miles away. My boss still gave me a three.

He also gave me a three in written communications skills. Well, I take SERIOUS issue with that. I am 50 days from finishing my Masters Degree in CIS. In the course of that pursuit, I have written over 120,000 words in papers to which I have received A's. My boss seems to think my writing skills are moderate but a well known university seems to think otherwise. OH, and not to mention that I was a technical editor for Defense documentation for 10 years.

One technique I've learned in communicating with management (especially in getting things done with an obstinant boss) is to go to a party with them. Once the guy is a little bit sloshed, I tell him that he'd really look good to the upper management if he'd do . Then stroke his ego by giving an example of how it will make him out to be the good guy. - In short, once it becomes their idea, you'd be suprised how quickly your suggestion will be adapted. - Naturally, you won't get the credit, but it can help improve the work situation. I also make sure that (like a hacker) I leave a little something to indicate that it was my idea originally so when the boss is finally outta there, you have something to show for your efforts. I just either hide it or put it somewhere that can't be erased. (i.e., the owner of a file, first comment line of code, etc.)

Like I said, it's too bad that it takes such action to improve certain work environments.

by j.lupo

Well, you definitely said it perfectly. My situation is a bit strange at this client site, so I figure if I can find a good positions somewhere else, then it will be worth putting effort into. This particular location is not interested in changing in any way.

As a consultant I don't get performance reviewed. Also, the issues they have with me here are not performance related. To put it bluntly, the environment is one where I am the only American Female and the only other female is Indian. My last conversation with my direct supervisor is that I should be more like the other female in the office. Oh don't get me wrong they attempt to hide this particular bias, but they aren't that good at it.

When it comes to communicating and writing, I am on the same page as you are. I too am finishing up an advanced degree with a 4.0 average out of a possible 4.0 for a major and well respected university.

I think, and this is just my opinion, that we - who wish to continue to grow and make positive differences - threaten their perceived positions. Instead of harnessing what we have to offer, which would make them look even better, they appear threatened by it.

Thank you for your suggestions. I may use them in a different setting. This one isn't going to matter.

by observant

I met an individual some years ago that had a profound impact on my management style. He looked like a plain man, nothing unusual about him. (I piped up to him about something and caught an ear full from those around me). He asked me what I thought about something while we were at a social function. I didn't work for him nor did anybody else at the function.

I told him my technical observations and the flaws I had observed in a particular process. He said "Thanks" and got up from the table and walked off. The man was David Packard from HP. Not too long after our brief discussion, changes were made to the process at great expense.

I'm not trying to say that to get things done you need to mouth off at a CEO but that his style of leadership worked real well.

A company had implemented a unique method of performance appraisals where the employees would rate their supervisors versus the usual boss rating the subordinates. If HIS supervisor noticed a trend coming from the workers, the issue was addressed. This also had the advantage of ruling out the one disgruntled employee ranting and raving and ripping on the boss. If 27 people have the same opinion, there is good statistical evidence of something.

My supervisor promoted a woman to a Net Admin position. The year before, she was turned down for the same position and EXPLODED at EVERY mid level supervisor in the building griping about how she deserved the job. Our boss told the interview committee this year "I hope this decision doesn't blow up in my face" after he promoted her. Needless to say, the woman is incompentent, has no technical ability, and is rude, arrogant, is only interested in being a team player if she can be in charge of the team. Yet, she got promoted. Our department wasn't the only one that had the "deer in the headlights" look when all that came down. The entire company (yes, the whole building) knew the reason she got promoted was because of her looks. Now, all of us who are highly technically qualified are turning down promotions into the net admin department because we don't want to have to constantly fix her problems.

I had a boss several years ago (retired Army Major) and I can see where his troops would fight for him. When something good happened, he wouldn't accept the credit. He would say, my team should get the credit. They are the ones that did the work. - On the converse, if something went wrong, he'd say, "my bad." and prevented it from trickling down to his team. I'd work for him again in a New York minute.

It goes back to a quality boss.

I'll stop droning on now.

by j.lupo

From your story it really goes to quality leadership versus managment. There is a very large difference and not all managers are leaders. If you are one of the lucky ones you will get a real leader for your company, department, team, etc. If not, well that is where your own abilities to deal with whatever comes up occurs.

Quite frankly, and this is just my opinion, it doesn't matter if you are male or female; black, red, white, or any other color; it doesn't matter if you have long hair or short; what matters is how well you know what needs to be done and how well you can work with others. That means collaboration, compromise, accountability, honesty, integrity, and a lot of other qualities.

Sometimes one can learn to be a leader, most times however (and this is a major debate in academic circles) one is born with leadership in them and all the education and training does is make them better at leading.

The problem is that in the business world, it is not about putting the right people with the right skills in the right positions. It appears to be about politics.

BTW: it may be that the woman who was made the network admin manager was not promoted for looks. You said she didn't get it the year before and started exploding at meetings. I suspect that she let them know she thought they denied her because she was female. The only way to protect themselves was to get evidence that she can't do the job. It has to be very documented. Then something can be done.

Just a thought. (P.S. I am female just in case someone thought I was being biased. I am not. I have seen this (and similar bias) card played to the detriment of companies.

by tony hopkinson

is what it's known as in the UK. It's only a personal problem if you want to be a manager though..
However particularly during the boom period organizations with no technical track in their salary structure had a really bad habit of promoting their techies to managers in order to pay them enough to keep them. As soon as you get manager in your title you are expected to manage not do.
Not just IT, seen them do it it electrical & mechanical engineers as well.
One of my best bosses, but worst managers could diagnose faults on the system by aking three questions, we had to manage ourselves though, he was too busy doing interesting things he should have delegated to us.

by observant

I agree with a lot you said, Paul. Many people are not cut out to be managers. Great ones, for some reason, just have in inate ability to lead. Still others can be taught (I prefer the term mentored) the necessary people skills.

However, of the qualities you listed like good communications skills, I would had to say that ethics and integrity should stand head and shoulders above everything else. Being a good communicator can sometimes just make you a good snake-oil salesman. An ethical boss will have a lot more respect from their subordinates than a boss who can charm the fangs out of a rattlesnake.

Granted, the individuals who move up in an organization are "usually" the ones that are smooth talkers and can stroke the egos of upper management - unfortunately. ... The captain of the Titanic was continually told the ship was unsinkable....

A truely excellent supervisor is the one that sees potential in their staff and will do everything possible to develop whatever talent is there. If the skill is databases, so be it. Put them in the correct department that can benefit from that skill and offer the tools to help them become a better DBA. If the skill is networks, a good boss will find a way for that person to work with the net-admins. I've been in an organization that had a few exceptional bosses like that. And they had no shortage of people wanting to transition into the department because the other employees saw them as someone that works to support them at their best, not pidgeon hole them. When their best employees move on (which is rare), only the best motivated individuals can fill the spots. And the cycle repeats. And the company benefits in the long run because now they don't have just one guru but a continually growing pool of gurus. The company gets better results in it's projects as well as respect in the industry. Word gets out that "Hey, that company over there does it's workers right."

All sound too pathetic, right. Well, it's rare because a lot of companies don't recognize the need to instill ethics, honor, integrity (sounds like a Military Recruiter ad) in the supervisory staff. Those that do, understand the investment will reward them.

I'm sure the grippy DBA in another post will have something to say but that's OK, i'm not hiring someone with that attitude anyway.

by tony hopkinson

This is the main reason why the fairer sex shouldn't be allowed in the profession. They keep making us blokes look stupid.
LOL

My most profound apologies.

by j.lupo

Let me take your example a step further Paul. You talk about rewarding based on where a person provides value. Suppose it isn't money that is important but career opportunity. Suppose the person wants a management (leadership) position and has the proven abilities, but because of their performance (make it sales, technical, whatever) does not get the promotion. Now what? How do you reward them? Offering money won't work because that is not the motivator in every case.

I have known people who meet your criteria of really good manager/leader for a company and yet don't get the position. In the end the company gets hurt worse because at best they leave at worse they bring morale down for everyone.

I think you need to expand your forumla. It is too simple and people are not that simple. If you have someone who is very good technically, but can also lead people and make a value to the company as a manager - then what?

I believe there are more variables here than you may be looking at. One of the things many in business forget is the cultural element, career goals, and so on for their people. There is more than the company bottom line to be watched. To improve that you need to account for the intangibles. That is a very difficult thing to do for anyone.

Just some thoughts on the topic.

by firstpeter

Your point is well taken, but let me make a quick clarification. My intent wasn't to imply that money was the only motivating factor or only reward, only that management promotions should not be considered a reward. I used money because it happened to be an easy one to identify and one that commonly ranks high (not necessarily, or even usually, highest - but high) on the list of most people's motivators.

If you're an excellent performer and looking for management, but you're simply not the kind of person folks want to put in management, then there's a problem. However, I wouldn't argue that it's a no-win situation. As a matter of fact, I was in that particular situation, but luckily I had a boss that understood where I was sitting and helped me.

The real key is to figure out "why" someone wants to be in management. For me it was two-fold. First, I had a mistaken notion that management=leadership, and I felt like I was a good leader (driven a lot by folks around me who thought so as well). If I was a good leader, I reasoned should be in management. Second, I have always enjoyed being able to help people, and management was the best way I saw to be able to make a tangible difference.

Ultimately my goals didn't really play out to a management role, but rather to a leadership role or a role in the company with more impact (to help people) than I had. However, _I_ wasn't the one who realized it - my manager did. Once I was able to re-orient myself I stopped being frustrated when management positions didn't open up.

But even if I say my goal is management and I won't budge but I'm just not management material, I don't think you can necessarily say the company loses. You could argue that the company takes a short-term hit because the star left, but you could also argue on that same vein that the company comes out ahead when all is said and done because the alternative would be someone who wasn't satisfied in their position (or with their future with the company) - a drain on productivity and morale.

One other note - we could get into a philosophical discussion about the purpose of a company, but this probably isn't the right topic to start that thread so I'll generalize what I'm headed towards instead. While I agree that there are cultural elements, career goals, etc., and that need to be accounted for, I would argue that I should not sacrifice the bottom line of the company only for those goals. If those help my folks become better managers/leaders/individual contributors - if they add more value to my company (whatever you want to define as value) - then I've make the right decision.

by j.lupo

I agree whole heartedly with you. I just wanted to elaborate that the formula you put together needed some expansion. Believe it or not, I have seen companies go out of business for not considering the intangibles that members bring to adding value.

I could go into examples too, but any philosophical discussions go beyond our points here.

I would like to express one other point that you made about not sacrificing the bottom line. I don't believe in that either. I just believe (and have witnessed personally) that the intangibles improve the bottom line when taken into consideration. In fact in your response you gave a perfect example. That is what happened when your "boss" helped you re-orient yourself about management and leadership. Some managers are leaders, most are not (in my opinion and according to a lot of literature I have read). This is a very large issue about management and leadership and what they actually mean.

Personally based on my own performance and career objectives I would be just as happy leading a team on a project as "managing" a department. It is the role not the title that is important. I, like you described for yourself, excel in that area and don't perform as well when asked to be a "drone". I will do the work for the sake of the company, but I will go home or to the gym every night where I can let out my own frustration and not show it at work.

by ohiois

I like this approach. I have argued for years that a good manager needs to know maybe 20% of the actual work. The other 80% is babysitting! How to handle disagreements, workloads, motivational factors (whatever they may be.) A manager must know HOW to get the right people to find the answers. There is no need for him to have all the answers. Unless this is a very small shop where half of the manager's job is hands-on work, technical skills are not the most important thing he brings to the table. People skills are.

by jbaker

Politics will always play a role in the workplace. That is why it is such a good idea to get a member of upper management on your side. As much as we hate it, more companies than not will have an engineer or chemist or some completely unrelated job specialty running the IT department. And we, as IT professionals know that this does not work, but we are forced to deal with it, becasue that is just the nature of the beast. Plus, wouldn't you rather be on the front lines actually doing the work rather than in management getting the crap that rolls down on you from above, and the blame when anything in the department goes wrong?

by ohiois

I fully understand that I do not know everything. And I am definately not trying to change anything. I guess what I'm really looking for is how to ask questions that will not ruffle feathers. When I am trying to resolve an issue, I try to look at everything. If I don't understand how something works, I question not only what the process is, but whether or not it is even remotely possible that it could be affecting other things. If it is, then as a group I would expect a discussion on what could be done to solve the issue AND allow the process to continue. I do not feel that either one is more important than the other. However, I do argue that if users are unable to connect, it doesn't matter how pretty the reports are. I do not understand why this is not a logical troubleshooting technique. Or why some people are overly sensitive to questions.

Maybe having a type A personality makes me less sensitive to critisism, therfore I am less empathetic to those that are easily offended.

This discussion is closed to new replies.